Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

I'm not suggesting that you're suggesting otherwise but that seems sensible as well.
I wouldn't have suggested that you were suggesting that I was suggesting otherwise, but I agree.

The reluctance to raise the alert level from three to four looked to me like timidity. Modifying the pandemic phase criteria on the fly seemed like a dodge. But now that it's a question of raising it from five to six, my view has changed. The WHO continues to take a very methodical approach, but they are doing so in a suitably flexible way. If that means making adjustments to methods and definitions that were designed before this virus emerged, then so be it; it does make better sense to do that than it would to cling rigidly to assumptions made questionable by a virus that keeps throwing one curve ball after another.
 
...
Is there any real doubt that millions of people are presently affected by the A-H1N1 virus, but just don't know it? Or am I reading this all wrong?
I think we are definitely in the tens of thousands and maybe in the hundreds of thousands. I'm not sure we are in the millions yet.
 
W.H.O. to Rewrite Rules for Declaring a Pandemic
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/23/health/policy/23who.html?_r=1&ref=global-home

snip
Dr. Keiji Fukuda, the deputy director general making the W.H.O. announcement, said that he could not predict exactly what the new rules would be but that criteria would include a “substantial risk of harm to people,” not just the geographic spread of a relatively benign virus. The six-point system was created in 2005 when the threat was H5N1 avian flu, which has a fatality rate of about 60 percent.

But the system does not take into account a virus’s lethality, and in the current outbreak, some countries have complained that the warning system created panic and pressure for border closings, even though the strain was less deadly.
 
Last edited:
Well, it's a little more complicated than that, but yeah, some -- maybe. It's discussed in the Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report released today:
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/PDF/wk/mm5819.pdf

Well, both. But the sites involved in transmission aren't necessarily the ones used in identification.

I can't cut-n-paste from a PDF, but basically, 1/3 of older adults >60 have some immunity to A-H1N1. This years seasonal vaccine doubles the immunity of adults in the 18-60 age group, from 6-9%. Doesn't help those over 64. (typo?)I'd say that is appreciable, but they don't. Doesn't do much for children, which makes me wonder if cross-reactive immunity is a requirement in all flu vaccines? Ought we give maaaaany vaccines to children?
 
I can't cut-n-paste from a PDF
Try highlighting (selecting) the text you want and copying it to your clipboard with Ctrl+Insert.

but basically, 1/3 of older adults >60 have some immunity to A-H1N1
There are basically two approaches to estimating the degree of immunity. The top-down approach is to look for demographic trends in the epidemiological data. Will we see an increase in cases (or serious cases) among older adults once the virus has penetrated deeper into populations? Unknown at this point. The bottom-up approach is to extrapolate from serological data. Does a given degree of cross-reactive antibody response indicate a given degree of protective immunity? And does the sample group fairly represent corresponding segments of the population at large? Judgement calls.

Wouldn't it be something if it turned out that those vaccinated for swine flu in 1976 got immunity to this virus out of the deal?
 
I can't cut-n-paste from a PDF, ...
Why not? A few of them are copy protected but most aren't.

The results indicated that before vaccination, no cross-reactive antibody to the novel influenza A (H1N1) virus existed among children. Among adults, before vaccination, cross-reactive antibody was detected in 6%–9% of those aged 18–64 years and in 33% of those aged >60 years. Previous vaccination of children with any of four seasonal trivalent, inactivated influenza vaccines (TIV) or with live, attenuated influenza vaccine (LAIV) did not elicit a cross-reactive antibody response to the novel influenza A (H1N1) virus. Among adults, vaccination with seasonal TIV resulted in a twofold increase in cross-reactive antibody response to the novel influenza A (H1N1) virus among those aged 18–64 years, compared with a twelvefold to nineteenfold increase in cross-reactive antibody response to the seasonal H1N1 strain; no increase in cross-reactive antibody response to the novel influenza A (H1N1) virus was observed among adults aged >60 years.



Doesn't do much for children, which makes me wonder if cross-reactive immunity is a requirement in all flu vaccines? Ought we give maaaaany vaccines to children?
There is some truth to that. For kids under 9, we give 2 doses of flu vaccine the first year they are vaccinated for the very reason you suggest. After age 9, most never vaccinated kids have had at least one natural infection with influenza. That primes the pump for future vaccine boosters.
 
Last edited:
The H1N1 virus responsible for the 1918 flu pandemic continued to circulate in the population until 1957, when an H2N2 virus displaced it, he said.

"Thus, the first experience with influenza for most individuals born between 1918 and 1957 would have been with H1N1," he said. Those people are now between 52 and 91 years old.

If that previous exposure provided residual protection against the new swine flu virus, as observations seem to support, "there may well be some degree of protection sufficient, at least, to prevent serious illness in a significant proportion" of the population, he said.
http://abcnews.go.com/Health/SwineFluNews/story?id=7647943&page=1

Old guys rule!



How many times does the WHO have to cry "wolf" before they are not believed at all?
 
How many times does the WHO have to cry "wolf" before they are not believed at all?


You have just committed a sin.
As penance you must read all 450 posts in this thread and the 11 page transcript of Friday's WHO press conference.
After that you might just be up to speed

Now go away and sin no more.

God bless,
Fr BillyJoe
 
Last edited:
....



How many times does the WHO have to cry "wolf" before they are not believed at all?
If you think the WHO has been crying wolf, you are sadly ignorant of the facts.

The news media has distorted the alarm, both too loud and not loud enough, but the WHO's response has been reasonable and based on science.
 
You have just committed a sin.
As penance you must read all 450 posts in this thread and the 11 page transcript of Friday's WHO press conference.
After that you might just be up to speed

Now go away and sin no more.

God bless,
Fr BillyJoe
:D
 
Swine Flu Is Spreading Wider Than Official Data Show (Update2)

Already a Pandemic

Community spread of the new virus in a second region means WHO’s criteria for a pandemic has been met, said Michael T. Osterholm, director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy of the University of Minneapolis.

Britain’s Health Secretary Alan Johnson told WHO Director- General Margaret Chan at the organization’s annual meeting last week that disease severity and other determinants besides geographic spread need to be considered before the pandemic alert is raised to the highest of WHO’s 6-level scale.

“The move to phase 6 means that emergency plans are instantly triggered around the globe, and in the U.K. this would mean increased vigilance and activation of the UK’s own ‘inter- pandemic’ phases,” the U.K.’s Department of Health said in a May 18 statement.

At phase 6, many pharmaceutical companies would switch from making seasonal flu shots to pandemic-specific vaccine, potentially creating shortages of an immunization to counter the normal winter flu season, the department said.
 
Suspected Cases: 1043
Confirmed Cases: 11053
Fatal Cases: 18
Negative Cases: 8
This is an aggregate data point for United States.

Remember all the hype about the first few cases, and the first two deaths? It continues, and I'm rather surprised the 10K mark was not even acknowledged by the media (as far as I know.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom