If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am not sure what you are asking here...

You seemed to be implying that the ROOSD narrative provides insight into some recommendations that NIST missed, so I was asking what you think they were. I'll take "Super high rise buildings do not make sense in the first place" as a defensible position, but then it becomes even more important to not create the false impression that maybe we'll be okay if we avoid the OOS design.

I think the OOS system which moved the axial capacity to the perimeter AND was use as a wind shear strategy created... an effective tube which funneled the falling debris and caused the peel sending material as far away as 400+ feet.

I'm sure the close-spaced columns and spandrel plates created more of a "funnel effect" than a curtain wall, but once the floor connections were broken there was obviously more than enough excess energy to dispense with them. I believe that what kept most of the debris headed down was not any funnel effect, but being trapped under tons of other debris, nowhere near the edge of a 200-foot-wide building. I think this is another case where the ROOSD narrative is misleading if this "funnel effect" is taken as more than a circumstantial detail.
 
You seemed to be implying that the ROOSD narrative provides insight into some recommendations that NIST missed, so I was asking what you think they were. I'll take "Super high rise buildings do not make sense in the first place" as a defensible position, but then it becomes even more important to not create the false impression that maybe we'll be okay if we avoid the OOS design.

Proscription against lightweight long span trusses for one... absence of girders/bays in the floor system... ie not one huge floor slab. alternate strategies for wind shear perhaps...

I'm sure the close-spaced columns and spandrel plates created more of a "funnel effect" than a curtain wall, but once the floor connections were broken there was obviously more than enough excess energy to dispense with them. I believe that what kept most of the debris headed down was not any funnel effect, but being trapped under tons of other debris, nowhere near the edge of a 200-foot-wide building. I think this is another case where the ROOSD narrative is misleading if this "funnel effect" is taken as more than a circumstantial detail.

Curtain walls are actually pretty fragile and attached to the perimeter steel frame with clips. I suspect that there would be much less confinement and funneling and without a almost solid stiff structural wall... no peeling. There was no peeling in 7wtc because it was a top down collapse and the floor systems likely were pulled into the collapse cire region... as opposed to the twins whose core was not the recipient of all the OOS floor collapse material (or so it seems)

maybe...

How would a very very tall grain filled silo respond to a dynamic load of lots of lead shot dropping on it? Where would the silo's walls fail? Would there be a peel? or a bursting near the bottom? or what?

comments in red
 
You seem to have become rather choosey about when misleading terminology matters and when it doesn't. :rolleyes:

How is it misleading?
Final word "destruction" CHECK yep it is that.
First word modifier "runaway" CHECK yep

What was being destructed in rapid runaway fashion? The "office space" CHECK
What characteristic is very prominent about that office space? "Open" floor plan of widely separated columns.CHECK.

Fact is that you could write several (perhaps several dozen) paragraphs that succinctly describe the collapse progression. A few engineers might even read it. Perhaps if you push and push, maybe even a few interested persons might read it. If you are lucky, a small percentage might retain it in its entirety.
BUT....
You could also summerize the event, within that longer description, in a single phrase that is easily recalled.

I also like " Internal Avalanche of Debris" IAD. Its even pronouncable. I make no distinction on applicability of such things based on who came up with it. Hell if Gage himself ever came up with something good, I'd use it.

Happens a lot. I gave the example of AIDS "Aquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome". Really? Not very descriptive at all, and yet its widely used. Hardly anyone ever even uttering the whole phrase, using the acronym almost exclusively.


Analogy gets used a lot too. Have you ever used analogies to make a point? How about similie or metaphor? Of course not, because in doing so you would be getting rather loose with the absolute truth and using misleading terminology.
 
Last edited:
How is it misleading?
Final word "destruction" CHECK yep it is that.
First word modifier "runaway" CHECK yep

What was being destructed in rapid runaway fashion? The "office space" CHECK
What characteristic is very prominent about that office space? "Open" floor plan of widely separated columns.CHECK.

Fact is that you could write several (perhaps several dozen) paragraphs that succinctly describe the collapse progression. A few engineers might even read it. Perhaps if you push and push, maybe even a few interested persons might read it. If you are lucky, a small percentage might retain it in its entirety.
BUT....
You could also summerize the event, within that longer description, in a single phrase that is easily recalled.

I also like " Internal Avalanche of Debris" IAD. Its even pronouncable. I make no distinction on applicability of such things based on who came up with it. Hell if Gage himself ever came up with something good, I'd use it.

Happens a lot. I gave the example of AIDS "Aquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome". Really? Not very descriptive at all, and yet its widely used. Hardly anyone ever even uttering the whole phrase, using the acronym almost exclusively.


Analogy gets used a lot too. Have you ever used analogies to make a point? How about similie or metaphor? Of course not, because in doing so you would be getting rather loose with the absolute truth and using misleading terminology.

You're forgetting the stigma of Aids, I think that William is saying that such simple terms as ROOSD and AIDs carry undue influence as a limited explanation and stigmatize certain forms of construction where it might not be a valid case.

FIROOSD would be a vastly more accurate discription. Or IFiROOSD.
Impact And Fire Induced ROOSD.

We all can agree I think without impact and fire there would be no ROOSD.

Linking ROOSD to the impact and Fires is what I believe William is hinting at being missing From ROOSD.

That does lead some to believe the buildings were poorly designed and constructed which is definitely not the case.

Although I could be wrong on what William feels is misleading about ROOSD, and why such a name would induce an unwarranted stigma.
 
JayDH that is an excellent post!

It really get at the brilliant use of descriptive language if NIST - global collapse. From the Dictionary:

"Simple Definition of global

: involving the entire world

: involving all of something and especially a computer system, file, etc.

Full Definition of global

1 : spherical

2 : of, relating to, or involving the entire world : worldwide <a global system of communication>; also : of or relating to a celestial body (as the moon)

3 : of, relating to, or applying to a whole (as a mathematical function or a computer program) : universal <a global search of a file>"

NB how well the term NIST uses describes what happens and BTW used for all three buildings... as if they were notably similar.
 
... NIST punts and doesn't explain much.....
There is nothing to learn after initiation. NIST did not Punt, they did not waste time for a study which is not needed.
The only study we need for the collapse after initiation is on video; no need to waste time making up BS or some BS study of what is known.

The collapse continues is due to the structure and overwhelming mass falling... we know the structure limitations and the global collapse continues. Further study past initiation, knowing the structure will fail, becomes a waste;

NIST's goals did not cover BS studies of the collapse. Even NIST can figure out a floor can hold 29,000,000 pounds, a fact based on the structure. NIST did not punt, that is a baseless opinion.
 
There is nothing to learn after initiation. NIST did not Punt, they did not waste time for a study which is not needed.
The only study we need for the collapse after initiation is on video; no need to waste time making up BS or some BS study of what is known.

The collapse continues is due to the structure and overwhelming mass falling... we know the structure limitations and the global collapse continues. Further study past initiation, knowing the structure will fail, becomes a waste;

NIST's goals did not cover BS studies of the collapse. Even NIST can figure out a floor can hold 29,000,000 pounds, a fact based on the structure. NIST did not punt, that is a baseless opinion.

It's obvious to anyone who has the slightest clue about physics that once the huge mass was moving down... it was unstoppable by the floors and the columns would collapse without bracing. This may seem trivial to engineers... but not to congress or lay persons.

NIST initiation scenarios are only hypothetical and not convincing to some people... others don't care.
 
You're forgetting the stigma of Aids, I think that William is saying that such simple terms as ROOSD and AIDs carry undue influence as a limited explanation and stigmatize certain forms of construction where it might not be a valid case.

FIROOSD would be a vastly more accurate discription. Or IFiROOSD.
Impact And Fire Induced ROOSD.

We all can agree I think without impact and fire there would be no ROOSD.

Linking ROOSD to the impact and Fires is what I believe William is hinting at being missing From ROOSD.

That does lead some to believe the buildings were poorly designed and constructed which is definitely not the case.

Although I could be wrong on what William feels is misleading about ROOSD, and why such a name would induce an unwarranted stigma.

ROOSD only attempts and does quite well describing the collapse phase... and indeed ROOSD could be initiated by CD as well...

The "induced" part is the phase and the transition to ROOSD or "initiation"... ROOSD had nothing to do with fire and destroyed a ambient temperature intact more or less pristine 90 or so floors.

It is debatable if the towers were "poorly" designed or built. They certainly were adequately designed... very economically designs and inexpensively built. These were the KEY objective for the developers. Architecturally they were considered by most abominations.

The stigmatizing of OOS buildings is well deserved!
 
You're forgetting the stigma of Aids,
I fail to see any significance in public stigma of one acronym, to the discussion of simple, easy to understand acronyms in general.

I think that William is saying that such simple terms as ROOSD and AIDs carry undue influence as a limited explanation and stigmatize certain forms of construction where it might not be a valid case.
That's a reach. AIDS carries a stigma because of the primary manner of its transmission, a factor that doesn't even enter into the acronym, and most certainly has no analogue in the mechanisms involved in the collapse of the towers.

MY point is that these type of acronyms are bloody commonplace in our society and not a one is particularly accurate or detailed in explain what they are attached to.

FIROOSD would be a vastly more accurate discription. Or IFiROOSD.
Impact And Fire Induced ROOSD.

We all can agree I think without impact and fire there would be no ROOSD.

Linking ROOSD to the impact and Fires is what I believe William is hinting at being missing From ROOSD.

That does lead some to believe the buildings were poorly designed and constructed which is definitely not the case.

Although I could be wrong on what William feels is misleading about ROOSD, and why such a name would induce an unwarranted stigma.
All very true but really, just how many letters in an acronym are too many? IFIROOSD is just fine. That's what, three syllables in pronunciation? I suggest adding no more. Perhaps it'll catch on.
 
JayDH that is an excellent post!

It really get at the brilliant use of descriptive language if NIST - global collapse. From the Dictionary:

"Simple Definition of global

: involving the entire world

: involving all of something and especially a computer system, file, etc.

Full Definition of global

1 : spherical

2 : of, relating to, or involving the entire world : worldwide <a global system of communication>; also : of or relating to a celestial body (as the moon)

3 : of, relating to, or applying to a whole (as a mathematical function or a computer program) : universal <a global search of a file>"

NB how well the term NIST uses describes what happens and BTW used for all three buildings... as if they were notably similar.
Thanks JSO. I really do not understand the tearing of clothes and gnashing of teeth over an acronym.

Jeez!


Tis English, a crazy language that uses words to mean many disparate things.

Shall we examine the names of different quarks in subatomic physics?


As for NIST, I think it was obvious to those working on the report that once the upper section began moving, the structure was doomed, all the people in the building were doomed. That there was little to nothing at all that could be recommended in building standards that could arrest collapse after that point. The focus then would be how to not get to that point, if that is even relevant at all or if the event is so rare as to not be feasible to design against.

Just how far into collapse should NIST have described it? One level below initialization? Two? Twenty? Ninety+? Is it possible, is it relevant to NIST's task?
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by jaydeehess
...I contend that that very initial condition (for the progression we refer to as ROOSD) would be much less likely in a closer spaced lattice

That is the way I read your post.
My engineer's gut feeling says you are probably right. BUT dont ask me to prove it....


....YET. ;)

Agreed and TAOTSSOLSBPFCACCBAIVOMFA somehow doesnt strike me as likely to gain support.
Me 2

Which is the purpose despite all the garbage that has been heaped on it.

But how would a lattice structure hold up to a high-speed airliner impact? Didn't the Twin Towers sway considerably on impact, which would have dissipated a great deal of kinetic energy? Wouldn't a closely spaced lattice be less flexible, ergo more prone to breakage?

I ask in the spirit of requesting an informed opinion. Unlike our recent temporarily (?) departed guest, I respect the limits of my expertise. As a retired industrial chemist, I can tell you why nanothermite is bunk, but when it comes to structural engineering, I have only my knowledge of lower-division college physics.
 
But how would a lattice structure hold up to a high-speed airliner impact? Didn't the Twin Towers sway considerably on impact, which would have dissipated a great deal of kinetic energy? Wouldn't a closely spaced lattice be less flexible, ergo more prone to breakage?
Recall my earlier comment - which was responding to the transition from initiation to progression:
My engineer's gut feeling says you are probably right.
...i.e. a lattice layout should in my gut feeling guess be harder to transition to progression. (NOT ROOSD - which is the main but only one of the components of progression).

Your question Redwood is IMO a full grade more complicated. So I won't hazard even a gut feeling guess until I give it some serious thought. And I'm sure it will be very much situation specific with probably NO generic overriding "lean" either way.

I ask in the spirit of requesting an informed opinion. Unlike our recent temporarily (?) departed guest, I respect the limits of my expertise.
Understood - I'm pretty sure of my own limits and rarely venture beyond them UNLESS with explicit disclaimers.
As a retired industrial chemist, I can tell you why nanothermite is bunk, but when it comes to structural engineering, I have only my knowledge of lower-division college physics.
The structural engineering isn't necessarily the dominating need. Most of the structural components are relatively straight forward. The difficulties and confusions mostly come in the adding up the bits into the whole picture which is as much a matter of clear thinking and logic as it is structural engineering. Remember we are a couple of grades more complicated that needed to design a safe building to remain standing. With patience on both sides - explainer and explainee - most of the apparently complex stuff involved in WTC Twin Towers collapses can be explained to persons capable of high school level physics.
 
Last edited:
...All very true but really, just how many letters in an acronym are too many? IFIROOSD is just fine. That's what, three syllables in pronunciation? I suggest adding no more. Perhaps it'll catch on.
Don't miss the big trick Crazy C is proposing - he has changed the object of the acronym.

It is an acronym to describe ONE SPECIFIC part of the progression stage of collapse. That is the way I use it. I'm even more careful then M_T on being specific. (He has on occasions included or implied the inclusion of the second sub mechanism - perimeter peel off - as part of ROOSD) Whether my strict usage or Major_Tom's sometimes looser usage it is ALWAYS bleeding obvious in context.

That part of the collapse was by falling of material in the Open Office space and attempts to say that is misleading are nonsense. If someone wants to include "core" in ROOSD - then take them to task for obvious misuse of a self defining acronym. Any one posting here regularly who thinks that the core of the Twin Towers was in the office space needs to seek help. The core - believe it or not - was in the middle of the building. The office space was around the core. And it was where the offices were - in that open space - the main design feature of the towers from the occupants perspective. Don't blame the acronym - blame those who misuse it - especially those who are deliberate in their mendacity.


:runaway
 
It is an acronym to describe ONE SPECIFIC part of the progression stage of collapse. That is the way I use it.

Yes, it's a narrative about one aspect of the progression stage of a specific pair of buildings, in which "open office space" was an innocent victim of circumstance. I'm glad you use it that way, but I haven't accused you of being misled into false generalizations, have I?

That part of the collapse was by falling of material in the Open Office space and attempts to say that is misleading are nonsense.

Then it would appear that you've missed a lot of comments like this one:
I suspect a system of beams and girder would fair better but it require larger columns at the facade where the concentrated girder loads would be carried. For a 110 story building this would mean much larger facade columns and loss of the membrane wind shear strategy... so the engineer made the facade of multiple smaller columns, made them vierendeel truss like a membrane would could move the forces effectively.. Clever but not for resisting an OOS runaway collapse.
JSO apparently believes the incompetent NIST analysis failed to provide the valuable insight that we can avoid ROOSD by not using OOS designs.

Don't blame the acronym - blame those who misuse it - especially those who are deliberate in their mendacity.


:runaway

:rolleyes:
 
It is an acronym to describe ONE SPECIFIC part of the progression stage of collapse. That is the way I use it.
Yes, it's a narrative about one aspect of the progression stage of a specific pair of buildings, in which "open office space" was an innocent victim of circumstance. I'm glad you use it that way, but I haven't accused you of being misled into false generalizations, have I?
No. You and I are usually on close to the same wavelength - same sheet of music....including some areas of difference...

..and - as I see it - BOTH of us are concerned about some others who are not so clear.

My constant despair in forum discussions is when I or some other member has carefully distinguished two issues and along comes another member who re-conflates them.

When debunkers do it I tend to avoid "rubbing their noses in it" BUT more often than not the slight gain in clarity has been thrown away. By the debunker who missed the point.

The metaphor/analogy I often use is when the discussion is about the differences between apples and bananas - and some astute person has carefully describe the differences in detail.

THEN along comes another person and says "what is the fuss about - they are both fruit"

OR - translating into the nonsense we see on this topic:
The discussion is about the progression (or collapse) of WTC 1 or 2 and contrasting it with other progressions (collapses) at other towers.

And some clown asserts - I'll leave it in analogy format - "we don't need a word for "apple" or "banana" because they are both "fruit" and to rub the salt into the wound of that bit of idiocy they assert "and only Botanists publishing in professional papers are entitled to recognise the difference and give them names" Utter crap. Repeated several times over recent years. (And - dropping the analogy - by engineers claiming only engineers are entitled to (whatever).....professional arrogance which is way beyond unwarranted.)

And I'll leave it for you to translate back from the analogy into engineering on the earlier points.

Then it would appear that you've missed a lot of comments like this one:
I suspect a system of beams and girder would fair better but it require larger columns at the facade where the concentrated girder loads would be carried. For a 110 story building this would mean much larger facade columns and loss of the membrane wind shear strategy... so the engineer made the facade of multiple smaller columns, made them vierendeel truss like a membrane would could move the forces effectively.. Clever but not for resisting an OOS runaway collapse.
JSO apparently believes the incompetent NIST analysis failed to provide the valuable insight that we can avoid ROOSD by not using OOS designs.
Didn't miss any of them. Hence my despair. In the last few posts both Sander and Crazy Chainsaw have missed the clarity presented for consideration and fogged it up again.

I'm well aware of Sander's "hot issues" and his antipathy towards NIST. Crazy C also totally missed the point and changes the object of ROOSD - trying to make it much more than it is. And - by doing so - putting layers of fog over what should be clarifying discussion.

I choose not to correct them every time. But it invariably stalls or circles the debate.

Members posting on forums display a wide range of conceptualising and reasoning skills. We have to live with it.

Don't blame the acronym - blame those who misuse it - especially those who are deliberate in their mendacity.

:runaway


:rolleyes:
Agreed. I tend to hope that astute members can see what is happening. BUT it is unlikely.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it's a narrative about one aspect of the progression stage of a specific pair of buildings, in which "open office space" was an innocent victim of circumstance. I'm glad you use it that way, but I haven't accused you of being misled into false generalizations, have I?



Then it would appear that you've missed a lot of comments like this one:

JSO apparently believes the incompetent NIST analysis failed to provide the valuable insight that we can avoid ROOSD by not using OOS designs.



:rolleyes:

You would still have potential for A Global collapse, if the buildings were damaged enough
By impact and fires it is not the design that is at fault, but the energy applied too it.

When such energies are applied a stiffer building will fall faster.

The design only determines the way in which energy flows though it, once the energy to sheer the connections is reached a cascade of one form or another will occur.

Yes JSO, and Jay are making an implication, about the buildings, Nist, and ROOSD that is not correct.

Nist didn't miss ROOSD, they chose to engineer to avoid, all forums of global collapse initiation in all buildings.

That's why I was making the point that there is a false invalid stigma about ROOSD that is unwarranted, it occured I believe because of the Truther Debunker psychological aspect.
 
Don't miss the big trick Crazy C is proposing - he has changed the object of the acronym.

It is an acronym to describe ONE SPECIFIC part of the progression stage of collapse. That is the way I use it. I'm even more careful then M_T on being specific. (He has on occasions included or implied the inclusion of the second sub mechanism - perimeter peel off - as part of ROOSD) Whether my strict usage or Major_Tom's sometimes looser usage it is ALWAYS bleeding obvious in context.

That part of the collapse was by falling of material in the Open Office space and attempts to say that is misleading are nonsense. If someone wants to include "core" in ROOSD - then take them to task for obvious misuse of a self defining acronym. Any one posting here regularly who thinks that the core of the Twin Towers was in the office space needs to seek help. The core - believe it or not - was in the middle of the building. The office space was around the core. And it was where the offices were - in that open space - the main design feature of the towers from the occupants perspective. Don't blame the acronym - blame those who misuse it - especially those who are deliberate in their mendacity.


:runaway

I am glad you use the acronym in a strict sense, that excludes the perimeter peel-off as well as the core mechanism.

I agree with your three main collapse progression mechanisms.

I also agree that the WTC had Open Office Spaces that went on experience a progressive collapse when falling debris was applied dynamically and separated the floor bays from the vertical supports.


And now to where we[*] disagree:
That's the assertion (or suggestion) that those floor bays being OOS was a necessary, or at least a highly significant, circumstance for this "ROOSD" mechanism to occur in the first place.
I dispute this, and so do tfk and WilliamSeger: Smaller floor bay areas may be vulnerable to the same collapse progression mechanism, and Ronan Point is an example of this.

There are reasons now why Ronan Point didn't progress to total collapse that have a lot, or everything, to do with RP having multiple and smaller bays.
I suggest: The OOS are a significant tributary circumstance not for the floors avalanching down, but for the perimeter peel-off to occur and doom the rest of the tower - because there essentially was only one floor bay.

I propose renaming "ROOSD" to "RD" to reflect the realization that the OOS were not necessary for RD, and inventing a new, catchy acronym to descibe the perimeter peel that includes "OOS":
OOSIPP - Open Office Space Induced Perimeter Peel

:D


[*] ETA: That's "we disagree" as in "some unspedified other(s) disagree with me, Ostein". Doesn't necessarily include you, ozeco, but anyone who choses to disagree
 
Last edited:
It is an acronym to describe ONE SPECIFIC part of the progression stage of collapse. That is the way I use it.

In fact Oystein accused me of moving the goalpost and including initiation when if one looks at the posts, Oystein first brought up the prior events(prior to runaway progression).

Yes, ROOSD is only to be a descriptor of the post initial collapse phase. I bowed to pressure earlier and said that if one wants to devise an acronym for the whole collapse that CC's IFIROOSD (Impact and Fire Induced Runaway Open Office Space Destruction). Redwood might have missed that post.

As I said though, with acronyms its best not to add too many syllables in the pronunciation, "eye-feer-oosed" is probably the limit.
 
I am glad you use the acronym in a strict sense, that excludes the perimeter peel-off as well as the core mechanism.

I agree with your three main collapse progression mechanisms.

I also agree that the WTC had Open Office Spaces that went on experience a progressive collapse when falling debris was applied dynamically and separated the floor bays from the vertical supports.


And now to where we[*] disagree:
That's the assertion (or suggestion) that those floor bays being OOS was a necessary, or at least a highly significant, circumstance for this "ROOSD" mechanism to occur in the first place.
I dispute this, and so do tfk and WilliamSeger: Smaller floor bay areas may be vulnerable to the same collapse progression mechanism, and Ronan Point is an example of this.

There are reasons now why Ronan Point didn't progress to total collapse that have a lot, or everything, to do with RP having multiple and smaller bays.
I suggest: The OOS are a significant tributary circumstance not for the floors avalanching down, but for the perimeter peel-off to occur and doom the rest of the tower - because there essentially was only one floor bay.

I propose renaming "ROOSD" to "RD" to reflect the realization that the OOS were not necessary for RD, and inventing a new, catchy acronym to descibe the perimeter peel that includes "OOS":
OOSIPP - Open Office Space Induced Perimeter Peel

:D


[*] ETA: That's "we disagree" as in "some unspedified other(s) disagree with me, Ostein". Doesn't necessarily include you, ozeco, but anyone who choses to disagree

Well, let's not forget the core. You also left out initiation, a point you seemed to wish to include several posts ago. We need to include a reference to impact and fire (CC's "IFI"), the perimeter peel, (your PP, although it needs a vowel to be pronounced) and perhaps one for core floor stripping induced Euler buckling.

Tell you what, just drop all use of acronym and write up a few paragraphs summarizing the collapse. Of course some will then point out that details are left out and you will then need to fill in those details to satisfy those persons. That'll bring you up to dozens of pages perhaps, then some will pick on further lack of details and you will be reduced to including all of the NIST reports plus Purdue U., plus Bazant (along with critiques on applicability ), plus maybe the work of online persons such as femr2 and M_T.

The acronym ROOSD is to apply to only the main driver of the progression through global collapse. Isn't what allowed the collapse to be global the main point of contention to the curious public? The open aspect allowed floor stripping to incorporate large areas, that floor destruction led to perimeter peel, and core instability.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom