Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

Continuing my reply....
....
Fair enough. I wonder why the nurse would make that statement if it was not true, at least in her experience. ..
True as far as the nurse's biased interpretation of her experience. The question is then, how well has the nurse assessed the evidence in her experience? When it comes to influenza, the average health care worker's knowledge including many physicians is one of the worst track records for the profession.

. And I wonder how often a seriously ill patient would go straight home from ICU?
Not all that uncommon depending on the condition one is in ICU with. Infectious disease lends itself to discharge from ICU to home because antibiotics have the potential for dramatic cure. In this case, one could easily go home from the ICU rather than a slower recovery once the illness peaked.

But I am no more concluding the patient needed ICU care than I'm concluding he didn't. I merely said I would check on the nurse's claim before taking it as fact.

...
(On the other hand giving birth couldn't be more uncomfortable than delivering a constipated stool could it? :cool:)

BillyJoe
:eek: Are you suggesting you've had poo as big as a baby's head?
 
Anecdotal evidence collected systematically using controls to tease out the variable you want to test makes up a huge proportion of medical research.
Maybe I have a different understanding of what constitutes anecdotal evidence. To me it's someone giving a personal account of something that happened to them and then coming to a conclusion about its cause or resolution. You seem to be talking about a collection of anecdotes in a clinical trial. I have no doubt that conclusions can be drawn from a series of anecdotes, controlled in the way you describe above, in a large enough clincal trial.

How would you test a pain medicine if not for anecdotal evidence? You can check range of motion and other objective measures, but subjective measures are very important.
Sorry, I did not think subjective reports of pain forming part of the data in a clincal trial of the effectiveness of an analgesic constituted "anecdotal evidence".

It isn't the anecdote that is the problem. It's how you draw conclusions from the data where the errors occur.
Maybe it's just a difference of definition.
In any case, I would not draw any general conclusions based on the personal experience of the person featured in that article.

When it comes to influenza, the average health care worker's knowledge including many physicians is one of the worst track records for the profession.
$#!+, I hope that's not true. It's just reached Australia and we're about to hit Winter in just under two weeks. :(

Infectious disease lends itself to discharge from ICU to home because antibiotics have the potential for dramatic cure. In this case, one could easily go home from the ICU rather than a slower recovery once the illness peaked.
My mistaken impression then.

BillyJoe
 
In any case, I would not draw any general conclusions based on the personal experience of the person featured in that article.

Whoever suggested that?? ....:boggled:

The call to action is for your personal response....
If in the same room - take some action

In the same neighborhood - prepare for some action if at risk

In the same country - listen for further development positive or negative.

On the other side of the world.....watch for similar cases

The biggest issue with this strain???.....no conclusions CAN be drawn as yet.
 
Maybe I have a different understanding of what constitutes anecdotal evidence. To me it's someone giving a personal account of something that happened to them and then coming to a conclusion about its cause or resolution. You seem to be talking about a collection of anecdotes in a clinical trial. I have no doubt that conclusions can be drawn from a series of anecdotes, controlled in the way you describe above, in a large enough clincal trial.
You are confusing the evidence with the conclusion. The anecdote is the story. What it supposedly 'proves' is often the false conclusion we associate with the claim, anecdotal evidence is unreliable.

Sorry, I did not think subjective reports of pain forming part of the data in a clincal trial of the effectiveness of an analgesic constituted "anecdotal evidence".
Systematically collecting anecdotal evidence is indeed a far cry from saying a single anecdote proves anything.

Maybe it's just a difference of definition.
In any case, I would not draw any general conclusions based on the personal experience of the person featured in that article.
But I was saying something different. One can draw some tentative conclusions from the anecdote. I explained what those were.

Think about it. It is pretty hard for any health care provider do a good patient assessment without the patient history. That history is anecdotal evidence. You learn to assess that anecdote, you don't always take it on face value.

$#!+, I hope that's not true. It's just reached Australia and we're about to hit Winter in just under two weeks. :( ...
Buyer beware applies to health care just as much as it applies to other products. Don't assume the product is good, verify that it is. And the better informed you are, the better health care you can acquire.
 
<snip>

Buyer beware applies to health care just as much as it applies to other products. Don't assume the product is good, verify that it is. And the better informed you are, the better health care you can acquire.

You and others have led me to believe that it's pointless learning about medicine unless you go to medical school and become a practitioner.

Now you're saying patients can be informed enough to question the reasoning and opinions of medical professionals they consult (except any of those on this forum, of course:)).

Make up your mind Skeptigirl!
 
You are confusing the evidence with the conclusion.
Well, I meant that you cannot make any conclusions based on a story relating a personal experience.

The anecdote is the story. What it supposedly 'proves' is often the false conclusion we associate with the claim, anecdotal evidence is unreliable.
Okay, perhaps unreliable rather than useless.

Systematically collecting anecdotal evidence is indeed a far cry from saying a single anecdote proves anything.
We are on song. :)

But I was saying something different. One can draw some tentative conclusions from the anecdote. I explained what those were.

Think about it. It is pretty hard for any health care provider do a good patient assessment without the patient history. That history is anecdotal evidence. You learn to assess that anecdote, you don't always take it on face value.
Fair enough, it is becoming clearer what you mean.
I not sure, though, if a story pieced together out of a back and forth question and answer session qualifies as an anecdote.

Buyer beware applies to health care just as much as it applies to other products. Don't assume the product is good, verify that it is. And the better informed you are, the better health care you can acquire.
Oh well, maybe you are sufficiently informed and can make that assessment, but I doubt someone like, for example, Ivan ;) could.

regards,
BillyJoe
 
In case anyone doesn't believe there's hype, I saw a headline yesterday that said

Swine Flu Deaths Hit Double Digits in U.S.


That means, 10.
 
Hm. Media Hype. Just what kind of reporting on this is acceptable then? They are just typically reporting. I guess they should use a different standard for this type of news, but ask the reporters what they think about that. At least the WHO and the CDC don't use that "kind" of reporting on their websites. It's better to just expect better standards from those (WHO, CDC) sources I guess?
 
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5hG6zmXnY6v5La-llZ8qbQIrdE-WAD98BEP686

Many countries fear a pandemic declaration would trigger mass panic, and be economically and politically damaging. For developed countries that already have activated their pandemic preparedness plans, a pandemic declaration would change little in their response strategies.

Earlier this week, Britain and other countries urged WHO to reconsider its pandemic definition.

WHO hastily responded to these concerns, as Fukuda said the agency would revise the conditions needed to move from the current phase 5 to the highest level, phase 6, which makes it a pandemic.

"The countries are telling us now that moving from phase 5 to 6 is not so helpful," Fukuda said. He said the alert phases were developed before the outbreak hit, and now need to be adjusted to the reality of the situation.

The virus' lethality could become one of the required criteria before a pandemic is declared, Fukuda said.

I was wondering why it was still at 5....
 
I was wondering about the immune system.

Wouldn't exposure to an H1N1 virus, plus later, an H2N2, infer immunity to : H1N1, H2N2, H1N2, and H2N1?

Throw in a couple more flus over the years, and old folks would have lots of immmunity.

Aren't Hx and Nx receptor sites involved in transmission? Or are they only good for identification purposes?
 
I was wondering why it was still at 5....
It really underscores the point that while the science of epidemiology has made considerable advances in recent decades, the ability to track (much less predict) a virus like this one is still not very good, and a lot of the planning has yet to stand up to a real test. It also underscores the point that the WHO does not operate in a political or economic vacuum.
 
Wouldn't exposure to an H1N1 virus, plus later, an H2N2, infer immunity to : H1N1, H2N2, H1N2, and H2N1?

Well, it's a little more complicated than that, but yeah, some -- maybe. It's discussed in the Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report released today:
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/PDF/wk/mm5819.pdf

Aren't Hx and Nx receptor sites involved in transmission? Or are they only good for identification purposes?
Well, both. But the sites involved in transmission aren't necessarily the ones used in identification.
 
Last edited:
The virus' lethality could become one of the required criteria before a pandemic is declared, Fukuda said.
Seems sensible. PANDEMIC sounds so scary after all.

Dymanic: It also underscores the point that the WHO does not operate in a political or economic vacuum.
I'm not suggesting that you're suggesting otherwise but that seems sensible as well. After all they should be about trying to minimise harm. It there is a "pandemic" of a rather harmless virus, declaring a PANDEMIC may cause a lot of harm for essentially no good.

BJ
 
You and others have led me to believe that it's pointless learning about medicine unless you go to medical school and become a practitioner.

Now you're saying patients can be informed enough to question the reasoning and opinions of medical professionals they consult (except any of those on this forum, of course:)).

Make up your mind Skeptigirl!
This is a false dichotomy Ivor.
 
I was wondering about the immune system.

Wouldn't exposure to an H1N1 virus, plus later, an H2N2, infer immunity to : H1N1, H2N2, H1N2, and H2N1?

Throw in a couple more flus over the years, and old folks would have lots of immmunity.

Aren't Hx and Nx receptor sites involved in transmission? Or are they only good for identification purposes?
No, there are many subtypes within the H and N categories which result in our immune systems not recognizing a new flu strain.
 
I was wondering why it was still at 5....

Yes. In terms of its own system, there is a pandemic happening.

Seems sensible. PANDEMIC sounds so scary after all.

Maybe the next level could be "SUPER-PANDEMIC!" to cover a widespread disease which is also quite serious.

I'm not suggesting that you're suggesting otherwise but that seems sensible as well. After all they should be about trying to minimise harm. It there is a "pandemic" of a rather harmless virus, declaring a PANDEMIC may cause a lot of harm for essentially no good.

BJ

How harmless is it?

It seems to me that there must be a huge number of unidentified cases. The Jap volleyballer is reputed to have given it to 100 or so people, so it's obviously highly communicable.

It's also very mild, as evinced by people with very minor symptoms and no fever.

In those circumstances, it seems to me that it's probably already been pandemic for at least a couple of weeks, but the medical systems haven't seen the cases because most people will have written it off as a cold or other minor virus.

Using Japan as an exemplar, they have been screening for temperature - clearly people without fever will have passed the checkpoints and gone on to infect others. I have seen very few statements of symptoms shown by people who had the disease mildly, but most of the confirmed Kiwi cases were surprised they'd had any kind of influenza.

Is there any real doubt that millions of people are presently affected by the A-H1N1 virus, but just don't know it? Or am I reading this all wrong?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom