Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Yes, I found his characterization of Appalachian culture to be troubling.

--------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 327 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.

Yeah, "American Nations" does too much stereotyping of the indiviudal sections.
 
Yeah, I was kind of blown away by that rhetoric. Then I saw some videos, for example, where college students were talking about being ashamed of being white and such nonsense. It seems like everywhere you turn, there is some variation of white guilt being promoted. There is no doubt that white males in particular take a lot of heat these days; even in this forum I have seen it lobbed around as a means of invalidating opinions.

I can imagine that sort of thing makes a lot of people promote white solidarity. Which is also criticized as a bad thing, of course.
White liberals are the only group with an out group bias.
 
Maybe that BLacks have been treated as second or third class citizens so long has something to do with that.
It's always amusing to see the racists try to jusiry their racism, though.


So, the way this reads is:

"Black solidarity is good and acceptable, because whites are bad. White solidarity is unacceptable because whites are bad."
 
So, the way this reads is:

"Black solidarity is good and acceptable, because whites are bad. White solidarity is unacceptable because whites are bad."

If that's true, your reading skills are exceedingly substandard.
 
So, the way this reads is:

"Black solidarity is good and acceptable, because whites are bad. White solidarity is unacceptable because whites are bad."
Now your getting how to be an anti-racist.
 
Debating whether the dilution of a white populace has had a negative impact on society, and whether those concerns were/are justified is a different debate. And I am sure a lively one.
It's the whole basis of "replacement theory." White people (a vocal minority, really) are afraid of white people losing their grip on the reins of power because they think this will have a negative impact on society. That's the whole thing in a nutshell.

My question is: why would this have a negative impact on society? What's the problem with having more non-white people being represented in the workforce and in positions of power? How do white people lose out by having the rest of society uplifted? Isn't a truly equal society -one where "race" is not a factor- a good thing for everyone in the country?

This is a real head-scratcher for me . . . unless, of course, proponents of "replacement theory" think there is something different about non-white people . . . something that makes them less American, perhaps? Or less capable of running things? But that can't possibly be the case, can it? I mean, proponents of this "theory" keep saying that they aren't racist . . .
 
If that's true, your reading skills are exceedingly substandard.


So, then you agree that white solidarity is acceptable...just like black solidarity?

That would be great. Otherwise my interpretation of dudalb seems pretty accurate, based on the prior discussion.
 
Last edited:
It's the whole basis of "replacement theory." White people (a vocal minority, really) are afraid of white people losing their grip on the reins of power because they think this will have a negative impact on society. That's the whole thing in a nutshell.

My question is: why would this have a negative impact on society? What's the problem with having more non-white people being represented in the workforce and in positions of power? How do white people lose out by having the rest of society uplifted? Isn't a truly equal society -one where "race" is not a factor- a good thing for everyone in the country?
Diversity targets and affirmative action means explicitly treating people differently based on race, not the same. All that anti-racism stuff that's being taught is about treating people differently based on race, not the same. In the US affirmative action came in, I think, as a temporary measure in 1961. Is the process nearly done? It's been 60 years. Affectively it's a permanent measure. Your side is the one that is in favour of explicitly making race a factor in decisions.
 
So, then you agree that white solidarity is acceptable...just like black solidarity?

That would be great. Otherwise my interpretation of dudalb seems pretty accurate, based on the prior discussion.
#itsoktobewhite
 
So, the way this reads is:

"Black solidarity is good and acceptable, because whites are bad. White solidarity is unacceptable because whites are bad."

No one, literally, has said that.

There is nothing wrong with loving and celebrating your culture. I mean if white people were getting together to promote the joys of aspic-encased vegetables, Nicholas Sparks and Ferlin Husky, no one would have an issue.

But you do understand that the contributions and history of the White people has been the standard teaching in this country since forever, right? That the contributions and history of Native Americans, Blacks, Hispanics, etc has been minimized or all together ignored? So when those groups get together to raise awareness of that history and contribution and to advocate for better representation, they are expanding the record, so to speak. They are letting the world know that they also exist in this country and they also have contributed to it's success. We don't need the "Association for the Advancement of White People," because that already exists and is also known as "The public school system," and "The United States government" and "The corporate world."
 
Last edited:
I really do enjoy when Racists out themselves.

'Wahhh. whites feel bad over things that happened in the past, and now!'

So many racist snowflakes. 'Blacks were oppressed, but that's all in the past, lets celebrate WHiTe CulTUrE!'
 
So, then you agree that white solidarity is acceptable...just like black solidarity?

That would be great. Otherwise my interpretation of dudalb seems pretty accurate, based on the prior discussion.

At this point I'm pretty sure you're just putting people on, I suppose because you enjoy winding people up for some reason. But just for laughs, I'll parse it out for you.

You posted two sentences. The first is:

Black solidarity is good and acceptable, because whites are bad.

Nobody said that. Nobody said anything like that, or anything that could be reasonably misconstrued in that way. Black solidarity exists because in the USA blacks have been historically discriminated against and repressed, and although there's been improvement over the years racism still exists and profoundly affects the black community. It's a natural, expected reaction to literally centuries of abuse. It isn't because "whites are bad," something no one here has said (and for the record, the "poor, pitiful me" act wore threadbare long ago).

As for your second sentence:

White solidarity is unacceptable because whites are bad

Again, we can dismiss everything after the word "unacceptable" as a figment of your imagination (or perhaps more charitably, lack of reading comprehension). As for "White solidarity is unacceptable," it depends on what you mean by the term "white solidarity." Most of the time I've encountered it, it's a barely disguised euphemism for racism. But extending some very unearned benefit of the doubt, I'll take the words literally, devoid of their usual context, and say it already exists, and has since the colonization of North America. Good, bad, or indifferent, it's already there. Attempting to compare it with black solidarity is an apples-and-oranges thing, because one is a response to historical repression, while the other at best is a continuation of the privileged status quo, and at worst an attempt to put very cheap lipstick on a racist pig.
 
So, then you agree that white solidarity is acceptable...just like black solidarity?

What would we be solid about? I can't see any point to "white solidarity", unless it was to oppose not so white people, and I wouldn't call that acceptable.


I understand "black solidarity".


I'll meet you halfway, though. I could go for "American solidarity". I'm perfectly ok with that, and I'm sure lots of forumites would cast some hate toward it.
 
You guys must not have seen the training materials that Coca-Cola had. From none other than Robin DiAngelo, best-selling author of "White Fragility".

Another slide suggests “try to be less white” with tips including “be less oppressive,” “listen,” “believe” and “break with white solidarity.”


This is the prevailing attitude...that white solidarity is bad. Even JoeMorgue casually implied such a thing, to start this discussion. Sometimes I think the reason that people refuse to acknowledge this stuff is that they have already been brainwashed.

In fact, I know they have.
 
Last edited:
The replacement boys don't need to feel guilt about their grandpas calling black people names.

That wasn't the replacement boy's doing.

What the replacement boys should be guilty about is sitting on their hands while white nationalists and neo-nazis use their conspiracy theory as an excuse to gun down Jews, blacks, latinos, gays or anybody else considered culturally deficient.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 328 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Again, we can dismiss everything after the word "unacceptable" as a figment of your imagination (or perhaps more charitably, lack of reading comprehension). As for "White solidarity is unacceptable," it depends on what you mean by the term "white solidarity." Most of the time I've encountered it, it's a barely disguised euphemism for racism. But extending some very unearned benefit of the doubt, I'll take the words literally, devoid of their usual context, and say it already exists, and has since the colonization of North America. Good, bad, or indifferent, it's already there. Attempting to compare it with black solidarity is an apples-and-oranges thing, because one is a response to historical repression, while the other at best is a continuation of the privileged status quo, and at worst an attempt to put very cheap lipstick on a racist pig.
The thing is, this is just your political read of history. You reminded my of a conversation between two MPs in the UK around the issue of whether there should be parliamentary time to debate men's issue. If I recall the issue was that every International Women's Day there was a debate on women's issues. There had never been a similar debate on International Men's day. The male MP wanted to discuss male suicide and things like that. The female MP laughed at him and said that every day was International Men's Day.

The thing is, if you don't share this privilege hierarchy view of the world where it is a good thing to explicitly discriminate against some racial groups and one sex, then the whole thing can come across as kind of like an attack on a class of people.

Now, I understand that the majority view on the forum is that this is a noble effort. The thing is, the opinions I now have that are so objectionable on the forum are a consequence of that effort. 5 or 10 years ago, I had very normy unconsidered views. It was exactly the attitudes of the noble warriors against Nazism, like the ones on this forum, that got me thinking and made me open to these ideas.

Is there something about the race based attacks of the liberals that have a special quality their recipients aren't allowed to form some kind of collective consciousness around?
 
The replacement boys don't need to feel guilt about their grandpas calling black people names.

That wasn't the replacement boy's doing.

What the replacement boys should be guilty about is sitting on their hands while white nationalists and neo-nazis use their conspiracy theory as an excuse to gun down Jews, blacks, latinos, gays or anybody else considered culturally deficient.


Anyone who believes in Replacement Theory should not feel guilty in any way about the actions of the mentally deranged. That makes zero sense.

Just like people who are against abortion shouldn't feel guilty when some nutcase blows up an abortion clinic.
 
You guys must not have seen the training materials that Coca-Cola had. From none other than Robin DiAngelo, best-selling author of "White Fragility".




This is the prevailing attitude...that white solidarity is bad. Even JoeMorgue casually implied such a thing, to start this discussion. Sometimes I think the reason that people refuse to acknowledge this stuff is that they have already been brainwashed.

In fact, I know they have.

I"ll give you a point: anyone that says whiteness is bad is misguided at best. But fundamentally what people have a problem with isn't whiteness, it's the elevated position whiteness has in our society. Whiteness isn't bad at all. I like pot roast and Willie Nelson too! But whiteness isn't better than anything else either.

Excuse the snark here, but I get the feeling that many white people do think their people and culture are better than anyone else's and that whiteness deserves an elevated place in society. That "American" equates to "White." This is much worse than misguided.
 
You guys must not have seen the training materials that Coca-Cola had. From none other than Robin DiAngelo, best-selling author of "White Fragility".




This is the prevailing attitude...that white solidarity is bad. Even JoeMorgue casually implied such a thing, to start this discussion. Sometimes I think the reason that people refuse to acknowledge this stuff is that they have already been brainwashed.

In fact, I know they have.
Have you read Ibram X Kendi? My kids school was name checking that a year or two ago for their anti-racism effort back when that statue of Churchill was being attacked by BLM.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom