Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

At this point "culture" is rapidly become a meaningless concept. The world's too connected.

And in the minority in across a lot of the political spectrum that I think this is a good thing IN GENERAL.

A LOT of my mentality here (making allowances for one topic being far, far, far, far, far less odious) is very similar to liberal whining about "cultural appropriation."

Cultures are just collections of ideas and ideas are not sacred. They are only worth what...well they are worth.
 
Last edited:
To be fair, I do think there's a difference between people talking about "preserving the white race" and "preserving the Maori race".

I think in one case "preserving the race", is really about preserving a culture. There is no "white culture".

There is, I would argue, a "western culture" or a "European culture", and I think it is worthy of defense, and I even think it's under attack. You can count me in if you want to preserve a reverence for the legacy of ancient Greece, or the plays of Shakespeare, or the philosophical foundation that led to both the scientific revolution and to democracy. I'm all in.

Unless you start calling it "white", because that has nothing to do with it.

That's the key difference I think. The various Native American tribes are trying to preserve their cultures. Remember, they were driven off of their own lands by foreign invaders, concentrated into small "reservations," and then marginalized. And in preserving their culture, they aren't demanding that the "White culture" goes away and assimilates into their culture. They just want recognition. So I don't think there is anything racist about that.

As you point out, there really isn't even one monolithic White culture. I would expand that though, to what you are calling Western or European culture. There is no such thing. It's not even true about Hispanic or Black Culture.

Maybe, there is a "Western Value System," that we all have in common.
 
Certainly the colour of the European skin is not the reason the "Western" or "European" culture arose. (I would even advance a tentative suggestion that the geographic, geological, and climatic conditions pertaining in europe are at least partly responsible for both the culture and the lack of melatonin)

(Don't forget for our USA folk at least a few of the European countries are non-white.)

And you are now another one talking about "the culture" yet not defining what culture you are talking about! It's getting a tad frustrating.
 
Warp, the problem is you haven't said did-dilly about the lives and rights of non-whites?

Your single focus on white victimhood suggests a certain bias.

Is this the thread to discuss the plight and concerns of non-whites?

Yes, especially since some might be immigrants and or non-citizens.

I am trying to present a viewpoint, and some arguments, as to why such ideas as Replacement Theory might have merit, to some. I mean, that is the question posed in the thread title, right?

So I'll move it along by asking you if you think non-whites (i.e. those who might be thought to "replace" white Americans) immigrating to the U.S. have rights?

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 329 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
So I'll move it along by asking you if you think non-whites (i.e. those who might be thought to "replace" white Americans) immigrating to the U.S. have rights?


Of course they have rights, and I have not suggested that they don't, nor even that they should have less rights than whites.
 
Last edited:
Of course they have rights, and I have not suggested that they don't, nor even that they should have less rights than whites.

So they have the right to immigrate?

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 329 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Are you aware how large and diverse Europe is? There are over 40 countries for a start, do you really think there is a shared culture that covers all those countries? And if so what is it?

There are two mutually-antagonistic cultures within the city of Derry/Londonderry for example.
 
So they have the right to immigrate?

Absolutely, within the established legal constraints.

Ah, so now we get to the heart of the matter. . .provided the immigrant "follows the rules" may that right be restricted because the nation to which they are coming believes their immigration will help to make the country's culture and predominant race extinct?

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 329 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
Ah, so now we get to the heart of the matter. . .provided the immigrant "follows the rules" may that right be restricted because the nation to which they are coming believes their immigration in help to make the country's culture and predominant race extinct?

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 329 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.


Don't try to twist things, here. They have rights, and those rights are determined and protected by law. I am just clarifying that there is a lawful process. I don't support illegals being granted the additional rights and privileges that are afforded to citizens. I don't support illegal immigration. The only way to prevent prevailing law from impacting these rights would be to have unrestricted immigration, which is not reasonable.
 
Last edited:
When the GOP still had a platform the Official position of both parties was that PR should decide there own fate be it Statehood, independence, or continueing as his, IIRC, both parties favored statehood over the alternatives though.

Personally, I favor reducing the size of the D.C. of Washington DC to the minimum required by the constitution and wrapping the rest of it back into which ever state makes the most sense. A city sized state seems a bit odd, that an issues with most of the other US territories becoming states, the are tiny for the most part.

When 90% of a group votes one way, its difficult to parse racism from partisan politics. Republicans didn't become the party of racism until long after the Black Americans starting voting Dem reliably.
DC has a larger population than Vermont and Wyoming.
Puerto Rico has a population larger than 20 states.
 
Don't try to twist things, here. They have rights, and those rights are determined and protected by law. I am just clarifying that there is a lawful process. I don't support illegals being granted the additional rights and privileges that are afforded to citizens. The only way to prevent prevailing law from impacting these rights would be to have unrestricted immigration, which is not reasonable.

So who's in charge of creating "the lawful processes?"

Betcha in your world it's white people.
 
Don't try to twist things, here. They have rights, and those rights are determined and protected by law. I am just clarifying that there is a lawful process. I don't support illegals being granted the additional rights and privileges that are afforded to citizens. I don't support illegal immigration. The only way to prevent prevailing law from impacting these rights would be to have unrestricted immigration, which is not reasonable.

So who's in charge of creating "the lawful processes?"

Betcha in your world it's white people.


Well, generally speaking, people who are elected or appointed to do so. They don't have to be white. I have not made such a claim.
 
Ah, so now we get to the heart of the matter. . .provided the immigrant "follows the rules" may that right be restricted because the nation to which they are coming believes their immigration will help to make the country's culture and predominant race extinct?

Don't try to twist things, here. They have rights, and those rights are determined and protected by law. I am just clarifying that there is a lawful process. I don't support illegals being granted the additional rights and privileges that are afforded to citizens.

Not trying to twist anything. That's question that goes to the heart of the matter.

The replacement theory uses the specter of illegal aliens as a sort of boggie man, but the theory is really about the fear that non-white and non-Christians might wipe out the predominantly white, Christian culture of the U.S.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 329 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
Current "Affirmative Action" programs are a topic of their own, although I wouldn't be surprised if Replacement Theory touched on the subject.
Affirmative action has nothing to do with it. Implying that one must hark back to the days of slavery to find discrimination and hatred suggests an unfortunate lack of observation and perspective. The statement I was criticizing is both hyperbolic and ignorant.
 
Affirmative action has nothing to do with it. Implying that one must hark back to the days of slavery to find discrimination and hatred suggests an unfortunate lack of observation and perspective. The statement I was criticizing is both hyperbolic and ignorant.


I don't think you can discuss the realities of modern discrimination without broaching the topic of affirmative action programs. You may disagree, and I am OK with that. As I say, that is a different topic.
 
Environmental racism rings a bell?

There was a concept that got tossed around the thinkpiece circuit a few years back; environmental colonialism.

Sure it sounds like someone trying to win a "Pair up the two most Left Wing 3rd rail buzzwords you can imagine" contest and winning but the basic idea, while I didn't quite agree with it fully, had some validity to it.

Basically the big players like America, Europe, maybe others only got really into pretending like they cared about the environment when it let them tell developing countries to not develop.

Like we're aware now of the damage an industrial revolution has on the environment, but also haven't really figured a replacement for it as a way to pull a society out of being stuck in the 1800s forever.

So now American, Europe, arguably China, all the big boys who have already had their industrial revolutions and benefitted from are now telling the rest of the developing world "Okay but you don't get to do because we're afraid it might be bad for the planet."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom