Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

It would only be hypocritical if you had some kind of universalist view where you didn't think citizens should be preferred to non-citizens. Is it hypocritical to care more for one's own children than other peoples? You only run into these problems if you have some universalist, rationalistic conception of your country where if it was OK for your ancestor to come, then there must be some "right" to do that and since rights are universal, the right must still exist.


That is generally not how it works.The conceptions of rights and your values are culturally specific to you and the culture you were brought up in. They are no more universal than the culture in Iran or China. The idea that you can be reasoned into a set of values is like imagining you can be reasoned into a religion... I'm sure it happens, but it is a rare event. Values aren't products of reason.
You do know that most blacks have been brought up immersed in the the culture in this country, right? And I'm pretty sure there are more native born hispanic folks than hispanic immigrants.

Your issue targeting the evil immigrants is misplaced. You don't like how the culture around you is shifting. Too bad, you can't stop it from happening. And immigration while being an easy political target is not the cause of the shift.
 
When I hear about "replacement theory," I'm always reminded of the old Vietnam era meme, "we had to burn the village to save it." There are many ways in which our culture is greater in potential than in practice, but when I think of those ideals, I think of things like human rights, freedom, tolerance, diversity, democracy. And of course jazz. Replacement theory is a suicide bomb wrapped in a flag.
 
This lament about the impending demise of "white culture"...are people being prevented from dancing around a Maypole now? Where will it end?

Note it is always this never defined, never pinned down "culture" that is under attack. As if a "majority white" country has a single identifiable mono-culture.
 
If there is one thing that unites the crazy believers in the replacement theory and the crazy liberals on this forum, it's that immigrants will automatically become Democrats.
 
I did. Moral equality is not a particularly Christian or western value. You have a poor grasp on history and morality.
I didn't say it was uniquely Western. I said that it was not universal, and that the enlightenment notions of "all men are created equal" came out of a Christian tradition. This is like reading a fact check where they widen what was claimed in order to debunk it.
 
Majority white changing to minority white, yep, I buy that, it's inevitable eventually.
Who knows what is inevitable.

You seem to think every person with a darker shade of white doesn't share your culture. I have news for you, they do.
Another person who came to the conversation holding a stick man with a bunch of bad opinions that are then attributed to the people you are arguing with. This is the problem with the world at the moment. You don't listen to what other people think. That this place had the gall to put skeptics in its name is a joke. This is one of the most unquestioningly dogmatic places I spend any time.
 
Last edited:
If there is one thing that unites the crazy believers in the replacement theory and the crazy liberals on this forum, it's that immigrants will automatically become Democrats.
I would say whether they stay democrats is more what is in doubt. My concern is more that if everybody is broken up into these identity groups, then they can just be politically played off one against the other. It's like the Amazon thing about diversity being great because it made unionising less likely.
 
... This is the problem with the world at the moment. You don't listen to what other people think. That this place had the gall to put skeptics in its name is a joke. This is one of the most unquestioningly dogmatic places I spend any time.

Well setting your self righteous whinging about "no one listening to what you think," We listen to what you articulate and based on it have a fair idea of what you think. You reinforce our notion of what you are thinking with your subsequent posts of "No you misunderstood my point" in which you inadvertently only confirm what we deduced, but with different words.

Your problem seems to be more that we see no reason to validate the inherent racism and hold it up as some sort of reasonable counter to what you see as threats to your notion of the ideal society.

I have listened, understood, and consider your ideas garbage.
 
Why would I want to be empathetic about racism fuelled paranoia? I do understand the world view that instill bigotry...it's just that i don't feel the need to validate or coddle it.
 
No, you guys absolutely don't. What happens is the ideologues of the forum apply the same paint by numbers stereotype to people they disagree with regardless. The lack of empathy and inability to understand world views other than one's own is staggering.

You lack empathy regarding non white people, we lack empathy regarding hateful racists. See how this works?...... Of course you don't.:rolleyes:
 
It's a sign of the times when the concept of preserving or defending your own race is considered "racism". Oddly, this only seems to apply to whites, however. Hmmm. :con2:

When I was a kid, there were several people who said "I'm not a racist, I'm a racialist. The argument was rubbish then, and this is just the same


It's a sign of the times when promoting racist ideas is considered racism.
 
What happens is the ideologues of the forum apply the same paint by numbers stereotype to people they disagree with regardless.


One of the fantasy of some of the replacement boys is that they are living out the events of one of the movement's dystopian novels like The Camp of the Saints or Submission in which they, the faithful and true, are frustrated by cowardly, unaware liberal elitists who endlessly apologize for mainstream, white culture and side with the fictional invading, culture wrecking, hordes of Muslims, Mexicans and blacks.

Some of these these replacement boys need to get lives.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 329 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
One of the fantasies of the replacement boys is that they are living out the events of one of the movement's dystopian novels like The Camp of the Saints or Submission in which they, the faithful and true, are frustrated by cowardly, unaware liberal elitists who endlessly apologize for mainstream, white culture and side with the fictional invading, culture wrecking, hordes of Muslims, Mexicans and blacks.


There is some fantasizing going on, alright. :rolleyes:
 
It's a sign of the times when the concept of preserving or defending your own race is considered "racism". Oddly, this only seems to apply to whites, however. Hmmm. :con2:

When I was a kid, there were several people who said "I'm not a racist, I'm a racialist. The argument was rubbish then, and this is just the same
.


Good story, but I don't see the relevance to my statement?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom