If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

And yet it doesn't look to be going away any time soon. So what's the point in harping on this, aside from smug mockery of a strawman Christianity?

I don't believe in any of the tenets of Christianity either, but that just seems rather...rude and juvenile, to me.

You say potato.....
 
It's fine to say that Catholics are wrong, or fundamentalists are wrong, or both are wrong. What I don't get is the insistence that both are wrong, but that the fundamentalists are actually right.

It's not that we find them right. It's merely that we find them consistent. Someone who honestly believes every word in the Bible, and ONLY those words, are inspired by God is historically illiterate (the Church never denied Nicea, the RCC even has a creed with that name), but they are internally consistent. Someone who says that some parts of the Bible are true, while others aren't, however, usually runs into trouble in that they can't adequately explain how they chose which parts to believe. You'd think it would be obvious that the Bible stating that something is a parable is proof enough that it's not to be taken literally, but I've seen posters on this board argue otherwise.

In the end, most non-literalists pick and choose which parts of the Bible to believe as literally true for very non-Biblical reasons--those same reasons which provide most atheists with their own moral code, in fact (social preasure, mostly). Not all of them, but enough of them do that when confronted with a non-literalist (or a pseudoliteralist, who says they are a literalist but acts as a nonliteralist), it's safest to assume that they follow the social norms in choosing which passages are literal and which aren't. It's not fool-proof, as no short-cut to thinking is, but it's pretty darned effective.

ANTPogo said:
It's like the flip side of a Christian trying to convince an atheist of the error of his ways by saying "The fool has said in his heart there is no God! Hah hah!" It's simply not going to convince anyone who doesn't already think that way.
Most atheists don't present the argument properly; they confuse a short-cut with the argument. The full argument is something along the lines of "You already don't believe the Bible is 100% literally true, based on these examples. Thus, unless justification is provided, there's no reason for me to assume that any of the rest of it is literally true--it could, you must admit, be something that's not to be taken literally, as these other parts are. What is your justification for believing [insert Biblical statement here]?" When they fail to produce evidence, or their evidence fails to withstand scientific scruteny, you can conclude that since there's no reason to believe it's literally true that part can be treated as a story. Once the whole book is dismissed in this manner, or at least the significant parts of it, you can ignore the religion. (For clarification, by "significant parts" I mean parts that are significant to the religion--whether Jesus rose from the dead is signficant, but whether he went to Caina for a wedding isn't; whether he could cure the sick is significant, whether he rode an ass into the city isn't; the Bible necessarily is going to contain SOME true statements, otherwise it would be uninteligible, and it's fallacious to conclude that because the minor, trivial parts are true therefore the major, logic-defying parts are as well [though I forget the fallacy's specific name]).

Few enough people go through this whole process, and I'll admit that I haven't. My process is much simpler: I realized, after studying paleontology and geology, that any true fact will have multiple lines of evidence pointing towards it. The date of, for example, the Chatsworth Formation is indicated by stratigraphic position, tectonics, the stratigraphy of the beds, and fossil evidence. Each independently suggests (and some independently prove) the age; when multiple lines converge on an answer it's right. Similarly, if gods exist multiple lines of evidence should lead to that conclusion. Since we know that most if not all holy books are edited and revised and translated and copied, all of which have the potential to introduce errors, and that all religious cerimonies have been altered through time, it's safest to simply ignore religion (except where it invades science). If the religion is true an honest evaluation of the evidence will lead to that conclusion. If it's not, at least this way I'm not required to unlearn anything.
 
I don't believe in any of the tenets of Christianity either, but that just seems rather...rude and juvenile, to me.
The attempted degradation and dilution of science education by the religious - particularly when it comes to biology - is a very serious issue to many of us in the United States. I know that wasn't the original premise I submitted in the OP, but I feel that's the practical result of these questions.

I don't think it's 'rude or juvenile' to point out what the some of the claims in the foundational texts of the religions of many of those trying to shoehorn these things into public schools actually are.
 
Last edited:
The attempted degradation and dilution of science education by the religious - particularly when it comes to biology - is a very serious issue to many of us in the United States.

I don't think it's 'rude or juvenile' to point out what the some of the claims in the foundational texts of the religions of many of those trying to shoehorn these things into public schools actually are.

I don't think it is rude to point out that believing in a god is as juvenile as believing in the Tooth Fairy and the Easter Bunny. Let them believe what they like, as long as they don't impose their views on others, that's fine. But they do. Look at the more strict Islamic counties, it's a scandal.
 
westprog said:
ever, there are various issues on which you differ with other atheists. There is no total atheist consensus.
This is the part that I find facinating about theists: they assume that atheism is one single monolithic entity. This is obviously false--Karl Marx and Any Rand were both atheists, despite disagreeing on nearly everything else in life.

All atheism is, is the lack of belief in gods. All theism is, is the belief in gods. It is rediculous to assume that while there are numerous groups that believe in gods there is only one group that disbelieves. Humans simply don't work that way. ANTpogo recently posted about a schism in Islam that started when Mohammid died. Catholicism started fracturing almost as quickly, and had several episodes where heretics were eliminated (the most recent was the Reformation, but it was only the latest [it was successful, so no further purges were possible] in a long line of such events). I'm curious--what makes theists believe that atheists are going to buck this trend? What makes them think that we're all going to band together under one common banner? Why is anyone, ever, surprised to find that atheists disagree with one another?
 
The attempted degradation and dilution of science education by the religious - particularly when it comes to biology - is a very serious issue to many of us in the United States.

Luckily the schools here are too intelligent to teach intelligent design, but if I lived the States I would take it as a very serious issue, I would not want my children to be exposed to that nonsense.That would be insulting them.
 
Presumably god would have known what a lobster was, seeing that he created it. It just proves the point that the Old Testament was written by primitive men.

Using a different definition doesn't make someone primitive, c.f. "Pluto" and "planet".
 
This is the part that I find facinating about theists: they assume that atheism is one single monolithic entity. This is obviously false--Karl Marx and Any Rand were both atheists, despite disagreeing on nearly everything else in life.

All atheism is, is the lack of belief in gods. All theism is, is the belief in gods. It is rediculous to assume that while there are numerous groups that believe in gods there is only one group that disbelieves. Humans simply don't work that way. ANTpogo recently posted about a schism in Islam that started when Mohammid died. Catholicism started fracturing almost as quickly, and had several episodes where heretics were eliminated (the most recent was the Reformation, but it was only the latest [it was successful, so no further purges were possible] in a long line of such events). I'm curious--what makes theists believe that atheists are going to buck this trend? What makes them think that we're all going to band together under one common banner? Why is anyone, ever, surprised to find that atheists disagree with one another?

Well put.
 
The attempted degradation and dilution of science education by the religious - particularly when it comes to biology - is a very serious issue to many of us in the United States.

I don't think it's 'rude or juvenile' to point out what the some of the claims in the foundational texts of the religions of many of those trying to shoehorn these things into public schools actually are.

And that's an issue that needs to be addressed (and something that needs to be stopped cold).

But it's also disconnected from the question posed in the OP (which was about the theological implications for Christians of certain descriptions in the Bible being false as modern science understands them), as well as disconnected from the large chunks of Christianity (like Catholicism or Anglicanism) which aren't interested in the least in doing things like shoehorning literal interpretations of Genesis into classrooms, because they don't believe those interpretations either.
 
Last edited:
Intelligent Design is a throughly discredited nutcrtack of an idea somewhat like Creationism
 
Using a different definition doesn't make someone primitive, c.f. "Pluto" and "planet".

At least we knew that it was an object in the Solar System and not a light put into the firmament by god. Science discovered Pluto, it doesn't matter what it is classified as.
 
This is the part that I find facinating about theists: they assume that atheism is one single monolithic entity. This is obviously false--Karl Marx and Any Rand were both atheists, despite disagreeing on nearly everything else in life.
Another thing to add is that throughout history, you didn't ever have tribes, cults, sects, denominations, parishes or other groups of atheists warring with and murdering each other or others over the 'correct doctrine of atheism.' Atheism is simply a lack of belief in god(s).

And as far as Zeus and Apollo go, all Christians are actually atheists when it comes to those supernatural beings. I digress - getting a bit off topic, but there it is :-)
 
Last edited:
It's not that we find them right. It's merely that we find them consistent. Someone who honestly believes every word in the Bible, and ONLY those words, are inspired by God is historically illiterate (the Church never denied Nicea, the RCC even has a creed with that name), but they are internally consistent. Someone who says that some parts of the Bible are true, while others aren't, however, usually runs into trouble in that they can't adequately explain how they chose which parts to believe. You'd think it would be obvious that the Bible stating that something is a parable is proof enough that it's not to be taken literally, but I've seen posters on this board argue otherwise.

That's certainly an issue for those protestants who work in the standalone tradition, but believers in a continuous Christian church certainly don't make up their own minds from scratch about doctrine.
 
And that's an issue that needs to be addressed (and something that needs to be stopped cold).

But it's also disconnected from the question posed in the OP (which was about the theological implications for Christians of certain descriptions in the Bible being false as modern science understands them), as well as disconnected from the large chunks of Christianity (like Catholicism or Anglicanism) which aren't interested in the least in doing things like shoehorning literal interpretations of Genesis into classrooms, because they don't believe those interpretations either.
I added a caveat to the quote you quoted from me while probably while you were responding because I realize that it's a different issue from the OP, even though the subjects overlap in some areas. Thanks.
 
Orthodox Jews believe that the Earth is 5771 years old. Why are we only talking about Christianity? I am atheistic towards all religions, let's bring a few more in.
 
Using a different definition doesn't make someone primitive, c.f. "Pluto" and "planet".

A better argument here is that an omniscient god should know the difficerence between Arthropoda and Chordata. One means of determining plagerism is to look for shared errors--if two people make the same errors throughout a work, it's likely that the reason for this is that one of them was copying the other. The Bible shares the common error of the time of classifying a lobster as a fish. Since it would be trivial for a god to say otherwise (seriously, how hard would "The stuff with bones inside are fish" be? We're not talking proving that acorn worms are chordates here), but failed to, it's evidence--not proof but evidence--that God said no such thing, and that this is nothing more than a very human cultural norm.

ANTPogo said:
But it's also disconnected from the question posed in the OP (which was about the theological implications for Christians of certain descriptions in the Bible being false as modern science understands them), as well as disconnected from the large chunks of Christianity (like Catholicism or Anglicanism) which aren't interested in the least in doing things like shoehorning literal interpretations of Genesis into classrooms.
Well, to be fair if you get punched in the face often enough you tend to start swinging yourself.

And Catholicism/Christianity have done little to fight these literalists. Contrast this to what happens when honest scientists discover a fraud. The fact that these organizations aren't fighting the Creationists is extremely problematic, not just from a political standpoint but also from a theological one. It's implicite support for Creationism, for one thing, as well as allowing a heresy to go unanswered. When members of your community are attacking other members of other communities (and often their own!), and you do nothing to stop it, you forfeit the moral high ground.

If the Catholics and Christians and the rest were arguing against Creationism along side the scientists I'd say that they were at least honest. That they don't is a rather damning fact in my opinion.
 
If the Catholics and Christians and the rest were arguing against Creationism along side the scientists I'd say that they were at least honest. That they don't is a rather damning fact in my opinion.

Hear hear!
 
The Bible says so.
Jesus gets angry though, doesn't he?

He goes into the temple and smashes up all the merchants' and money lenders' stalls.

Isn't wrath one of the seven deadly sins? Why is it ok for Jesus to go and smash a place up and shout at people but when I get angry and contain it within myself it's a sin?
 
The Bible shares the common error of the time of classifying a lobster as a fish. Since it would be trivial for a god to say otherwise (seriously, how hard would "The stuff with bones inside are fish" be?

Except that this is assuming that God should agree with the modern, limited definition of the term "fish" instead of some older definition.

The limitation of the term "fish" to only apply to a particular class of aquatic chordates is a relatively recent invention.

The use of the Hebrew word "dag" to refer to all sea creatures is no less appropriate or correct. There simply isn't an error at all; there's only a decision by modern culture to give a word a specific, technical definition that it did not always have.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom