If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

"The Lord works in mysterious ways."

So watching millions die of diseases over the centuries and keeping the cures from them and giving false information about animals is mysterious? Sounds more like wickedness to me.
 
So watching millions die of diseases over the centuries and keeping the cures from them and giving false information about animals is mysterious? Sounds more like wickedness to me.

Well somethings got to get you - otherwise it would be getting pretty crowded about now
 
The Catholic church should not be fostering division and attacking other churches over issues that have nothing to do with religion. The pope made a strong statement over evolution.

I've got to give you credit--you're only demanding YOUR side comply with your wishes at this point.

However, I still find that a single strong statement isn't nearly enough. Would a single strong statement from a university chair prove to you that the university was serious about rooting out rampant fraud? Particularly after that institution has shown itself to be more or less without any ethics (any institution knowingly covering for child molesters cannot claim to be ethical)?

I'll agree that the child abuse scandal is a major reason for the migration out of Catholicism. However, I don't agree that it's THE reason. A lot of atheists say that studying evolution led them to abandon faith. It's likely a combination of reasons, unique to each person, with the evolution/Creationism thing being one side of it.
 
I'll answer it this way - you're a self-described Biblical literalist. Fine.

Do you believe that snakes can talk?

Of course they can, you haven't seen Harry Potter?

:D

I think you are barking up the wrong tree. It's a thing that we atheists do, we see the world as..... you know... the place around us. But believers see magic (for lack of a better word) and incorporate it into their world view.

You and I hear "talking snake" and we think "there is NOTHING like that in nature, currently or in the historical record." To defeat the talking snake argument we assume we can appeal to reason with logical arguments, "there is no proof of talking snakes in science" but to someone with a magical worldview it's an easy leap to insert sky daddy magic into the mix.

Perhaps I am not telling you anything you don't already know but, while I see your line of thinking as completely compelling and logical, it's a very uncompelling tact with someone who believes in hocus pocus, they can just pull out their magical "god did it" get out of jail free card.
 
I've got to give you credit--you're only demanding YOUR side comply with your wishes at this point.

However, I still find that a single strong statement isn't nearly enough. Would a single strong statement from a university chair prove to you that the university was serious about rooting out rampant fraud? Particularly after that institution has shown itself to be more or less without any ethics (any institution knowingly covering for child molesters cannot claim to be ethical)?

I'll agree that the child abuse scandal is a major reason for the migration out of Catholicism. However, I don't agree that it's THE reason. A lot of atheists say that studying evolution led them to abandon faith. It's likely a combination of reasons, unique to each person, with the evolution/Creationism thing being one side of it.

There may well be Catholics who lost their faith over evolution, but I doubt if there were that many. A typical Catholic over the last fifty years would have been taught about evolution at school, and never heard anything against it in church.

I really don't think that the Catholic church's disgraceful record on child abuse is remotely comparable with their restrained and sensible stance on evolution.
 
Of course. And it still isn't any impediment to the faith of most Christians these days.
But, as has been pointed out, I'm a bit late to this thread, for those xians for whom it is a problem, it's a big problem; and one that they're very vocal in denying. Not to mention forcing their views on others.

However, there are various issues on which you differ with other atheists. There is no total atheist consensus.
So what? The idea that all atheists are part of one group is rubbish, a concept held to only by believers.
 
Which are not true? And please explain.

Well... the Earth wasn't created in six days, there was no Adam and Eve, snakes don't talk, people don't live to be 900, there was no global flood, language and civilization predate the creation of the world, there is no evidence for the flight from Egypt, there are two contradictory accounts of creation, the flood and the genealogy of Jesus, etc.
 
I disagree.

I would be willing to wager dimes to donuts your next response will quote the Romans 5 parenthetical.

The bible does not explicitly give an age, but it's easy to add up the various years to get an approximate read. None of those could possibly give millions of years -- to say nothing about billions.

Which of my statements are you interpreting as meaning this?

This one:

Many Biblical literalists, myself included, don't believe in original sin.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom