If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

Some Christians interpret the Bible literally. Others do not.

That doesn't exactly seem like a difficult concept to grasp.

Surely their god would expect them to take it literally. He must be very irked with them. Perhaps he does cause all the natural disasters, but his aim isn't good and innocent people are caught in the crossfire.
 
It's more that they believe the essential spiritual truths of the Bible are not described literally in the Bible, but allegorically, and that physical reality as revealed by science and God's Word as revealed by the Bible cannot be in conflict.



As Leo XIII notes, the idea that the Scriptures don't actually conflict with observable scientific fact because the descriptions in the Bible are metaphorical and not literal goes back to also warned against Christians insisting on a literal interpretation of Scripture which contradicts observable scientific fact because it made Christians look like idiots to non-Christians.



In other words, Christians have long since dealt with the theological problems presented by scientific errors in their Scriptures. Well, on a theoretical basis, at least. In practice, it...varies.

And, of course, there's the modern evangelical literalist movement, so this certainly doesn't apply to all Christians even now.



As far as I know, they chalk it up to one of those "so far deep in the mists of time that science will never actually be able to discover one way or the other" things.
.
Augustine was a Catholic, and therefore not a Christian... :)
 
No many Christians have considered Genesis to be an allegorical story as far back as about 400AD

It's earlier than that. The first questioning of the logic of the Genesis story I've found is in the theologian Origen (c.184-253). In his On First Principles he points out that it's impossible for light to have existed before the sun and moon, and therefore that the passage has to be interpreted by a 'spiritual' (ie, allegorical) meaning rather than a literal one. He may have lived before science, but he was classically educated and knew his (Aristotelian) logic. There may also be earlier examples.
 
It's earlier than that. The first questioning of the logic of the Genesis story I've found is in the theologian Origen (c.184-253). In his On First Principles he points out that it's impossible for light to have existed before the sun and moon, and therefore that the passage has to be interpreted by a 'spiritual' (ie, allegorical) meaning rather than a literal one.

Well, there are stars that also provide light, but point taken.

And I have to say, duh! It seems pretty obvious, one would think. Yet, there are those who insist that it does not need to be so...
 
So who's right? Maybe a question for another thread, so let's limit it to the OP.

Is the creation story literally true?

I certainly don't think so. But that wasn't the question posed in the OP - it was if it isn't literally true, how do Christians deal with it? And the answer ranges from "they think of it as allegory" to "they think it's literally true anyway, and it's reality that's wrong".

Some Christains believe that, some do not. That is why the whole thing is a farce, there are no real Christians.

Alternately, they're all "real Christians".

.
Augustine was a Catholic, and therefore not a Christian... :)

Touché.
 
Last edited:
So you believe every word. i work on Sundays sometimes. When are you coming to kill me?
.
We got double time on Sundays, and working over the Xmas holidays, the filthy lucre rolled in!:D
 
The "picking and choosing" parts of the bible to believe is what leads folks to assert that homosexuality is abomination (see: the bible, esp Leviticus) but that gays should not be put to death for it, although that is the next line.

You should hear the gay-bashers stumble over that one. "Oh, that's not my job" (to put gay people to death). Why not? Why is it any less your job than condemning them in the first place?

Yeah, it's REAL easy to hide behind the bible to condemn someone, but then pretty darn cowardly to wuss out on following through what the bible says to do about it.

Edit: Correct the bible reference
 
Last edited:
Well, there are stars that also provide light, but point taken.
.

Not until day 4 there wasn't
14 And God said: 'Let there be lights in the firmament of the heaven to divide the day from the night; and let them be for signs, and for seasons, and for days and years; 15 and let them be for lights in the firmament of the heaven to give light upon the earth.' And it was so. 16 And God made the two great lights: the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night; and the stars. 17 And God set them in the firmament of the heaven to give light upon the earth, 18 and to rule over the day and over the night, and to divide the light from the darkness; and God saw that it was good. 19 And there was evening and there was morning, a fourth day
also, somethings gone wrong with the moon lately, the original design clearly states that its supposed to generate its own light, not reflect it from the Sun
:D
 
Last edited:
Besides, everyone knows that the true Sabbath is on Saturday, not Sunday.

;)
Don't you blaspheme in here! Don't you dare blaspheme!

bluesbrothers425.jpeg
 
Yes, but whether there was a Fall or not is not tied to a literalistic reading of Genesis. The Catholic Catechism, for instance, says quite explicitly "The account of the fall in Genesis 3 uses figurative language, but affirms a primeval event, a deed that took place at the beginning of the history of man. Revelation gives us the certainty of faith that the whole of human history is marked by the original fault freely committed by our first parents."

So there's an original sin, rather than a long-term human condition, but the bible may not tell us what that is ? Gee, if it gets that wrong, it still makes the rest of the book highly suspicious. I mean, if I get the problem wrong, what are the odds that the solution is correct ?
 
Individual sin.

That's not what the bible says, mister litteralist.

Jesus is needed because men sin, and thus condemn themselves.

That's hilarious. The man is required because he decided that people who do things he doesn't want them to do would burn for all eternity. It's like saying an abusive father is needed to forgive you of the things you do that cause him to beat you up.
 
Our lost state is a direct consequence of our own behaviors.

Speak for yourself. I am not lost. What has gone wrong with your life that leads you to believe that you are lost? (could someone quote me please)
 
Not at all, but you now appear to be saying that you are a Biblical literalist, but that the Bible is not to be interpreted literally (at least in the REALLY crazy and ridiculous parts).

A literalist telling us not to be literal. Have I got this wrong?

I don't want to derail the thread and get into a debate about your personal beliefs (I'm the one who asked, I know), but at the same time, it is helpful and germane to the discussion to understand the perspective of a Biblical literalist when asking questions about Biblical creation, Genesis, creationism, etc. Even it it's a literalist that doesn't take it literally. ;-)

Keep in mind tha the Bible is a collection of many works written over the course of at least centuries. It's pretty clear that the purposes of some of these works are rather different from others, so I don't see it as inherently contradictory to think that Paul's direct letters of instruction should be read rather plainly, while the book with a talking snake whose literal reading contradicts known facts probably shouldn't be.

You also might want to check out these three posts by a Christian who's an expert in Ancient Near East Studies regarding the issue of ancient cosmologies.
 
Because Romans chapter 3 explains that we all fall short and find ourselves in need of salvation.

I don't recognise god's authority as to what I should and should not do.

Did you forget that we were discussing the beliefs of Biblical literalists based on what the Bible does or doesn't say?

You believe things because the bible says so in one breath, and in the other you say some things are not to be taken litterally... 1) how are you a litteralist ? and 2) how can you determine which passage is litteral and which isn't ?
 
So there's an original sin, rather than a long-term human condition, but the bible may not tell us what that is ? Gee, if it gets that wrong, it still makes the rest of the book highly suspicious. I mean, if I get the problem wrong, what are the odds that the solution is correct ?

I'm not saying that Catholics are right in how they deal with the issue. I'm just describing how they deal with the issue.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom