Introductory Physics Vs. 9/11 TRUTH!!!

The 'truthseekers' contend that a high explosive would create a vacuum on the floor where it occurs thus sucking the building down faster than a free fall event.
That should be easy to test. Look at video of a known demolition and see if there is any evidence that the building accelerates faster (or even as fast as) free fall.
 
The 'truthseekers' contend that a high explosive would create a vacuum on the floor where it occurs thus sucking the building down faster than a free fall event.


As J5 said: I [rule8] you not.

No, gumboot said that.

But I was thinking it. :)
 
That should be easy to test. Look at video of a known demolition and see if there is any evidence that the building accelerates faster (or even as fast as) free fall.

That would be a difficult test for troofers, since they have no idea what "free fall" actually means.
 
No, gumboot said that.

But I was thinking it. :)


[conspiracy]No wayyyy!!!11!!

I distinctly remember it was you. OBVIOUSLY the record has been altered to now show that gumboot said it and you are covering for him or you are a patsy taking the heat for the facist overlords controlling the evidence.[/conspiracy]


:blush:
My bad,
credit gumboot with the statement.
 
That should be easy to test. Look at video of a known demolition and see if there is any evidence that the building accelerates faster (or even as fast as) free fall.

Hmmmm, I seem to recall seeing someone who stated that all CD's do fall faster than normal. It was such insanity that I ignored it especially given that the poster did not have any evidence to back the contention up with.
 
To elaborate further: In physics there is no "deceleration"; the term "acceleration" covers any change in velocity. It could be a change to a higher rate of speed, to a lower rate of speed, or a change in direction (since velocity is a vector representing speed and direction).

Also, "negative acceleration" is not deceleration, but acceleration in a "negative" direction.

ETA: The reason I know this is that, to counter the troofer arguments, I had to be sure I knew what I was talking about, so I brushed up on my physics. In that sense, the debates over 9/11 conspiracies have been a positive experience for me!

Yes I know there's no such concept in physics as "deceleration", I should have just said "speed reduced from 500mph to 0 in less than a second" my bad.
 
OK, the physics of WTC 1 & 2 collapses as I understand it.

1. Both towers were impacted by passenger airliners travelling at approx 500 mph, according to eye-witness and video evidence. The collision zone on the second tower was much lower than on the first.

2. 500 mph is approx 220 metres per second. The speed was reduced to 0 in less than a second by collision. Hence the aircraft accelerated at 220 metres per second squared in the direction opposite to the direction of travel.

3. The mass of one of these aircraft is approx 100 tons = approx 100,000 kg.
From F=ma, the aircraft experienced a force of 22 million Newtons.

4. From Newton's Third Law, the tower experience a force of 22 million newtons in ithe direction of travel. Since it was anchored to the ground it didn't move but the force puts considerable stress on the tower structure, particularly at the impact zone. The impact zones are also doused in burning aviation fuel, the heat of which weakens the structure yet further until it can no longer support the weight above it. Unsurprisingly, the impact zone of the second tower becomes too weak first and collapses. Both towers break first at the impact zone, consistent with being due to weakened structure.

5. From t=sqrt(2d/g) where d is the height of the towers (approx 400 metres) and g is the acceleration due to gravity (approx 9.8 metres per second squared, free fall from the top of the towers would be approx 9 seconds. It's hard to time the fall time of the towers exactly because all the debris created conceals the final seconds of the collapse but it seems to be 14 - 15 seconds. This would be because the structure below the collapseng part would slow the fall. The falling structure does more damage as it falls, causing the parts of the towers below the impact zones to collapse also.

CONCLUSION. The observed collapse of the towers is consistant with the hypothesis that it was caused by the impact of the planes.

Have I missed anything?
 
Yes I know there's no such concept in physics as "deceleration", I should have just said "speed reduced from 500mph to 0 in less than a second" my bad.

It's tough to use conversational language to discuss technical issues, since everyday words can have different meanings...kind of like the word "theory" as used by creationists.
 
OK, the physics of WTC 1 & 2 collapses as I understand it.

1. Both towers were impacted by passenger airliners travelling at approx 500 mph, according to eye-witness and video evidence. The collision zone on the second tower was much lower than on the first.

2. 500 mph is approx 220 metres per second. The speed was reduced to 0 in less than a second by collision. Hence the aircraft accelerated at 220 metres per second squared in the direction opposite to the direction of travel.

3. The mass of one of these aircraft is approx 100 tons = approx 100,000 kg.
From F=ma, the aircraft experienced a force of 22 million Newtons.

4. From Newton's Third Law, the tower experience a force of 22 million newtons in ithe direction of travel. Since it was anchored to the ground it didn't move but the force puts considerable stress on the tower structure, particularly at the impact zone. The impact zones are also doused in burning aviation fuel, the heat of which weakens the structure yet further until it can no longer support the weight above it. Unsurprisingly, the impact zone of the second tower becomes too weak first and collapses. Both towers break first at the impact zone, consistent with being due to weakened structure.

5. From t=sqrt(2d/g) where d is the height of the towers (approx 400 metres) and g is the acceleration due to gravity (approx 9.8 metres per second squared, free fall from the top of the towers would be approx 9 seconds. It's hard to time the fall time of the towers exactly because all the debris created conceals the final seconds of the collapse but it seems to be 14 - 15 seconds. This would be because the structure below the collapseng part would slow the fall. The falling structure does more damage as it falls, causing the parts of the towers below the impact zones to collapse also.

CONCLUSION. The observed collapse of the towers is consistant with the hypothesis that it was caused by the impact of the planes.

Have I missed anything?

Maybe the force of the upper part of the building colliding with the lower part as it collapsed?

I'm sure a clever differential equation could be put together to represent this, as the mass of the mobile section grew as it got closer to the ground.

One of the points I have brought up with troofers (one which they completely failed to grasp, of course) was that if the lower section was sturdier, then the force of the upper section hitting it would be greater, since the speed would decrease more rapidly. Thus, a sturdier structure is no guarantee that collapse could be arrested.

(Of course, this is somewhat meaningless since there are no actual numbers involved, but it does show that the troofers' mental model of a collapsing building doesn't even consider important factors like this.)
 
I guess it was consumed in the ensuing implosion of reality.

The government planted some C4 on those mathematical units and then they "pulled it" and pulverized them into dust.

That would also explain Killtown's ft + mph = ft calculation.

How do you convert logb(x) to logk(x)? Easy, you just multiply... or divide... or something! ADD TWO! It's so obvious and common sense!
 
Just wanted to properly formulate this:

[latex]$$log_b(x) = \frac{log_b(x) \times 2}{something} ? + 2? = log_k(x)$$[/latex]
 
Last edited:
The government planted some C4 on those mathematical units and then they "pulled it" and pulverized them into dust.

That would also explain Killtown's ft + mph = ft calculation.

How do you convert logb(x) to logk(x)? Easy, you just multiply... or divide... or something! ADD TWO! It's so obvious and common sense!

Check out this page for how to change the base of a log:

http://oakroadsystems.com/math/loglaws.htm

Look in the section "Changing the base".

The result is:

logbx = (logax) / (logab)
 
Last edited:
Check out this page for how to change the base of a log:

http://oakroadsystems.com/math/loglaws.htm

latex.php


It was a joke, only a joke. I do know how to change a log base, but I would imagine many CTists don't.

The page is interesting though, thank you.

ETA: Oh, you tricky devil, you added it to your post too.
 
How did you render your formula?

Looks like you somehow use a latex function built in to the forum software.

Is there documentation for it?

http://www.andy-roberts.net/misc/latex/latextutorial9.html

Has some info on the math functions. Specifically, this is what I typed:

[latex]$$log_b(x) = \frac{log_k(x)}{log_k(b)}$$[/latex]

Apparently you can do all kinds of crazy stuff with it, including very complex formulas and tables and what-not, but I've just got the basics down.
 
Maybe the force of the upper part of the building colliding with the lower part as it collapsed?

According to 28K, this could all be figured out using common sense. You see, the upper part should have slid off the lower part, or bounced off, or something, since the upper part was tilting when it hit the lower.

Also, 28K believes that the lower part of the building hit the ground three seconds before the upper part did.

Of course, he might have been lying about all of that.

Back to the numbers!
 
Ah, what was your point again? The fact I mock your silliness obviously angers you, so the slam on my "maturity". Eh, still not impressed with your rhetoric.
So, you're telling me an orthodoxy exists. Care to give some real-world examples, you know, something that exists outside of the space between your ears?
Or is that too "orthodox" for you?

Lol, So what do we do? Do you take my word for it that it really doesn't bother me or we can carry on with does, doesn't, does so, doesn't so.

I was having fun with the irony of someone accusing me of silliness in such an immature way, and it was very funny, well it made me smile anyway.

It's clearly very important to you to try to demonstrate my sillines with your pointless baiting so I'll leave it alone now and go back to talking with the big boys.
 
Lol, So what do we do? Do you take my word for it that it really doesn't bother me or we can carry on with does, doesn't, does so, doesn't so.

I was having fun with the irony of someone accusing me of silliness in such an immature way, and it was very funny, well it made me smile anyway.

It's clearly very important to you to try to demonstrate my sillines with your pointless baiting so I'll leave it alone now and go back to talking with the big boys.
William, would you be kind enough to point to an example of the political orthodoxy applied to physics by an anti-CT poster here on a JREF forum post?

I am attempting to understand your unsupported assertion.

DR
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom