Is bossnapping OK?

Is kidnapping your boss, to try and save your job, acceptable?

  • Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures

    Votes: 18 15.0%
  • No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

    Votes: 102 85.0%

  • Total voters
    120

Giz

Philosopher
Joined
Jul 24, 2002
Messages
8,709
Morality survey: Is bossnapping OK?

So this poll/thread is a result of my incredulity at the results of the Guardian's poll on whether bossnapping is a protest too far, where 48% think it is fine.

I mean really? Holding people against their will - kidnapping - because they don't want to employ you anymore? When the heck did half the population start thinking that being cheesed off with someone gives you the right to kidnap them? (Ok, ok, I know Guardian readers are thankfully not representative of the population as a whole but it does have pretensions towards being a serious, quality newspaper…)




The poll (you may have to vote to see the result):

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/poll/2009/apr/08/job-losses-protest



Background story from the Guardian:
The first Britons to be caught up in the spate of "bossnappings" in France were today released by their staff after being held captive overnight.
Three British managers, including one woman, and a French male colleague were detained at the factory in Bellegarde in the foothills of the French Alps when negotiations over terms of the plant's closure broke down yesterday.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2009/apr/08/bossnapping-france-scapa



Interested as to how the split comes out here...
 
I think it's a huge step too far. That step involves going over a cliff. Kidnapping is a federal felony in the US. :eek:
 
The only hesitation I had in answering the poll question is that "a step too far" is a gross understatement. It's about 15 steps too far!! It's not okay to kidnap anyone! It's not okay to slash their car tires, either. It's not okay to punch them in the face, or even to threaten to do so, over a job.

Employment needs to be voluntary. You work for an employer because you want to; they hire you / keep you on because they want to. There are mechanisms in place to protect people against arbitrary firings over things that have nothing to do with job performance (eg, your new boss only wants Mormons to work for him).

The sheer idiocy of workers in today's economic meltdown astounds me. Boeing's workers at the Omaha facility authorized a strike because, as one rep said at an interview, "It's our turn to get a slice of the pie." This, in one of the largest economic downturns in our nation's history...when plane orders are being cancelled, flights are being reduced by airlines and--hope this doesn't surprise anyone--there will be a few bankruptcies in the airline industry as the over-stocked providers winnow themselves down to a sustainable number. Boeing is issuing layoffs--and these guys want to strike because the contract offer doesn't have enough additional money?! People are living in a world far removed from reality.

France is deeply limited economically by the social support for labor unions. They literally have strikes that incapacitate one industry or another on an annual basis. They have a 35-hour work week, mandatory 4-week vacation (might be 5), generous sick leave, many holidays, etc. They also have a horrendous unemployment rate, especially among the young; and the largest employer in France is the government.

But I have digressed from my main point, which is that it's not okay to kidnap your boss--or anyone else--to force them to hire you / keep you in a job. If there isn't enough business to afford the current size workforce, there isn't enough business! No amount of threatening the bearer of the bad tidings is going to change that fact.

Some folks think that "companies" have vaults of money somewhere that "they" could give more of if they wanted to. It's simply not true, most companies operate on a fairly small margin.

Furthermore, the end does not justify the means. Reformat the question a little: Is it "okay" to kidnap your boss's children to make him keep you on the job? How about your neighbor's children?? It's really the same question. Is it okay to use force to make your economic demands, or not?

These guys are playing the same game as the Somalis, really. And they should be given as little sympathy.

Just my thoughts, MK
 
Here are the current results as of posting:

Is bossnapping ever justifiable?
48.3% Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures
51.7% No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

Really, now?
 
I worked for a small company where the boss was directly involved in the future of the company, but all the others I've worked for, any locally available boss was quite removed from the company's decision process so that interfering with him would accomplish nothing relative to the overall policies of the company other than create an opening for another boss to come in and replace him.
And "holding a hostage" is many steps a graver crime than just stupid!
 
Presumably the bosses will be getting paid double time for those periods during which their employees incarcerate them; so what are they complaining about?
 
Morality survey: Is bossnapping OK?

So this poll/thread is a result of my incredulity at the results of the Guardian's poll on whether bossnapping is a protest too far, where 48% think it is fine.

I mean really? Holding people against their will - kidnapping - because they don't want to employ you anymore?


Well, you listen to power-hungry politicians who tell you that you're the center of reality, so all laws should bend to you, for several generations, this is the "ethics" that evolves.


See, what wins elections is "it's not your fault you're at the whims of the winds". What wins elections is "they're evil and out to get you and don't care...but fortunately I carevoteforme", with the attendent creation of an ethics in the mind that it's therefore Ok to force businessmen to hire you, or not fire you unless you repeatedly murder fellow employees, with a 6 months paid vacation while the investigation occurs, and only then if the business can ensure your family is taken care of and has some place to go and food to eat. Since it's all their fault, and you are just a helpless child in their vicious business world, anything goes.



Unless someone else has a better explanation. :)
 
Bossnapping: Yet more evidence that the French are, in fact, jerks.



Jeffrey Dahmer: Yet more evidence that Americans are cannibals.


As to the original post, they should be treated as any hostage taker and dealt with accordingly. If they do not peacefully surrender in a timely manner, send in a hostage rescue team and bring the kidnappers out in bodybags.
 
I think it's a huge step too far. That step involves going over a cliff. Kidnapping is a federal felony in the US. :eek:

Indeed.

wiki said:
Following the highly publicized 1932 Lindbergh kidnapping, Congress authorized the FBI to investigate kidnapping at a time when the Bureau was expanding in size and authority. The fact that a kidnapped victim may have been taken across state lines brings the crime within the ambit of federal criminal law. The Bureau made kidnap for ransom a special priority, and continues to do so today. It pursues kidnap cases ferociously; agents who have rescued kidnap victims have been known to describe these rescues as personal high points of their careers.
There are several deterrents to kidnapping in the United States of America. Among these are:

  1. The extreme logistical challenges involved in successfully exchanging the money for the return of the victim without being apprehended or surveiled.
  2. Harsh punishment. Convicted kidnappers can expect to face lengthy prison terms. If a victim is brought across state lines, federal charges can be brought as well.
  3. Good cooperation and information sharing between law enforcement agencies, and tools for spreading information to the public (such as the AMBER Alert system.)
The harsh sentences imposed and the poor risk-to-benefit ratio compared with other crimes have caused kidnap for ransom virtually to die out in the United States. One notorious failed example of kidnap for ransom was the Chowchilla bus kidnapping, in which 26 children were abducted with the intention of bringing in a $5 million ransom.[2] Kidnappings for profit that do occur in or into the United States today are often connected to other ongoing criminal activity, such as human trafficking.
 
France is deeply limited economically by the social support for labor unions. They literally have strikes that incapacitate one industry or another on an annual basis. They have a 35-hour work week, mandatory 4-week vacation (might be 5), generous sick leave, many holidays, etc.

France is actually doing extremely well economically though compared with Britain and the USA? And these are the normal working conditions in almost every civilized nation - "The average leave and public holiday entitlements across all EU states is 34 days. The UK and Netherlands provide just 28 days off while Ireland gives 29. At the other extreme, Greece, Austria, and Finland provide the most time off - 37, 38 and 39 days respectively." This is paid holiday - paid bereavement, sickness and maternity leave are in addition. source: http://www.prnewswire.co.uk/cgi/news/release?id=106596 Most of these countries are performing well enough economically, compared to the USA and Japan? Dunno.

Why how much paid holiday is the compulsory minimum in the states? Is it less than 28 days???

cj x
 
"compulsory minimum"? Well, I get 8 paid holidays that are not considered PTO's, so it must be equal or less than 8. However, the company I work for gives me 11 PTO's for this year.
 
Presumably the bosses will be getting paid double time for those periods during which their employees incarcerate them; so what are they complaining about?
All I can say about that is that if I am a boss smart enough to stay armed(but never obvious about it) and am kidnapped the result for the kidnappers will not go well. Especially since kidnapping IS a federal offense here - and I can quite easily and successfully argue that if my employees were insane or desperate enough to kidnap me/hold me hostage then I can legally be in fear of my life and am free to defend myself.
 
All I can say about that is that if I am a boss smart enough to stay armed(but never obvious about it) and am kidnapped the result for the kidnappers will not go well. Especially since kidnapping IS a federal offense here - and I can quite easily and successfully argue that if my employees were insane or desperate enough to kidnap me/hold me hostage then I can legally be in fear of my life and am free to defend myself.

wow, you really value your free time :rolleyes:

I worry about statements like this. Kids, not having the same reasoning skills as an adult might see this as "If some teacher is going to try and keep me here in detention against my will I'm blasting my way out"

Being inconvienced by a distraught or mentally unstable person is no reason for advocating lethal force.

@fuelair- I didn't read the OP as the person was armed, if they were armed I would advocate lethal force as you did.
 
wow, you really value your free time :rolleyes:

I worry about statements like this. Kids, not having the same reasoning skills as an adult might see this as "If some teacher is going to try and keep me here in detention against my will I'm blasting my way out"

Being inconvienced by a distraught or mentally unstable person is no reason for advocating lethal force.

@fuelair- I didn't read the OP as the person was armed, if they were armed I would advocate lethal force as you did.
My impression is that it was a group, not one person. Groups have a way of becoming mobs. I do not plan to die or be injured because someone else is distraught - unless the nature of the distraught leads me to CHOOSE to put myself in danger.
 
Kidnapping is a crime. Being "downsized" is not.

But that may not be the case in France.

:rolleyes:
 
Here are the current results as of posting:

Is bossnapping ever justifiable?
48.3% Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures
51.7% No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

Really, now?

Thankfully the JREF forumites seem to be more reasonable!

Would still like to see a serious defence of it by one of the 4 'yes' voters...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom