Introductory Physics Vs. 9/11 TRUTH!!!

Yes, thank you. The force of the impact didn't transfer into the force of collapse. The impact caused damage but it was the weakened steel that let loose the concrete slab which started in collapse. The force of impact is therefore inconsequential to the force of collapse and cannot be added to the equation as kinetic energy.

No one has claimed it can be added in, that's a straw man you've constructed.

Post where I said that the force of the collision can be added to the force involved in the collapse, or stop invoking this ridiculous straw man.

Actually, it wasn't just the concrete slab that initiated collapse, it was the entire mass above the point of failure.
 
Your belief that I am adding the two forces is both incorrect and unsupported by a single word I've said.
a = F/m

From which we derive the classic F = ma equation, that gives us an idea of the huge freaking amounts of force involved in the collision between an airplane going 500 miles and hour and a bloody building! Never mind the massive amounts of force involved when a huge chunk of that building comes down. But no, the lower floors should have somehow stopped a huge chunk of mass somehow using, perhaps, magic.

It sounds to me like you are trying to factor in the airplane impact. If that isn't what you meant then explain the 500 mile an hr comment and how that works it's way into the equation

I also never claimed that the simple calculation for free fall somehow showed how fast the buildings should fall with a given amount of resistance. That is goalpost shifting you added in. I was simply addressing the "faster than free-fall" claim I have heard truthers bandy about.
d = ½gt

Which handily disproves claims that, say, it should've taken the towers 42 seconds to fall under the influence of gravity alone.

That's what you said. That doesn't say anything about faster than freefall, it says that it refutes the fact that it should take the buildings 42 secs to collapse. The truthers say that 42 sec is the amount of time it would take to fall with the resistance of the building. So the resistance is added in by implication.
 
Well, the point of my OP was that the truthers often discount the amount of force imparted on impact to the structural columns of the towers. This damage subsequently reduced the load-bearing abilities of the structural support.

So yes, the force of the impact was just slightly important to the collapse. So was the fire, the length of time involved, and the load above the point of impact. I didn't mention those either, but that doesn't mean I don't understand them.

Your belief that I am adding the two forces is both incorrect and unsupported by a single word I've said.

I also never claimed that the simple calculation for free fall somehow showed how fast the buildings should fall with a given amount of resistance. That is goalpost shifting you added in. I was simply addressing the "faster than free-fall" claim I have heard truthers bandy about.

You don't even seem to be able to accurately comprehend what I actually said and did not say. For one thing, your idea that I am somehow adding the force of the collapse and the force of the airliner collision is truly bizarre, as I said or implied no such thing.

The post wasn't supposed to be a comprehensive list of all the physical elements of the collapse. Perhaps that was unclear to you.
This is why I stated that Without Rights is ?"Really, really functionally illiterate and wilfully stupid "
He cannot comprehend the relationships. It wasn't fire, it wasn't collision. It was the two in combination! The towers maintained structural integrity after the collision--for quite some time.
The fires themselves could have brought the buildings down, given time--but the likelyhod of such intense, unrestrained fires occuring without the a/c ramming into the buildings is near zero. since the suppression system would work if intact, the fires would not have reached that intensity required to fail the various elements of the structure.
Meanwhile, CT'ers are running around in semi-literate dazes:
"Thunder! Lightning! Isn't it amazing how often they occur so close together in time!"
 
It sounds to me like you are trying to factor in the airplane impact. If that isn't what you meant then explain the 500 mile an hr comment and how that works it's way into the equation

Apparently your reading comprehension is terrible. I mentioned the force imparted to the building (and, by extension, the structural elements of the building) by the airplane. I then placed a period, which indicates that one sentence has ended and a new one is about to begin. I then mentioned in passing the force involved in the building collapse, totally independent of the airplane collision.

So what proof do you have that the lower floors were capable of providing significant resistance to the building? You do, of course, understand that real controlled demolition simply blows out a minimal number of support columns to allow a building to collapse, right? It doesn't just make all the supporting elements turn into dust.
 
This is why I stated that Without Rights is ?"Really, really functionally illiterate and wilfully stupid "
He cannot comprehend the relationships. It wasn't fire, it wasn't collision. It was the two in combination! The towers maintained structural integrity after the collision--for quite some time.
The fires themselves could have brought the buildings down, given time--but the likelyhod of such intense, unrestrained fires occuring without the a/c ramming into the buildings is near zero. since the suppression system would work if intact, the fires would not have reached that intensity required to fail the various elements of the structure.
Meanwhile, CT'ers are running around in semi-literate dazes:
"Thunder! Lightning! Isn't it amazing how often they occur so close together in time!"

Hell, he apparently thinks that I connected the forces of collision and collapse together somehow, while quoting a paragraph where I did no such thing. I'm not thinking much of his reading comprehension right now.
 
Yes, thank you. The force of the impact didn't transfer into the force of collapse. The impact caused damage but it was the weakened steel that let loose the concrete slab which started in collapse. The force of impact is therefore inconsequential to the force of collapse and cannot be added to the equation as kinetic energy.
Wrong again. As always.
It was buckling of the vertical beams (columns) and floor truss system that started the collapse
 
No one has claimed it can be added in, that's a straw man you've constructed.

Post where I said that the force of the collision can be added to the force involved in the collapse, or stop invoking this ridiculous straw man.

Actually, it wasn't just the concrete slab that initiated collapse, it was the entire mass above the point of failure.

Then why is "The airliner cannot be added as force into the equation, the force is the load of the upper floors falling on the lower floors." such a ridiculous thing to say if you agree with it? You were arguing that fact the whole day and called me stupid because I said it. Now you say you never said it. Why didn't you just correct me on my first post if I misconstrued your statement? And why do I get a line in your signature for stating that they cannot be added together?
 
True, but when it hits a skyscraper it decelerates from 500 mph to 0 in less than a second. Mechanical impact alone would have done serious damage, never mind the thousands of gallons of burning aviation fuel.

The reason for using the kinetic energy calculation is that we then know, since the aircraft stopped moving, how much energy was absorbed by the buildings. That's assuming we know the mass of the aircraft and the velocity at impact. That energy had to go into the impact - there was nowhere else for it to go.

In the same way, the easiest calculation for the energy in the falling building is the formula for gravitational potential energy - mgh. We know the mass, the height* and the acceleration due to gravity, so we know how many joules/tons of TNT were released when the buildings fell.

(*the height of the centre of gravity of the buildings is the only slightly tricky one, as the lower part was more massive than the upper).
 
This is why I stated that Without Rights is ?"Really, really functionally illiterate and wilfully stupid "
He cannot comprehend the relationships. It wasn't fire, it wasn't collision. It was the two in combination! The towers maintained structural integrity after the collision--for quite some time.
The fires themselves could have brought the buildings down, given time--but the likelyhod of such intense, unrestrained fires occuring without the a/c ramming into the buildings is near zero. since the suppression system would work if intact, the fires would not have reached that intensity required to fail the various elements of the structure.
Meanwhile, CT'ers are running around in semi-literate dazes:
"Thunder! Lightning! Isn't it amazing how often they occur so close together in time!"

Ok, sure it was the collision and the fire that initiated the collapse but that is not what is claimed by the equation. I gather that you have not understood a word I said. The cause of collapse is not even in question in this thread.
 
Actually, it wasn't just the concrete slab that initiated collapse, it was the entire mass above the point of failure.

It can be clearly seen in film of the collapse that the top part of the building is falling as a single intact item, at least at first.
 
I beg to differ, this equation only proves that the towers did not fall at freefall speed. It can only measure falls with insignificant resistance. All I get from this is 10 sec at freefall speed is 1600 ft and the towers were 1360 ft. This equation cannot tell us how long it would take with the added resistance of the building. Therefore it cannot disprove a claim that states it would it take the towers 42 secs to fall with the resistance of the building.

The resistance of the building being whatever number gets plugged in.

What we do know is that buildings are built to support the stationary weight. The forces exerted by a falling mass are vastly more. This can easily be visualised by gently placing a bowling ball on a glass table, and then dropping the ball from six feet above.
 
Then why is "The airliner cannot be added as force into the equation, the force is the load of the upper floors falling on the lower floors." such a ridiculous thing to say if you agree with it? You were arguing that fact the whole day and called me stupid because I said it. Now you say you never said it. Why didn't you just correct me on my first post if I misconstrued your statement? And why do I get a line in your signature for stating that they cannot be added together?

I find the following things stupid about the quote and reasoning underlying it:

1) You believed that anyone was trying to add two completely unrelated force vectors.

2) You stated that the impact of the plane was a non-factor and we should be looking at the force of the collision instead.

3) Your statement was in response to an equation talking about the collision, not the collapse.

I should really add a link to your post so it's clearer.

Here you quoted me when I was clearly talking about the collision between plane and building, then you let that particular gem out of your mouth, then spent the next page talking about how I was trying to add the two forces together.

You're right, when taken out of context, what you said actually sounds reasonable. However, in response to what I actually said, it just looks like you didn't understand a word I wrote.

ETA: There, I edited it to provide proper context.
 
Last edited:
The resistance of the building being whatever number gets plugged in.

What we do know is that buildings are built to support the stationary weight. The forces exerted by a falling mass are vastly more. This can easily be visualised by gently placing a bowling ball on a glass table, and then dropping the ball from six feet above.

Especially as energy increases directly proportional to the square of the velocity, so as the downward velocity of the collapsing mass increases, the energy involved increases considerably.
 
The resistance of the building being whatever number gets plugged in.

What we do know is that buildings are built to support the stationary weight. The forces exerted by a falling mass are vastly more. This can easily be visualised by gently placing a bowling ball on a glass table, and then dropping the ball from six feet above.

I agree, so how does
d = ½gt handily disprove claims that, say, it should've taken the towers 42 seconds to fall under the influence of gravity alone?

or how does a = F/m prove the lower floors could not have absorbed the force of collapse?

They can't is the answer, which was the point of me chiming in. I never said I think bombs were used, I never said I don't think it was a pancake collapse. I said these equations do not prove the truthers wrong. It is only rhetoric and twisting of science that matches that of the truthers. This is just plain bad physics, period. All we can derive from these equations is that 1600ft in 10 sec is freefall speed with insignificant resistance. We can't say 42 seconds is unreasonable because that is a number derived from equations where resistance is factored in. The truthers maybe are misrepresenting the resistance but that is not evident by this equation.
 
Especially as energy increases directly proportional to the square of the velocity, so as the downward velocity of the collapsing mass increases, the energy involved increases considerably.

However:
One can "back-out" the average resistive force to collision.
Take the actual time to fall (call it 12 seconds, 10 seconds whatever you want--just peer through the dust couds with your little CT X-ray vision if you don't believe official theory)
s=1/2*a*t^2
s=N floors*12 feet/floor
t=12
You get "a"
F=m*a
subtract that from F=m*g
just remember--m will be the average mass, which is
((113-N)floors*mass/floor)+(((N-0)floors/2)*mass/floor)

But consider this:
For 1360 feet, T=9.2 seconds at 1 g
For t=10 seconds, a=27.2 ft/sec^2
for t=12 sec, a=18.88ft/sec^2
so at 10 seconds, the resisting force (average) is 4.8 in/sec^2* (average mass)
and at 12 seconds fall, resistance (average is 13 in/sec^2*(average mass)

Pretty hefty resistance there.
 
I find the following things stupid about the quote and reasoning underlying it:
1) You believed that anyone was trying to add two completely unrelated force vectors.
Why didn't you correct me instead of arguing against me on it.
2) You stated that the impact of the plane was a non-factor and we should be looking at the force of the collision instead.
The collision and impact are the same thing, but assuming you meant collapse instead of collision;
It is a non-factor if you are trying to refute the fact that 42 sec is an unreasonable amount of time for a collapse to occur with an undetermined resistance.
3) Your statement was in response to an equation talking about the collision, not the collapse.
Then how can it debunk a claim about the collapse if it was about the collision?



http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2398963#post2398963
You're right, when taken out of context, what you said actually sounds reasonable. However, in response to what I actually said, it just looks like you didn't understand a word I wrote.
Then you should of corrected me instead of arguing against it. It still doesn't help your claim that the equations discredit the 42 sec theory. Why would you even use a measurement of collision to discredit a measurement of collapse?
 
I agree, so how does
d = ½gt handily disprove claims that, say, it should've taken the towers 42 seconds to fall under the influence of gravity alone?

However:
One can "back-out" the average resistive force to collision.
Take the actual time to fall (call it 12 seconds, 10 seconds whatever you want--just peer through the dust couds with your little CT X-ray vision if you don't believe official theory)

(snip)

so at 10 seconds, the resisting force (average) is 4.8 in/sec^2* (average mass)
and at 12 seconds fall, resistance (average is 13 in/sec^2*(average mass)

Pretty hefty resistance there.

So, assuming an average of 0.33 m/s^2 of resitance, that would put our net downward acceleration at approximately 9.47 m/s^2, on average.

So, Without Rights, given that value for net force, how do you obtain a value of 42 seconds?
 
Last edited:
So, assuming an average of 0.33 m/s^2 of resitance, that would put our net downward acceleration at approximately 9.47 m/s^2, on average.

Given that value for net force, how do you obtain a value of 42 seconds?
Woa, Nellie!
Leave me out of that folklore.
I figure 10-12 seconds is a LONG time for the building to fall!
 
Then you should of corrected me instead of arguing against it. It still doesn't help your claim that the equations discredit the 42 sec theory. Why would you even use a measurement of collision to discredit a measurement of collapse?

What in the world are you talking about? Those two points have always been separate. One regarded the force imparted to the support structure of the towers by the collision, the other involved the time to collapse.

The issue of resistance is yet another issue.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom