westprog
Philosopher
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2006
- Messages
- 8,928
That was true until iirc the 17th century, Whales weren't reclassified as mammals until then, the only dissenter was Aristotle who laughingly (for the time) around 2400bce claimed that whales are mammals, not fish, because they nurse their young and breathe air like other mammals, either way if you're relying on Jonahs swallower being a whale then it can only be a Sperm Whale, as every other great whale has a throat the width of a football. Even then in the entire history of human whale interaction there have been only two reports of humans being swallowed and one of them is of extremely dubious origin. Basically you'd need to arrange it with a Deity to have any chance of success
This is often cited as an example of an error in the Bible, but I don't think that's valid. It's quite reasonable to describe anything that lives in water as a fish. It's also reasonable to describe a fish as having gills and scales, and another animal that breathes air and suckles live-born young as a mammal. The second definition is more likely to appeal to a biologist, but that doesn't make the first definition wrong. It's just a different way to look at it.
In the same way, Aristotle supposedly claimed that flies have four legs. As we can see from the article, it depends what is meant by a leg. It's now generally accepted that all insects have six legs - but even this can be readily disproved.
A caterpillar clearly has a lot more than six legs. However, biologists get around this by saying it has six "true legs". It just depends what you mean.