Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

:confused:


Maybe I didn't understand what he meant, but I think I'm buying that story.


While it may be true in an absolute sense, in the practical demonstration of what we accept and often embrace in society, it is not.
 
While it may be true in an absolute sense, in the practical demonstration of what we accept and often embrace in society, it is not.

Well I don't think Joe was talking about what we often embrace in society. I think he was answering a question.
 
To be fair, I do think there's a difference between people talking about "preserving the white race" and "preserving the Maori race".

I think in one case "preserving the race", is really about preserving a culture. There is no "white culture".

There is, I would argue, a "western culture" or a "European culture", and I think it is worthy of defense, and I even think it's under attack. You can count me in if you want to preserve a reverence for the legacy of ancient Greece, or the plays of Shakespeare, or the philosophical foundation that led to both the scientific revolution and to democracy. I'm all in.

Unless you start calling it "white", because that has nothing to do with it.
 
To be fair, I do think there's a difference between people talking about "preserving the white race" and "preserving the Maori race".

I think in one case "preserving the race", is really about preserving a culture. There is no "white culture".

There is, I would argue, a "western culture" or a "European culture", and I think it is worthy of defense, and I even think it's under attack. You can count me in if you want to preserve a reverence for the legacy of ancient Greece, or the plays of Shakespeare, or the philosophical foundation that led to both the scientific revolution and to democracy. I'm all in.

Unless you start calling it "white", because that has nothing to do with it.
Isn't there a European culture? I've got to admit, "white culture", "whiteness" ect, are jarring terms. I impulsive assume folks that use them, are racist. But if you substituted European, it would be, less triggering.

Certainly, Americans using terms like white culture and whiteness are almost certainly just thinly veiled racists.
 
Certainly, Americans using terms like white culture and whiteness are almost certainly just thinly veiled racists.


Best-selling, and widely-loved racists like author/speaker Robin DiAngelo.

She tells people what it means to be "less white", and they applaud her. I think I have even seen her "work" celebrated on this site.
 
Isn't there a European culture? I've got to admit, "white culture", "whiteness" ect, are jarring terms. I impulsive assume folks that use them, are racist. But if you substituted European, it would be, less triggering.

Certainly, Americans using terms like white culture and whiteness are almost certainly just thinly veiled racists.

Agreed.

And I think I said that there is, indeed, a "European Culture". The only thing confusing about the term is that I think we, in America, are part of it. I think "western culture" is a slightly better descriptor.

There is some difference between "old world culture" and "new world culture", but they are branches of the same tree, in my opinion.
 
I didn't say it was uniquely Western. I said that it was not universal, and that the enlightenment notions of "all men are created equal" came out of a Christian tradition. This is like reading a fact check where they widen what was claimed in order to debunk it.
And I didn't accuse you of saying it was uniquely Western (or Christian). This is like talking to someone who doesn't know how to read for comprehension.

Your whole position is an incoherent mess. You argue against moral universalism (without understanding what it is), strongly implying support for some flavor of moral relativism. You then point to racist countries as grounds for accepting racism in your own culture, without even the dimmest sense that this kind of sauce-for-the-goose argument is a universalist position. You identify anti-racism as a western value, state that you have a preference for your own culture, and fail to realize that this would imply that you, too, should reject precisely the kind of racist/"culturist" ideas that you hold, because that's what your own culture has done.

Just be a ****** old racist, if that's what you want to do. It would be preferable to this kind of abuse of history, logic, and morality.
 
Last edited:
But you are someone who makes racist arguments and denies being racist

"Preserving your own race" is indeed a racist idea.

Only when it is white people promoting it, obviously.

Warp, the problem is you haven't said did-dilly about the lives and rights of non-whites?

Your single focus on white victimhood suggests a certain bias.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 329 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Then can you explain the fact that former presidents Gerald Ford and George H.W. Bush both supported statehood for P.R., as well as the likes of Mitt Romney, Rick Scott, Marco Rubio, and Jeb Bush, all Republicans in good standing? And if it would be such a slam dunk for the Democrats, why hasn't it already happened, since it plays so well into their "agenda" and would pay off instantly (as opposed to waiting years while immigrants gain citizenship and start voting)?

As for the U.S.V.I., I was unaware that there was anything resembling a serious active initiative to grant them statehood, at least not within the past 30 years or so. Who, exactly, is pushing that idea these days?

(Kind of surprised you didn't mention D.C., although perhaps that would be harder to disguise as an "immigration" issue as opposed to plain ol' racism.)

Statehood for PR and USVI would require 60 votes. The current makeup of the Democrat Senator majority does NOT support killing the filibuster for purely ideological bills.
 
Agreed.

And I think I said that there is, indeed, a "European Culture". The only thing confusing about the term is that I think we, in America, are part of it. I think "western culture" is a slightly better descriptor.

There is some difference between "old world culture" and "new world culture", but they are branches of the same tree, in my opinion.

Overlapping Venn diagrams there for sure. I'd argue and I think with evidence that the major differences between US Culture and European Culture is the influence of African Culture and to a lesser degree Asian and Native American Cultures.

Also Latin American culture but they are also mixtures of the previously mentioned cultures.
 
Then can you explain the fact that former presidents Gerald Ford and George H.W. Bush both supported statehood for P.R., as well as the likes of Mitt Romney, Rick Scott, Marco Rubio, and Jeb Bush, all Republicans in good standing? And if it would be such a slam dunk for the Democrats, why hasn't it already happened, since it plays so well into their "agenda" and would pay off instantly (as opposed to waiting years while immigrants gain citizenship and start voting)?

As for the U.S.V.I., I was unaware that there was anything resembling a serious active initiative to grant them statehood, at least not within the past 30 years or so. Who, exactly, is pushing that idea these days?

(Kind of surprised you didn't mention D.C., although perhaps that would be harder to disguise as an "immigration" issue as opposed to plain ol' racism.)

When the GOP still had a platform the Official position of both parties was that PR should decide there own fate be it Statehood, independence, or continueing as his, IIRC, both parties favored statehood over the alternatives though.

Personally, I favor reducing the size of the D.C. of Washington DC to the minimum required by the constitution and wrapping the rest of it back into which ever state makes the most sense. A city sized state seems a bit odd, that an issues with most of the other US territories becoming states, the are tiny for the most part.

When 90% of a group votes one way, its difficult to parse racism from partisan politics. Republicans didn't become the party of racism until long after the Black Americans starting voting Dem reliably.
 
Agreed.

And I think I said that there is, indeed, a "European Culture". The only thing confusing about the term is that I think we, in America, are part of it. I think "western culture" is a slightly better descriptor.

There is some difference between "old world culture" and "new world culture", but they are branches of the same tree, in my opinion.

Are you aware how large and diverse Europe is? There are over 40 countries for a start, do you really think there is a shared culture that covers all those countries? And if so what is it?
 
Warp, the problem is you haven't said did-dilly about the lives and rights of non-whites?
Your single focus on white victimhood suggests a certain bias.


Is this the thread to discuss the plight and concerns of non-whites? I am trying to present a viewpoint, and some arguments, as to why such ideas as Replacement Theory might have merit, to some. I mean, that is the question posed in the thread title, right?
 
Last edited:
To be fair, I do think there's a difference between people talking about "preserving the white race" and "preserving the Maori race".

I think in one case "preserving the race", is really about preserving a culture. There is no "white culture".

There is, I would argue, a "western culture" or a "European culture", and I think it is worthy of defense, and I even think it's under attack. You can count me in if you want to preserve a reverence for the legacy of ancient Greece, or the plays of Shakespeare, or the philosophical foundation that led to both the scientific revolution and to democracy. I'm all in.

Unless you start calling it "white", because that has nothing to do with it.

Certainly the colour of the European skin is not the reason the "Western" or "European" culture arose. (I would even advance a tentative suggestion that the geographic, geological, and climatic conditions pertaining in europe are at least partly responsible for both the culture and the lack of melatonin)
 
Isn't there a European culture? I've got to admit, "white culture", "whiteness" ect, are jarring terms. I impulsive assume folks that use them, are racist. But if you substituted European, it would be, less triggering.

Certainly, Americans using terms like white culture and whiteness are almost certainly just thinly veiled racists.

No.

If there is an European 'culture' it's about attacking our neighbors for doing things differently.
Now that we can't do that with actual weapons anymore it's down to words and football matches, but even within countries there is no real single culture.
Try to cheer for the English rugby team in Glasgow, talk in dutch in the south of Belgium (or vise versa) etc etc.
 
If you know anything about Evolution, you should know that "preserving your race" is not only harmful to said race, but also impossible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom