Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

Oy yeah. The quacks are just going to say he may have appeared healthy, but was full up with toxins from eating junk food and getting vaccines, so that is why the flu got im so bad. Shoulda used quacky products to detoxify and declog the immune system, yadda yadda.

So now I should read all those personal stories? :confused:
 
I can't believe some of the responses this article is getting
But here is an interesting one:


And Now a word from the ER Nurse


It is a well known fact that when men get sick, they all think they are going to die. He had the flu for goodness sake. The fever, mylagia,loss of appetite and lethargy are all part of it. As for the part about being admitted to the ICU, I can attest that if there are empty beds in an ICU and census is low, they will admit inappropriate patients to the unit to justify it's continued existance and prove the need for an ICU in a hospital. Suck it up Buttercup and stay away from the ER where you are only spreading the virus..


Oh well, she may be a little sexist, but I liked it :)
 
Well, okay, I have now read the article, but I have to tell you it was a complete waste of my time.

How do you decide what was real and what was exaggeration? He was sent home twice from a clinic. Were they wrong to do so? The patient says he felt like he was dying. His symptoms sound like those of a flu. Not surprising since he did have a flu. The hospital representative impies his case was mild. They admitted him to ICU for two days "which may not have been necessary" but "to be extra vigilant and to ensure the patient responded to treatment". They discharged him directly home from intensive care instead of recuperating him in the general ward.

So what are the lessons here.
For me there are exactly zero lessons in this little story.

BillyJoe
You get different information from different kinds of evidence. From that news story I was disturbed by a couple things.

First, I've seen plenty of corroborating evidence people are getting the wrong impression from the continual news accounts calling the infection mild, reporting every death as "someone with an underlying medical condition", discussing the virus as if it has now run its course and nothing came of it. Here was a family experiencing the misconception first hand.

That doesn't mean exaggerating the risk is the right answer. But Goldilocks can't seem to find the right temperature porridge here.

The second thing I found disturbing in the article was this comment:
And Now a word from the ER Nurse

It is a well known fact that when men get sick, they all think they are going to die. He had the flu for goodness sake. The fever, mylagia,loss of appetite and lethargy are all part of it. As for the part about being admitted to the ICU, I can attest that if there are empty beds in an ICU and census is low, they will admit inappropriate patients to the unit to justify it's continued existance and prove the need for an ICU in a hospital. Suck it up Buttercup and stay away from the ER where you are only spreading the virus..

Submitted by amonavis at 8:08 PM Sunday, May 17 2009
If this is indeed an ED nurse, and I have no reason to think it isn't, then this nurse's comment suggests incompetence. He/she seems rather ignorant of the capacity of the influenza virus to cause serious disease. This ignorance does not surprise me as I've seen it many times before. The nurse is suggesting no one with flu come to the ED. That is a dangerous comment and attitude.

One of the issues here is why did this man not get Tamiflu initially and why bother wasting it on him 12 days into his illness when all the evidence suggests it isn't likely to have any effect after the first 48 hours? There is one possibility. He had something else at first and got the flu later, maybe even during the first clinic visit.

The chronology:
he went to a walk-in clinic at Six Points Plaza in Etobicoke, where he says he was sent away with a seven-day supply of antibiotics.

But the 27-year-old's symptoms only worsened and 10 days later, on May 4, he went back to the clinic.....Extensive tests were done at the clinic but results weren't immediately available.

When, on May 6, he finally did go to Etobicoke General Hospital –...The hospital treated him for dehydration, and even gave him a spinal tap and a test for meningitis. He was put on the antiviral drug Tamiflu and given more antibiotics. For the pain – severe headaches, chest pain and general body aches – he got morphine.

After two nights in intensive care, he was sent home on May 8.

Two days later, Toronto public health called and informed him he had the notorious swine flu.

Did the first clinic misdiagnose him on Apr 24? Or is it possible he actually had something else and contracted the flu at the clinic or someplace else a few days later? That almost makes more sense given when the disease finally let up and when the culture was taken. You are not likely to still see a positive flu culture on day 10 and there are no tests for antibodies yet so a culture is all we have.

From the CDC web guide:
Specimens to be used with rapid tests generally should be collected as close as is possible to the start of symptoms and usually no more than 4-5 days later in adults. In very young children, influenza viruses can be shed for longer periods; therefore, in some instances, testing for a few days after this period may still be useful.
 
I also posted the following in the thread on the NYC death.

Here's an analysis on the contributing underlying medical conditions which the flu fatalities had in North America (predominantly Mexico).

Update. Influenza A (H1N1) Regional Report (16 May 2009) (PanAmerican Health Organization)
The median of the age was of 31 years old (range of 0-75), with a predominance of females (26 of 45 cases corresponding to 58%). The time elapsed from the onset of the symptoms up to the admission in the hospital had a median of 6 days (range 1-20) and to the time of the death of 10 days (range 2-33).

Approximately half of the dead cases were in previously healthy people 23/43 (53%). Preexisting conditions were present in 20 of the 43 cases studied (46%). The most frequent underlying condition was morbid obesity, no insulin-dependent diabetes, systemic hypertension, or a combination of the above in 12 of the 20 cases (60%). One of the dead cases was pregnant with 34 weeks of gestation that finished prematurely in caesarean section, with survival of the newborn. With regard to the administered treatments, 27 of 45 (61%) received antivirals: Oseltamivir (19), Amantadine (6), and Zanamivir (2). The median between the symptom onset and the administration of this treatment was of 8 days (range 1-26); 69% (27/39) of the patients received support with mechanical ventilation.

Most of the cases arrived with multiple complications, being the most frequent syndrome of acute pulmonary respiratory insufficiency in 27/45 (60%) and renal failure or multiple organ failure in 11/45 (24%). Bacterial co-infection was registered only in 3/45 cases. Finally, the most frequent diagnosis on death certificates was atypical pneumonia in 49%, followed by syndrome of acute respiratory insufficiency in 33%.
 
Here's a sad prequel to the NYC death.

Assistant Principal's Family Blasts City
Adam Weiner: Dad Had No Pre-Existing Medical Conditions...

His wife, who also works at IS 238, earlier said her husband urged the principal, Mr. Gates, to close the school last week. ...

Outside Flushing Hospital, Mitchell Weiner's 23-year-old son disputed news reports that his father's health was compromised by diabetes.

"First of all, he has no preexisting that would ... the only diabetes is myself. He doesn't have diabetes. He had gout a year ago," Adam Weiner said.
 
Yahoo News: Japan closes 2,000 schools as swine flu spreads
Authorities said the real number of infections could already be in the hundreds with the virus spreading fast in the densely populated island nation.

The Japanese outbreak increases the chance the World Health Organization may raise its pandemic alert level to six -- the top level which would indicate sustained community transmission in a second region outside the Americas.

Experts in Japan now believe the virus spread quickly between the two urban areas after high schools from Kobe and Osaka met for a volleyball tournament, with some players and coaches feeling feverish after the games.

"We have to contain this in the region, but it is becoming very difficult," said Toshizo Ido, governor of Hyogo Prefecture, which includes Kobe....

... In Kobe, many office workers, shop staff and public transport officials were wearing masks on the first working day since the outbreak hit the city. Public health announcements were broadcast via train station loudspeakers.

Hotel manager Kotaro Takeda said: "We have received more than 120 cancellations, mostly because of the influenza. We are concerned that groundless rumours may affect our business further."...

...No cases have yet been reported in greater Tokyo, which with almost 36 million people is the world's most populous urban area.

Japan's first confirmed cases of swine flu were four people who tested positive after they flew in from the United States earlier this month. They were immediately quarantined along with about 50 fellow passengers.
 
But Goldilocks can't seem to find the right temperature porridge here.
My only point was that we are unlikely to get the temperature right by reading at stories about personal experiences.

This particular story may have been accurate, but it may just as easily have been an exaggeration, and there is at least some conflicting evidence from other sources about the severity of the illness.

If this is indeed an ED nurse,

My mistake, perhaps, but the headline: "And Now a word from the ER Nurse" (my emphasis) lead me to believe this particular nurse was in attendance upon this patient (perhaps that is unlikely when I think about it). And I didn't mean to imply her account was accurate because she could just as easily have exaggerated in the opposite direction, but it did sound funny against the "near death" account by the patient.

The upshot is that I find these stories pretty useless.

Did the first clinic misdiagnose him on Apr 24? Or is it possible he actually had something else and contracted the flu at the clinic or someplace else a few days later?

Well, that's the point, isn't it. How do you know if any of the details given by the patient are accurate. He could certainly have exaggerated his symptoms, and his lack of knowledge could easily have caused him to misinterpret things.

Sexist and ignorant.
Unless she was commenting about her knowledge of this particular case and then it depends on how accurately she reported it.
 
The upshot is that I find these stories pretty useless.
I find about ninety percent of what appears in mainstream media to be pretty useless. But the fact that a thing like this is considered newsworthy might be considered newsworthy in itself. New York City saw more than thirty thousand deaths during the Spanish flu pandemic. As long as a single death is still national news, things could be a lot worse.

What would be useful would be stories about people with mild illness. I'm particularly interested in how many of these there are in northern and central California. I'm picturing headlines like:

"Sacramento Man Misses a Couple Days Work Due To Slight Fever"
 
So now I should read all those personal stories? :confused:
Nah. Just saying that some people will say that if you "live right" (use their quacky products and take their quacky advice), then the flu won't kill you. They don't agree that the flu will kill a totally healthy individual unless they are doing something wrong. This just points to their ignorance about microbes.
 
That's a given.

Because of the unknown nature of this particular strain, the death of a healthy person has the potential to be Patient One of a nastier version. t's one reason officials try and track back to original source....

Serious Virus'

During today's joint news conference, a reporter asked why officials are so concerned about the new flu virus, given the fact that normal seasonal flu kills an average of 36,000 people in the U.S. during a typical flu season.

The reason is that it's a new, unpredictable virus that "has pandemic potential," Fauci replied. "It really is something different."
"This is a serious virus, this is a serious outbreak," Besser agreed.

"You don't know if it's going to fizzle out in a couple weeks or become more or less virulent or severe in the diseases it causes," Besser said. "If we could see into the future, that would be wonderful. But that's not the case.

Contained.....a new variation could be doused before it spreads ( as SARS was at great expense )....the ONLY way to to do it is vigilance where a death of an otherwise healthy person is concerned.

There are simply too many unknowns
 
In Japan

WHO Stays the Course as Japan Grapples With Swine Flu

By Dennis Normile
ScienceNOW Daily News
18 May 2009

The number of confirmed influenza A (H1N1) cases in Japan exploded over the weekend, going from an officially reported four--all in returning vacationers--on 16 May to 129 as of today. The 125 new cases are all among high-school students in Osaka and Kobe, two neighboring cities in western Japan. None of these cases has yet been linked to a returning traveler. Japanese media, citing their own surveys of local health offices, are reporting 135 confirmed cases as of late afternoon, Japan time. Despite the surge, the World Health Organization (WHO) hasn't yet raised its pandemic alert level to indicate that a global pandemic is under way. "What we're seeing now is not the trigger for phase 6," says Peter Cordingley, spokesperson for WHO's Western Pacific Regional Office in Manila.

more

http://sciencenow.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/2009/518/1
 
My only point was that we are unlikely to get the temperature right by reading at stories about personal experiences.

This particular story may have been accurate, but it may just as easily have been an exaggeration, and there is at least some conflicting evidence from other sources about the severity of the illness.
That may be true for many people. I'm looking at the anecdotes for a different kind of evidence than what you are referring to. And posting in this thread is not limited to listing the evidence the public checks the porridge temperature by.



My mistake, perhaps, but the headline: "And Now a word from the ER Nurse" (my emphasis) lead me to believe this particular nurse was in attendance upon this patient (perhaps that is unlikely when I think about it). And I didn't mean to imply her account was accurate because she could just as easily have exaggerated in the opposite direction, but it did sound funny against the "near death" account by the patient.
We both filtered the post with different biases. You saw "the nurse" and interpreted that to be a first hand account. I saw "ED nurse" and thought of all the 'think-they-know-more-than-they-do' ED nurses I've encountered in my career.



The upshot is that I find these stories pretty useless.
They are useful for some things and useless for others. Medical research includes a lot of anecdotal evidence.



Well, that's the point, isn't it. How do you know if any of the details given by the patient are accurate. He could certainly have exaggerated his symptoms, and his lack of knowledge could easily have caused him to misinterpret things.
You learn from research and experience how to judge the validity of patient histories. Of course, not being able to directly interview the patient means you have to speculate quite a bit.

Dates were given. That tends to be more accurate than generalizations of time periods. There's no reason to think the story is totally made up, so I think it's safe to believe the ICU admission occurred and the diagnosis from the culture. And the window one would see a positive flu culture is pretty well established with exceptions for specific cases like kids and immunocompromised patients can shed virus longer.

I wouldn't believe the ED nurse's statement on face value that patients are admitted to the ICU simply because beds are empty. If it mattered, I'd look further into that claim to verify if it were true or not.

As for the patient's description of how much pain he was in, meh... I take that with a grain of salt but the ICU admission suggests he was at least moderately ill, and maybe severely ill if the ED nurse's claim is one of personal bias more than valid observation.

So by this kind of process, one can evaluate an anecdote such as the story here.



Unless she was commenting about her knowledge of this particular case and then it depends on how accurately she reported it.
It is ignorant to make a statement influenza is nothing to worry about. Whether guys are wimps when it comes to flu symptoms is another story. ;)
 
That may be true for many people. I'm looking at the anecdotes for a different kind of evidence than what you are referring to. And posting in this thread is not limited to listing the evidence the public checks the porridge temperature by.
Horses for courses then.

We both filtered the post with different biases. You saw "the nurse" and interpreted that to be a first hand account. I saw "ED nurse" and thought of all the 'think-they-know-more-than-they-do' ED nurses I've encountered in my career.
I am happy to be on an equal footing. :cool:

They are useful for some things and useless for others. Medical research includes a lot of anecdotal evidence.
Really?
No, I mean I'm asking, because I thought anecdotal evidence was close to an oxymoron if not actually so.

You learn from research and experience how to judge the validity of patient histories. Of course, not being able to directly interview the patient means you have to speculate quite a bit.
Well, I'm thinking that the amount of speculation I would have to do would make any conclusions I would draw from them pretty close to useless, if not totally useless.

Dates were given. That tends to be more accurate than generalizations of time periods. There's no reason to think the story is totally made up, so I think it's safe to believe the ICU admission occurred and the diagnosis from the culture. And the window one would see a positive flu culture is pretty well established with exceptions for specific cases like kids and immunocompromised patients can shed virus longer.
I was happy accept all that when I read this story.

I wouldn't believe the ED nurse's statement on face value that patients are admitted to the ICU simply because beds are empty. If it mattered, I'd look further into that claim to verify if it were true or not.
Fair enough. I wonder why the nurse would make that statement if it was not true, at least in her experience. And it sort of passes the smell test - patient who thinks he's dying gets bed in ICU only because there was one vacant and on the understanding that if they get a real patient he will be pushed out quick smart. But I don't know if this actually happens.

As for the patient's description of how much pain he was in, meh... I take that with a grain of salt but the ICU admission suggests he was at least moderately ill, and maybe severely ill if the ED nurse's claim is one of personal bias more than valid observation.
There was also the hospital spokesman in the main article who implied that his case was mild - they admitted him to ICU for two days "which may not have been necessary" but "to be extra vigilant and to ensure the patient responded to treatment". And I wonder how often a seriously ill patient would go straight home from ICU?

So by this kind of process, one can evaluate an anecdote such as the story here.
Well, perhaps you are in a stronger position than I am.

It is ignorant to make a statement influenza is nothing to worry about. Whether guys are wimps when it comes to flu symptoms is another story. ;)
Twenty years ago I had the flu which kept me to bed for five days. My wife still makes fun of that episode.
(On the other hand giving birth couldn't be more uncomfortable than delivering a constipated stool could it? :cool:)

BillyJoe
 
Swine flu finally hits Australia....

...in fact in my home state of Victoria:

http://www.theage.com.au/national/swine-flu-three-brothers-test-positive-20090520-bf2q.html

Two brothers have joined their younger sibling in testing positive for swine flu, taking the number of confirmed cases in Victoria to three
All three boys remain at home where they are getting the care that they need because they are not ill enough to be hospitalised,
Most parents spoken to seem to be unconcerned believing the swine flu threat to be a media beat up.

BJ
 
...
Really?
No, I mean I'm asking, because I thought anecdotal evidence was close to an oxymoron if not actually so....
That's a big misconception among skeptics.

Anecdotal evidence collected systematically using controls to tease out the variable you want to test makes up a huge proportion of medical research. How would you test a pain medicine if not for anecdotal evidence? You can check range of motion and other objective measures, but subjective measures are very important.

There are many examples besides pain relief.

It isn't the anecdote that is the problem. It's how you draw conclusions from the data where the errors occur.

I'll have to get to the rest of your post later.
 
anecdotal evidence

what do you think an eye witness account in a murder trial is..?..:garfield:
It's only one person....

It's drawing broad conclusions from low incidence accounts without controls where the problem arises.

Hypothesis in science arise from systematically studying the original anecdotal bits of evidence and them purveying that into a testable theory.

It's part of a spectrum -

Drawing conclusions from insufficient base is where the problem occurs.
 
It seems to me that the cat is out of the bag and this will go phase 6 in the not so distant future.
[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/30/Influenza-2009-cases.png[/qimg]

Wouldn't it be more meaningful for this graph to be logarithmic?

They are now using a logarithmic scale:
Influenza-2009-cases-logarithmic.png
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom