Is bossnapping OK?

Is kidnapping your boss, to try and save your job, acceptable?

  • Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures

    Votes: 18 15.0%
  • No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

    Votes: 102 85.0%

  • Total voters
    120
And the tradition of men taking their spoucal rights from their wife also had a long tradition.



I thought we were looking for reasons that the taking of hostages in france was not ever harmful, not more reasons why it might be difficult to find evidence of people speaking against it. Thanks for adding more weight to my argument though.

While I voted no, are you seriously going to try to argue that management in France suffers from Battered person syndrome?:boggled:
 
They threaten you with harm at the DMV now if you want to walk out of the Que and leave? They are hard core in Chicago.

Citation for the threats in France? Oh wait, you're once again assuming that it happens a certain way without bothering to substantiate the point.
 
And the tradition of men taking their spoucal rights from their wife also had a long tradition.

I mean honestly, did you even read what I wrote? See that word "harmful?" The space between my one sentence explanation and your astonishing misread or willful manipulation is less than an inch on the screen. How can you do that with a straight face?

I thought we were looking for reasons that the taking of hostages in france was not ever harmful, not more reasons why it might be difficult to find evidence of people speaking against it. Thanks for adding more weight to my argument though.

Huh? You're serious? You think management is suffering from battered person's syndrome. Haha, awesome.

I put that link there so you could read about the characteristics of people suffering that condition. Now it's up to you to deal with your greatest fear: facts.

You need to show how the people in question satisfy that diagnosis.
 
Note that I've never compared it to anything really horrible. I simply think that it's wrong, and that the people doing the detaining are wrong for doing it, and that French authorities are wrong for not doing something about it.

Naming the crime they are comitting seems to be enough. Taking peopel hostage is no big deal in france, they just roll that way you know.
 
So either then french unions are terrorists, or the hostage takers in the 80's were not doing anything really wrong. You don't see any fundamental problem with taking people hostage it seems.


So as long as it is for a few hours kidnapping is OK?

Alright, you're a joke. I've tried responding reasonably to your nonsense, but this is just getting sad. I've answered this about 20 times now, and you haven't modified your argument at all. It's just a tired reiteration of the same factless, garbled nonsense.

I find it surprising that so many people on a forum dedicated to skeptical thinking can reduce an issue to a binary, black and white choice. It's really startling.
 
Well, then I owe you a bit of an apology. At this point I got you confused with the people who compared this to abusing muslim women, the KKK, piracy, and an assortment of other overblown situations.

Remember that spousal rape was criminalized in the US in the 1980's. Up until 1975 being married as a defense against rape charges in south dakota. I have not seen any thing about muslim women.

And of course any analogy to other situations where crimes were clearly committed but not prosecuted is not relevant for some reason I can't quite see.
 
While I voted no, are you seriously going to try to argue that management in France suffers from Battered person syndrome?:boggled:

The reasons why they are not demanding these crimes be prosecuted are the same. Of course in civilized nations you do not need the victim to demand that the crime be prosecuted for the crime to be prosecuted, but I am aware that this is france and not a civilized nation.
 
Citation for the threats in France? Oh wait, you're once again assuming that it happens a certain way without bothering to substantiate the point.

Are these hostages free to go or not? If they are, then they are not hostages. Look at the very words that are used to describe the situation, it depends on there being force or threat of force.
 
Alright, you're a joke. I've tried responding reasonably to your nonsense, but this is just getting sad. I've answered this about 20 times now, and you haven't modified your argument at all. It's just a tired reiteration of the same factless, garbled nonsense.
.

Well it is good to know for any vacation planning that kidnapping is legal in frace. You can be held hostage for quite some time and the locals just don't care.
 
Remember that spousal rape was criminalized in the US in the 1980's. Up until 1975 being married as a defense against rape charges in south dakota. I have not seen any thing about muslim women.

And of course any analogy to other situations where crimes were clearly committed but not prosecuted is not relevant for some reason I can't quite see.

Yes, you can't see it, it's surprising, but true.

Again, it's not just the non-prosecution, it's the complete lack of anyone demanding a prosecution. You challenged me to show that people in the south were upset about law enforcement's blind eye to their needs, I gave you plenty of quotes and resources. You have shown nothing similar in the case of France.

One more time, so you don't raise this again: it isn't just the lack of prosecution, it's the lack of anyone asking for prosecution.

That cannot be said of battered wives, and it cannot be said of the segregated south.

If you want to make that claim for "bossnapping," prove it.
 
The reasons why they are not demanding these crimes be prosecuted are the same. Of course in civilized nations you do not need the victim to demand that the crime be prosecuted for the crime to be prosecuted, but I am aware that this is france and not a civilized nation.

Where's your evidence that the management in France is suffering from a psychological condition that limits their ability to raise their own grievances?

Because that's what battered person's syndrome does.

