Is bossnapping OK?

Is kidnapping your boss, to try and save your job, acceptable?

  • Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures

    Votes: 18 15.0%
  • No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

    Votes: 102 85.0%

  • Total voters
    120
I think we agree it "goes to motive". If it's in the best interest of everyone invloved it's OK, if not there are problems.

Nope, it goes to who can make an informed choice. Children can not make an informed choice, and so they can be held agaisnt their will by their parents or their parents representatives.
Whenever I think of this I consider hazing. When it is taken too far it's assault, but in the right context it's commonplace. lol, as the french say "C'est la vie" :D

Again the issue is consent. Here it seems that the people do not consent or they would not be hostages.
 
Haha, are you Andy Kauffman? Is this some kind of performance comedy? Even so, I've seen better.

Again, this has already been discussed.

So you agree then that they do sell it as being forced violations of peoples rights. We are getting somewhere.
 
I don't think that PTurtle reads any of the things he objects to. He prefers his strawmen. At least he's able to defeat those.

You know you still haven't responded at all to how you think jobs made obsolete by technology should be handled. We have hostage taking being a technique but no mention of the goal.
 
Nice dodge by cutting up my post you were responding to by cutting this part as part of the previous response

They clearly don't care about people who might be afraid to report such things. Or have much consern for people having their rights violated as long as it is short term.

And I never new before this thread that the Chicago DMV was holding members of the public hostage for any length of time. You learn new things everyday.
 
Amazing how some people can get totaly upset about a Manager been taken away his freedom for a few hours. While those same people seem not to be upset at all when 300 people loose their job and get nothing, and it was not their fault.

but the management that is actually responsible for the loss of jobs get neat compensations so much like those other workers will not earn in 10 years working.

I dont think it is OK to just lock up your boss, but in some cases i can totaly undestand it.
 
Amazing how some people can get totaly upset about a Manager been taken away his freedom for a few hours. While those same people seem not to be upset at all when 300 people loose their job and get nothing, and it was not their fault.

The difference is who was having their rights violated. It is sad that those people lost their job, but jobs come and go. Unless the french goverment now needs to suport any factory and keep them open no matter how inefficient the factory is, to keep the jobs.
but the management that is actually responsible for the loss of jobs get neat compensations so much like those other workers will not earn in 10 years working.

Possibly. But what if the management isn't responcible and it is just a shift in the ecconomy? Do we hold the world hostage for these jobs?
 
The only hesitation I had in answering the poll question is that "a step too far" is a gross understatement. It's about 15 steps too far!! It's not okay to kidnap anyone! It's not okay to slash their car tires, either. It's not okay to punch them in the face, or even to threaten to do so, over a job.

Employment needs to be voluntary. You work for an employer because you want to; they hire you / keep you on because they want to. There are mechanisms in place to protect people against arbitrary firings over things that have nothing to do with job performance (eg, your new boss only wants Mormons to work for him).

The sheer idiocy of workers in today's economic meltdown astounds me. Boeing's workers at the Omaha facility authorized a strike because, as one rep said at an interview, "It's our turn to get a slice of the pie." This, in one of the largest economic downturns in our nation's history...when plane orders are being cancelled, flights are being reduced by airlines and--hope this doesn't surprise anyone--there will be a few bankruptcies in the airline industry as the over-stocked providers winnow themselves down to a sustainable number. Boeing is issuing layoffs--and these guys want to strike because the contract offer doesn't have enough additional money?! People are living in a world far removed from reality.

France is deeply limited economically by the social support for labor unions. They literally have strikes that incapacitate one industry or another on an annual basis. They have a 35-hour work week, mandatory 4-week vacation (might be 5), generous sick leave, many holidays, etc. They also have a horrendous unemployment rate, especially among the young; and the largest employer in France is the government.

But I have digressed from my main point, which is that it's not okay to kidnap your boss--or anyone else--to force them to hire you / keep you in a job. If there isn't enough business to afford the current size workforce, there isn't enough business! No amount of threatening the bearer of the bad tidings is going to change that fact.

Some folks think that "companies" have vaults of money somewhere that "they" could give more of if they wanted to. It's simply not true, most companies operate on a fairly small margin.

Furthermore, the end does not justify the means. Reformat the question a little: Is it "okay" to kidnap your boss's children to make him keep you on the job? How about your neighbor's children?? It's really the same question. Is it okay to use force to make your economic demands, or not?

These guys are playing the same game as the Somalis, really. And they should be given as little sympathy.

Just my thoughts, MK

Yes, it's OK because it's funny. However, you shouldn't expect a good outcome.
 
The difference is who was having their rights violated. It is sad that those people lost their job, but jobs come and go. Unless the french goverment now needs to suport any factory and keep them open no matter how inefficient the factory is, to keep the jobs.


Possibly. But what if the management isn't responcible and it is just a shift in the ecconomy? Do we hold the world hostage for these jobs?

yeah you see no problem with a management that gives itself far to huge wages and boni. Because it is all legal.

But forcing the Manager to negotiations is a huge crime, because it takes away the freedom of a manager for some hours.

Would Manager still live in reality, maybe people would care more about their rights.
 
yeah you see no problem with a management that gives itself far to huge wages and boni. Because it is all legal.

But forcing the Manager to negotiations is a huge crime, because it takes away the freedom of a manager for some hours.

Would Manager still live in reality, maybe people would care more about their rights.

No, we just object to using criminal methods to force management to negotiations. Especially when there is a legal method to more effectively accomplish the same thing. It's called a strike.
 
yeah you see no problem with a management that gives itself far to huge wages and boni. Because it is all legal.

No, it is just a different issue. Is that the level of management that is even being kidnapped?
But forcing the Manager to negotiations is a huge crime, because it takes away the freedom of a manager for some hours.

Kidnapping people is wrong. Maybe that is a difference in the US vs Europe, we care more about the rule of law.
 
No, it is just a different issue. Is that the level of management that is even being kidnapped?


Kidnapping people is wrong. Maybe that is a difference in the US vs Europe, we care more about the rule of law.

Not really :)
you cannot generalize it to whole Europe not even the EU.

I agree it is wrong. And i even think they should face justice and pay a fine.
but still i can understand it very very well.
 
No, we just object to using criminal methods to force management to negotiations. Especially when there is a legal method to more effectively accomplish the same thing. It's called a strike.

Most wages of Managers are criminal :)
 
You know you still haven't responded at all to how you think jobs made obsolete by technology should be handled. We have hostage taking being a technique but no mention of the goal.

You still haven't acknowledged that technology doesn't make jobs obsolete. Technology as such only serves to make the work needed to do the job easier. Capitalism makes jobs obsolete:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4604963#post4604963
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4610523#post4610523
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4610668#post4610668
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4610671#post4610671
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4611155#post4611155
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4611223#post4611223
This one in particular: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4612004#post4612004
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4613010#post4613010
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4613370#post4613370
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4613819#post4613819

Now you want me to do something very different from what I’ve been doing. You still deny the fact that captalism, not technology, makes people redundant, but nevertheless you want me to tell you how I ”think jobs made obsolete by technology should be handled”.

My answer is fairly easy to deduce from my writing so far: Since capitalism causes unemployment instead of alleviating the work load of workers, i.e. for the remaining few the work is intensified whereas the rest are ‘alleviated’ from not only the work load but also the income, the cause of unemployment should be made redundant!
In capitalism the machinery does not serve the worker, the worker serves the machinery
And since the cause of unemployment is not technology, there is no need to accuse the opponents of this feature of capitalist ‘progress’ of being Luddites, but then again: You lot are fond of the strawman!
 
Last edited:
No, we just object to using criminal methods to force management to negotiations. Especially when there is a legal method to more effectively accomplish the same thing. It's called a strike.

A strike may be used as a tool to put pressure on the factory owners as long as every day of the strike stops the production of goods that the owners are eager to get on the market and sell for a profit. In the present crisis, with management threatening to close down the factory, it is of no use whatsoever - unless it's only a bluff to pressure the workers into accepting lower wages and/or longer hours.
The workers will have to put a stop to this mode of production altogether - or accept redundancy.
 
You still deny the fact that captalism, not technology, makes people redundant

How does this follow? Can you explain your logic? Some technologies just make others redundant. Sometimes this can even effect people in unrelated industries. Even technology created by communists could still displace workers within the system. E.g. they may have to change jobs. This seems unavoidable if you are trying to create better or more efficient technology.
 
You still deny the fact that captalism, not technology, makes people redundant

Just saw this quoted by Newton...

Computers are very good at making jobs obsolete by advancing technology.

I am responsible for the production of thousands of digital images per day using digital cameras. I am sure that their advance has contributed to the making redundant of a few jobs in the photo-industry: Nobody needs to develop any film for me.

Speech recognition is another example - my dad dictates reports on tape and they are typed out later by somebody else. IF speech recognition software improves further, the job of his secretary will be partly redundant.

Yes, you could argue that it's all a problem of capitalism - without it, nobody would care much about efficiency or quality I suppose. Maybe nobody would bother to develop technices that made jobs quicker, safer and easier to do (but I doubt that.) But in a world with limited resources that's not going to stop any time soon, I think.
 
You still haven't acknowledged that technology doesn't make jobs obsolete. Technology as such only serves to make the work needed to do the job easier. Capitalism makes jobs obsolete:

So what do the boilermakers and pipe fitters do when the machines that they were trained and hired to service are no longer being used?

Or as I said computers used to be people adding up lines of numbers all day long, electronic computers put them out of work pretty efficiently.

My answer is fairly easy to deduce from my writing so far: Since capitalism causes unemployment instead of alleviating the work load of workers, i.e. for the remaining few the work is intensified whereas the rest are ‘alleviated’ from not only the work load but also the income, the cause of unemployment should be made redundant!
In capitalism the machinery does not serve the worker, the worker serves the machinery
And since the cause of unemployment is not technology, there is no need to accuse the opponents of this feature of capitalist ‘progress’ of being Luddites, but then again: You lot are fond of the strawman!

So we must never let productivity improve.
 
Just saw this quoted by Newton...

Computers are very good at making jobs obsolete by advancing technology.

I am responsible for the production of thousands of digital images per day using digital cameras. I am sure that their advance has contributed to the making redundant of a few jobs in the photo-industry: Nobody needs to develop any film for me.

Speech recognition is another example - my dad dictates reports on tape and they are typed out later by somebody else. IF speech recognition software improves further, the job of his secretary will be partly redundant.

Yes, you could argue that it's all a problem of capitalism - without it, nobody would care much about efficiency or quality I suppose. Maybe nobody would bother to develop technices that made jobs quicker, safer and easier to do (but I doubt that.) But in a world with limited resources that's not going to stop any time soon, I think.

Ah don't you see, it was capitalism that got them to lose their jobs, they should have kept their job developing film even if there was never film to develop. Not sure how this would be done, probably by the goverment mandating it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom