A little harsh, don't you think? I can barely add 2+2, but I'm fairly intelligent in other areas, and most importantly, I *know* I can't do maths, so I let people who can, do it instead. It requires an element of trust on my part, but I'm comfortable with that. I wish the troofers were...
No, I have the utmost respect for people who admit openly that they don't understand. I, for example, do
not understand advanced physics
at all. I may have the capacity to eventually understand it, but I lack the needed education to understand the concepts involved.
If you claimed you knew everything about physics in the next breath, you would be a moron. Because you're willing to admit what you don't know, you're a freaking genius.
My basis for calling the troofers "stupid" isn't based on their lack of physics (I can't really talk, after all), but on their lack of honesty. They all claim they can figure it out using things like "common sense".
A more appropriate equation would have been
Kinetic Energy=(0.5)m(v^2)
The problem with using F=ma is that an airplane traveling at a constant velocity has zero acceleration.
Point taken, I suppose it would be a simpler approach to the problem.
The F=ma equation isn't entirely inappropriate though, since there must be a force acting on the plane in order to maintain its speed and negate the decelleration due to the friction of the air it's travelling through. Your formula is just a lot simpler to use because you don't have to waste a whole ton of time trying to figure what that force is, since you already know those particular variables . . . (m & v)
I was thinking of using the deceleration, which probably wasn't the best or simplest approach. As steve pointed out, using the equation for kinetic energy would be a heck of a lot simpler from a mathematical perspective.
You will understand in time that the only acceptable Physics on this forum comes from politically orthodox contributors. The free fall thing has been done to death but I have posted on this previously and offer this slightly edited version of that explanation to you.
What I've seen is that the acceptable physics comes from people who understand the physics they put forward and can explain it sufficiently. Please define "politically orthodox" further, it means little to nothing in the context you use it.
It is very difficult for us to intuitively grasp terms like Joules and g so don't be phased and put off the mathematics by people quoting numbers like 10^11 Joules. It becomes even more confusing when Physicists revert to the energy model for falling objects (KE. PE etc) but again the mathematics is relatively easy to understand so don't be phased by it.
Actually, I'm not "phased" by that at all. I have the requisite mathematics background to understand the simpler concepts involved, and am currently pursuing the background needed to understand the higher level, calculus-based concepts. Since those aren't strictly necessary to develop a basic understanding of the physics at work, I'm not troubled by that.
I fail to see how energy is irrelevant because an object is falling. Energy is still present in the equation, so why shouldn't we consider it? I don't find it confusing at all.