Facts, facts, where are your facts? Your imagination isn't that entertaining, so maybe try a different approach.
 
Yes, you can't see it, it's surprising, but true.

Again, it's not just the non-prosecution, it's the complete lack of anyone demanding a prosecution. You challenged me to show that people in the south were upset about law enforcement's blind eye to their needs, I gave you plenty of quotes and resources. You have shown nothing similar in the case of France.

And in france hostage means you are free to go when ever you want, you are just hanging out drinking coffee.

link


I guess people like the president of france do not count. He is not french enough.
 
Where's your evidence that the management in France is suffering from a psychological condition that limits their ability to raise their own grievances?

Because that's what battered person's syndrome does.

Facts, facts, where are your facts? Your imagination isn't that entertaining, so maybe try a different approach.

And your position is that no one in france cares if you hold people hostage for periods of time. Or that hostages in france are free to go.
 
If the child is underage then their parents of their parents representatives can hold them against their will. Now if it was an emancipated minor it would be a different issue.

Want to know something? As an EMT I could not transport adults against their will, it would be kidnapping, but minors could not legally refuse medical care as they can not take responsibility for what happens to them.

I think we agree it "goes to motive". If it's in the best interest of everyone invloved it's OK, if not there are problems.

Whenever I think of this I consider hazing. When it is taken too far it's assault, but in the right context it's commonplace. lol, as the french say "C'est la vie" :D
 
And in france hostage means you are free to go when ever you want, you are just hanging out drinking coffee.

link


I guess people like the president of france do not count. He is not french enough.

I mean this in all honesty: do you read anything I write?

I have dealt with this about 4 times. This situation appears to be slightly different than the typical action, therefore the French are cracking down. They are beginning to fear an escalation of the practice.

It's very simple: when it becomes harmful, or the French definitively describe it as illegal, the game stops being a game.

You're pointing out things that happened pages ago and acting like they're revelations.
 
And your position is that no one in france cares if you hold people hostage for periods of time. Or that hostages in france are free to go.

Haha, are you Andy Kauffman? Is this some kind of performance comedy? Even so, I've seen better.

Again, this has already been discussed.
 
I can imagine a whole lot of things, too, but that doesn't make it so.
which includes the idea that the detained managers thought this was OK. That was kind of my point.


I already did. Here it is again:
"It's true that this might seem surprising abroad, but it's less surprising in France, where we're more used to this kind of situation," said a Sony spokeswoman.
Sony had an incident a few years back.

Nice dodge by cutting up my post you were responding to by cutting this part as part of the previous response
cwalner said:
While you are correct I don't have evidence of either, both are very reasonable explanations why the actual victims (the ones kidnapped, not some mouthpiece hired by thier compnay) are not speaking out about this and are just as valid as the explanation that they accept it and are ok with it.
You see, that parenthetical part, which I bolded this time so you don't ignore it completely this time, shows that I was aware of this argument already but that also could smell it for the horse**** that it is. I don't care what the company or its spokepeople think of thier lower management being detained, I care what the detainee thinks.

While we're at it, you're argument seems to claim that this 'theater' is acceptable because it is the only way to get the company to see how badly they are treating thier employees by laying them off. What makes you think that a compnay that cares so little for its employees, suddenly has this emotional epiphany when moving one rung up the ladder and gives a rat's ass about its lower management?

That's the part that you seem to completely fail to get. The person who is paying the price for the worker's being upset by losing his freedom (for however a brief of time) Had absolutely no say whatsoever in the decision to lay off the workers in the first place, and is barely above the workers within the corporate structure in the second place. Most low level managers are just as hard working employees as the people they manage. They have much more in common with thier employees than they do with thier company's upper management. The only major difference between them and thier detainers is the title of manager.

This is why I have such a problem with this. Not only is somebody being detained against his will and the society in which it happens doesn't seem to care. The person being detained is not even the person responsible for the decision that got the detainers upset in the first place.

Also what would you think if this were slightly reversed. What would be your opinion if the manager told all employees they had to work a single mandatory graveyard shift, or lose thier job? Would the fact that most, maybe all of the employees would grudgingly do this make this right? Would the fact that they probably would not complain out of fear of losing thier job make it right?
 
That's the part that you seem to completely fail to get. The person who is paying the price for the worker's being upset by losing his freedom (for however a brief of time) Had absolutely no say whatsoever in the decision to lay off the workers in the first place, and is barely above the workers within the corporate structure in the second place. Most low level managers are just as hard working employees as the people they manage. They have much more in common with thier employees than they do with thier company's upper management.

This is usually correct but I didn't get this from the articles I read. It would seem the kidnappings are at smaller businesses where the boss is more directly responsible. You're assuming that a number of people are kidnapping someone with little or no power. That would even more case for it being a symbolic act. In either case I'm not buying your argument.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom