If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

A rose by any other name...

What would you call it?

It's not an argument about what to call it; it's an argument about whether or not it's correct.

Many Biblical literalists, myself included, don't believe in original sin.
 
Last edited:
A great read on this:


The Biblical Necessity of Adam and Eve


In essence, Schneider is saying, “It’s time to face facts: There was no historical Adam and Eve, no serpent, no apple, no fall that toppled man from a state of innocence.”[4] In doing so, he’s echoing the growing number of professing evangelical theologians, scientists, and scholars who share his views and who have abandoned the once unquestioned existence of Adam and Eve.
 
Last edited:
It's not an argument about what to call it; it's an argument about whether or not it's correct.

Many Biblical literalists, myself included, don't believe in original sin.
So why the need for salvation, then?

If humans after 'the fall' were not created in sin, then (as another poster said) Jesus is really irrelevant.

Do you believe that? If not, what are your beliefs on this point?
 
Last edited:
So why the need for salvation, then?

If humans after 'the fall' were not created in sin, then (as another poster said) Jesus is really irrelevant.

Do you believe that? If not, what are your beliefs on this point?

Individual sin.

My own need for salvation is based on my own sins, not the sins of my ancestors.

Jesus is needed because men sin, and thus condemn themselves.

That's also why we don't practice infant baptism. Babies don't sin and don't need to be saved.
 
What if people don't sin? Do they still have to believe in Yahweh and accept Jesus as their savior to be saved?

Nope. Any individual who refrains from ever once sinning is just fine without Jesus.

Christians usually believe that the set of such people = Jesus.
 
Those pictures are photoshopped. I swear. ;)

But seriously, why do you find it unlikely?

Because Romans chapter 3 explains that we all fall short and find ourselves in need of salvation.
 
Last edited:
The Bible says so.

And it says that all the rest of us have or will.
The Bible also professes that Adam and Eve were real people, that snakes talked, that slavery was permissible, that whales were fish, etc.

Just because the Bible says it doesn't make it true.
 
The Bible also professes that Adam and Eve were real people, that snakes talked, that slavery was permissible, that whales were fish, etc.

Just because the Bible says it doesn't make it true.

Did you forget that we were discussing the beliefs of Biblical literalists based on what the Bible does or doesn't say?
 
Did you forget that we were discussing the beliefs of Biblical literalists based on what the Bible does or doesn't say?
Not at all, but you now appear to be saying that you are a Biblical literalist, but that the Bible is not to be interpreted literally (at least in the REALLY crazy and ridiculous parts).

A literalist telling us not to be literal. Have I got this wrong?

I don't want to derail the thread and get into a debate about your personal beliefs (I'm the one who asked, I know), but at the same time, it is helpful and germane to the discussion to understand the perspective of a Biblical literalist when asking questions about Biblical creation, Genesis, creationism, etc. Even it it's a literalist that doesn't take it literally. ;-)
 
Last edited:
It's not an argument about what to call it; it's an argument about whether or not it's correct.

Many Biblical literalists, myself included, don't believe in original sin.

So you believe every word. i work on Sundays sometimes. When are you coming to kill me?
 
that whales were fish, etc.

Just because the Bible says it doesn't make it true.

That was true until iirc the 17th century, Whales weren't reclassified as mammals until then, the only dissenter was Aristotle who laughingly (for the time) around 2400bce claimed that whales are mammals, not fish, because they nurse their young and breathe air like other mammals, either way if you're relying on Jonahs swallower being a whale then it can only be a Sperm Whale, as every other great whale has a throat the width of a football. Even then in the entire history of human whale interaction there have been only two reports of humans being swallowed and one of them is of extremely dubious origin. Basically you'd need to arrange it with a Deity to have any chance of success
:D

I don't want to derail the thread and get into a debate about your personal beliefs

then don't ask him, if you want to know his personal beliefs just read any of his posts in the religion forum
;)
 
Last edited:
Not at all, but you now appear to be saying that you are a Biblical literalist, but that the Bible is not to be interpreted literally (at least in the REALLY crazy and ridiculous parts).

I'm not sure what I said that you're reading that way.
 
I know, however, that there will be atheists who will continue to insist on biblical inerrancy. They don't go for flat earthism or geocentricity, however. It seems to be an American thing. I don't think European atheists have the same attachment to the literal bible.

Well this European atheist would like to know how you go about determining which parts of the Bible are mean to be true and which parts are meant to be just a story. That way I might be able to make sense of the nonsense that Christians substitute for logic.

I have some respect for the literalists, at least they are consistent in their approach.

Yes, but whether there was a Fall or not is not tied to a literalistic reading of Genesis. The Catholic Catechism, for instance, says quite explicitly "The account of the fall in Genesis 3 uses figurative language, but affirms a primeval event, a deed that took place at the beginning of the history of man. Revelation gives us the certainty of faith that the whole of human history is marked by the original fault freely committed by our first parents."

What 'revelation' are they referring to that gives us certainty? Otherwise this reads a lot like 'we know this didn't happen, but it must have happened because it's in the Bible, so we'll say it didn't happen but did happen at the same time and hope they fall for it.'

Jesus is needed because men sin, .

Remind me how that works again? How exactly is Jesus 'needed'? Why couldn't God just do what he wanted to do rather than go through this convoluted route?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom