Is bossnapping OK?

Is kidnapping your boss, to try and save your job, acceptable?

  • Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures

    Votes: 18 15.0%
  • No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

    Votes: 102 85.0%

  • Total voters
    120
If there is not, then this is being sold the wrong way. Either this is something between the managers and the workers as a protest, in which case I don't have a problem. Or it is the workers holding the managers against their will, in which case the workers need to be prosecuted.

As it is being sold to the public as the managers being held by the workers, the workers should be tried, convicted and sentanced based on the crime the commit.

Sold to the public, eh? Why don't you link some articles or quotes that support your position? Just one would be nice.

You guys are talking about this like it's the darkest corner of Attica, but you never bother to find a single line to support anything you say. So they're worried about being hit in the mouth? News to me, a citation might make sense.

But the general consensus seems to be in favor of continued hysteria.
 
Really? You're claiming that being forced to stay at your place of employment (which is a stretch anyway, it's an agreed upon custom, management doesn't really try to escape) for one night is an unacceptible loss of liberty?

Honestly, look at what's really going on here. The United States was hooking electrodes up to people's balls and detaining them for years in secret locations without telling them the charges. The bosses spend one night being fed takeout and continuing the negotiation. The "kidnapping" is only symbolic.

Ok, lets narrow it down to just one part of the 'War on Terror' that is more analagous. Do you think it is right or wrong that people with Arabic names and of darker complexion, or generally appearing 'middle eastern' are detained for an additional 15-20 minutes and searched with more scrutiny than other passengers before boarding an airplane?

Again, this is general custom. The majority support it. They are only be detained for less than half an hour. All of this is irrelevant to deciding whether the detention is right or wrong. They are specifically being targeted because they are members of a minority, which the majority fears and distrusts (and yes that is just as accurate discription of management in a pro-labor society). This might make the practice acceptable within the society, but it does not make it right.
 
Ok, lets narrow it down to just one part of the 'War on Terror' that is more analagous. Do you think it is right or wrong that people with Arabic names and of darker complexion, or generally appearing 'middle eastern' are detained for an additional 15-20 minutes and searched with more scrutiny than other passengers before boarding an airplane?

Again, this is general custom. The majority support it. They are only be detained for less than half an hour. All of this is irrelevant to deciding whether the detention is right or wrong. They are specifically being targeted because they are members of a minority, which the majority fears and distrusts (and yes that is just as accurate discription of management in a pro-labor society). This might make the practice acceptable within the society, but it does not make it right.

Sure, let's examine that analogy.

Is there outcry by people complaining about being unfairly singled out?

Well, here's a blogpost by the son of an Egyptian man complaining about the detention:

http://goatmilk.wordpress.com/2009/...lebrities-flying-while-brown-by-sherri-eldin/

You can find plenty more with simple google searches.

So the "victims" in this case are upset and calling for change. I might buy your analogy if you can show me something similar in France.
 
Sure, let's examine that analogy.

Is there outcry by people complaining about being unfairly singled out?

Well, here's a blogpost by the son of an Egyptian man complaining about the detention:

http://goatmilk.wordpress.com/2009/...lebrities-flying-while-brown-by-sherri-eldin/

You can find plenty more with simple google searches.

So the "victims" in this case are upset and calling for change. I might buy your analogy if you can show me something similar in France.

Pithy response: Murder victims never complain about being victimized.

Actual response: As you have stated there is wide societal acceptance of this practice. That can provide a lot of motivation to the victims to keep thier mouths shut regardless of what they think about it. It is the very same phenomenon that has allowed spousal abuse to persist for so long. Too many victims are simply too afraid to speak out.

For the managers, I can see pressure coming from both ends. They could be very much afraid that if they speak out against it, the threats made during the abduction may become reality. On the other side, they may be afraid of losing thier job because they would be seen as disloyal by higher management. While you are correct I don't have evidence of either, both are very reasonable explanations why the actual victims (the ones kidnapped, not some mouthpiece hired by thier compnay) are not speaking out about this and are just as valid as the explanation that they accept it and are ok with it.

If you can provide evidence that even a single victim explicitly stated that he/she had no problem with the detention, then I will back off this point and give your explanation for the silence of the others more weight. Until then, I will not grant that silence = consent with such strong societal pressures in play.
 
Sold to the public, eh? Why don't you link some articles or quotes that support your position? Just one would be nice.

link

It says that the bosses were held, not part of a protest. Held means that they did not choose it. This is just a form of kidnapping that the french will never prosecute.
 
Pithy response: Murder victims never complain about being victimized.

Actual response: As you have stated there is wide societal acceptance of this practice. That can provide a lot of motivation to the victims to keep thier mouths shut regardless of what they think about it. It is the very same phenomenon that has allowed spousal abuse to persist for so long. Too many victims are simply too afraid to speak out.

Loot at spoucal rape 50 years ago, nice and legal, and condoned by society. Therefor there was nothing wrong with raping your wife.
 
Is that the situation? Find me some evidence of that.
We've been over this: Is the manager free to leave any time he wants? No? Then he's being held by force, or the threat of force. Feel free to take "punched in the nose" as a figure of speech; I have no evidence that this is the specific form the use of force would take. Maybe it would take the form of physical restraint by several burly men. Maybe it'd take the form of being tripped to the ground and kicked repeatedly. Maybe it'd take the form of being beaten with sticks or folding chairs.

Simple question: Can. The. Manager. Leave. Whenever. He. Wants. Well?
 
link

It says that the bosses were held, not part of a protest. Held means that they did not choose it. This is just a form of kidnapping that the french will never prosecute.

"We are aware that in France there was recently a number of circumstances in which unions have held hostages but it was not envisaged in our case, a number of meetings took place before."

So in this case normal protocal was violated. The article also points out that Sarkozy will start cracking down on the practice, which is something I pointed out quite a while ago.

Again, if it becomes violent or threatening, it will likely be stopped, but it hasn't so far. Given the increasingly desperate tone of protests, I'd imagine France will now crack down.

But that doesn't mean that what happened was a serious violation of personal liberties.
 
If there is not, then this is being sold the wrong way. Either this is something between the managers and the workers as a protest, in which case I don't have a problem. Or it is the workers holding the managers against their will, in which case the workers need to be prosecuted.

As it is being sold to the public as the managers being held by the workers, the workers should be tried, convicted and sentanced based on the crime the commit.

I'm not sure about this PT. I mentioned before detention. This is a common practice in the US. Even more egregious is the fact that they are usually children being held against their will! Should a school teacher be prosecuted for holding a strudent against their will?

I say it's a double standard here, if you believe holding a boss in detention during contract negotiations is criminal, then certainly holding a child against their will, without any due process is equally, if not more, egregious? (there's no real threat of force assumed here, although preventing someone from egress may be present in both. I don't think it's far fetched to say a teacher may obsruct a student from leaving dentention, in the same way a group of protesters may obstruct a boss from leaving)
 
Pithy response: Murder victims never complain about being victimized.

Actual response: As you have stated there is wide societal acceptance of this practice. That can provide a lot of motivation to the victims to keep thier mouths shut regardless of what they think about it. It is the very same phenomenon that has allowed spousal abuse to persist for so long. Too many victims are simply too afraid to speak out.

For the 20 milionth time: Then find some goddamn evidence to support this. I was challenged and immediately found evidence that people in the south were complaining about the lack of enforcement. You have done nothing to establish that case with the French situation.

All of your arguments are jsut spurious navel-gazing until you can support them.

And pithy? Try insanely bizarre.

For the managers, I can see pressure coming from both ends. They could be very much afraid that if they speak out against it, the threats made during the abduction may become reality. On the other side, they may be afraid of losing thier job because they would be seen as disloyal by higher management. While you are correct I don't have evidence of either, both are very reasonable explanations why the actual victims (the ones kidnapped, not some mouthpiece hired by thier compnay) are not speaking out about this and are just as valid as the explanation that they accept it and are ok with it.

I can imagine a whole lot of things, too, but that doesn't make it so.

We're talking about management here, not a battered wife in Mississippi. If they have a problem they are more then able to go to the press. Oh wait, they did go to the press and said it wasn't a big deal.

If you can provide evidence that even a single victim explicitly stated that he/she had no problem with the detention, then I will back off this point and give your explanation for the silence of the others more weight. Until then, I will not grant that silence = consent with such strong societal pressures in play.


I already did. Here it is again:

"It's true that this might seem surprising abroad, but it's less surprising in France, where we're more used to this kind of situation," said a Sony spokeswoman.

Sony had an incident a few years back.

The opinion in France seems to be that the tactic is getting too confrontational, thus the president said he will crack down. That certainly changes matters, but doesn't alter the facts about the tactic in the past.
 
We've been over this: Is the manager free to leave any time he wants? No? Then he's being held by force, or the threat of force. Feel free to take "punched in the nose" as a figure of speech; I have no evidence that this is the specific form the use of force would take. Maybe it would take the form of physical restraint by several burly men. Maybe it'd take the form of being tripped to the ground and kicked repeatedly. Maybe it'd take the form of being beaten with sticks or folding chairs.

Simple question: Can. The. Manager. Leave. Whenever. He. Wants. Well?

This is what stubborn, (insert personal insult) people do. You take a situation with sublety to it and try to distill it into a simple situation.

I've got another one: You either support the war on terror or you don't. Are you with us or against us? If you're against us you love terrorists and want to give them therapy.

That kind of nonsense just won't do here.

What's also funny is that I already answered this childish response. In life there are a variety of reasons I cannot do whatever I want whenever I want. I used a different scale earlier, but let's use from "the doctor is late for my appointment" to "you have been detained by the United States government as an enemy combatant," the "bossnapping" is mildly worse than an afternoon at the DMV.

You trying to pretend like it's all or nothing is just melodrama. I can't take you seriously if you're unable to differentiate between degrees.

And again, management is used to it. They don't really care.
 
Loot at spoucal rape 50 years ago, nice and legal, and condoned by society. Therefor there was nothing wrong with raping your wife.

Sigh...it's like talking to a brick wall.

Once again, it isn't right because it's a tradition, it's a tradition that isn't harmful.

Honestly, how difficult is that?

Again, we understand the psychological condition that causes women in abusive relationships to defend their assailants. It has an unusually apt name: battered wives syndrome, which has now been expanded to include other victims of the same psychology.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battered_person_syndrome

I'm happy to deal with an argument from the unhinged histrionics crowd where you show that management in France has similarly been affected. Go ahead, make your case, I'm sure it will be entertaining.
 
Really? You're claiming that being forced to stay at your place of employment (which is a stretch anyway, it's an agreed upon custom, management doesn't really try to escape) for one night is an unacceptible loss of liberty?

Yes, it is unacceptable. Being detained by illegal use of force is illegal use of force, whether it be for Ten minutes or Ten Hours.
 
Yes, it is unacceptable. Being detained by illegal use of force is illegal use of force, whether it be for Ten minutes or Ten Hours.

But the French haven't viewed as illegal use of force. According to Sarkozy it might be changing, and now we will see if the workers use the tactic if it carries actual consequence.

This is going around and around in circles.

"Hey, sorry, my daughter took a candy bar from your shelf."
"SHE IS A THIEF, WE MUST CUT OFF HER HANDS."
"Yeah, I know it's technically illegal, but you could probably let it slide."
"ILLEGAL TAKING OF ANOTHER'S PROPERTY IS ILLEGAL TAKING OF ANOTHER'S PROPERTY, WHETHER IT BE FOR TEN CENTS OR TEN THOUSAND DOLLARS!!!!"
 
Waiting in line at the DMV: Not particularly OK.

Being detained by ex-employees against my will: Also not particularly OK.

Of course, if you want to get all nuanced about it, the line at the DMV is due to a basic limitation in available resources, and is a situation entered into consensually by all participants.

Meanwhile, being detained by ex-employees is due to... well, it's due to a basic limitation of human nature, I guess. And I still can't figure out if you think the manager is entering into the arrangement consensually or not. I'm pretty sure it's "not".

Note that I've never compared it to anything really horrible. I simply think that it's wrong, and that the people doing the detaining are wrong for doing it, and that French authorities are wrong for not doing something about it.

You're the one who keeps trying to downplay it as no big deal. And then whenever someone tries to press you on what, exactly, you think is going on, you accuse us of blowing it out of proportion.

The fact that the manager "goes along to get along" or whatever no more justifies or excuses the detention than does the rampant custom of bribery in certain societies justify bribery as a method of doing business.
 
"We are aware that in France there was recently a number of circumstances in which unions have held hostages but it was not envisaged in our case, a number of meetings took place before."

So either then french unions are terrorists, or the hostage takers in the 80's were not doing anything really wrong. You don't see any fundamental problem with taking people hostage it seems.
But that doesn't mean that what happened was a serious violation of personal liberties.

So as long as it is for a few hours kidnapping is OK?
 
I'm not sure about this PT. I mentioned before detention. This is a common practice in the US. Even more egregious is the fact that they are usually children being held against their will! Should a school teacher be prosecuted for holding a strudent against their will?

If the child is underage then their parents of their parents representatives can hold them against their will. Now if it was an emancipated minor it would be a different issue.

Want to know something? As an EMT I could not transport adults against their will, it would be kidnapping, but minors could not legally refuse medical care as they can not take responsibility for what happens to them.
 
What's also funny is that I already answered this childish response. In life there are a variety of reasons I cannot do whatever I want whenever I want. I used a different scale earlier, but let's use from "the doctor is late for my appointment" to "you have been detained by the United States government as an enemy combatant," the "bossnapping" is mildly worse than an afternoon at the DMV.

They threaten you with harm at the DMV now if you want to walk out of the Que and leave? They are hard core in Chicago.
 
Waiting in line at the DMV: Not particularly OK.

Being detained by ex-employees against my will: Also not particularly OK.

Of course, if you want to get all nuanced about it, the line at the DMV is due to a basic limitation in available resources, and is a situation entered into consensually by all participants.

Meanwhile, being detained by ex-employees is due to... well, it's due to a basic limitation of human nature, I guess. And I still can't figure out if you think the manager is entering into the arrangement consensually or not. I'm pretty sure it's "not".

Note that I've never compared it to anything really horrible. I simply think that it's wrong, and that the people doing the detaining are wrong for doing it, and that French authorities are wrong for not doing something about it.

You're the one who keeps trying to downplay it as no big deal. And then whenever someone tries to press you on what, exactly, you think is going on, you accuse us of blowing it out of proportion.

The fact that the manager "goes along to get along" or whatever no more justifies or excuses the detention than does the rampant custom of bribery in certain societies justify bribery as a method of doing business.


Well, then I owe you a bit of an apology. At this point I got you confused with the people who compared this to abusing muslim women, the KKK, piracy, and an assortment of other overblown situations.

I will say this about the French custom, and it seems we will just not agree on this: because they have consistently used it as a negotiating ploy for 40 years and no one has been harmed or arrested during those 4 decades, I don't see any reason why we should call for them to stop.

Now, it appears that the tactic is becoming more radical and potentially more dangerous. Sarkozy wants to crack down on it, I'm perfectly supportive of that as well. I see no benefit to it, and if it really does become harmful, then I agree it should be stopped.

But as it stands now, it's kind of a game between the sides. Labor disputes can lead to negotiations that keep people bargaining for much longer than the single night of "bossnapping." It seems to me, from all of the stories I've read, is that the only difference between what our media views as kidnapping and normal negotiations is the theater of parking cars in front of the exit. It's a symolic captivity that no one has really tried to break in 40 years.
 
Sigh...it's like talking to a brick wall.

Once again, it isn't right because it's a tradition, it's a tradition that isn't harmful.

And the tradition of men taking their spoucal rights from their wife also had a long tradition.

Again, we understand the psychological condition that causes women in abusive relationships to defend their assailants. It has an unusually apt name: battered wives syndrome, which has now been expanded to include other victims of the same psychology.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battered_person_syndrome

I thought we were looking for reasons that the taking of hostages in france was not ever harmful, not more reasons why it might be difficult to find evidence of people speaking against it. Thanks for adding more weight to my argument though.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom