Introductory Physics Vs. 9/11 TRUTH!!!

So, Without Rights, given that value for net force, how do you obtain a value of 42 seconds?

I don't, I am not saying they are correct. I am saying you are wrong. The data that your equations provide doesn't refute their claim. If the claim was an airliner couldn't cause a collapse then you would have something but the claim is that it would take 42secs for a collapse with resistance of concrete and steel. Your equation cannot refute that claim because your equation measures freefall speed or "insignificant resistance". So, you can use it to refute their calculations on what is freefall time but you offer no data to represent resistance so how can your calculation refute how long a pancake collapse would take?
 
I don't, I am not saying they are correct. I am saying you are wrong. The data that your equations provide doesn't refute their claim. If the claim was an airliner couldn't cause a collapse then you would have something but the claim is that it would take 42secs for a collapse with resistance of concrete and steel. Your equation cannot refute that claim because your equation measures freefall speed or "insignificant resistance". So, you can use it to refute their calculations on what is freefall time but you offer no data to represent resistance so how can your calculation refute how long a pancake collapse would take?

But then you take other simple formulas and back into the resistance, plug the revised value for acceleration (after all, g is simply a value for acceleration) into the same equation, and you still don't get 42 seconds, or anything even close to it.

I never said that these are the only formulas that are needed to understand what happened, only that even these simple formulas begin to punch holes in many of the troofer claims.

You're not familiar with the source for the figure of 42 seconds, are you? It was not an attempt to include resistance in the calc, it was an attempt by a truther to calculate the time for unresisted free fall using truly wretched mathematics. They said that the towers should have collapsed in 42 seconds if they were falling at free fall speeds.

But hey, you're familiar with "their" calculations, so you must know that already.

This idea that I was trying to "refute" every claim with those simple formulas is just another straw man.
 
What in the world are you talking about? Those two points have always been separate. One regarded the force imparted to the support structure of the towers by the collision, the other involved the time to collapse.

The issue of resistance is yet another issue.

Yet you claim that their resistance model is refuted by your "insignificant resistance" equation.
 
Yet you claim that their resistance model is refuted by your "insignificant resistance" equation.

I know, I know--you don't have to act stupid....
Who in he!! says the resistance was insignificant? 10-40% is significant. It is that the forces being opposed were so massive.
Go take a look at my posting, above.
Oops- sorry- I forgot. You guys don't know how to deal with "numb3rs" and equations. If it ain't on video, it don't exist, right?
 
Yet you claim that their resistance model is refuted by your "insignificant resistance" equation.

Actually, I didn't. Keep in mind what I originally said was:

Me said:
Which handily disproves claims that, say, it should've taken the towers 42 seconds to fall under the influence of gravity alone.

Did I say "when incorporating resistance from the building" or anything else of the sort? No. I was specifically referring to truther free-fall calcs not including building resistance.

And the equation doesn't assume "insignificant resistance", it assumes no resistance, including no air resistance. Yes, it's a simplification, as is the number 9.8 m/s^2 to begin with.
 
You're not familiar with the source for the figure of 42 seconds, are you? It was not an attempt to include resistance in the calc, it was an attempt by a truther to calculate the time for unresisted free fall using truly wretched mathematics. They said that the towers should have collapsed in 42 seconds if they were falling at free fall speeds.
I did read a claim by some woman who showed billiard balls hitting eachother to show resistance and her calculations were that it would take at least 42 secs for a pancake collapse to occur. That is what I was referring to, I have never heard anyone say that a freefall would take 42 secs to happen and if I did I would laugh. So if you are refuting some idiot that said freefall speed is 42 sec for 1380 ft than I completely back you and it was a simple misunderstanding based on the model I read that said 42 sec with resistance is minimal.
 
I did read a claim by some woman who showed billiard balls hitting eachother to show resistance and her calculations were that it would take at least 42 secs for a pancake collapse to occur. That is what I was referring to, I have never heard anyone say that a freefall would take 42 secs to happen and if I did I would laugh. So if you are refuting some idiot that said freefall speed is 42 sec for 1380 ft than I completely back you and it was a simple misunderstanding based on the model I read that said 42 sec with resistance is minimal.

You could've just asked for clarification to begin with, rather than insisting I was making claims I wasn't. All that does is make you look farkin' stupid. It doesn't help that I was quite clear that I was talking about gravity-only falls, and that I wasn't adding the unrelated force vectors.

I've seen the infamous billiard ball calc. Judy Wood used extremely naive calculations to determine that "pancake collapse" would require something between 30 and 100 seconds. Her modelling appears to assume that the mass collapsing above would stop at each floor, then collapse and continue. She ignores a couple key points:

1) The initial mass collapsing was 10-20 stories, not 1.
2) The collapsing mass will continue to accumulate, reducing the ability of subsequent floors to resist the force involved.

Yes, it is difficult to run exact numbers, but we've looked at ballpark figures in this forum in the past. Bottom line is that the towers had no chance of withstanding the amount of mass that dropped when the supports failed. Once that initial collapse occurs, it's all downhill (no pun, really) from there.

Wood's diagrams can be found here. Her modelling vastly over-estimates the capability of the structural elements underneath the collapse to withstand the collapsing section.

As an aside, she apparently believes the government used a space beam to vaporize the towers, so that should give some idea of where she's coming from in terms of reality-based reasoning.
 
Actually, I didn't. Keep in mind what I originally said was:



Did I say "when incorporating resistance from the building" or anything else of the sort? No. I was specifically referring to truther free-fall calcs not including building resistance.

And the equation doesn't assume "insignificant resistance", it assumes no resistance, including no air resistance. Yes, it's a simplification, as is the number 9.8 m/s^2 to begin with.

Well, I guess we argued all day for nothing. But the equation formulated by Galileo states that d=distance with insignificant resistance.
 
I know, I know--you don't have to act stupid....
Who in he!! says the resistance was insignificant? 10-40% is significant. It is that the forces being opposed were so massive.
Go take a look at my posting, above.
Oops- sorry- I forgot. You guys don't know how to deal with "numb3rs" and equations. If it ain't on video, it don't exist, right?

Who are "you guys". Is that an attempt to bind me with CT's? Nice ad hominem. Too bad I never claimed to believe what they say, so I guess your pulling that out of thin air huh? Good job, keep smearing people, it really shows how (un)intelligent you are.
 
You could've just asked for clarification to begin with, rather than insisting I was making claims I wasn't. All that does is make you look farkin' stupid. It doesn't help that I was quite clear that I was talking about gravity-only falls, and that I wasn't adding the unrelated force vectors.

I've seen the infamous billiard ball calc. Judy Wood used extremely naive calculations to determine that "pancake collapse" would require something between 30 and 100 seconds. Her modelling appears to assume that the mass collapsing above would stop at each floor, then collapse and continue. She ignores a couple key points:

1) The initial mass collapsing was 10-20 stories, not 1.
2) The collapsing mass will continue to accumulate, reducing the ability of subsequent floors to resist the force involved.

Yes, it is difficult to run exact numbers, but we've looked at ballpark figures in this forum in the past. Bottom line is that the towers had no chance of withstanding the amount of mass that dropped when the supports failed. Once that initial collapse occurs, it's all downhill (no pun, really) from there.

Wood's diagrams can be found here. Her modelling vastly over-estimates the capability of the structural elements underneath the collapse to withstand the collapsing section.

As an aside, she apparently believes the government used a space beam to vaporize the towers, so that should give some idea of where she's coming from in terms of reality-based reasoning.

Well I looked and I don't see any claims from anyone in the truth movement that says that freefall is 42 sec so my mistake was that I didn't know you were refuting some guy nobody knows. I thought you were referring to a para-mainstream idea that the truther community collectively holds. Not one that Joe Nobody said one time on some forum or personal website.
 
You could've just asked for clarification to begin with, rather than insisting I was making claims I wasn't. All that does is make you look farkin' stupid.

Well, this was my first post
I beg to differ, this equation only proves that the towers did not fall at freefall speed. It can only measure falls with insignificant resistance. All I get from this is 10 sec at freefall speed is 1600 ft and the towers were 1360 ft. This equation cannot tell us how long it would take with the added resistance of the building. Therefore it cannot disprove a claim that states it would it take the towers 42 secs to fall with the resistance of the building.

You could of easily cleared this up right of way. So if I looked farkin stupid it was because you perpetuated an argument that didn't exist. I didn't pay attention to detail but neither did you.
 
You could of easily cleared this up right of way. So if I looked farkin stupid it was because you perpetuated an argument that didn't exist. I didn't pay attention to detail but neither did you.

To which I responded (my first response):

Truthers are always claiming the towers fell faster than free fall, but they can't even calculate free fall.

Is the definition of "free fall" unclear? Is that the problem?

I have always stated that I used these calculations to determine free fall speeds and to address claims related to free fall. Free fall involves no resistance, so I have no idea why you dragged building resistance into this. Again, that had nothing to do with my OP or the subject matter I was addressing.
 
Ooh yeah, ya got me there!

I wasn't implying, I was saying, nothing underhand at all. There is an orthodoxy on here.

Do you deny that?

Read "The Structure of Scientific Revolutions" by Thomas Kuhn. It covers the nature of scientific "orthodoxy;" both its necessity, and how it changes.
 
Yet you claim that their resistance model is refuted by your "insignificant resistance" equation.

It is up to those who dispute the 'unaided' progressive collapse timing to provide evidence for how much resistance the structure would have provided.

In fact, I would be REALLY interested to see a design by a CT structural engineer of a building such as the twin towers which could resist the progressive collapse witnessed on 9/11. Then we could compare it with what was actually built.

ummmmm chicken wire models don't count. :D
 
Wasn't it the weakening of the steel that caused the steel to buckle.



No...

The exterior columns bowed inwards because the floor trusses sagged. There is no indication that the exterior columns were weakened by fire.

-Gumboot
 
Want to take a wild guess at what appears to be the single most difficult concept on the planet? Any device that is used inline with something else. Usually this applies to VCR's, answering machines and caller ID boxes.

Wall --> Wire --> Device --> Wire --> Device

I explain it. I draw pictures. I demonstrate it with items in the store. I am met with the confused gaze of a dog attempting to do calculus.



Heh... our first lecture for cinemtography was black box theory. Basically being that all electrical equipment is made up of one or more black boxes. A black box takes an input, changes it to something else, and outputs it. As long as you match the outputs and inputs for two different black boxes, they will work.

For example... a video camera consist of several black boxes. The lens takes an input of light and converts it to an image (frame). The CCD takes an input of an image and converts it to electrical impulses. The recorder takes an input of electrical impulses and converts it to either a magnetic pattern on a tape or data on a harddrive.

And so forth.

All electrical stuff seems really easy once I learned black box theory.

-Gumboot
 
I agree, so how does
d = ½gt handily disprove claims that, say, it should've taken the towers 42 seconds to fall under the influence of gravity alone?

or how does a = F/m prove the lower floors could not have absorbed the force of collapse?

They can't is the answer, which was the point of me chiming in. I never said I think bombs were used, I never said I don't think it was a pancake collapse. I said these equations do not prove the truthers wrong. It is only rhetoric and twisting of science that matches that of the truthers. This is just plain bad physics, period. All we can derive from these equations is that 1600ft in 10 sec is freefall speed with insignificant resistance. We can't say 42 seconds is unreasonable because that is a number derived from equations where resistance is factored in. The truthers maybe are misrepresenting the resistance but that is not evident by this equation.

Just to add some clarification, those two equations -- the truncated form of Newton's Second Law and its equivalent for a free body in a constant field -- do not, by themselves, prove the Troother's objections ("they collapsed too fast") to be incorrect. But similarly trivial reasoning does. Poster rwguinn explained it properly.

I offer here a previous post that expands on his argument. In brief, it shows that the buildings could be expected to collapse quickly, i.e. between 10 and 15 seconds, for a huge range of energy values needed to destroy the lower structure.

On this basis, I can indeed say that 42 seconds is unreasonable. This case would require such a delicate energy balance, and such an overbuilt structure experiencing an orderly collapse, that it may be instantly discarded.
 
Just to add some clarification, those two equations -- the truncated form of Newton's Second Law and its equivalent for a free body in a constant field -- do not, by themselves, prove the Troother's objections ("they collapsed too fast") to be incorrect. But similarly trivial reasoning does. Poster rwguinn explained it properly.

I offer here a previous post that expands on his argument. In brief, it shows that the buildings could be expected to collapse quickly, i.e. between 10 and 15 seconds, for a huge range of energy values needed to destroy the lower structure.

On this basis, I can indeed say that 42 seconds is unreasonable. This case would require such a delicate energy balance, and such an overbuilt structure experiencing an orderly collapse, that it may be instantly discarded.

Thank you, sir. Your post explains it succinctly and better than mine.
Unfortunately, these guys (kids?) don't believe anything un-animated.
and do believe anything that is.

"As far as I'm concerned, if you don't know calculus, you're illiterate!"
Christopher Stashef, "We Open on Venus"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom