Introductory Physics Vs. 9/11 TRUTH!!!

d = ½gt

Which handily disproves claims that, say, it should've taken the towers 42 seconds to fall under the influence of gravity alone.

I beg to differ, this equation only proves that the towers did not fall at freefall speed. It can only measure falls with insignificant resistance. All I get from this is 10 sec at freefall speed is 1600 ft and the towers were 1360 ft. This equation cannot tell us how long it would take with the added resistance of the building. Therefore it cannot disprove a claim that states it would it take the towers 42 secs to fall with the resistance of the building.


a = F/m

From which we derive the classic F = ma equation, that gives us an idea of the huge freaking amounts of force involved in the collision between an airplane going 500 miles and hour and a bloody building!

The airliner cannot be added as force into the equation, the force is the load of the upper floors falling on the lower floors. To come to definitive conclusion using this equation you need a lot more data than you provide. You can't even do the math in your example because you don't have the numbers.
 
I beg to differ, this equation only proves that the towers did not fall at freefall speed. It can only measure falls with insignificant resistance. All I get from this is 10 sec at freefall speed is 1600 ft and the towers were 1360 ft. This equation cannot tell us how long it would take with the added resistance of the building. Therefore it cannot disprove a claim that states it would it take the towers 42 secs to fall with the resistance of the building.




The airliner cannot be added as force into the equation, the force is the load of the upper floors falling on the lower floors. To come to definitive conclusion using this equation you need a lot more data than you provide. You can't even do the math in your example because you don't have the numbers.

All of which supports the "official story" more than any conspiracy theory. That is because, absent the known values needed to perform a complete calculation, you next must look at the evidence itself. We can conclude that the resistance provided by the structure was insufficient to overcome the downward forces because we can see it happen from numerous recordings of the event. Since conspiracy theorists think this evidence "looks wrong", they distrust it, and so don't even have that to help them come to a conclusion. All they have is a fervent belief based on...well, you tell me.

Once again, strong evidence that the troofers come up with the conclusions first, then beginning fishing for "evidence".
 
We can conclude that the resistance provided by the structure was insufficient to overcome the downward forces because we can see it happen from numerous recordings of the event.

I don't understand what you mean. The point was that these equations cannot come to the conclusions that the author is using them for. The rest of the evidence is not correlated to these equations and to use them in the context above is unscientific and disregards the whole purpose of the equations.
 
I beg to differ, this equation only proves that the towers did not fall at freefall speed. It can only measure falls with insignificant resistance. All I get from this is 10 sec at freefall speed is 1600 ft and the towers were 1360 ft. This equation cannot tell us how long it would take with the added resistance of the building. Therefore it cannot disprove a claim that states it would it take the towers 42 secs to fall with the resistance of the building.

You're just being silly. I'm not going to bother dredging this up again, but the amount of kinetic energy brought to bear by 10-20 stories of a building crashing down on the rest of the building is considerable. Too considerable, in fact, to allow the lower structure to offer much resistance.

And clearly the towers didn't fall at "free fall speeds", they fell in roughly 12-19 seconds, several seconds slower than free fall. If you think it fell "too fast" then you're welcome to provide your own calculations. I'll put my trust in the thousands upon thousands of far more knowledgable people who ran the numbers and found nothing suspicious about them, as I see nothing particularly odd about the circumstances.

You've just moved the goalposts anyhow. Truthers are always claiming the towers fell faster than free fall, but they can't even calculate free fall.

The airliner cannot be added as force into the equation, the force is the load of the upper floors falling on the lower floors. To come to definitive conclusion using this equation you need a lot more data than you provide. You can't even do the math in your example because you don't have the numbers.

Actually, you can. All you need to know is the approximate mass of the airliner, the speed it was traveling, and the approximate time it took to come to rest. You want to do it without that, just use this:

latex.php


Which only requires approximate mass and approximate velocity on collision to determine kinetic energy at impact.

You're also equating force of collision with the load on the building when those are two different things. That can also be figured, but it requires more structural calculations than are provided by basic physics, which puts it kind of outside the scope of my OP. You can talk to some structural engineers if you want some idea of how it works.

You don't seem to know anything about the concept of "force", especially as I was talking about the initial collision and was very clear about that fact.

I think I'll add that silly quote to my sig line now, thanks.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand what you mean. The point was that these equations cannot come to the conclusions that the author is using them for. The rest of the evidence is not correlated to these equations and to use them in the context above is unscientific and disregards the whole purpose of the equations.

You either didn't read my post or didn't understand it. You also don't appear to have read or understood the posts that followed it.
 
You're just being silly. I'm not going to bother dredging this up again, but the amount of kinetic energy brought to bear by 10-20 stories of a building crashing down on the rest of the building is considerable. Too considerable, in fact, to allow the lower structure to offer much resistance.

That is a story that these equations do not tell.
And clearly the towers didn't fall at "free fall speeds", they fell in roughly 12-19 seconds, several seconds slower than free fall. If you think it fell "too fast" then you're welcome to provide your own calculations.

I didn't say that, I actually said your equation (1st) only proves that they did not fall at freefall speeds. It offers no math on how much the buildings resistance would slow the collapse, which is what you were claiming.


Actually, you can. All you need to know is the approximate mass of the airliner, the speed it was traveling, and the approximate time it took to come to rest. You want to do it without that, just use this:

You don't understand. The force of collapse and the force of impact are 2 seperate figures. You cannot add the force of the impact to the force of collapse because they are uncorrelated. If the jetliners hit the building from the top and the collapse began subsequently then you can add the force of the jetliner but the story is the steel weakened and the floors fell ontop of eachother, so the force in the equation would only be the force caused by the upper floors.

http://www.randi.org/latexrender/latex.php?$$KE = \begin{matrix}\frac{1}{2}\end{matrix}mv^2$$
You're also equating force of collision with the load on the building when those are two different things.

No, that's what you are doing when you add the force of impact to the force of the collapse.
That can also be figured, but it requires more structural calculations than are provided by basic physics
Exactly, that's why your take on these equations is skewed. You don't have the data yat you claim to have the results.


You don't seem to know anything about the concept of "force", especially as I was talking about the initial collision and was very clear about that fact.

I know your logic is skewed by the fact that the force of the airliner is not what brought the towers down. It was the force of the floors that caused the collapse. To add the force of the airliner into the equation is a big mistake that you are overlooking.
I think I'll add that silly quote to my sig line now, thanks.

I would be honored.
 
You either didn't read my post or didn't understand it. You also don't appear to have read or understood the posts that followed it.

So what are you trying to measure, the force of impact or the force of collapse. If you are measuring the force of impact then you are barking up the wrong tree. It is the force of collapse that needs to be measured.
 
You don't understand. The force of collapse and the force of impact are 2 seperate figures. You cannot add the force of the impact to the force of collapse because they are uncorrelated. If the jetliners hit the building from the top and the collapse began subsequently then you can add the force of the jetliner but the story is the steel weakened and the floors fell ontop of eachother, so the force in the equation would only be the force caused by the upper floors.

True--you cant add them together--they are orthogonal vectors.



I know your logic is skewed by the fact that the force of the airliner is not what brought the towers down. It was the force of the floors that caused the collapse. To add the force of the airliner into the equation is a big mistake that you are overlooking.

BZZZZZZTTTT!
You are obviously willfully ignorant.
The two events not only display correlation, they are intimately tangled together.
Cause-->effect.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand what you mean. The point was that these equations cannot come to the conclusions that the author is using them for. The rest of the evidence is not correlated to these equations and to use them in the context above is unscientific and disregards the whole purpose of the equations.

Even if that's true, it doesn't change the fact that a belief that the building should have taken as long to collapse as it did is supported by video evidence, whereas the belief that it should have taken longer is supported only by the will to believe.

The belief that the evidence is correct is further supported by calculations done by structural engineers, none of which were surprised that the building fell as fast as it did.
 
BZZZZZZTTTT!
You are obviously willfully ignorant.
The two events not only display correlation, they are intimately tangled together.
Cause-->effect.

Cause and effect is not what we are talking about. We are talking about measuring the force of the collapse. The force of the impact is uncorrelated to the force of collapse. What is ignorant is adding the force of the jetliner to the collapse when they are 2 seperate events. If you want to measure the force of impact to claim that such force can start a pancake collapse then you are on the right track. If you want to measure the force of impact to claim that somehow the kinetic energy of the plane crashing was transferred to the collapse that happened 30 min later you are delusional and have a weak grasp of physics.
 
Even if that's true, it doesn't change the fact that a belief that the building should have taken as long to collapse as it did is supported by video evidence, whereas the belief that it should have taken longer is supported only by the will to believe.

And I never claimed that. I only said that these equations do not support what he claims they support.

The belief that the evidence is correct is further supported by calculations done by structural engineers, none of which were surprised that the building fell as fast as it did.

Well the equation the engineers did may very well be viable, but these equations are not.
 
Cause and effect is not what we are talking about. We are talking about measuring the force of the collapse. The force of the impact is uncorrelated to the force of collapse. What is ignorant is adding the force of the jetliner to the collapse when they are 2 seperate events. If you want to measure the force of impact to claim that such force can start a pancake collapse then you are on the right track. If you want to measure the force of impact to claim that somehow the kinetic energy of the plane crashing was transferred to the collapse that happened 30 min later you are delusional and have a weak grasp of physics.

Except that one of the key factors is the ability of the structure to resist a collapse. That number was changed by the airliner impact, and further by the ensuing fire.

Are you arguing that, with a free-falling upper structure as a given, the lower structure should have been able to survive the downward forces? Or, are you just trying to obfuscate?

I'm betting on option #2.
 
True--you cant add them together--they are orthogonal vectors.





BZZZZZZTTTT!
You are obviously willfully ignorant.
The two events not only display correlation, they are intimately tangled together.
Cause-->effect.

Ok, After your reply, I'm going to change that "willfully ignorant" to:
Really, really functionally illiterate and wilfully stupid
 
Except that one of the key factors is the ability of the structure to resist a collapse. That number was changed by the airliner impact, and further by the ensuing fire.

Ok, and that would be something to factor into the resistance of the building. You cannot factor it into the force of collapse. Force and resistance are nearly opposites and what the author of the thread is trying to do is bind them together.

Are you arguing that, with a free-falling upper structure as a given, the lower structure should have been able to survive the downward forces? Or, are you just trying to obfuscate?

Neither, I never said the structure should have survived the force of the upperfloors falling on top of eachother and I am not trying to confuse anyone. I said the force to be measured in the collapse is that of the upper floors falling on top of eachother which is a complicated equation because force is added into the equation after each floor is added into the collapse. The junior high physics displayed here do nothing to support the claims made. Keep in mind that I am not saying that these things have not been disproved or that the official theory is wrong, I only say that these equations do not support the claims made by the author.

I'm betting on option #2.
It may very well be confusing to you, that doesn't mean that I am trying to confuse you.
 
That is a story that these equations do not tell.

Tell me, do you believe that the floor assembly of the towers was designed to withstand the impact of the floor above falling down upon it?

If so, how many floors falling upon one floor assembly do you think it was designed to support?

Can you also describe what functions the floor assemblies performed, apart from providing a platform for the offices themselves?

cheers
 
I'd just like to point out some very simple math that seems relevant.

The kinetic energy of the jet impact was actually quite simple, in relation to the rest of the events that occured that day. My back-of-the envelope calculations are as follows:

(per tower)
KE of Aircraft: 3 GJ
Chemical Energy of Jet Fuel: 1500 GJ
Gravitational Energy of Building: 800 GJ
Chemical Energy of Office fire: Alot

To some extent, the impact of the aircraft was really a minimal amount of energy, but it was imparted in a tiny fraction of the time, so it was quite damaging. However, mostly, the impact's two major contributions to the collapse were damaging the fire-proofing, and putting all that fuel into the building and starting those fires.
 
Ok, After your reply, I'm going to change that "willfully ignorant" to:
Really, really functionally illiterate and wilfully stupid

Is that your argument? Well do tell, how does the cause and effect correlate into the force of collapse?
 
So what are you trying to measure, the force of impact or the force of collapse. If you are measuring the force of impact then you are barking up the wrong tree. It is the force of collapse that needs to be measured.

Well, the point of my OP was that the truthers often discount the amount of force imparted on impact to the structural columns of the towers. This damage subsequently reduced the load-bearing abilities of the structural support.

So yes, the force of the impact was just slightly important to the collapse. So was the fire, the length of time involved, and the load above the point of impact. I didn't mention those either, but that doesn't mean I don't understand them.

Your belief that I am adding the two forces is both incorrect and unsupported by a single word I've said.

I also never claimed that the simple calculation for free fall somehow showed how fast the buildings should fall with a given amount of resistance. That is goalpost shifting you added in. I was simply addressing the "faster than free-fall" claim I have heard truthers bandy about.

You don't even seem to be able to accurately comprehend what I actually said and did not say. For one thing, your idea that I am somehow adding the force of the collapse and the force of the airliner collision is truly bizarre, as I said or implied no such thing.

The post wasn't supposed to be a comprehensive list of all the physical elements of the collapse. Perhaps that was unclear to you.
 
I'd just like to point out some very simple math that seems relevant.

The kinetic energy of the jet impact was actually quite simple, in relation to the rest of the events that occured that day. My back-of-the envelope calculations are as follows:

(per tower)
KE of Aircraft: 3 GJ
Chemical Energy of Jet Fuel: 1500 GJ
Gravitational Energy of Building: 800 GJ
Chemical Energy of Office fire: Alot

To some extent, the impact of the aircraft was really a minimal amount of energy, but it was imparted in a tiny fraction of the time, so it was quite damaging. However, mostly, the impact's two major contributions to the collapse were damaging the fire-proofing, and putting all that fuel into the building and starting those fires.

Yes, thank you. The force of the impact didn't transfer into the force of collapse. The impact caused damage but it was the weakened steel that let loose the concrete slab which started in collapse. The force of impact is therefore inconsequential to the force of collapse and cannot be added to the equation as kinetic energy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom