I can imagine a whole lot of things, too, but that doesn't make it so.
which includes the idea that the detained managers thought this was OK. That was kind of my point.
I already did. Here it is again:
"It's true that this might seem surprising abroad, but it's less surprising in France, where we're more used to this kind of situation," said a Sony spokeswoman.
Sony had an incident a few years back.
Nice dodge by cutting up my post you were responding to by cutting this part as part of the previous response
cwalner said:
While you are correct I don't have evidence of either, both are very reasonable explanations why the actual victims (the ones kidnapped, not some mouthpiece hired by thier compnay) are not speaking out about this and are just as valid as the explanation that they accept it and are ok with it.
You see, that parenthetical part, which I bolded this time so you don't ignore it completely this time, shows that I was aware of this argument already but that also could smell it for the horse**** that it is. I don't care what the company or its spokepeople think of thier lower management being detained, I care what the detainee thinks.
While we're at it, you're argument seems to claim that this 'theater' is acceptable because it is the only way to get the company to see how badly they are treating thier employees by laying them off. What makes you think that a compnay that cares so little for its employees, suddenly has this emotional epiphany when moving one rung up the ladder and gives a rat's ass about its lower management?
That's the part that you seem to completely fail to get. The person who is paying the price for the worker's being upset by losing his freedom (for however a brief of time) Had absolutely no say whatsoever in the decision to lay off the workers in the first place, and is barely above the workers within the corporate structure in the second place. Most low level managers are just as hard working employees as the people they manage. They have much more in common with thier employees than they do with thier company's upper management. The only major difference between them and thier detainers is the title of manager.
This is why I have such a problem with this. Not only is somebody being detained against his will and the society in which it happens doesn't seem to care. The person being detained is not even the person responsible for the decision that got the detainers upset in the first place.
Also what would you think if this were slightly reversed. What would be your opinion if the manager told all employees they had to work a single mandatory graveyard shift, or lose thier job? Would the fact that most, maybe all of the employees would grudgingly do this make this right? Would the fact that they probably would not complain out of fear of losing thier job make it right?