Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

http://www.haverford.edu/biology/edwards/disease/viral_essays/warnervirus.htm

While it was later discovered that the disease, called Legionnaire's Disease, was caused by a relatively unknown bacteria, and was in no way connected to swine flu, the press had already played its part.
Immediately, despite no evidence to support the claim, the connection was made in the media between the Legionnaires' Disease and swine flu.
This was enough public agitation to push necessary legislation through congress, allowing the NIIP to go forward.
While the press had helped to save the immunization program, it had done so using extravagant claims, and it might have proved useful if the NIIP had not survived at all. (Silverstein: 98-99, 106) Another example of sensationalism in the media occurred when a few days after the beginning of the immunization program three elderly people died at a vaccination station. Once again, while there was no evidence that the deaths were related to the vaccine, the press quickly exaggerated the story, creating an imagined "body-count" of vaccine victims. T
he hysteria that followed caused nine states to close down their immunization programs until the CDC announced decisively that the deaths were in no way connected to the vaccination. (Silverstein: 110-111) Judging from these incidents, it is not surprising that the press acted little differently when the actual connection between GBS and the vaccine was discovered. While the press can be slighted for its sensationalist portrayals of the immunization program, the leaders of the program should also be held responsible, for not creating a better relationship with the media, and not using this source as a way to educate the public about the program and influenza.
 
So, for the first time people were tracked after getting the vaccine in 1976. As usual, everything gets blamed on the vaccines even though the vaccine didn't cause the illnesses nor the deaths. The media, as usual, takes these reports and run with them, causing panic about the vaccines. Just history, that repeats itself even today, and no evidence the vaccine killed anyone. Legionnaire's Disease, standing in line with a bad heart, and other unrelated causes did kill people though.

As per the previously posted link by Deetee, GB is not worse amongst the vaccinated. Instead, this was the first time it was noted that (like surgery and the actual contraction of the flu) GB is not totally prevented by the vaccine. GB sucks, but surgery and vaccination must go on. Too bad there is no way to tell if you're at risk for GB, but whether you get the flu or the shot you'll still get it.

So, the fiasco with 1976 was the usual media blundering causing people to freak out about a vaccine. Also, it was a pandemic that didn't happen. Those two things, IMO, is what the "1976 swine flu fiasco" was.
 
The last summary of the 1976 flu vaccine that I read concluded that there was, on ther balance of probabilities, a increase above background levels in the number of GBS cases following the administration of the vaccine which turned out to be unnecessary.
 
The last summary of the 1976 flu vaccine that I read concluded that there was, on ther balance of probabilities, a increase above background levels in the number of GBS cases following the administration of the vaccine which turned out to be unnecessary.

This is largely correct. But I think the point cannot be ignored that infections can precipitate GBS. The problem is that vaccines, behaving in a similar fashion from the host's perspective, may also contribute to GBS.

The issue then becomes one of risk/benefit. If there was widespread vaccination for a disease that didn't happen (swine flu pandemic in 1976) we would expect to se a blip in GBS cases, because tens of thousands of people are put at minimal but not zero risk (of vaccine related GBS) in a short space of time. But had there been a swine flu pandemic, the number of cases of GBS caused by the flu would have likely been far greater. These are the risk assessments antivaxers also undertake (but in a twisted fashion) when they decide not to immunise their kids against say measles. They say the rsiks of getting the side effect outweigh the risk from the disease, but this is only true if there is no disease (because everyone vaccinates and keeps it at bay, whereas if noone vaccinated everyone would get it!)

So with the current flu pandemic we could predict that at least a quarter, maybe a third, of us will get it within the next 6 months. This means that many people will get GBS after getting flu infection. Vaccination, which might be targetted at say half the overall population, might give some recipients GBS, but probably less cases would occur overall. So if people use the 1976 experience (when there was no widespread flu pandemic) to argue against flu vax now, is misguided.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom