If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

The Bible posits that man is encouraged to explore and learn about the world on his own. God generally didn't provide maps.
Any reason why there was (and still is) no direct help with any scientific discovery in human history?

We don't know, but apparently it had legs. It is usually depicted as unique (not a member of a living species).
Depicted by whom?

Jesus and Paul both quote passages and attribute them to Moses.
But how do you know that Moses wrote it? And is it an eyewitness account?
 
Last edited:
Any reason why there was (and still is) no direct help with any scientific discovery in human history?
The idea is that God built the place, then let us loose to develop and use it at our own ace. Even in Genesis, where God is pretty hands-on about stuff, it gives us a description of what human beings came up with what technology (no indication that God helped.)

Depicted by whom?
I'm talking about artist depictions.

But how do you know that Moses wrote it?
Again, because the Bible says so.

And is it an eyewitness account?
Exodus through Deuteronomy are. Genesis covers thousands of years of human history prior to Moses.
 
So when does that take place? At what point does the baby go from 'sinless' to 'sinner'?

Further more if this is all gods doing then (and this has been explained [Read: painfully so] in another thread) there is no free will.

To answer your question: When the baby decides that it want's to stray from gods loving light and start thinking for itself; Few years later its accepting the devils favourite tool, science and before you know it BOOM full blown stage 6 sinner!
 
The idea is that God built the place, then let us loose to develop and use it at our own ace. Even in Genesis, where God is pretty hands-on about stuff, it gives us a description of what human beings came up with what technology (no indication that God helped.)
So was Genesis an eyewitness account or not?

And is there a particular reason God stopped being so "hands-on?"

I'm talking about artist depictions.
Of what relevance is an artist's depiction to that specific question?


Again, because the Bible says so.
I'm asking how others who do not believe the Bible is 'evidence' for anything are to know that as a fact.

The Book of Mormon says that Jesus and Lucifer were actually brothers. Therefore, it must be true because a sacred text says it.

Also, Allah is the one true God and Muhammad is his prophet. A sacred text says it.

All legit, right?

Exodus through Deuteronomy are. Genesis covers thousands of years of human history prior to Moses.
So it was written by whom? Was it an eyewitness account?
 
Well, to be fair if you get punched in the face often enough you tend to start swinging yourself.

Believe me, I understand that sense of frustration. You of all posters know how I've banged my head against the brick wall of Creationist obstinacy here!

I just think that if you're getting punched in the face, it's better to focus on the ones actually doing the punching, and not lash out at people who aren't attacking you.

And Catholicism/Christianity have done little to fight these literalists. Contrast this to what happens when honest scientists discover a fraud. The fact that these organizations aren't fighting the Creationists is extremely problematic, not just from a political standpoint but also from a theological one. It's implicite support for Creationism, for one thing, as well as allowing a heresy to go unanswered. When members of your community are attacking other members of other communities (and often their own!), and you do nothing to stop it, you forfeit the moral high ground.

If the Catholics and Christians and the rest were arguing against Creationism along side the scientists I'd say that they were at least honest. That they don't is a rather damning fact in my opinion.

Well, I'd certainly rather that Catholics stay out of the way in the fight, as opposed to joining up with the Creationists.

But there are many Catholics who have taken an active stand against Creationism, like Kenneth Miller, who has testified in court a number of times against both it and Intelligent Design (including doing so in the landmark Dover case). And on an institutional level, so have Catholic lay publications, Vatican officials, and even the Pope himself making it clear that Creationism and Intelligent Design are contrary to the position of the Church and that evolution is fully accepted.

The RCC isn't exactly my most favoritest organization on the planet, but when it comes to Evolution vs. Creationism, they're way, way down my list of groups that earn my ire.
 
Last edited:
So was Genesis an eyewitness account or not?
Not.

And is there a particular reason God stopped being so "hands-on?"
Human maturity.

Of what relevance is an artist's depiction to that specific question?
It speaks to the conventional understanding of the serpent. The Bible, like I said, doesn't address the issue.

I'm asking how others who do not believe the Bible is 'evidence' for anything are to know that as a fact.
They may not. In fact, the standard non-Christian understanding is the "documentary hypothesis", which involves the use of three or four authors much later than Moses.

So it was written by whom? Was it an eyewitness account?
By Moses, and no.
 
Well, I'd certainly rather that Catholics stay out of the way in the fight, as opposed to joining up with the Creationists.

But there are many Catholics who have taken an active stand against Creationism, like Kenneth Miller, who has testified in court a number of times against both it and Intelligent Design (including doing so in the landmark Dover case), as well asCatholic lay publications, Vatican officials, and even the Pope himself making it clear that Creationism and Intelligent Design are contrary to the position of the Church and that evolution is fully accepted.

It would be entirely inappropriate for Catholics to take the current understanding of any scientific issue and make it a matter of doctrine. The Pope has made it clear that Catholics can and probably should accept evolution. That's as far as the religious end should go. However, individual Catholics are another matter. I simply don't believe that it's true that it's just atheists on one side and creationists on the other, with all the other religions turning away. What is true is that some creationists and some atheists want it to be religion against science, and work up between them an artificial dichotomy to deliberately exclude everyone else. When Dawkins is on a pro-evolution platform Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, and he's anti-religion Tuesdays, Thursdays and Saturdays, it makes it difficult to work with him.
 
It would be entirely inappropriate for Catholics to take the current understanding of any scientific issue and make it a matter of doctrine. The Pope has made it clear that Catholics can and probably should accept evolution. That's as far as the religious end should go. However, individual Catholics are another matter. I simply don't believe that it's true that it's just atheists on one side and creationists on the other, with all the other religions turning away. What is true is that some creationists and some atheists want it to be religion against science, and work up between them an artificial dichotomy to deliberately exclude everyone else. When Dawkins is on a pro-evolution platform Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, and he's anti-religion Tuesdays, Thursdays and Saturdays, it makes it difficult to work with him.

When will the Pope admit that Jesus died a long time ago?
 
It would be entirely inappropriate for Catholics to take the current understanding of any scientific issue and make it a matter of doctrine. The Pope has made it clear that Catholics can and probably should accept evolution. That's as far as the religious end should go. However, individual Catholics are another matter. I simply don't believe that it's true that it's just atheists on one side and creationists on the other, with all the other religions turning away. What is true is that some creationists and some atheists want it to be religion against science, and work up between them an artificial dichotomy to deliberately exclude everyone else. When Dawkins is on a pro-evolution platform Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, and he's anti-religion Tuesdays, Thursdays and Saturdays, it makes it difficult to work with him.

In many parts of the US at least these types of debates are hard to engage in. Most of are going to meet creationist in our working life, however religious discussions are covered under 'protected classes'. I was a supervisor of a hard core creationist, and I could do nothing about it - or I would end up in HR getting my arse handed to me
 
In many parts of the US at least these types of debates are hard to engage in. Most of are going to meet creationist in our working life, however religious discussions are covered under 'protected classes'. I was a supervisor of a hard core creationist, and I could do nothing about it - or I would end up in HR getting my arse handed to me

We don't have any creationists here in Flanders. At least, I've never come across one.
 
Doesn't a true biblical literalist HAVE TO ACCEPT ALL of the stories at face value?
No questioning the talking snake, the whale, killing your daughters and sons,
beating your slaves only halt to death....
A more pragmaticist approach would be to consider the environment of the times of the tales, and conclude we don't do that anymore because it's wrong.
But if it's wrong today, why not 3000 years ago?
These beliefs are absolute, after all.
Especially when considering the number of deaths murders religion has to it's everlasting shame.
There's no picking and choosing and interpreting permissible for the card carrying literalist.
 
We don't have any creationists here in Flanders. At least, I've never come across one.

Well the Belgiums have always been noted for their education system - proof might just be in the pudding
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom