If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

That was true until iirc the 17th century, Whales weren't reclassified as mammals until then, the only dissenter was Aristotle who laughingly (for the time) around 2400bce claimed that whales are mammals, not fish, because they nurse their young and breathe air like other mammals, either way if you're relying on Jonahs swallower being a whale then it can only be a Sperm Whale, as every other great whale has a throat the width of a football. Even then in the entire history of human whale interaction there have been only two reports of humans being swallowed and one of them is of extremely dubious origin. Basically you'd need to arrange it with a Deity to have any chance of success

This is often cited as an example of an error in the Bible, but I don't think that's valid. It's quite reasonable to describe anything that lives in water as a fish. It's also reasonable to describe a fish as having gills and scales, and another animal that breathes air and suckles live-born young as a mammal. The second definition is more likely to appeal to a biologist, but that doesn't make the first definition wrong. It's just a different way to look at it.

In the same way, Aristotle supposedly claimed that flies have four legs. As we can see from the article, it depends what is meant by a leg. It's now generally accepted that all insects have six legs - but even this can be readily disproved.

Papilio_polyxenes3.jpg


A caterpillar clearly has a lot more than six legs. However, biologists get around this by saying it has six "true legs". It just depends what you mean.
 
Well this European atheist would like to know how you go about determining which parts of the Bible are mean to be true and which parts are meant to be just a story. That way I might be able to make sense of the nonsense that Christians substitute for logic.

I have some respect for the literalists, at least they are consistent in their approach.

"some respect" or just less contempt? Why should Christians feel bound by a set of rules that they don't believe in and you don't believe in?

As has been clearly pointed out above, the idea of the bible as a guide to scientific fact was abandoned very early on in church history. It was never part of mainstream church history.

What 'revelation' are they referring to that gives us certainty? Otherwise this reads a lot like 'we know this didn't happen, but it must have happened because it's in the Bible, so we'll say it didn't happen but did happen at the same time and hope they fall for it.'

As I've suggested before - it sounds like atheism is the right choice for you. Why you think that makes you able to judge which version of Christianity you believe more I don't know. It's like a tennis player wanting to set the rules of the local golf club.

This "everything must come from the bible" attitude has been repeatedly debunked. You don't believe it yourself, so why do you insist that anyone else believe it?

Remind me how that works again? How exactly is Jesus 'needed'? Why couldn't God just do what he wanted to do rather than go through this convoluted route?
 
Some Christians interpret the Bible literally. Others do not.

That doesn't exactly seem like a difficult concept to grasp.

You'd think so, wouldn't you?

The diversity of opinion among atheists isn't considered a weakness in atheism. Why should it be? We don't say "Some atheists support Romney, some support Obama - therefore God exists. They can't make their mind up."

Actually, a very very tiny number of Christians interpret the bible literally. It's almost impossible to really do so. There's a kind of intermediate thing going on where they say they believe everything exactly as written, but really don't quite. Hence the shortage of geo-centric flat-earthers.
 
Exactly. No real atheists either.

No. I am a real atheist. No belief in any god or gods, that is the definition of atheism. If I wasn't a real atheist then I would believe in one or more gods.
 
Last edited:
I'm not saying that Catholics are right in how they deal with the issue. I'm just describing how they deal with the issue.

It's fine to say that Catholics are wrong, or fundamentalists are wrong, or both are wrong. What I don't get is the insistence that both are wrong, but that the fundamentalists are actually right.
 
I just don't understand why some atheists seem to think this is any kind of slam-dunk argument against believers. "The Bible says the Earth is only 6,000 years old and has talking snakes, and neither of those things is literally true! Hah hah!"

When the truth is that, to most Christians, the response to the above is, "Yes, we know. And?"

It's like the flip side of a Christian trying to convince an atheist of the error of his ways by saying "The fool has said in his heart there is no God! Hah hah!" It's simply not going to convince anyone who doesn't already think that way.
 
Last edited:
still not getting away from it the Earth is 4.5 billion years old

the Universe is 13.9 Billion years old
 
Even a lobster?

Why not? It's a matter of definition, not fact. Certainly a lobster isn't a fish according to the biological definition. However, fish were known and described long before there was any consistent biological understanding of how the various species interrelated. I don't think anyone would object to seeing live lobsters in the fish section of the local Chinese supermarket.
 
I just don't understand why some atheists seem to think this is any kind of slam-dunk argument against believers. "The Bible says the Earth is only 6,000 years old and has talking snakes, and neither of those things is literally true! Hah hah!"

When the truth is that, to most Christians, the response to the above is, "Yes, we know. And?"

It's like the flip side of a Christian trying to convince an atheist of the error of his ways by saying "The fool has said in his heart there is no God! Hah hah!" It's simply not going to convince anyone who doesn't already think that way.

It doesn't matter to me what they say. I just enjoy these threads.
 
Why not? It's a matter of definition, not fact. Certainly a lobster isn't a fish according to the biological definition. However, fish were known and described long before there was any consistent biological understanding of how the various species interrelated. I don't think anyone would object to seeing live lobsters in the fish section of the local Chinese supermarket.

Presumably god would have known what a lobster was, seeing that he created it. It just proves the point that the Old Testament was written by primitive men.
 
No. I am a real atheist. No belief in any god or gods, that is the definition of atheism. If I wasn't a real atheist then I would believe in one or more gods.

However, there are various issues on which you differ with other atheists. There is no total atheist consensus.
 
Of course. The bible is an optional extra to many Christians, which rather defeats the object.

And yet it doesn't look to be going away any time soon. So what's the point in harping on this, aside from smug mockery of a strawman Christianity?

I don't believe in any of the tenets of Christianity either, but that just seems rather...rude and juvenile, to me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom