Is bossnapping OK?

Is kidnapping your boss, to try and save your job, acceptable?

  • Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures

    Votes: 18 15.0%
  • No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

    Votes: 102 85.0%

  • Total voters
    120
Yes, due to the purpose of the "technological shifts", not due to the technology. It is a necessity of capitalism.

Do to technological advancement. It is a nessacary part of technological advancement.

Which is why so many of them have more than one job, I guess. This is a question of poverty, not choice.

And as such it should be addressed in a different fashion. What you want is that glorious russian comunist system, they had no poverty or unemployment.

Because you appear to be unable to understand any other change than the one an employer introduces in order to save expenses.

I can see many changes, but much of technological innovation is about labor saving devices. WHen you have labor you don't need as many laborers.
No, it isn't. It is the nature of improvements in technology in capitalism!
See earlier post.

So you perfer the soviet method? They had no unemployment after all.
 
Do to technological advancement. It is a nessacary part of technological advancement.

No, it isn't.

And as such it should be addressed in a different fashion. What you want is that glorious russian comunist system, they had no poverty or unemployment.

The strawman that defenders of the poverty produced by capitalism always seem to resort to.

I can see many changes, but much of technological innovation is about labor saving devices. WHen you have labor you don't need as many laborers.

Or the workers don't have to work as long or as hard as they used to. No, wait, we are not talking technological innovation, we're talking capitalist technological innovation.

So you perfer the soviet method? They had no unemployment after all.

Strawman repetition. It is true, though, that they had no unemployment, one of the reasons why they were so inefficient as exploiters. They were really no match for capitalism in that respect.

From 1917 to PerestroikaThe Victory of Morality over Socialism
The Soviet Union: Socialism as a World Power
A topical but false classic. Lenin: Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism
The Most Stupid Laws of Marxism-Leninism
More criticism of socialism and left-wing ideas here and here
 
No, it isn't.

So what do you do with all the pipe fitters, boiler makers and so on that are needed to make steam engines run but not needed when you switch to diesel locomotives? What about saddle and harness makers when tractors and the automobile took over? What about a typewriter repairmen in the current world?


The strawman that defenders of the poverty produced by capitalism always seem to resort to.

They had the 100 percent employment that you want, and kept people doing jobs long after the jobs themselves became meaningless. This seems to be exactly what you want.

This is not a problem that is best resolved by private industry but by public policy.

Or the workers don't have to work as long or as hard as they used to. No, wait, we are not talking technological innovation, we're talking capitalist technological innovation.

Most people could work less hours than they do, they choose to work more for more money.
Strawman repetition. It is true, though, that they had no unemployment, one of the reasons why they were so inefficient as exploiters. They were really no match for capitalism in that respect.

You are defending inefficiency though. You what people to be employed or at least not to loose their jobs no matter if it is the more efficient solution.
 
No, it is just that people know that the police will not protect them and that they do not care about the law. The suitable reference was when the KKK was harrassing and killing civil rights workers. The law didn't care about those violations of rights either.

This is silly. Once more, provide something resembling a fact to support this. I would be interested to see you try to establish that management and executive workers in France feel like the police won't respond to their needs. Go ahead, I'd even take a random blog post somewhere to begin.

I'll even give you a big hint about where to start: why don't you try to show that someone actually called the police before, during, or after the "kidnappings." Because I've already given you quotes by the so-called victims who say it wasn't that big of a deal.

As you said, "the KKK was harrassing and killing civil rights workers." Nothing like that is happening here, you're just engaging in unhinged melodrama.

Provide one single bit of evidence that shows worry on the behalf of people in France about this issue. Show me one single person who claims to have been injured, either physically or emotionally, by the ordeal, because your KKK example has actual victims.

But thank you, I didn't anticipate the KKK analogy, that gave me a good laugh to start my day. Unbelievable.
 
Last edited:
I'll even give you a big hint about where to start: why don't you try to show that someone actually called the police before, during, or after the "kidnappings." Because I've already given you quotes by the so-called victims who say it wasn't that big of a deal.

Why does someone need to call the police for it to be a crime?
As you said, "the KKK was harrassing and killing civil rights workers." Nothing like that is happening here, you're just engaging in unhinged melodrama.

So when the police ignored the harrassment that was fine, it was only when the police ignored the killings that it was a problem.
Provide one single bit of evidence that shows worry on the behalf of people in France about this issue. Show me one single person who claims to have been injured, either physically or emotionally, by the ordeal, because your KKK example has actual victims.

Show me one bit of evidence that people in the south broadly cared about a bit if roughing up civil rights demonstrators.
 
dann, do you think the law should guarantee your income? If so, how much income should be guaranteed to you? Do you think there's anything you should guarantee in return? If not, why not? If so, what should you guarantee, and what should the law do if you do not honor your guarantee?
 
Isn't that the common definition of Unionism?

Unions are complicated. I was talking to a teacher who was in an odd situation. NYC school districts were closing large schools in favor of small schools. She has 30 years experiance as a special eduction teacher and so earns a proportionatly high salary. The new smaller schools that are replacing the large school(4 of them in the same building as the school she currently works in) do not want to hire the older teachers because they earn too much and it comes from the schools budget. But the teachers are not fired because the school they were in was taken appart because in many cases they did nothing wrong. So the school disctrict still keeps them on the payroll and they hire new teachers who earn less because it saves money for the school but not the school disctrict.

I don't think that the union is bad in this situation, school teachers need protection because school disctricts have little motivation to care about experiance, just the bottom line.

I am not against unions or social support networks, they just are not the issue under discussion here.
 
In this case the definition is strawman!

Not really. You are not presenting a position, you are just saying that capitalism is bad. As you are not actualy making specific suggestions for what should happen, for example when diesel trains replaced steam, we have to guess at what your solution would be. It is clear that innovation is something you are against, as it destroys jobs and sectors of the ecconomy, or at least something that you are against in many instances.

You are only makeing negative comments and not saying one thing about how you want things to work.
 
Progress without unemployment? Is it even possible? I mean in practice, not in theory.

To make Muscatel, one must crush a few grapes.
 
So what do you do with all the pipe fitters, boiler makers and so on that are needed to make steam engines run but not needed when you switch to diesel locomotives? What about saddle and harness makers when tractors and the automobile took over? What about a typewriter repairmen in the current world?

What about them? Do you mean to say that you actually don't know what happens to them "in the current world"??!


They had the 100 percent employment that you want, and kept people doing jobs long after the jobs themselves became meaningless. This seems to be exactly what you want.

Interesting! They had what I want?! Now you suddenly seem to know very much about what I want, but then again: When you make up your strawmen as you go along, it's very easy to be in full control of any discussion.

This is not a problem that is best resolved by private industry but by public policy.

The problem of poverty is not only not "resolved by private industry", it is actually produced by private industry and its assistant, public policy.


Most people could work less hours than they do, they choose to work more for more money.

Because they need more money to make ends meet.

You are defending inefficiency though.

It's just raining strawmen today!

You what people to be employed or at least not to loose their jobs no matter if it is the more efficient solution.

No, I don't, and "the more efficient solution" for whom???!
 
Progress without unemployment? Is it even possible? I mean in practice, not in theory.

To make Muscatel, one must crush a few grapes.

And to make the accumulation of capital work, one must crush a lot of workers ...
 
You are only makeing negative comments and not saying one thing about how you want things to work.

And still you are able to invent soluttions that I allegedly propose, which is the same thing as admitting to your strawman argument.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom