If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

It has been proved beyond all reasoanble doubt the Earth is 4.5 billion years old, stacks of evidence some of it rock hard too
 
Last edited:
Speak for yourself. I am not lost. What has gone wrong with your life that leads you to believe that you are lost? (could someone quote me please)
.
Too many people accept the burden of being born a sinner, without having done anything "sinful"... except maybe a little self-pleasuring in the womb.
And others with poor self images accept the burden when they're informed of it.
"The sins of the fathers" is a mighty good club to beat up on people with.
 
I believe Genesis 3's description of a serpent talking, yes.
So snakes can talk?

It's a serious question. We have absolutely NO evidence anywhere that snakes talk or can talk.
 
Last edited:
well no, not really, the idea that Genesis states the world is 6000 years old first appeared in "Annales Veteris Testamenti, a prima mundi origine deducti, una cum rerum Asiaticarum et Aegyptiacarum chronico, a temporis historici principio usque ad Maccabaicorum initia producto"
in the 17th century
and is called "the Ussher chronology"

Ussher wasn't the first one to count the years from the Bible, only the most famous. For example, Martin Luther published one such chronology as did Jean Calvin and I'm quite certain that neither of them was the first. Luther's figure was that the creation happened in 3970 BC, I can't remember Calvin's and can't be bothered trying to find it. It was in the same ballpark, anyway. (By the way, Ussher himself did't say that the world is 6000 years old as by his figures it was only 5653 years old back then).

While it is true that the Bible doesn't state the year of the creation anywhere, it's true in exactly the same way that it's true that Plutarch didn't say that the Temple of Artemis in Ephesos was burned down on on the sixth day of the month Hekatombæon. Instead what Plutarch did was to write that Alexander the Great was born on that day and that the Temple of Artemis burned on the same day that Alexander was born. A reader eager to jump on conclusions might use those two bits of information to conclude that Plutarch thought that Herostratos did his deed on Hekatombæon 6 but it's not explicitly stated.

The same way, a reader who goes through the chronologies of the Old Testament will find that there's an unbroken chain of years (well, a few such chains) that starts at the creation of Adam and ends around the time of the destruction of Jerusalem. Summing those years together and adding them to the time when Nebuchadrezzar reigned gives a figure that's somewhere around 4000 BC and the exact number depends on what route you take from the beginning.
 
This is like the poster thread for special pleading and retreationalism

"The bible says what it says, except when it doesn't"
 
...then doesn't that make the Old Testament account of 'creation' in Genesis absolutely wrong as a point of fact?

And if there was no 'fall of man' as described in that story, then doesn't that mean there was no 'original sin' which is stamped onto every human being since that time?

And if there is no 'original sin' that man as a 'kind' (as the religious use the term) is guilty of, then isn't it then true that there is no need for Jesus to come and 'save' anyone from it?

And if that's the case, then isn't the entire salvation doctrine of Christianity null and void?

I've summarized that argument several times on this forum when someone asks why creationists can't accept evolution, even God-guided evolution. It's a common theme in creationist books by authors like Ken Ham and Duane Gish.

Steve S
 
I've summarized that argument several times on this forum when someone asks why creationists can't accept evolution, even God-guided evolution. It's a common theme in creationist books by authors like Ken Ham and Duane Gish.

Steve S
I assume it's this notion that Richard Dawkins is referring to when he says that a true understanding of evolution is very corrosive to religious belief. I'm picking on Christians here, of course, but it's certainly applicable to the each of the Abrahamic faiths, as well as any other religions with creation myths that figure prominently in their respective mythologies.

The notion that life evolved and that humans had common ancestors with other animals in evolutionary history, and that man was not created in present form by a god or gods, is a very corrosive notion for literalists of any religious doctrine with a creation myth.
 
Last edited:
Ussher wasn't the first one to count the years from the Bible, only the most famous. For example, Martin Luther published one such chronology as did Jean Calvin and I'm quite certain that neither of them was the first. Luther's figure was that the creation happened in 3970 BC, I can't remember Calvin's and can't be bothered trying to find it. It was in the same ballpark, anyway. (By the way, Ussher himself did't say that the world is 6000 years old as by his figures it was only 5653 years old back then).
Theres a few others mentioned in the link I posted earlier
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ussher_chronology
Ussher's proposed date of 4004 BC differed little from other Biblically based estimates, such as those of Jose ben Halafta (3761 BC), Bede (3952 BC), Ussher's near-contemporary Scaliger (3949 BC), Johannes Kepler (3992 BC) or Sir Isaac Newton (c. 4000 BC).[citation needed] Ussher's specific choice of starting year may have been influenced by the then-widely-held belief that the Earth's potential duration was 6,000 years (4,000 before the birth of Christ and 2,000 after), corresponding to the six days of Creation, on the grounds that "one day is with the Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day" (2 Peter 3:8).
This Biblical math was probably the best entertainment to be had in those dark old days before TV and condoms
:D
 
Last edited:
Then again, perhaps you don't have people in Europe trying to shoehorn these myths - with the Bible and specifically Genesis as a 'reference point' - into public school science classrooms.

So the literalists here have to be taken at their word that they believe the Bible is literally true as written, and is the unalterable and inerrant word of God. There is no way around it.

As such, we who are opposed to their efforts treat them on that level - if you're going to assert it as literal truth, you'll be forced to defend it on those grounds.

Yes, I think it's reasonable to take at their word the people who insist that they take the bible literally. What I don't get is the determination to insist that the people who describe themselves as Christians should take the bible literally in all cases. As CJ.23 has pointed out in another thread, Christianity predates the bible. It's perfectly possible to be a Christian and not take the bible literally.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom