If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
My perspective is that ROOSD describes the trade center tower collapses... Bays can have runaway collapse but it wouldn't necessarily bring the whole building down... Ronan Point shows this... Twin towers came totally down because there were no bayes and it was an OOS design... PLUS unlike 7WTC it had closely spaced face of columns which because of their staggered arrangement and tight spacing PEELED.. sort of pulling a whole bunch of columns in huge sheets. That will not likely happen in a bayed 30' spacing of columns facade. Peel was rather unique to the OOS design towers.

The only thing not terribly unique in the building was the core. but it had some odd things as well because the massive antenna had to have the load redistributed because the columns under it framed a shaft and were not very large... as the loads they carried for 110 floors were the smallest in the building (more or less)... so rather than beef up 109 floors of columns, using up real estate and costing money... the hat truss was added which also could move lateral (and if needed axial loads about).

The twin tower OOS system used 80" oc whimpy trusses which did not "match" to the core column positions... so a belt girder was cantilevered from the perimeter of the core and acted as a "transfer" structure... moving the 80" oc truss loads to the 25' OC or so core columns.

So the twins were no only lacking bays... but their OOS system drove other engineering decisions which seem to me led to the runaway collapse AND the form it took.

But yes the core floor collapse was within a bay system... although there was lots of shafts with no floors to collapse in the first place... such as most of the areas between rows 500 and 600 where the express cars ran.

Runaway floor collapse leaves columns unbraced and they will fall because of their too high slenderness ratio... doesn't have to be a "column" free space... but a bay IS a column free space... bounder by usually 4 columns!

The belt girder, and the panel columns of the facade were driven by the choice for a light weight slab spanning only 80"... with no girders of course.
 
By the way: I don't actually, personally have a problem with adopting the "ROOSD" label. I have used it in the past in lieu of "pancaking". In my mind, both describe the same - one dominant of several significant mechanisms by which the twin towers' collapses progressed after they initiated.

There are problems with both labels: "Pancaking" has been used to describe an initiation hypothetisis which NIST has rejected - that confuses trurthers, and some debunkers, and is reason to avoid the term. Also, it invokes the idea that the floor came down in clean, whole, horizontal, flat pieces - which they certainly did not.
So that's why I adopted the "fresh" label "ROOSD", but it has its problems too: The "OOS" part is questionable and potentially misleading, and too specific; and it is giving too much credit to M_T who has not discovered anything that others already weren't perfectly well aware of - the others including Bazant and NIST (and ozeco).

I don't quite understand how this isn't consensus here.
 
OMGDC

Something Cole can't model due to overwhelming missing brain mass collapse falling faster than gravity. Can Cole model Overwhelming Mass Gravity Driven Collapse...
 
There are problems with both labels: "Pancaking" has been used to describe an initiation hypothetisis which NIST has rejected - that confuses trurthers, and some debunkers, and is reason to avoid the term. Also, it invokes the idea that the floor came down in clean, whole, horizontal, flat pieces - which they certainly did not.
So that's why I adopted the "fresh" label "ROOSD", but it has its problems too: The "OOS" part is questionable and potentially misleading, and too specific; and it is giving too much credit to M_T who has not discovered anything that others already weren't perfectly well aware of - the others including Bazant and NIST (and ozeco).

I don't quite understand how this isn't consensus here.

I too moved away from 'pancake' for the same reason. Using it always required including a caveat that the collapses were not full single level horizontal release.

As far as M_T goes, he is a maddingly ego driven sob. That said, I find no reason to cut out references that emanate from him just because of his personality. I mean Newton was reportably quite an sob himself( not that I equate MT in intellect, to Newton). If ROOSD is better than 'pancake' because it eliminated the required caveat then I use it. It does not mean I am feeding MT's ego. In fact almost anytime anyone uses it here his name isnt mentioned. If he posts harfd copies of posts contsining ROOSD on his bedroom walls in order accomplish a self stroking, that doesnt reflect on me afaiac.
 
Last edited:
OMGDC

Something Cole can't model due to overwhelming missing brain mass collapse falling faster than gravity. Can Cole model Overwhelming Mass Gravity Driven Collapse...
I thought that stood for Oh My Gosh, Damn Cole!
 
By the way: I don't actually, personally have a problem with adopting the "ROOSD" label. I have used it in the past in lieu of "pancaking". In my mind, both describe the same - one dominant of several significant mechanisms by which the twin towers' collapses progressed after they initiated.
That is the way I use it AND the logical significance I attribute to it as the leading sub-process of a three part mechanism
There are problems with both labels: "Pancaking" has been used to describe an initiation hypothesis which NIST has rejected - that confuses truthers, and some debunkers, and is reason to avoid the term.
Agreed - "pancaking" was subject of deliberate misuse by truthers and some probably genuine confusion by debunkers. However attacks and misrepresentation of ROOSD come mostly from debunkers. (And some history of lack of clarity by the proponent M_T - let's not go there. :rolleyes:)
Also, it invokes the idea that the floor came down in clean, whole, horizontal, flat pieces - which they certainly did not.
True. I have tended (deliberately) to overlook that aspect of reality unless it was the specific issue in question. The overview of understanding collapse is not altered by the partial floor sequencing issues. So necessary simplification IMO.
So that's why I adopted the "fresh" label "ROOSD", but it has its problems too: The "OOS" part is questionable and potentially misleading, and too specific;
At first reading I disagree with all three. I am interested to see why you make them - here are my "takes" on the three:
(a) Why is OOS "questionable"? Do you disagree with mass falling down that area OR just the labelling of the area as OOS?
(b) I don't see how we can blame a specific and descriptive acronym when persons go outside it's scope to get them selves misled. Many of them following a known pre-set bias of their own belief system. A main reason for a catchy acronym is to save repetitious restatements of lengthy descriptive text. ROOSD puts it all in one package. And all proposals I have seen - including the recent ones - change the scope. So the person proposing a different acronym has already missed the point.
(c) If it is "too specific" are you sure that you want an acronym for just that sub-mechnaism? Aren't you flagging a wish to go broader in scope. Possibly similar to Crazy Chainsaw's suggestion?

and it is giving too much credit to M_T who has not discovered anything that others already weren't perfectly well aware of - the others including Bazant and NIST (and ozeco).
That is the real reason IMO - nail M_T into his corner and hang the cost.

I've deliberately played - and will continue to play - devils advocate. If M_T or any other person designated by the mob on this forum to be a truther makes a true statement I will not declare it false.

I have consistently supported the truth of those points which M_T validly asserts to be true. Whilst spending more time coaching him on issues of reasoning and style/ego than I think any other member of this forum or The911I will NOT I think I'm the only debunker he has favoured with a personal thread - dedicated to his ongoing character assassination of me.

I don't quite understand how this isn't consensus here.
It is a consequence of one of the big and enduring memes of this forum - "Truthers are always wrong" - the rest of the details flow from gymnastic efforts to avoid admitting he got a few things right.
 
Open office space is a realtor or interior design term.
It’s neither defined nor quantified by the author or the others that embrace that term.
Useless to engineers.
All floor space nor occupied by a column or bearing wall is all open space.
Therefore all buildings including WTC7 are open space.
Anyone that uses roosd to attempt to convey information about the collapses of the towers is a clueless poopiehead.
 
I too moved away from 'pancake' for the same reason. Using it always required including a caveat that the collapses were not full single level horizontal release.

As far as M_T goes, he is a maddingly ego driven sob. That said, I find no reason to cut out references that emanate from him just because of his personality. I mean Newton was reportably quite an sob himself( not that I equate MT in intellect, to Newton). If ROOSD is better than 'pancake' because it eliminated the required caveat then I use it. It does not mean I am feeding MT's ego. In fact almost anytime anyone uses it here his name isnt mentioned. If he posts harfd copies of posts contsining ROOSD on his bedroom walls in order accomplish a self stroking, that doesnt reflect on me afaiac.
:thumbsup:

clap.gif
 
Open office space is a realtor or interior design term.
It’s neither defined nor quantified by the author or the others that embrace that term.
Useless to engineers.
All floor space nor occupied by a column or bearing wall is all open space.
Therefore all buildings including WTC7 are open space.
Anyone that uses roosd to attempt to convey information about the collapses of the towers is a clueless poopiehead.

That's playing with words... the twin towers had column free rental / tenant space outside the core... The idea at the time was do the interiors with "office landscape"... the birth of the cubicle!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This saved the developer money because they didn't have any build out allowances for the leaser.

+++

The acronym is short hand and ROOSD works... Who the eff cares who coined it...

how about:

RCFFD

runaway column free floor destruction

I don't have much interaction with Tom... but his web site is a wealth of information... Having read and looked at a lot of the material on his site... I don't see how someone would conclude he's a truth guy.
 
That's playing with words... the twin towers had column free rental / tenant space outside the core... The idea at the time was do the interiors with "office landscape"... the birth of the cubicle!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This saved the developer money because they didn't have any build out allowances for the leaser.

+++

The acronym is short hand and ROOSD works... Who the eff cares who coined it...

how about:

RCFFD

runaway column free floor destruction

I don't have much interaction with Tom... but his web site is a wealth of information... Having read and looked at a lot of the material on his site... I don't see how someone would conclude he's a truth guy.

1) Opinions of no import.
2) He's a stealth truth guy. It works on the suckers. You fell for it.
 
1) Opinions of no import.
2) He's a stealth truth guy. It works on the suckers. You fell for it.

This is way off topic... I have idea what he is... I don't care.... I didn't fall for anything... You comment was uncalled for and rude. As you say.... your opinion is of no import.
 
Last edited:
How about, ROBCAP.

Rapid Open Bay Collapse and Peel. For the ROOSD phase, that is more descriptive of what occured.

Then IFIROBCAP. For initiation to ROOSD.

Or ROBCAFWAP

Rapid Open Bay Connection Associated Failure With Associated Peel.

IFIROBCAFWAP

If I ROB CAF WAP.

I also Have no problem with those who use ROOSD, I do not use it I prefer, Gravity Driven Connection failures. Which is more descriptive of the whole events in all three buildings.

Oh and any building is subject to collapse, if initiation occurs because connections work independently to resist such massive dynamic loading, not collectively.
 
How about, ROBCAP.

Rapid Open Bay Collapse and Peel. For the ROOSD phase, that is more descriptive of what occured.

Then IFIROBCAP. For initiation to ROOSD.

Or ROBCAFWAP

Rapid Open Bay Connection Associated Failure With Associated Peel.

IFIROBCAFWAP

If I ROB CAF WAP.

I also Have no problem with those who use ROOSD, I do not use it I prefer, Gravity Driven Connection failures. Which is more descriptive of the whole events in all three buildings.

Oh and any building is subject to collapse, if initiation occurs because connections work independently to resist such massive dynamic loading, not collectively.

If you can get it to work, I'd go with ROBOCOP....
 
How about, ROBCAP.

Rapid Open Bay Collapse and Peel. For the ROOSD phase, that is more descriptive of what occured.

Then IFIROBCAP. For initiation to ROOSD.

Or ROBCAFWAP

Rapid Open Bay Connection Associated Failure With Associated Peel.

IFIROBCAFWAP

If I ROB CAF WAP.

I also Have no problem with those who use ROOSD, I do not use it I prefer, Gravity Driven Connection failures. Which is more descriptive of the whole events in all three buildings.

Oh and any building is subject to collapse, if initiation occurs because connections work independently to resist such massive dynamic loading, not collectively.

Sure any of those works, some better than others. GDC, sure!
However, if the only reason anyone is casting about for something other than ROOSD is that it originates from M_T, then I must ask myself how I managed to get back into middle school in my sixth decade of life.
 
Last edited:
So that's why I adopted the "fresh" label "ROOSD", but it has its problems too: The "OOS" part is questionable and potentially misleading, and too specific;
At first reading I disagree with all three. I am interested to see why you make them - here are my "takes" on the three:
(a) Why is OOS "questionable"? Do you disagree with mass falling down that area OR just the labelling of the area as OOS?
(b) I don't see how we can blame a specific and descriptive acronym when persons go outside it's scope to get them selves misled. Many of them following a known pre-set bias of their own belief system. A main reason for a catchy acronym is to save repetitious restatements of lengthy descriptive text. ROOSD puts it all in one package. And all proposals I have seen - including the recent ones - change the scope. So the person proposing a different acronym has already missed the point.
(c) If it is "too specific" are you sure that you want an acronym for just that sub-mechnaism? Aren't you flagging a wish to go broader in scope. Possibly similar to Crazy Chainsaw's suggestion?
a) "OOS" stands for the words "Open", "Office" and "Space". I agree with "mass falling down that area" I agree with labeling the area as OOS - but only if we were talking architecture and interior design, which we are not. The structural reality is "unusually long floor trusses spanning between core and perimeter". It is essentially irrelevant that this structural design creates "open spaces" well-suited for "office" in the opinion of 1960s designers.
b) It's misleading for reasons already stated, reasons that directly stem from the very words "Open", "Office" and "Space". An "open space" would be a room design that is void of fixed obstacles and partitions. Including the words "Open Space" clearly suggests that "ROOSD" is a mechanism that plays out in "open space" design only; but it would have happened without difference if the architects had build fixed, though non-structural partition walls to permanently obstruct the open spaces. Some here, including WS and tfk, say or suggest that the "ROOSD" mechanism can also function in structural designs without long-span trusses and more conventional column spacing. Lastly, it is obviously FALSE to insinuate that the usage of the open space / wide floor spans for "offices" is in any way shape or form relevant. There's be no difference if the open spaces were used for Apartments, Retail, Exhibitions or whatever. We don't want to introduce the new and additional labels ROASD, RORSD and ROESD the next time a building with different use collapses in the same way as the WTC, do we?
c) And that answers the "too specific" part - yes, I want to broaden the scope beyond the two buildings WTC1 and WTC2, to include the next building that experiences progressive collapse of pancaking floors. There is nothing we can possibly learn for the future if we artificially limit the scope to exactly two historical events.



Something is just now dawning on me...
Oz, what part of the collapse does the "ROOSD" label apply to? In my mind, that's the pancaking of the floors between core and perimeter - excluding the subsequent column failure modes. Hence only the first of your three collapse progression modes.
 
Sure any of those works, some better than others. GDC, sure!
However, if the only reason anyone is casting about for something other than ROOSD is that it originates from M_T, then I must ask myself how I managed to get back into middle school in my sixth decade of life.

I don't care where the name comes from, only that it is an inclusive accurate description of the responce of the structure to the energy applied to it.
 
There's be no difference if the open spaces were used for Apartments, Retail, Exhibitions or whatever. We don't want to introduce the new and additional labels ROASD, RORSD and ROESD the next time a building with different use collapses in the same way as the WTC, do we?
c) And that answers the "too specific" part - yes, I want to broaden the scope beyond the two buildings WTC1 and WTC2, to include the next building that experiences progressive collapse of pancaking floors. There is nothing we can possibly learn for the future if we artificially limit the scope to exactly two historical events.
If the floor plan was divided up into, for instance, Apartments, then the dividers would not be load bearing and only contributing to the static load on the floor. It would matter in the collapse as much as the furniture does.



Something is just now dawning on me...
Oz, what part of the collapse does the "ROOSD" label apply to? In my mind, that's the pancaking of the floors between core and perimeter - excluding the subsequent column failure modes. Hence only the first of your three collapse progression modes.
Yes. The perimeter and core failures came about as a result of the destruction of the floor spans. Truthers want to know how it came about that the entire building was destroyed. It came about due to a huge mass stripping the floors away from columns. No one in their right mind could expect the perimeter to remain intact after that, and its quite obvious that if a huge mass was buffeting and bashing the open office space, then a similar thing was occurring in the core.

One could shorten it to RD but that is even less descriptive and no more so than simply "PC" Progressive Collapse. Its only distinct from something like a tree being felled, "MBFC" Massive Base Failure Collapse.
 
I don't care where the name comes from, only that it is an inclusive accurate description of the responce of the structure to the energy applied to it.

yep.

ROOSD and several other descriptors do exactly that.
One could add detail as we said above with IFIROOSD, or remove detail, simply RD, or do away with a summarizing acronym and go with several paragraphs of summary.

In fact, do you think its possible for those of us who do believe that the tower's destruction was led by truss connection failure from massive overload, to produce a summary we can all use? anytime a CT comes on JAQing about the towers we just post a link to that summary.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom