Is bossnapping OK?

Is kidnapping your boss, to try and save your job, acceptable?

  • Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures

    Votes: 18 15.0%
  • No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

    Votes: 102 85.0%

  • Total voters
    120
And to make the accumulation of capital work, one must crush a lot of workers ...
Your understanding of business dynamics would make you a very successful capitalist!

Now, go forth and apply that understanding...
 
Why does someone need to call the police for it to be a crime?

You serious? You're claiming they can't rely on the police. How are you going to prove it? In the south during Jim Crow there were many examples of juries letting people off, police not investigating crimes, and general willful ignorance on the part of law enforcement. Thus, you would need to show something similar for your childish comparison to have any weight.

You, of course, won't bother to support it at all.

So when the police ignored the harrassment that was fine, it was only when the police ignored the killings that it was a problem.

But you still need to prove there was harassment in France. The spokespeople for management don't view it as harrassment. If you want to make that claim, you need to provide evidence. It isn't harrassment res ipsa loquitur.

Show me one bit of evidence that people in the south broadly cared about a bit if roughing up civil rights demonstrators.

Man, you are just a treat. The point here is that the people who you claim are victims in the "bossnappings" do not view the incident as especially annoying. Are you really asking me to produce evidence that the civil rights workers in the south viewed their harrassment with fear? Ok, I think I might be able to do that:

http://mshistory.k12.ms.us/articles...nt-in-mississippi-on-violence-and-nonviolence
According to Bob Moses and other civil rights activists, they hoped and often prayed that television and newspaper reporters would show the world that the primary reason blacks remained in such a subordinate position in the South was because of widespread violence directed against them.


In 1955, Reverend George Lee, vice president of the Regional Council of Negro Leadership and NAACP worker, was shot in the face and killed for urging blacks in the Mississippi Delta to vote. Although eyewitnesses saw a carload of whites drive by and shoot into Lee's automobile, the authorities failed to charge anyone. Governor Hugh White refused requests to send investigators to Belzoni, Mississippi, where the murder occurred.

Hmm, what's that? Evidence of people demanding investigations and the political/legal structure denying them due process. This is exactly what you need to show in France, which you cannot and will not.

Here's the wiki article about the Freedom Summer and the death of James Chaney.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_Summer

Do you want more? Because I'm not talking out of my ass and basing my argument on pure ignorance, I can keep them coming, can you offer me a single fact on your side? So far, no.
 
Last edited:
You serious? You're claiming they can't rely on the police. How are you going to prove it? In the south during Jim Crow there were many examples of juries letting people off, police not investigating crimes, and general willful ignorance on the part of law enforcement. Thus, you would need to show something similar for your childish comparison to have any weight.

What about them? Do you mean to say that you actually don't know what happens to them "in the current world"??!


Looking at unemployment rates in the US over the last 60 years, I see that generally our rate of unemployment is pretty low. There was a period of almost a year of over 10% unemployment, but most of the time it under 7.5% and often much lower.

What I take from this: Just because people lose their jobs due to technological advances, or other "capitalist" reasons, doesn't mean they're out of work forever. They find jobs with other employers, or in different industries. Loss of specific jobs is not the same as an overall loss in total jobs.
 
Last edited:
Looking at unemployment rates in the US over the last 60 years, I see that generally our rate of unemployment is pretty low. There was a period of almost a year of over 10% unemployment, but most of the time it under 7.5% and often much lower.

What I take from this: Just because people lose their jobs due to technological advances, or other "capitalist" reasons, doesn't mean they're out of work forever. They find jobs with other employers, or in different industries. Loss of specific jobs is not the same as an overall loss in total jobs.

Ok, I'm not sure how that's a response to the portion of my comment you quoted.
 
Ok, I'm not sure how that's a response to the portion of my comment you quoted.

Me neither! :confused: I don't know what happened there. I was trying to quote and respond to this post:



What about them? Do you mean to say that you actually don't know what happens to them "in the current world"??!


I'd like to say it was a forum glitch, but it was probably user error.


ETA: I edited the post, but I left the original quote in so that your reply wouldn't appear nonsensical.
 
Last edited:
Me neither! :confused: I don't know what happened there. I was trying to quote and respond to this post:

I'd like to say it was a forum glitch, but it was probably user error.

We can write that off as some paranormal revenge by the forces at odds with James Randi.
 
All I can say about that is that if I am a boss smart enough to stay armed(but never obvious about it) and am kidnapped the result for the kidnappers will not go well. Especially since kidnapping IS a federal offense here - and I can quite easily and successfully argue that if my employees were insane or desperate enough to kidnap me/hold me hostage then I can legally be in fear of my life and am free to defend myself.

Easy there cowboy. You might want to dial back the bloodlust just a notch. These are Frenchmen we're talking about: living breathing creatures with basic rights. In fact scientists studying the Frenchman in their native environment have observed sophisticated tool use and complex displays of emotion akin to human beings. Now if you were directly threatened by one of these… what’s the phrase?... “chesse eating surrender monkeys” then feel free to use whatever means you have at hand to defend yourself but if the only aggressive action they've taken is to lock a door and you kill one of them for it, then some namby pamby liberal pinko is bound to ask why you didn't aim for the lock instead.
 
Last edited:
You serious? You're claiming they can't rely on the police. How are you going to prove it? In the south during Jim Crow there were many examples of juries letting people off, police not investigating crimes, and general willful ignorance on the part of law enforcement. Thus, you would need to show something similar for your childish comparison to have any weight.

You, of course, won't bother to support it at all.

I have no idea why the french don't enforce their laws. I was wondering about parralells to other cases were breaches of ones rights were not prosecuted.

I just feel that laws should be enforced especialy when they are crimes that specificialy prevent people from useing their rights.

But you still need to prove there was harassment in France. The spokespeople for management don't view it as harrassment. If you want to make that claim, you need to provide evidence. It isn't harrassment res ipsa loquitur.

So the boss was free to go? Either that or there were threats made, but such threats are legal in france I guess. Just like there is no reason to differentiate muggers from beggers. They both want your money, one just uses threats to get it, but no big deal I guess.

Man, you are just a treat. The point here is that the people who you claim are victims in the "bossnappings" do not view the incident as especially annoying. Are you really asking me to produce evidence that the civil rights workers in the south viewed their harrassment with fear? Ok, I think I might be able to do that:

And the "victims" of statutory rape also do not veiw themselves as such so should we ignore those crimes too? We do when it is a hot older woman and a young boy, so why not be even and always disregard it?

Hmm, what's that? Evidence of people demanding investigations and the political/legal structure denying them due process. This is exactly what you need to show in France, which you cannot and will not.

Fine the french do not care about the rule of law, and only prosecute those who are unpopular. Best justice in the world that is.
 
These are Frenchmen we're talking about: living breathing creatures with basic rights.

So the factory managers are not Frenchman (according to some who have posted here).

In US philosophy the three basic human rights that are listed in our founding documents are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness. For the French, they are Liberty, Equality, and Fraternety.

Interesting that the one that we share, both the French workers and thier American supporters posting here seem to think don't apply to company managers.

Just an observation.
 
I have no idea why the french don't enforce their laws. I was wondering about parralells to other cases were breaches of ones rights were not prosecuted.

I just feel that laws should be enforced especialy when they are crimes that specificialy prevent people from useing their rights.

If some labor group in the United States were to kidnap their boss tomorrow, I would be in full agreement with you so far as that act was concerned. It would be hostile and aggressive, even if no harm befell the boss.

That assessment is based on how we in America view labor negotiations. The French, however, are much more dramatic. None of the parties involved seem to have a problem with the bossnapping beyond minor annoyance. Thus, their culture, so far, doesn't consider that a crime. Who knows, it may become more violent and have to be repressed, but right now it isn't a big deal--to the French.

So the boss was free to go? Either that or there were threats made, but such threats are legal in france I guess. Just like there is no reason to differentiate muggers from beggers. They both want your money, one just uses threats to get it, but no big deal I guess.

That's why it's theater. The boss doesn't really try to leave, that's part of the game. If you could find an example of a boss sometime in the 40 year history of the custom attempting an escape, then you might have an argument. It's a mutually agreed upon tactic: the boss gets tagged "it" and stays at the base. Neither side has any interest in escalating anyting beyond a game.

And the "victims" of statutory rape also do not veiw themselves as such so should we ignore those crimes too? We do when it is a hot older woman and a young boy, so why not be even and always disregard it?

Once again, a melodramatic analogy. I think many instances of statutory rape probably are not crimes. As in, two 16 year olds have sex, the male is now a rapist and must register as a sex offender for the rest of his life.

But that's neither here nor there. We have made the judgment that age discrepancy will likely lead to coersion, therefore people under the age of majority cannot consent, they don't have the ability.

But again, statutory rape has obvious victims with obvious, discernable psychology. If you want to present an argument that management in France is similarly lacking in free will, such that their lack of interest in prosecuting the kidnappers amounts to a sort of battered wives' syndrome, go for it. You're still going to have to involve facts at some point.

Fine the french do not care about the rule of law, and only prosecute those who are unpopular. Best justice in the world that is.

This is just laughable. They absolutely care about the rule of law, they just don't view this particular custom as violating the law.

Once again you managed to provide a response completely devoid of anything resembling a fact.
 
So the factory managers are not Frenchman (according to some who have posted here).

In US philosophy the three basic human rights that are listed in our founding documents are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness. For the French, they are Liberty, Equality, and Fraternety.

Interesting that the one that we share, both the French workers and thier American supporters posting here seem to think don't apply to company managers.

Just an observation.

More hollow platitudes completely divorced from any factual undestanding of what's going on.

French management does not view this as a breach of their rights. It's a negotiating ploy with a 40 year history that is tolerated. If you want to make the case that rights are being violated, why don't you try finding something resembling evidence?

The spokespeople for French management in the articles I linked earlier unanimously say that it isn't a big deal.
 
More hollow platitudes completely divorced from any factual undestanding of what's going on.

French management does not view this as a breach of their rights. It's a negotiating ploy with a 40 year history that is tolerated. If you want to make the case that rights are being violated, why don't you try finding something resembling evidence?

The spokespeople for French management in the articles I linked earlier unanimously say that it isn't a big deal.

Ad populum fallacy. Just because 'everybody' in france is ok with this does not mean that the manager is not being deprived of his liberty.

What you don't seem to get is that it is precisely because this action is tolerated by the society in which it happens that we find it so disturbing. The very fact that a society founded on the principles of Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity, thinks it is acceptable to abandon those principles in any cases should be disturbing.
 
Ad populum fallacy. Just because 'everybody' in france is ok with this does not mean that the manager is not being deprived of his liberty.

What you don't seem to get is that it is precisely because this action is tolerated by the society in which it happens that we find it so disturbing. The very fact that a society founded on the principles of Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity, thinks it is acceptable to abandon those principles in any cases should be disturbing.

Look, you seem to have popped in here without reading what came before, I can't exactly blame you for that, but I would recommend reading the links I provided earlier.

It is not a violation of anyone's rights. It isn't that everyone in France is ok with it, it's that the people whom you claim are being abused don't view the activity as a problem. They have been doing this in France for 40 years now, no one has been hurt, no one has been arrested, and as near as I can tell, no one has really even complained about it.

The posts in this thread have been alternately hysterical and melodramic. Despite your full-throated outrage, I would consider yours one of the more tame reactions. Yet you still need to provide some factual evidence that this is a problem. In France, the spokespeople for management, the so-called victims, view this as nothing more than a negotiating ploy. They haven't called for an end to it.

If you want to prove that this is a violation of rights, you have all of your work in front of you. All that happens is that the bosses lose a night's sleep eating take-out with their employees. This is literally the case, which you would know if you read about the actual practice.
 
So the factory managers are not Frenchman (according to some who have posted here).

Don't you know? No! The factory managers were Englishmen: the finest accomplishment of mother nature to date. This wouldn't be in the news if it were just the french dicking with the french as they have been for decades.
 
Look, you seem to have popped in here without reading what came before, I can't exactly blame you for that, but I would recommend reading the links I provided earlier.

It is not a violation of anyone's rights. It isn't that everyone in France is ok with it, it's that the people whom you claim are being abused don't view the activity as a problem. They have been doing this in France for 40 years now, no one has been hurt, no one has been arrested, and as near as I can tell, no one has really even complained about it.

The posts in this thread have been alternately hysterical and melodramic. Despite your full-throated outrage, I would consider yours one of the more tame reactions. Yet you still need to provide some factual evidence that this is a problem. In France, the spokespeople for management, the so-called victims, view this as nothing more than a negotiating ploy. They haven't called for an end to it.

If you want to prove that this is a violation of rights, you have all of your work in front of you. All that happens is that the bosses lose a night's sleep eating take-out with their employees. This is literally the case, which you would know if you read about the actual practice.

I have been reading and following this thread from the beginning. I posted some immature pith early on and have been following ever since.

There are some things that I am an absolutist about. One is that a society should be held accountable for living up to its own stated ideals. In the US these are summarized quite beautifully by Jefferson in the phrase Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Hapiness. The US has not always lived up to these ideals and in the last 8 years has been fairly poor about it. Many overseas, including the French, have quite rightly criticized us for this, especially because many Americans did not seem to have any problems with this.

Here is a case where the French are not living up to thier core principles of Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity. The fact that only a small fraction of people are losing thier liberty, the fact that the loss of liberty seems quite small, the fact that the majority of the people are OK with this are exactly the arguments the US used to quell French criticism of US policies over the last 8 years. In both cases those facts are equally irrelevent. Allowing a minority (wither it be Arabs or factory managers) to lose a piece of thier liberty because 'the majority' is OK with it is just plain wrong.
 
I have been reading and following this thread from the beginning. I posted some immature pith early on and have been following ever since.

There are some things that I am an absolutist about. One is that a society should be held accountable for living up to its own stated ideals. In the US these are summarized quite beautifully by Jefferson in the phrase Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Hapiness. The US has not always lived up to these ideals and in the last 8 years has been fairly poor about it. Many overseas, including the French, have quite rightly criticized us for this, especially because many Americans did not seem to have any problems with this.

Here is a case where the French are not living up to thier core principles of Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity. The fact that only a small fraction of people are losing thier liberty, the fact that the loss of liberty seems quite small, the fact that the majority of the people are OK with this are exactly the arguments the US used to quell French criticism of US policies over the last 8 years. In both cases those facts are equally irrelevent. Allowing a minority (wither it be Arabs or factory managers) to lose a piece of thier liberty because 'the majority' is OK with it is just plain wrong.

Really? You're claiming that being forced to stay at your place of employment (which is a stretch anyway, it's an agreed upon custom, management doesn't really try to escape) for one night is an unacceptible loss of liberty?

Honestly, look at what's really going on here. The United States was hooking electrodes up to people's balls and detaining them for years in secret locations without telling them the charges. The bosses spend one night being fed takeout and continuing the negotiation. The "kidnapping" is only symbolic.

I'm mostly on board with your commitment to those core principles, but you have to be able to distinguish actual loss of rights from theater.

This is why I keep asking people to provide facts about the phenomenon. If you read about it, it's a joke. We get hysterical in the US because we're basically an anti-labor country and the idea of seizing a boss would undoubtedly lead to violence. That is not, however, what's going on in France.

You have to find me some actual harm here, or even actual mild discomfort voiced by management.
 
Okay, look: It's a loss of liberty.

Obviously it's not "unacceptable", since people clearly can and do figure out ways to accept it, get through it, get over it, and move on with their lives.

But you're still putting a guy in a situation where he's forced to ask himself "is it worth getting punched in the nose to get out of this situation?" Just because he decides that no, it's not worth getting punched in the nose, that doesn't excuse you putting him in that situation to begin with.

You know what other piece of theater is generally annoying and unacceptable? Children who go to great lengths to push their parents as far as they can, without quite doing something that would merit serious consequences. Children who know better, and whose parents let them get away with it, end up being spoiled brats... kind of like the French.
 
But you're still putting a guy in a situation where he's forced to ask himself "is it worth getting punched in the nose to get out of this situation?" Just because he decides that no, it's not worth getting punched in the nose, that doesn't excuse you putting him in that situation to begin with.

Is that the situation? Find me some evidence of that.
 
Is that the situation? Find me some evidence of that.

If there is not, then this is being sold the wrong way. Either this is something between the managers and the workers as a protest, in which case I don't have a problem. Or it is the workers holding the managers against their will, in which case the workers need to be prosecuted.

As it is being sold to the public as the managers being held by the workers, the workers should be tried, convicted and sentanced based on the crime the commit.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom