If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

There is no Flanders bible belt and I feel sorry for the country that has one.

Not as bad you would think actually - In the town I am in we seem to be avoiding a lot of the social dysfunction you see in similar sized towns.
 
I didn't mean that no individual Christians/Catholics contested Creationism. I'm saying that as institutions they more or less ignore the issue. This is akin to a university ignoring egregious fraud on the part of one of their professors. For an institution to refuse to address an issue declared in the name of their founding document implies, to many, that they support it.

westprog said:
It would be entirely inappropriate for Catholics to take the current understanding of any scientific issue and make it a matter of doctrine.
Where did anyone say that they should make it a matter of doctrine? What I would expect is a few archbishops, or Elders, or whatever the institutions have as mid- to high-level authorities stating publicly and unambiguously "Creationism is bilge and all those who support it are wrong." Until they are willing to do that, it's not clear where they stand. A generous view is that they're ignoring heresy building in their midst. A less generous view is that they're waiting to see where it goes, to jump on the winning side.

When Dawkins is on a pro-evolution platform Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, and he's anti-religion Tuesdays, Thursdays and Saturdays, it makes it difficult to work with him.
What makes you think it's any easier working with you when the guy to your left is openly calling me a liar and a fraud?
 
Where did anyone say that they should make it a matter of doctrine? What I would expect is a few archbishops, or Elders, or whatever the institutions have as mid- to high-level authorities stating publicly and unambiguously "Creationism is bilge and all those who support it are wrong." Until they are willing to do that, it's not clear where they stand. A generous view is that they're ignoring heresy building in their midst. A less generous view is that they're waiting to see where it goes, to jump on the winning side.

Catholics, at least, have done that, though. They aren't pushing it on an institutional level, since evolution is not an integral part of the Catechism the way properly theological issues are (in other words, they see evolution as perfectly compatible with their reading of Scripture as well as being scientific truth, but being Creationist just means you're wrong and probably ignorant about accepted science, not that you're being heretical) but they haven't ignored it at an institutional level, either.
 
Last edited:
Not ignored it, but they certainly aren't addressing it with any vigor. I'll go so far as to say that if even the American branch (which is dramatically different from the European in many ways, and which is in the area most directly impacted) actually addressed Creationism more aggressively I'd be happier.

It's not enough to simply say "Oh, they're not with us". You've got to demonstrate it as well. Again, look at what happens when a scientist is convicted of fraud--they are removed from their institution and science as such. Even if they don't view Creationism as heresy it's certainly an attack against their institution. The fact that they're losing people hand over fist right now demonstrates that.
 
Not ignored it, but they certainly aren't addressing it with any vigor. I'll go so far as to say that if even the American branch (which is dramatically different from the European in many ways, and which is in the area most directly impacted) actually addressed Creationism more aggressively I'd be happier.

It's not enough to simply say "Oh, they're not with us". You've got to demonstrate it as well. Again, look at what happens when a scientist is convicted of fraud--they are removed from their institution and science as such. Even if they don't view Creationism as heresy it's certainly an attack against their institution. The fact that they're losing people hand over fist right now demonstrates that.

The child abuse scandals haven't helped. Most of the people I know here in Flanders regard the Catholic Church as a joke and an abomination.
 
The child abuse scandals haven't helped. Most of the people I know here in Flanders regard the Catholic Church as a joke and an abomination.

Yeah, the abuse scandal has been the major reason people are turning their backs on the Church. And, in America at least, the disconnect between what the hierarchy says regarding the acceptability of things like birth control and how the populace feels regarding the acceptability of things like birth control is adding to it.
 
Not ignored it, but they certainly aren't addressing it with any vigor. I'll go so far as to say that if even the American branch (which is dramatically different from the European in many ways, and which is in the area most directly impacted) actually addressed Creationism more aggressively I'd be happier.

It's not enough to simply say "Oh, they're not with us". You've got to demonstrate it as well. Again, look at what happens when a scientist is convicted of fraud--they are removed from their institution and science as such. Even if they don't view Creationism as heresy it's certainly an attack against their institution. The fact that they're losing people hand over fist right now demonstrates that.

Most Christians who subscribe to creationism already have an extremely low opinion of Catholics to begin with - so chances they would feel any pressure over the issue is probably approaching zero
 
The Hebrews categorized animals primarily based on locomotion -- winged, water, crawling, walking. That's how we get such odd situations, relative to modern day classification, as bats being listed along with birds.


Not all snakes; just the serpent in the Garden (who we learn much later was Satan).

But no, this is a different book by the same author (Moses).

Why didn't god tell them that a bat is not a bird? It's not exactly dangerous knowledge. It seems that you are agreeing that the Old testament was written by primitive men and it is not the literal word of god.
 
Why didn't god tell them that a bat is not a bird? It's not exactly dangerous knowledge. It seems that you are agreeing that the Old testament was written by primitive men and it is not the literal word of god.

Its not exactly useful information either - really all we needed back then, can we eat it?
 
Where did anyone say that they should make it a matter of doctrine? What I would expect is a few archbishops, or Elders, or whatever the institutions have as mid- to high-level authorities stating publicly and unambiguously "Creationism is bilge and all those who support it are wrong." Until they are willing to do that, it's not clear where they stand. A generous view is that they're ignoring heresy building in their midst. A less generous view is that they're waiting to see where it goes, to jump on the winning side.

The Catholic church should not be fostering division and attacking other churches over issues that have nothing to do with religion. The pope made a strong statement over evolution. That's the extent of his responsibility on the matter. Meanwhile, evolution continues to be taught in thousands of Catholic schools around the world.
 
The Bible says so.

And it says that all the rest of us have or will.

So destroying some poor guy's fig tree is what?

Just mistake?

Didn't really happen?

Was only directed to one tree so doesn't apply to the rest of us trees?

Not a sin because the Son of God did it?

What is your explanation?

:boggled:
 
Perhaps a little useful information about how to cure leprosy would have been nice, though.

More information of that sort would not have gone amiss. I wonder why god didn't provide it? Sadism? Warped sense of humour?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom