Introductory Physics Vs. 9/11 TRUTH!!!

A little harsh, don't you think? I can barely add 2+2, but I'm fairly intelligent in other areas, and most importantly, I *know* I can't do maths, so I let people who can, do it instead. It requires an element of trust on my part, but I'm comfortable with that. I wish the troofers were...

Just got back with this thread.

bigLes, Drdisco, no insult intended, by either me (HS level Math and Physics and nothing since then) or Robert A. Heinlein. Because you do grasp the fundamental nature of math and physics and find their conclusions logical and evident. Which is more than can be said for numerous CT'ers of our acquaintance...

Mr. Rea, you state

I wasn't implying, I was saying, nothing underhand at all. There is an orthodoxy on here.

Could you please expound on this? As for a scientific orthodoxy, I would not dispute that F = ma and the other formulas here and I tend to doubt you would either. Therefore I am more interested in what you mean by a political, or perhaps a politico-scientific orthodoxy that does not allow us to see things that you may apparently see more clearly...if I mis-state your views, my apologies and I await further clairification...
 
More than likely most of them are. So what?

Do you agree there is an orthodoxy on here?


The problem occurs when someone makes a statement of fact which can easily be shown to be in error yet still adheres to the conclusions drawn purely out of a political bias. This happens mostly on the CT side of the issue. One can show the correct math and physics to some who will nonetheless adhere to the same conclusions even though they have been shown that the basis for their conclusions are in error.

Often they then simply fall back on their personal incredulity such as , "I just don't know how it is possible for three buildings to all collapse on one day?".

Is there an orthodoxy here? Yes, it is one that states that in order to draw conclusions about scientific or engineering questions one must make use of proper science, engineering and math concepts and that these trump such prejudices as personal incredulity or the assumed motives of persons in positions of power.
 
Personally, an introductory course in the game of paper,scissors,rock might be a better starting point for the CT guys.

The examples given about killtown are so stupid. Its annoying to see it pasted about the place with no concern of humility. And William Rea, you show why the CT tactics are so stupid. You blurt about the word phased/fazed without doing any simple research which would have uncovered your misspelling, yet you go on some rant about ownership of language and Shakespeare. You guys really should think before you open your mouths.
Sorry to sound condescending but the principle you apply is exactly how the CT movement does there maths,physics and general claims. Lots of hot air without any actual research. In your case it was such a simple thing, but shows nontheless the basic problem.
 
Last edited:
Just got back with this thread.

bigLes, Drdisco, no insult intended, by either me (HS level Math and Physics and nothing since then) or Robert A. Heinlein. Because you do grasp the fundamental nature of math and physics and find their conclusions logical and evident. Which is more than can be said for numerous CT'ers of our acquaintance...

Mr. Rea, you state



Could you please expound on this? As for a scientific orthodoxy, I would not dispute that F = ma and the other formulas here and I tend to doubt you would either. Therefore I am more interested in what you mean by a political, or perhaps a politico-scientific orthodoxy that does not allow us to see things that you may apparently see more clearly...if I mis-state your views, my apologies and I await further clairification...

I also think the problem is a little more complex than F=ma as you rightly point out.

I don't claim to see anything more clearly than anyone else, it is simply a fact that there is an orthodoxy on here.
 
Oh, I think I struck a nerve here!

There is an orthodoxy in science, yes. It requires things like facts, ability to reproduce results, and peer review to expose flaws.

However, that is not what you tried to imply. Your implication was that this "orthodoxy" was "political", keeping any real scientists from seeking the truth, for fear of being shunned and outcast, or suffering other consequences.

Just another tired attempt to tar the reputations of lots of good people, only trying to use different rhetoric to disguise it.

As much as you would like to think you struck a nerve I'm afraid not. That kind of proved my point about the maturity thing though didn't it.

Again I say to you I'm not implying anything, I'm telling you that an orthodoxy exists.
 
I was deliberately copying William's bigoted and self-important style, for (I hoped) satiric effect. It was he who claimed England as the only country with proper English.

As far as I'm aware, the word is "fazed" in all English-speaking countries.

And it isn't a slang word, so I'm not sure why William is making the excuse that his slang is not good.

Satirising my satire, that's so second generation my dear. Priceless.
 
Could you (or perhaps one of the other posters) be more specific regarding this orthodoxy? I'm not entirely sure what you're getting at.

Just explain it to me like you would to a high-school student, since that's pretty much the level where my grasp of physics is at. Or is physics not involved in the explanation?
 
jaydeehess said:
How's this;
Acceptable physics only available from the politically orthodox.

Was I really that far off? I don't think so. Did you see quotations around what I posted?
I think you'll find a deep chasm between acceptable and correct.


Ofurgawdsake

I personally only accept correct physics.

'Common sense' is not applicable to a question of whether or not the physics is acceptable or correct.

If one is stating something to the nature of
'near free fall' and calling that acceptable and correct physics, that is simply nonsense.

If one attempts to add a velocity and a length and arrive at number and claim it means that it is correct and acceptable physics/math they are spouting utter nonsense.

If someone else then shows that a building fell at x/I]% the rate of free fall, and their application of basic physics and math concepts is as would be taught in any first year physics program then that is acceptable and correct physics.

If someone writes a paper using engineering concepts to show that the initial failure would inevitably lead to a complete collapse then any critque of that paper must also use the approach of known engineering concepts.

So, enough banter about this. Do you have an example of someone using unacceptable or incorrect physics or engineering that illustrates this orthodoxy you are saying exists on this forum? Can you show that this unacceptable or incorrect math/physics/engineering orthodoxy is prevalent on this board?


We can show example after example of CT's who obviously do not understand math or physics. Killtown being the most prolific of course but also, IIRC off the top of my head, 28th Kingdom and Terrorstorm1234.
 
I think you'll find a deep chasm between acceptable and correct.

Please provide a pointer to a post on this forum that had incorrect physics but was generally accepted. Also provide a pointer to a post on this forum that had correct physics but was treated as unacceptable.
 
Last edited:
I think you'll find a deep chasm between acceptable and correct.
It may be deep,possibly on the i axis, but it is zero width in 3d space.

In case it escapes that feeble excuse for aq mind that occupies the space between your ears, that means the only acceptable answer is the correct one, in physics.
 
As much as you would like to think you struck a nerve I'm afraid not. That kind of proved my point about the maturity thing though didn't it.

Again I say to you I'm not implying anything, I'm telling you that an orthodoxy exists.
Ah, what was your point again? The fact I mock your silliness obviously angers you, so the slam on my "maturity". Eh, still not impressed with your rhetoric.
So, you're telling me an orthodoxy exists. Care to give some real-world examples, you know, something that exists outside of the space between your ears?
Or is that too "orthodox" for you?
 
A more appropriate equation would have been

Kinetic Energy=(0.5)m(v^2)

The problem with using F=ma is that an airplane traveling at a constant velocity has zero acceleration.

Steve S.

True, but when it hits a skyscraper it decelerates from 500 mph to 0 in less than a second. Mechanical impact alone would have done serious damage, never mind the thousands of gallons of burning aviation fuel.

Incidently, I know the "Truthseekers" have miscalculated freefall but from where do they get the notion that if a building is destroyed by explosives, the bits will fall faster than due to gravity alone?
 
Incidently, I know the "Truthseekers" have miscalculated freefall but from where do they get the notion that if a building is destroyed by explosives, the bits will fall faster than due to gravity alone?
To be fair, that's not what they generally claim.

True, some particularly stupid truther might have said "faster than freefall" or something to that effect.

The general argument is that without explosives the building should have offered "more" resistance, causing the collapse to last "longer" or even to stop somewhere in the middle.

I have never seen a truther quantify this, except Judy Wood. :)

The catch for the truthers is that for that argument to carry any weight, they need explosives at quite a few floors. That's a lot of explosives, for which of course they have zero evidence.
 
Last edited:
I don't claim to see anything more clearly than anyone else, it is simply a fact that there is an orthodoxy on here.

The orthodoxy is in using experimentally proven physics. If there are errors in the physics, or we are misapplying it, please explain how.
 
One of them quantified it by dividing the height of the towers by acceleration due to gravity.

I [rule8] you not.

Given what I've seen of Troofer math, that doesn't really surprise me at all.

What did they do with the spare s2, anyway? :)
 
True, but when it hits a skyscraper it decelerates from 500 mph to 0 in less than a second. Mechanical impact alone would have done serious damage, never mind the thousands of gallons of burning aviation fuel.

Incidently, I know the "Truthseekers" have miscalculated freefall but from where do they get the notion that if a building is destroyed by explosives, the bits will fall faster than due to gravity alone?


Dividing the momentum of the aircraft by the time it took to come to rest in the towers will give the force imparted to the building.

The 'truthseekers' contend that a high explosive would create a vacuum on the floor where it occurs thus sucking the building down faster than a free fall event.


As J5 said: I [rule8] you not.
 
I was asked the question because, by nature of my job, I am the expert on the subject. Then my conclusions and recommendations are rejected because the first party, who admits they know nothing about the subject tries to apply what they feel to be "common sense".

This happens several times a day.

My sympathies. I worked tech support for several years.

When something like this happened, I was tempted to say, "Well, it looks like you've got a handle on the problem. Have a nice day!"
 
True, but when it hits a skyscraper it decelerates from 500 mph to 0 in less than a second. Mechanical impact alone would have done serious damage, never mind the thousands of gallons of burning aviation fuel.

Incidently, I know the "Truthseekers" have miscalculated freefall but from where do they get the notion that if a building is destroyed by explosives, the bits will fall faster than due to gravity alone?

To elaborate further: In physics there is no "deceleration"; the term "acceleration" covers any change in velocity. It could be a change to a higher rate of speed, to a lower rate of speed, or a change in direction (since velocity is a vector representing speed and direction).

Also, "negative acceleration" is not deceleration, but acceleration in a "negative" direction.

ETA: The reason I know this is that, to counter the troofer arguments, I had to be sure I knew what I was talking about, so I brushed up on my physics. In that sense, the debates over 9/11 conspiracies have been a positive experience for me!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom