Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

The replacement boys don't need to feel guilt about their grandpas calling black people names.

That wasn't the replacement boy's doing.

What the replacement boys should be guilty about is sitting on their hands while white nationalists and neo-nazis use their conspiracy theory as an excuse to gun down Jews, blacks, latinos, gays or anybody else considered culturally deficient.

Anyone who believes in Replacement Theory should not feel guilty in any way about the actions of the mentally deranged. That makes zero sense.

Me thinks thou doest protest too much. ;-)

Perhaps it would be easier for all involved if you just told us what, if anything, you think the replacement boys are responsible for.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
This is the prevailing attitude...that white solidarity is bad.

Yes. I can see that.

I agree. White solidarity is bad. We don't have anything to be "solid" about, unless somehow it's related to opposing non-white people, which is bad.


I don't know. Maybe I've missed something. I can't see anything good coming out of "white solidarity".
 
Anyone who believes in Replacement Theory should not feel guilty in any way about the actions of the mentally deranged. That makes zero sense.

Just like people who are against abortion shouldn't feel guilty when some nutcase blows up an abortion clinic.

This brings me to another question:

If someone believes in replacement theory, what exactly are they supposed to do about it? Vote? Well, their own theory shows them that their votes won't be effective in the long run because they are supposedly being replaced and statistics show them that they will soon be a minority -in their own country, no less!!!!11! So, what is the final solution to this great replacement, exactly?
 
Yes. I can see that.

I agree. White solidarity is bad. We don't have anything to be "solid" about, unless somehow it's related to opposing non-white people, which is bad.


I don't know. Maybe I've missed something. I can't see anything good coming out of "white solidarity".


Because white people are bad...of course.

But all other races exhibiting solidarity? Good. Of course.
 
This brings me to another question:

If someone believes in replacement theory, what exactly are they supposed to do about it? Vote? Well, their own theory shows them that their votes won't be effective in the long run because they are supposedly being replaced and statistics show them that they will soon be a minority -in their own country, no less!!!!11! So, what is the final solution to this great replacement, exactly?


I don't know what they think, tbh. I'd say vote and breed, and discourage breeding outside of their own race? What else can you do?

Other than promote white interests, of course.
 
Last edited:
Yes. I can see that.

I agree. White solidarity is bad. We don't have anything to be "solid" about, unless somehow it's related to opposing non-white people, which is bad.


I don't know. Maybe I've missed something. I can't see anything good coming out of "white solidarity".
I was about to post, then erased, a similar statement. You said it more succinctly.
 
I don't know what they think, tbh. I'd say vote and breed, and discourage breeding outside of their own race? What else can you do?

Other than promote white interests, of course.
To the best of my knowledge there really isn't a generally agreed upon solution to this amongst people who believe in replacement.
 
Because white people are bad.

No. I didn't say, or imply, that, and I don't think many people would agree that white people are bad. At least, not many people here would. Some might, I suppose.



I think there is a movement in America to try to impose white guilt. I'm against that. So if "white solidarity" was limited to opposing white guilt, I could go for that.
 
No. I didn't say, or imply, that, and I don't think many people would agree that white people are bad. At least, not many people here would. Some might, I suppose.



I think there is a movement in America to try to impose white guilt. I'm against that. So if "white solidarity" was limited to opposing white guilt, I could go for that.


Well, I understand that you may not feel that white people are bad. But I think the overall message being pushed, on a large scale, is that being white carries a lot of bad/wicked baggage. And there is a shaming aspect that occurs because of that message.
 
Well, I understand that you may not feel that white people are bad. But I think the overall message being pushed, on a large scale, is that being white carries a lot of bad/wicked baggage. And there is a shaming aspect that occurs because of that message.

I think the "white shamers" are kind of fringe, but they certainly exist. There are enough of them to hold some rallies.

I don't feel threatened enough by them to feel like I need to form a "solidarity" group to protect my interests against them. I know it's fashionable to claim victimhood, but that will just have to be one more thing I'm not so fashionable about. I really don't feel oppressed these days, about whiteness or anything else I can think of.
 
I don't know. Maybe I've missed something. I can't see anything good coming out of "white solidarity".

Well, the Sudetenland isn't going to annex itself.

Here's the thing...Humans are nomads, always have been since we lost our tails, and figured out "Zero" was a thing. There isn't a stretch of fertile land that hasn't been fought over, or flat-out taken from someone who found it "first". There's a reason nobody speaks Iberian in Spain, and a reason Spain, France, and Italy have Latin-based languages. There's a reason why there is a Viking influence found throughout Europe, and a reason why some Laplanders, and people west of the Ural Mountains have Asian features.

The list of people who can claim a piece of land from the beginning, whatever that is, happens to be very short.

American history; North, Central, and South has always been about invasion and conquest by incoming peoples. What happened to the Olmec? Where did the Yavapai go? Both civilizations vanished long before white Europeans showed up. What happens today if a Blackfoot gets caught on the wrong part of the Sioux reservation?

If anything, the Americas are an example of not learning from its past.

And growing numbers of Americans are choosing to retire south of the border in places like Costa Rica, Panama, and Colombia. I think that's cool. Human migration isn't just a south-to-north thing. I took Spanish a few years back to add relocating to Panama as a retirement option myself, and learning the language introduced me to a lot of very nice people from places like Honduras, El Salvador, and Ecuador who are far more politically conservative than white MAGA**holes will ever be.

My favorite thing has been watching the local Hispanic community get racist with our growing Iraqi community. They ran the Korean families out of town only to be "overrun" by our new Arab neighbors who bought up the local tire shop, Chevron, grocery store, and a liquor store (called Mo's, short for Mohamed). The Latin community has softened somewhat now that the local junior high school, and high school soccer teams started winning, thanks to the Arab invasion. And the Latino boys stopped shaving their heads because the Iraqi boys were a big hit with Latino girls thanks to their flowing black hair.

Maybe I'm out of touch, but in general, I like people. Those whom I dislike earn that distinction through their actions, not where they come from, how they got here, and or where they go to church (if at all).

As for the idea of "White Pride" groups, we had those for 200 years. We called them "city councils", "State Senates", Maddison Avenue (still is, BTW), Congress, and just about every church, social, and fraternal organization in America. We rigged the system to keep out the darker-skinned among us, and found ways to void whatever contracts we signed with our indigenous citizens, and Mexicans who found themselves suddenly living in the US with the stroke of a pen on a big map.

And then who is "white" has certainly changed since 1788. Irish? Not really, they added Catholic influence into areas which were originally hardcore Protestant. Italians? Same problem, plus they didn't speak the language. Why were Polish jokes not only a thing, but big business for 120 years? Desegregation bumped a lot of people into the "White" category in the 1970s.

I wish I knew how to pull those sticks out of people's butts, but then I'd probably beat them with it.
 
Last edited:
Well, I understand that you may not feel that white people are bad. But I think the overall message being pushed, on a large scale, is that being white carries a lot of bad/wicked baggage. And there is a shaming aspect that occurs because of that message.

I think the "white shamers" are kind of fringe, but they certainly exist. There are enough of them to hold some rallies.

I don't feel threatened enough by them to feel like I need to form a "solidarity" group to protect my interests against them. I know it's fashionable to claim victimhood, but that will just have to be one more thing I'm not so fashionable about. I really don't feel oppressed these days, about whiteness or anything else I can think of.

Some folks have a history of claiming victimhood. I call them professional victims, but some of them are amateurs.

One not so tricky trick in their predictable bag is to find some fringe group on the opposite side of the political spectrum and comb through that group's verbiage until they find some statements that make it seem the latter group is dead set on, and able to, tar and feather the poor, would be, victim who has so far survived only by his wits and righteous bravery.

This ridiculous routine is why we have eight pages in this thread filled with entitled white Christians in a white Christian country laughingly claiming that the barbarians are at the gate. Of course these barbarians are recognized only by the brilliant and brave would be victims.

Oh, please. . .

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
...Is there something about the race based attacks of the liberals that have a special quality their recipients aren't allowed to form some kind of collective consciousness around?

This, and the rest of your post, is utter nonsense. Whatever cheap suit you want to disguise it in, at the end of the day your argument boils down to the fact that you want to keep America white by making it more difficult to immigrate here and become a citizen. Disagreeing with that aim, and your demented contention that it's all part for some liberal Master Plan to create voters for the Democrats, is not a "race based attack." It's simply recognizing your position for the racist hypocrisy it is.
 
"Entitled White Christians"???

Yeah!

"The liberals and the brown folks are out to get us" argument reminds me of the entitled kid I knew who showed up for college thinking he could BS his way through his freshman year by pretending he had completed the assigned readings and getting other people to write his papers.

It seems his family was hot stuff in the little town he'd grown up in and he got through his teen years on charm and the implied threat that his daddy, who owned half the town and was mayor, didn't want anybody messing this his little boy.

A couple of tenured professors took him down a couple of notches and he ended up going back to Smallville, where daddy wiped his little arse for another decade or so.

So why don't you cut to the chase and show us exactly how white folks are being substantively replaced, harmed or even so much as bothered?

Quotes from ubber-liberal bleeding heart 19 year-olds at Princeton whining 'bout how Woodrow Wilson was a racist don't count.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
Most of us don't give one single tiny crap if other people have the same melanin content as us.

"White" isn't part of my identity anymore than my blood type is.

Interestingly, in Japan and Korea, blood type is a very important part of one's identity. (Perhaps you knew that and brought it up for that reason.) Of course, that doesn't make it any more realistic.
 
Yes, I found his characterization of Appalachian culture to be troubling.

Yeah, "American Nations" does too much stereotyping of the indiviudal sections.

At one point he talks about Kentucky being Appalachian with a little enclave of Tide Water culture in the blue grass/horse farm area around Lexington.

As a Kentuckian familiar with the area I feel it just ain't that simple.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 329 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
It's much more like the latter. It's the claim that immigration is being used knowingly to turn the current majority into a minority whose ideas about what constitutes a just society will never again be allowed to be the dominant idea of the country. It's the replacement of one idea of the country by another through importing new citizens.


Suppose it was happening the other way and the immigrants were predominantly Ayn Rand and Pinochet fans and this was changing the country in a direction such that liberal politics would be in a permanent minority. Suppose further that this was being done by Trump. Would that be at all concerning?
Have you presented any evidence yet that our country is changing?

Majority white changing to minority white, yep, I buy that, it's inevitable eventually. But so what? The fear is in your head and in the heads of the white supremacists spreading the fear mongering message. You seem to think every person with a darker shade of white doesn't share your culture. I have news for you, they do.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom