Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

Won't it be too late for a vaccine by the time one gets developed and tested?
I doubt it. I suspect we'll be seeing this new strain for a couple years. On average (with a broad range) it takes about 18 months to see flu virus genetically drift enough to be replaced by the resulting offspring.

And what about this:
http://www.cbc.ca/health/story/2009/05/12/swine-flu-evolution.html


I think it is a bunch of hooey, but just read the comments this story is generating.
No one is totally dismissing it yet even though most people doubt the case is there to be made.
 
Over 4600 cases in the U.S now, three New York schools closed. With all the media generated panic about the first very few cases, I'm surprised they haven't done a running tally. If it gets exponential then we may have a problem.
There was also a news report one of the principals in one of the schools was on a ventilator and there is an additional death in one of the SW states. I am waiting for more reports.
 
Another NewScientist jewel of loose speculation. :rolleyes:

This virus has many months before it will have run its course. And there will be many people who avoid infection due to diligence and Tamiflu prophylaxis that will be left to benefit from the more permanent solution of a vaccine.


We'll have vaccine in about 4-5 months if no major hurdles occur.

Yahoo News: Swine flu set to spread: WHO
Pharmaceuticals giant GlaxoSmithKline meanwhile said they would start developing nearly 130 million doses of a vaccine for France, Belgium, Britain and Finland as soon as the WHO had provided the "virus seed" -- a medical breakdown of the new disease.

Britain's health ministry said they had also reached agreement with US drugs manufacturer Baxter to develop a vaccine before any pandemic begins.

Baxter said it was working with virus strains provided by the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to produce a vaccine.
 
GSK has evidently made its decision.

Not quite sure what this means:

"Glaxo will provide as many as 128 million doses for the European countries, and is in talks with “quite a few” other governments"

As far as I can tell, that has to be about the extent of their present capacity, so those talks must consist mainly of them explaining to those other governments why they won't be able to take their orders.
Where do you find information Glaxo is limited to 130 million dose capacity?

GSK press release
In clinical studies using the H5N1 influenza strain, an adjuvanted formulation has been shown to stimulate a higher immune response while using a smaller amount of antigen as compared to a formulation without adjuvant. The adjuvant system therefore helps to increase the number of vaccine doses that can be produced....

... * These include:
o Supplying the UK Government with 60 million doses of the candidate A (H1N1) adjuvanted influenza vaccine.
o The French Government intend to purchase 50 million doses of the candidate A (H1N1) influenza vaccine.
o The Government of Belgium intend to purchase 12.6 million doses of the candidate A (H1N1) influenza vaccine in order to stockpile and to protect, when needed, the total Belgian population.
o An agreement with the Government of Finland to supply 5.3 million doses of H1N1 antigen, which is expected to be used in conjunction with the government’s existing stockpile of GSK’s adjuvant system.
* GSK has made substantial investments to expand capacity for its adjuvant system. As part of the company’s commitment to maximising global manufacturing capacity of a pandemic vaccine, GSK is ready to engage in discussions with companies and governmental agencies that can combine the adjuvant system with alternatively sourced antigen.
* GSK is committed to addressing the needs of developing countries with use of this candidate adjuvanted vaccine. GSK will convert its intended donation to the WHO of 50 million doses of H5N1 pre-pandemic vaccine to the new candidate A (H1N1) adjuvanted influenza vaccine once production begins.
* In the future, as capacity increases, GSK will supply the candidate A (H1N1) adjuvantedinfluenza vaccine to developing countries under a tiered-pricing policy based on World Bank classifications and GAVI eligibility.

Seasonal influenza vaccine
GSK will continue to produce its seasonal influenza vaccine for the 2009/2010 Northern Hemisphere influenza season as planned and expects to complete production of this vaccine by the end of July. The company also continues to supply seasonal vaccine for use in the Southern Hemisphere as it enters the winter season this year.
 
It will take a year for all the necessary vaccine to be manufactured.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/may/15/uk-swine-flu-vaccine-doses
With half ready by Dec.
We have advance purchase agreements to provide vaccine for the entire UK population which will take effect when phase six pandemic is declared.

"It will then take over a year for all the vaccine necessary to be provided.

"These additional arrangements provide the opportunity by December this year to have enough pre-pandemic vaccine to protect at least half of the population from swine flu."
 
Yep, the principal in the NY school is actually an assistant principal and he/she is reportedly in critical condition. There was a new death in Phoenix, a woman in her 40s, and now another death, a man in his 30s in TX.

It's only the beginning.

Arizona H1N1 swine flu cases jump to 435; Phoenix-area woman dies

U.S. logs fifth H1N1 swine flu death, in Texas

Swine Flu Outbreak Shuts Down 3 Schools
New York City has closed three schools in response to a swine flu outbreak that has left an assistant principal in critical condition and sent hundreds of children home with flu symptoms, in a flare-up of the virus that caused such concern around the world last month.

Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg (I) said four students and the assistant principal have documented cases of the H1N1 flu at a Queens middle school. More than 50 students at the school have gone home sick with flulike symptoms, he said. At another Queens middle school, 241 students were absent Thursday. Dozens more were sick at an elementary school.

The health department said the assistant principal from the Susan B. Anthony middle school is on a ventilator, marking the most severe illness in the city from swine flu to date.
 
Where do you find information Glaxo is limited to 130 million dose capacity?
My choice of words there ("as far as I can tell") was intended to convey a degree of uncertainty, as I am unable to find recent information on GKS's current capacity. But unless there have been significant developments since the publication of these two news articles, 130 million doses is probably being generous:

"Construction of a second facility at the site is scheduled to begin in August 2005. Production will then commence in February 2008. The second unit will increase its annual production capacity from 30 million influenza vaccine doses per year currently, to 60 million doses annually before the end of this decade."
http://www.in-pharmatechnologist.com/Industry-Drivers/GSK-to-double-flu-vaccine-production-capacity

"GSK said the facility "will be used to help develop the next generation of vaccines," particularly in the influenza field. This is the latest in a series of investments in the vaccines filed at GSK, which last month said it was double production of flu vaccines at its Dresden, Germany manufacturing facility."
http://www.in-pharmatechnologist.com/Industry-Drivers/GSK-invests-further-in-flu-vaccine-capacity
 
Oh well, he lived, and the virus gave him fifteen seconds of fame, so what's he compalining about. And come Winter, he'll likely have at least some degree of immunity.
 
Oh well, he lived, and the virus gave him fifteen seconds of fame, so what's he compalining about.
If he wasn't complaining, he wouldn't have gotten five seconds of fame. There doesn't appear to be a shortage of people who would say "Yeah, I got it, but it was no big deal" -- there's simply a shortage of reporters interested in interviewing them.

And come Winter, he'll likely have at least some degree of immunity.
Sounds like there's a fair chance that he may have paid for it with at least some degree of permanent lung damage.
 
The take away is ........we don't know and it's erratic.
That was the horrid feature of the 1918 strain - how badly it hammered the young and healthy.

Often dead with 48 hours.....there is good reason to keep wary eye on this critter.
 
Sorry, Dympanic, my answer was not totally serious.

But I don't think personal stories help us much. They're more likely to emotionalise our responses which should rather be based on a critical analysis of the facts.

BJ
 
The take away is ...we don't know and it's erratic...there is good reason to keep wary eye on this critter.


From here:
http://www.theage.com.au/world/swine-flu-will-spread-further-across-world-who-20090516-b6cj.html

WHO Director-General Margaret Chan noted the virus had "quickly demonstrated its capacity to spread easily from one person to another, to spread widely within an affected country and to spread rapidly to additional countries". "We expect this pattern of international spread to continue," she said.
"This is a time of great uncertainty, and great pressure on governments, ministries of health and WHO.

BJ
 
But I don't think personal stories help us much.

ALL variations start with Patient One.

An old infirm patient dying of the flu does not help us much.

A young healthy person in a first world nation with a knee jerk over the top response to the threat ( due to SARS experience ) suffering severely is a very troubling scenario......even if 1% suffer this way the potential deaths in the young and fit are enormous and very costly to society.

This has a been a worrying feature of this variation - the outsized impact on the young who should shrug it off.

Too many unknowns - if it's mild why the hammer on the young ....sometimes. :con2:

I have a diabetic type One kid with obvioulsy compromised immune system...
If I now know a fully healthy kid not much older has a severe case about 30 km from here......you think just maybe I'm not better informed about potential risk....?

You think maybe I might keep him home if there is any evidence of an outbreak in his school??

Even one case where there are no other complicating factors and a young person with a normal immune system suffers badly is very informative.
 
I think it is sufficient to know that a young healthy person got a flu bad enough to end up in ICU.
I don't think we need to read his detailed personal story.
 
That's what draws the attention to it...a bland statistic does not.

It's also an indicator of potential course of events.
How did the medical community respond etc.
What was the patient's perception

You are always welcome NOT to read articles....:garfield:
 
Okay, I give up...

....you read up all the personal experiences you can find and I'll go with the statistics. ;)

BJ
 
No I'll go with both - by the time statistics catch up the window for personal action may well have closed.

A particular fire is just a statistic eventually as well....if it's next door you don't wait :garfield:
 
I think it is sufficient to know that a young healthy person got a flu bad enough to end up in ICU.
I don't think we need to read his detailed personal story.
Oy yeah. The quacks are just going to say he may have appeared healthy, but was full up with toxins from eating junk food and getting vaccines, so that is why the flu got im so bad. Shoulda used quacky products to detoxify and declog the immune system, yadda yadda.
 
No I'll go with both - by the time statistics catch up the window for personal action may well have closed.

A particular fire is just a statistic eventually as well....if it's next door you don't wait :garfield:

Well, okay, I have now read the article, but I have to tell you it was a complete waste of my time.

How do you decide what was real and what was exaggeration? He was sent home twice from a clinic. Were they wrong to do so? The patient says he felt like he was dying. His symptoms sound like those of a flu. Not surprising since he did have a flu. The hospital representative impies his case was mild. They admitted him to ICU for two days "which may not have been necessary" but "to be extra vigilant and to ensure the patient responded to treatment". They discharged him directly home from intensive care instead of recuperating him in the general ward.

So what are the lessons here.
For me there are exactly zero lessons in this little story.

BillyJoe
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom