Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

Regarding the WHO definition of pandemic, has there actually been a pandemic since those definitions were, er, defined? Or since the WHO has existed, for that matter?

On the one hand, it does seem a bit silly for them to be changing the definitions as they go. But on the other, if this is the first time the definitions, response levels and so on have actually been put to the test, isn't it quite likely that they may be found to be flawed? It's one thing to change the definitions because of political wranglings, but it's another to change them because you've realised that blindly following them the first time they're tested in the field would lead to an massive overreaction, panic and likely a substantial drop in trust in the future.
 
I guess, that by last week's definition and this week's numbers, the Swine Flu Pandemic is just about as deadly as the Sniffles Pandemic.
 
On the one hand, it does seem a bit silly for them to be changing the definitions as they go. But on the other, if this is the first time the definitions, response levels and so on have actually been put to the test, isn't it quite likely that they may be found to be flawed?
That nicely sums up where I presently stand on the matter.

The WHO does not operate in a political or economic vacuum, and the political and economic factors associated with a major epidemiological event have just as much potential for impacting public health as do the direct effects of the pathogen itself. What's interesting is that in pressuring the WHO not to go to phase six, the countries doing that seem to be saying: "Our response to a declaration of phase six is locked in; since our planning does not allow enough flexibility on the response end, we need the WHO to be flexible on the declaration end".

It's pretty simply, really: Everybody wants somebody else to take responsibility for the really difficult decisions.
 
Full credit to the WHO which has done the sensible thing in the circumstances.
 
Skeptigirl earlier likened this to a fire spreading. Not every spark will take hold, and you can stamp them out as they happen, but eventually something's going to catch.

There's definitely transmission in the community in Scotland now, with small outbreaks in two west coast towns - Greenock and Dunoon (they are linked by two regular ferry services). Although they say the sudden jump in the figures is due to the introduction of a faster testing system, so a backlog has all happened at once.

So far mostly mild illness though. One serious, though that patient is reported to have other health issues as well.

Rolfe.
 
Suspected Cases: 1043
Confirmed Cases: 11053
Fatal Cases: 18
Negative Cases: 8
This is an aggregate data point for United States.

Remember all the hype about the first few cases, and the first two deaths? It continues, and I'm rather surprised the 10K mark was not even acknowledged by the media (as far as I know.)
The number of new cases may have peaked in the US so that is one reason the press has lost interest.

http://www.cdc.gov/flu/weekly/
 
I guess, that by last week's definition and this week's numbers, the Swine Flu Pandemic is just about as deadly as the Sniffles Pandemic.
And the concept of, it ain't over yet, continues to elude people.

As the cases may be subsiding here, they are just beginning to increase in the southern hemisphere which is entering its seasonal flu season. And our flu season is still a few months away.
 
...
So far mostly mild illness though. One serious, though that patient is reported to have other health issues as well.

Rolfe.
The press for whatever reason just cannot let go of that other health issues claim. Fully half of the fatalities have been in otherwise healthy people. I'm not sure if the misinformation is coming from the health department reports or if the news people are ignoring the fact that in an adult population you could find a health issue with about 90% of the population if you use the most minor problems in your definition.
 
There is a general trend to compare any out breaks of any disease to the Spanish Flu outbreak of 90 years ago. But was that pandemic so unusual? Or was it just that by that point in time our world wide communication got fast enough for people to notice it? as in "Hey, this time it's not just our little village where "the Gripe" is deadly. It's affecting the whole world".

And, at that point in time, fast travel was becoming ubiquitous. Trains and steamers allowed the spread germs much faster. So fast as to make everybody in the world exposed in a year or two, rather than spreading the exposure out, time wise.

So, these modern "pandemics' are only visible due to the speed of exposure, and world wide communication of the news. Like the saying "All politics is local", all sickness only affects a single patient? But when there are many single patients all over, the modern communications makes it a noticeable "Pandemic" ?

Did I say that the whole world used to get the same kind of pandemics, but it used to take years? Where as today, it only takes weeks? And we can see the pandemics? So, nothing new on the virulence front, except speed? Or did I confuse everybody? myself included?
 
So, these modern "pandemics' are only visible due to the speed of exposure, and world wide communication of the news. Like the saying "All politics is local", all sickness only affects a single patient? But when there are many single patients all over, the modern communications makes it a noticeable "Pandemic" ?

I think the speed of exposure is the important point that you're not giving enough weight. It's not that that makes the pandemic visible, it's what makes a pandemic possible in the first place. I think there are two important aspects. Firstly, people actually visit other places more. A flu outbreak in Britain wouldn't have spread to America at all in, say, 1300, because no-one travelled between the two.

Secondly, the speed of travel between two places is also very important. If you have to spend a couple of months sailing to India, Africa, America or wherever, anyone with a serious disease will either have recovered or be dead long before they arrive, so the disease is very unlikely to spread. It's only since the advent of relatively fast steamers and then later air travel that has allowed people to travel between places while still contagious. The only diseases that managed to be pandemic before that were mostly things like the plague which could be spread by healthy people carrying rats with them rather than by the people themselves.

So no. Pandemics aren't just visible because of modern communication, they exist because of modern travel.

That said, AIDS may well be an exception here, as would any other disease that takes so long to kill people while still being contagious.
 
Sorry for the confusion caused by removing a spammer's posts - see: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=144477 & http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=144482 .I've moved the posts caused by that action to AAH - no one did anything wrong it's just to keep this thread on-topic!
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
Now it makes sense. I thought my memory was slipping about the post order.
 
There is a general trend to compare any out breaks of any disease to the Spanish Flu outbreak of 90 years ago. But was that pandemic so unusual?
YES!

Or was it just that by that point in time our world wide communication got fast enough for people to notice it? as in "Hey, this time it's not just our little village where "the Gripe" is deadly. It's affecting the whole world".

And, at that point in time, fast travel was becoming ubiquitous. Trains and steamers allowed the spread germs much faster. So fast as to make everybody in the world exposed in a year or two, rather than spreading the exposure out, time wise.
While troop movement at the end of WW1 contributed to the spread of the 1918 flu, the virus itself was considerably more lethal than the usual flu strains. It wiped out whole villages in Alaska when it got there. Seasonal flu doesn't do that.

So, these modern "pandemics' are only visible due to the speed of exposure, and world wide communication of the news. Like the saying "All politics is local", all sickness only affects a single patient? But when there are many single patients all over, the modern communications makes it a noticeable "Pandemic" ?

Did I say that the whole world used to get the same kind of pandemics, but it used to take years? Where as today, it only takes weeks? And we can see the pandemics? So, nothing new on the virulence front, except speed? Or did I confuse everybody? myself included?
Sorry, this is a bad hypothesis based on a poor understanding of the science.
 
Well, it looks like this thread's OP finally has an answer: yes. End of thread. Swine masks to the ready!
 
Last edited:
I heard that in Egypt the government is using this H1N1 viral illness as an excuse to kill all the pigs in the country, even though they aren't confirming that any of the pigs there are spreading the disease to humans. This will hurt non-muslims who have pig farms.

http://story.canadastandard.com/index.php/ct/9/cid/e974f944f2e7496e/id/495641/cs/1/

Cheap shot.

And yeah, far more people are killed by the regular seasonal flu bug, so why all the fuss about this flu bug?

I want to rant about the usual stupid media tunnel vision, but the WHO and CDC are also making a big deal out of it.

Well now they've apparently just about killed every pig in the country, literally.

Egypt hunts last pigs as three new swine flu cases confirmed
Cairo - As the number of confirmed cases of the A(H1N1), or swine flu, virus continued to climb in Egypt, the government vowed to redouble its efforts to hunt down the country's last surviving pigs. Assistant Health Minister Nasr al-Sayid on Friday confirmed three new cases of the disease, which the World Health Organization on Thursday labelled a global pandemic.

There is a silver lining to this madness, however. There is a fair amount of bird flu circulating in Egypt right now. Eliminating the potential pigs as mixing vessels is not all bad.
 
Last edited:
The public response to the declaration of the pandemic has been underwhelming.

Here in Victoria an expert has calculated that 1 in 3 have had or have swine flu. They stopped closing schools a few weeks ago. Recently routine swabbing of suspect cases has stopped. Any student with flu like symptoms is quaranteened for three days, but unaffected sibs can still attend school. Same for the general public. Tamiflu is reserved for patients with special risks like chronic disease or pregnancy. It seems that soon it will reduce to the same status as the seasonal flu.

But, as yet, there have been no deaths.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom