If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

That's certainly an issue for those protestants who work in the standalone tradition, but believers in a continuous Christian church certainly don't make up their own minds from scratch about doctrine.

I never said they did. They believe what they're told (or at least believe based on it), which is influenced by the timeperiod the person telling them their interpretation of the Bible lived in. For example, it would be extremely difficult for you to find a theologian who advocated the Rule of St. Benedict today, while in the Middle Ages it was harder (not impossible, but harder) to NOT find one.

In brief, the cultural influence comes at the point of interpretation; whether that interpretation is by the individual or someone else is irrelevent.

Another thing to add is that throughout history, you didn't ever have tribes, cults, sects, denominations, parishes or other groups of atheists warring with and murdering each other or others over the 'correct doctrine of atheism.' Atheism is simply a lack of belief in god(s).
This really doesn't matter that much, as a main reason you don't see this is that atheists tended to be extremely quiet minorities for a long time. And you do see various groups of atheists arguing with one another. Both Communism and Objectivism are atheistic philosophies, for example.

Atheists are humans. If most humans were atheists I've little doubt you'd see bands of atheists slaughtering each other just as we saw bands of theists slaughtering one another in the past (even most holy wars have very Earthly justifications).
 
Jesus gets angry though, doesn't he?

He goes into the temple and smashes up all the merchants' and money lenders' stalls.
Yes. Righteous anger, applied properly, is not sinful.

Isn't wrath one of the seven deadly sins?
The seven deadly sins is a Catholic invention, not a Biblical doctrine.

Why is it ok for Jesus to go and smash a place up and shout at people but when I get angry and contain it within myself it's a sin?
It's not necessarily. Malice is usually sinful; taking a righteous act when being motivated by righteous anger is not.
 
Except that this is assuming that God should agree with the modern, limited definition of the term "fish" instead of some older definition.

The limitation of the term "fish" to only apply to a particular class of aquatic chordates is a relatively recent invention.

The use of the Hebrew word "dag" to refer to all sea creatures is no less appropriate or correct. There simply isn't an error at all; there's only a decision by modern culture to give a word a specific, technical definition that it did not always have.

We've had this argument before and I've no interest in re-hashing it. If you're satisfied with a God that's entirely uninterested in basic biological facts, that's fine. However, from the outside it appears completely irrational, and the implication that taxonomy is nothing more than an invention is completely wrong. Remember, it was YOUR side, not mine, that created taxonomy.
 
Orthodox Jews believe that the Earth is 5771 years old. Why are we only talking about Christianity? I am atheistic towards all religions, let's bring a few more in.
Yeah, I admitted to picking on Christians here - guilty as charged! - but it is fair to note that this story of creation that comes from the Torah is actually common to both Jews and Christians.
 
Yes. Righteous anger, applied properly, is not sinful.


The seven deadly sins is a Catholic invention, not a Biblical doctrine.


It's not necessarily. Malice is usually sinful; taking a righteous act when being motivated by righteous anger is not.

So to what extent does righteousness excuse behaviour, and who decides if it's righteous or not?
 
We've had this argument before and I've no interest in re-hashing it. If you're satisfied with a God that's entirely uninterested in basic biological facts, that's fine. However, from the outside it appears completely irrational, and the implication that taxonomy is nothing more than an invention is completely wrong. Remember, it was YOUR side, not mine, that created taxonomy.

You'd think that god would have given his followers full information on these subjects, including the germ theory.
 
If you're satisfied with a God that's entirely uninterested in basic biological facts, that's fine.

I'm satisfied with a God who was entirely content to use the existing classifications for animals when telling the Hebrews which ones they could and could not eat, yes.

I personally have seldom gotten into the taxonomic classifications of animals when discussing what to have for dinner; this does not imply that I am ignorant of them or that I have no interest in them generally.

I also don't protest when lake trout shows up on the menu under "seafood". Word meanings do change over time and according to context.
 
Yeah, I admitted to picking on Christians here - guilty as charged! - but it is fair to note that this story of creation that comes from the Torah is actually common to both Jews and Christians.

True, but other religions have other stories.
 
We've had this argument before and I've no interest in re-hashing it. If you're satisfied with a God that's entirely uninterested in basic biological facts, that's fine. However, from the outside it appears completely irrational, and the implication that taxonomy is nothing more than an invention is completely wrong. Remember, it was YOUR side, not mine, that created taxonomy.

It would seem far more reasonable that the reason for the limitations are that the people who wrote the Bible and included the limitations were ignorant of taxonomy and general biology. If they weren't then such mistakes would not be so likely to be made.

Blame the ignorant writers on that one.
 
I'm satisfied with a God who was entirely content to use the existing classifications for animals when telling the Hebrews which ones they could and could not eat, yes.
What classification system was he using?

Is this the same book that said that snakes talk?
 
Righteousness doesn't excuse behavior; righteousness describes correct behavior taken with a correct attitude.

Ok, so if I am righteously angry I am behaving correctly with my legitimate anger yes?

So who decides if it's righteous?
 
What classification system was he using?
The Hebrews categorized animals primarily based on locomotion -- winged, water, crawling, walking. That's how we get such odd situations, relative to modern day classification, as bats being listed along with birds.

Is this the same book that said that snakes talk?
Not all snakes; just the serpent in the Garden (who we learn much later was Satan).

But no, this is a different book by the same author (Moses).
 
In the end, most non-literalists pick and choose which parts of the Bible to believe as literally true for very non-Biblical reasons--those same reasons which provide most atheists with their own moral code, in fact (social preasure, mostly). Not all of them, but enough of them do that when confronted with a non-literalist (or a pseudoliteralist, who says they are a literalist but acts as a nonliteralist), it's safest to assume that they follow the social norms in choosing which passages are literal and which aren't. It's not fool-proof, as no short-cut to thinking is, but it's pretty darned effective.

I have to disagree with you here - The Bible is not designed as one holistic genre. We cant have the same critical eye for Genesis as we could with the book of psalms.

The book of Genesis has been seen as allegorical from even the time of Nicaea. So it is not a case of God of the gaps - most Christians have never put any faith in the science of Genesis to begin with. Many have seen it as a way to simply get the Bible started. It is Adam and Eve and their relationship with God that is the important element, not how long it took to create the universe.

Then we look at the Book Psalms - essentially a collection of wisdom in poetry or prayer form. Take the first psalm Blessed is the one who does not walk in step with the wicked or stand in the way that sinners take or sit in the company of mockers

Regardless of the existence of God thats pretty good advice on any level. Stay out of trouble, and don't hang with a crowd that makes fun of people.
 
The Hebrews categorized animals primarily based on locomotion -- winged, water, crawling, walking. That's how we get such odd situations, relative to modern day classification, as bats being listed along with birds.
Is there a reason posited in the Bible that the god of that time didn't try to enlighten the population as to the true nature of the diversity of life on the planet?

Not all snakes; just the serpent in the Garden (who we learn much later was Satan).
What species of 'serpent' was it?

But no, this is a different book by the same author (Moses).
How do you know Moses wrote it? Was it an eyewitness account?
 
Is there a reason posited in the Bible that the god of that time didn't try to enlighten the population as to the true nature of the diversity of life on the planet?

And this matters how exactly?
 
Is there a reason posited in the Bible that the god of that time didn't try to enlighten the population as to the true nature of the diversity of life on the planet?

That's what puzzles me. What reason did god have for this odd behaviour? Why lead them up the garden path in a book that purports to be his holy word?
 
Is there a reason posited in the Bible that the god of that time didn't try to enlighten the population as to the true nature of the diversity of life on the planet?
The Bible posits that man is encouraged to explore and learn about the world on his own. God generally didn't provide maps.

What species of 'serpent' was it?
We don't know, but apparently it had legs. It is usually depicted as unique (not a member of a living species).

How do you know Moses wrote it?

Jesus and Paul both quote passages and attribute them to Moses.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom