Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

It's the whole basis of "replacement theory." White people (a vocal minority, really) are afraid of white people losing their grip on the reins of power because they think this will have a negative impact on society. That's the whole thing in a nutshell.


They're probably also afraid that if they become a minority, they'll be treated the way they've treated minorities. "Everyone else is secretly just as bad as me, no matter what they claim, so I'm not actually a bad person."
 
Good story, but I don't see the relevance to my statement?

And there lies the problem.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 329 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
They're probably also afraid that if they become a minority, they'll be treated the way they've treated minorities. "Everyone else is secretly just as bad as me, no matter what they claim, so I'm not actually a bad person."

It's just "Oh I totally (wink wink) am not for slavery... no siree. But have you thought about how the slaves might act when we free them?" again.
 
They're probably also afraid that if they become a minority, they'll be treated the way they've treated minorities. "Everyone else is secretly just as bad as me, no matter what they claim, so I'm not actually a bad person."


Yeah, they probably recall their days on the plantation, whippin' them negroes. White people are the devil, I tell ya! :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
If there is one thing that unites the crazy believers in the replacement theory and the crazy liberals on this forum, it's that immigrants will automatically become Democrats.
I'm not sure all the crazy liberals here share that fault. Which is not to say there's no such thing as a liberal Cuban, but it's certainly not a guarantee.
 
We've had multiple talks on this board in multiple contexts about the Democrat Party's assumption of minority votes and how often that's come back to bite them.
 
Why would I want to be empathetic about racism fuelled paranoia? I do understand the world view that instill bigotry...it's just that i don't feel the need to validate or coddle it.

Why, to better help you combat it. Its a cliche but you can't beat an enemy you don't understand. Do you feel the same about hate and terror motivated by Islam? Violence fueled by poverty and police violence?
 
I actually cannot wrap my head around how anyone can openly, shamelessly admit to and advocate racist ideas. That's kind of like openly, shamelessly admitting to and advocating pedophilia. I mean while I can conceive of a mentality so diseased as to harbor either kind of pathology --- racism, and/or pedophilia --- but I totally cannot even conceive of a mentality so utterly depraved that it isn't even ashamed of it.
 
I actually cannot wrap my head around how anyone can openly, shamelessly admit to and advocate racist ideas. That's kind of like openly, shamelessly admitting to and advocating pedophilia. I mean while I can conceive of a mentality so diseased as to harbor either kind of pathology --- racism, and/or pedophilia --- but I totally cannot even conceive of a mentality so utterly depraved that it isn't even ashamed of it.
I think maybe you have been very sheltered. I would say Warp12's ideas are better expressed than the average person holding those views, but they are not at all uncommon. More than that, Warp12s ideas aren't really the same as the caricature that they are typically presented as when they are attacked. You are used to living in a world where something like your ideas enjoy cultural hegemony so you don't have to deal with the reality of how most people think or what the genuine challenges are to your world view.

Warp12, and my ideas are far more discouraged than advocating paedophilia. It's been perfectly acceptable to do that in elite circles for decades. You don't lose your tenure for that, unless the unenlightened public create too much of a stink.
 
Last edited:
I actually cannot wrap my head around how anyone can openly, shamelessly admit to and advocate racist ideas. That's kind of like openly, shamelessly admitting to and advocating pedophilia. I mean while I can conceive of a mentality so diseased as to harbor either kind of pathology --- racism, and/or pedophilia --- but I totally cannot even conceive of a mentality so utterly depraved that it isn't even ashamed of it.

I strongly recommend watching "The mosted hated family in america" a documentary by Jon Ronson about the west burrough babtist church.

Oddly, not at all racist but they do have repugnant views otherwise. While I don't have much Sympathy for Fred Phelps, pretty much everyone else involved was trapped in that situation by his **********. The Teens especially were just ******. I distinctly remember one of the girls who was applying to college when asked about dating and marriage just responded by laughing and saying, she couldn't imagine anyone marrying her.

Anyrate, lots of extremists have similar stories. They're raised with those bad ideas or in a lot of cases teens/young adults searching for meaning landing on gross ideas and getting stuck there. Orwell had an essay about it, the challenges sociallists had in recruiting such people on account of Fascism offering meaning in a way that socialism didn't. Its probably why the Commie countries all basically turned towards nationalism eventually. A few generations before Fascism the cause of such people was anarchism.

Then there's folks that just seem meant for extremism. I recall reading an article about a Hungarian zionist extremist who had been a Nazi until he found out his grandparents were Jews.
 
Anyrate, lots of extremists have similar stories. They're raised with those bad ideas or in a lot of cases teens/young adults searching for meaning landing on gross ideas and getting stuck there. Orwell had an essay about it, the challenges sociallists had in recruiting such people on account of Fascism offering meaning in a way that socialism didn't. Its probably why the Commie countries all basically turned towards nationalism eventually. A few generations before Fascism the cause of such people was anarchism.
One of the primary reasons why they turned to nationalism is that the ideology they started with was causing chaos and collapse. Revolutionary ideologies about upending the hierarchy are good for causing the collapse of the system you want to overthrow, but not good for having a stable country afterwards. The un-nationalistic, globalist strain of Communism that Stalin threw out then weirdly turns into the neo-cons.
 
I think maybe you have been very sheltered. I would say Warp12's ideas are better expressed than the average person holding those views, but they are not at all uncommon. More than that, Warp12s ideas aren't really the same as the caricature that they are typically presented as when they are attacked. You are used to living in a world where something like your ideas enjoy cultural hegemony so you don't have to deal with the reality of how most people think or what the genuine challenges are to your world view.

Warp12, and my ideas are far more discouraged than advocating paedophilia. It's been perfectly acceptable to do that in elite circles for decades. You don't lose your tenure for that, unless the unenlightened public create too much of a stink.

What a victim you are - hated more than the paedophiles!
 
It's a sign of the times when the concept of preserving or defending your own race is considered "racism". Oddly, this only seems to apply to whites, however. Hmmm. :con2:

Nice angle. Call me a racist in a way that practically guarantees any dispute will thus reinforce your statement.

I'll just say, you are free to call me whatever you like...I am certain you feel quite emboldened to do so. Just because you personally believe it to be true, does not make it so.

But you are someone who makes racist arguments and denies being racist

It's a sign of the times when the concept of preserving or defending your own race is considered "racism". Oddly, this only seems to apply to whites, however. Hmmm. :con2:

When I was a kid, there were several people who said "I'm not a racist, I'm a racialist. The argument was rubbish then, and this is just the same
.


Good story, but I don't see the relevance to my statement?
"Preserving your own race" is indeed a racist idea.
 
But you are someone who makes racist arguments and denies being racist


"Preserving your own race" is indeed a racist idea.

Does that apply to the "First Nations" Americans? Or the Australian aboriginals? Or the Maori?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom