If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
One could shorten it to RD but that is even less descriptive and no more so than simply "PC" Progressive Collapse. Its only distinct from something like a tree being felled, "MBFC" Massive Base Failure Collapse.

I would not object to calling it Runaway Floor Destruction. That would cover what happened to the WTC OOS -- including JSO's conception of slabs breaking up before connections failed -- and also what happened to the WTC cores, and also what happened at Ronan Point and Skyline Towers and several other examples. In each case, the details are specific to the design and construction, but it simply recognizes that in a progressive collapse, floors are much more vulnerable than columns or load-bearing walls, and that columns and walls typically depend on floors for lateral restraint.
 
yep.

ROOSD and several other descriptors do exactly that.
One could add detail as we said above with IFIROOSD, or remove detail, simply RD, or do away with a summarizing acronym and go with several paragraphs of summary.

In fact, do you think its possible for those of us who do believe that the tower's destruction was led by truss connection failure from massive overload, to produce a summary we can all use? anytime a CT comes on JAQing about the towers we just post a link to that summary.

As far as Roosed is concerned, Just drop one O, and nothing is lost in the description of Open Space Collapse.
 
I thought that stood for Oh My Gosh, Damn Cole!

I spent 28 years in the USAF on active duty...
SIOP, MAGIC, SAC, ARCP, ARIP, AFWAL, AWACS, PFM, PAX, CCIP, BUFF, PACAF, PMEL, ECM, FTS, the list goes on.

We don't need another ... acronym...
We? Me and the mouse in my pocket...

paloalto knew 9/11 was coming, he could have insisted a retrofit of the WTC with masonry fire proofing in the upper sections which can't stop an aircraft impact...
Shell section of the WTC which are 20mm or thicker, let alone; Shell sections less than 20mm in thickness add fire proofing which can't be dislodge by an aircraft impact.


but back to reality... ? Cole? lol
Oh My Gosh, Damn Cole!
or dumb, or delusional, ...
OMGDC
 
a) "OOS" stands for the words "Open", "Office" and "Space". I agree with "mass falling down that area" I agree with labeling the area as OOS - but only if we were talking architecture and interior design, which we are not. The structural reality is "unusually long floor trusses spanning between core and perimeter". It is essentially irrelevant that this structural design creates "open spaces" well-suited for "office" in the opinion of 1960s designers.
b) It's misleading for reasons already stated, reasons that directly stem from the very words "Open", "Office" and "Space". An "open space" would be a room design that is void of fixed obstacles and partitions. Including the words "Open Space" clearly suggests that "ROOSD" is a mechanism that plays out in "open space" design only; but it would have happened without difference if the architects had build fixed, though non-structural partition walls to permanently obstruct the open spaces. Some here, including WS and tfk, say or suggest that the "ROOSD" mechanism can also function in structural designs without long-span trusses and more conventional column spacing. Lastly, it is obviously FALSE to insinuate that the usage of the open space / wide floor spans for "offices" is in any way shape or form relevant. There's be no difference if the open spaces were used for Apartments, Retail, Exhibitions or whatever. We don't want to introduce the new and additional labels ROASD, RORSD and ROESD the next time a building with different use collapses in the same way as the WTC, do we?

c) And that answers the "too specific" part - yes, I want to broaden the scope beyond the two buildings WTC1 and WTC2, to include the next building that experiences progressive collapse of pancaking floors. There is nothing we can possibly learn for the future if we artificially limit the scope to exactly two historical events.



Something is just now dawning on me...
Oz, what part of the collapse does the "ROOSD" label apply to? In my mind, that's the pancaking of the floors between core and perimeter - excluding the subsequent column failure modes. Hence only the first of your three collapse progression modes.

Thanks for the response Oystein - it gives me a very clear understanding as to why you and I are somewhat at crossed purposes - plus some insight into the more extreme bits of what I see as nonsense being posted on the topic.

Let me address your points in reversed order and I will deal only with the fourth and third in this post..

So this one:
Something is just now dawning on me...
Oz, what part of the collapse does the "ROOSD" label apply to? In my mind, that's the pancaking of the floors between core and perimeter - excluding the subsequent column failure modes. Hence only the first of your three collapse progression modes.
I'm surprised by "just now dawning" when my perspective has been fixed in my mind for about five years. So an example of how two people as close in understanding as you and I can still have fundamental differences of foundation understanding - and neither realises it.

So my answer in two parts.

First the "technical scope" aspect. Yes as I use "ROOSD" I take care to rigorously apply it to only that one of the "Three Mechanisms". However in earlier times Major_Tom sometimes conflated "Perimeter Peel Off" into "ROOSD" and my posts from that era would not have rigorously distinguished the two. The reason in my case is one of historical development of explanations in the face of the ongoing opposition which we are still seeing. I will explain further in the next section. However I have been putting ROOSD into the context which I label "Three Mechanisms" for about 4 years. Certainly one of my extensive explanations framed as "Three Mechanisms" was posted on DebatePolitics modifying a post I made on this forum for benefit of Clayton Moore some months earlier. I would need to search for the JREF original post.

BUT all that is "recent history" in my frame of reference.

Second the historic setting for the introduction of ROOSD It is still relevant and details under the spoiler if you want them.
In the era when I first entered forum discussion - Nov 2007 - the hot issue was the need to understand the progression stage of twin towers collapses. And the factors I will describe have been vigorously denied by some of the more vehement opponents of Major_Tom and the term ROOSD. I've often caught the side flack of those essentially personality conflicts.

So understanding the progression was the hot issue. It pre-dates the current two way polarisation into "truthers" and "debunkers" - neither term in common use and the demography was 4 ways and included a lot of what I now call "genuine truthers".

There were a couple of misleading "big issues":
Big Issue #1 The truther arguments were focussed on "squibs" - alleged use of explosives to facilitate progression by explosive cutting of floor joists;
Big Issue #2 The "official version" supporting explanations had a lot of confusion between the fairly obvious internal cascading of mass down that tube space AND the application of column crushing mechanisms (wrongly) derived from Bazant's work.

(And the ongoing arguments over recent years have almost always denied that there was confusion. I wont even attempt to prove that assertion once again at this stage. Ask yourself - why would ozeco41/econ41 spend a lot of effort explaining away confusion if there was no such confusion to explain away?)

So I needed to explain "progression" and did so in 2007 using that infamous crude graphic. At that stage unaware of the Bazant related confusions - I simply explained what to me was obvious. Meanwhile - totally unknown to me - Major_Tom and his colleagues were facing the same challenge. I think he first published ROOSD in 2009 and I became aware of JREF, The911Forum etc in about the same time frame.

Neither of us gave much attention to core collapse. It was not the focus of attention. I certainly saw it as "too complicated" in those days. Ity was some years later before the essential simplicity became clear to me.

So M_T introduced the acronym - It was a descriptive acronym and easy to use so I chose to use it.

The key points include:
1`) It was a label for the specific aspect which defined the progression collapse mechanism of the WTC Twin Towers collapses;
2) It was introduced by M_T and used by me to clearly distinguish the "abstract limit case model of column crushing" which never happened from the "columns bypassed model" which did happen.

Which leads me to your third point
:
c) And that answers the "too specific" part - yes, I want to broaden the scope beyond the two buildings WTC1 and WTC2, to include the next building that experiences progressive collapse of pancaking floors. There is nothing we can possibly learn for the future if we artificially limit the scope to exactly two historical events.
My comment should be obvious.

ROOSD is WTC Twin Towers specific and that is how I use it. If you want an acronym or other label for future generic uses then develop one. Why argue that the specific explanation is wrong because it is not generic? We are drifting back to the (two unnamed engineers) false assertions that "apple" is not broad enough to generically describe "fruit". (Anyone who cannot decode the analogy - just ask.)

IF you are developing generic models that need to address any number of "exact events" - you need to develop generic principles which encompass the specific events NOT by denying the specific events.
 
I would not object to calling it Runaway Floor Destruction. That would cover what happened to the WTC OOS -- including JSO's conception of slabs breaking up before connections failed -- and also what happened to the WTC cores, and also what happened at Ronan Point and Skyline Towers and several other examples. In each case, the details are specific to the design and construction, but it simply recognizes that in a progressive collapse, floors are much more vulnerable than columns or load-bearing walls, and that columns and walls typically depend on floors for lateral restraint.
:thumbsup: :thumbsup:

Well said sir. That would be a better way to go if we could restart from zero base.

Isn't hindsight wonderful? ;)

HOWEVER

The barrier is essentially an issue of marketing. How do you supplant an established "brand" in the marketplace.

I dunno about US - or any other than AU usage - BUT "ball point pens" are still commonly called "Biros" in AU

... and I think use of vacuum cleaners is still called "Hoovering" in UK
 
Last edited:
...Why argue that the specific explanation is wrong because it is not generic?...
Strawman.
I didn't say the acronym is wrong to describe these specific two collapses.
I said it is misleading, as the O, the other O and the S make it appear as if the usage "Office", the interior design choice "Open" and the rough span category "Space" were relevant to the mechanics.
I also said it is too specific - by artificially and consciously limiting the scope, learning to improve the world is unnecessarily contrained.

I accept that there is a history of misunderstandings, false pretenses and hot bitching and see that at one time, the label historically helped you and M_T to keep things separated in your heads.

I also said that I have not a personal problem, and that I use the label quite similarly to the way you do - when talking with you, or M_T, or others who may be interested in M_T's work.

However, objections have been raised
- against the O
- against the other O
- and against the S
by people thinking one step ahead, and outside the box of ISF and the very few forums that the tiny numbers of truthers vs debunkers frequent.
What if we wanted to "sell" the concepts, the best description of the real collapse mechanisms, to a larger audience of reality-minded engineers, and perhaps the occasional genuine newbee truther? Do we want/need to burden them with the history of your debates? Certainly not! We'd want to give them a description, and perhaps a label, that are not misleading, and have a useful scope.

After all, a science where every law, every theory, applies to only one incident, is a completely useless science.
 
This has to be a joke. It has to be, unless you're a CIA or MI6 asset. There is no way a licensed, practicing structural engineer would compare Ronan Point to the WTC buildings. It just wouldn't happen. If you really are an engineer, you're paid to be here.

So, no politics inform your views of 9/11, eh? Just the Laws of Physics?

Right...
 
I spent 28 years in the USAF on active duty...
SIOP, MAGIC, SAC, ARCP, ARIP, AFWAL, AWACS, PFM, PAX, CCIP, BUFF, PACAF, PMEL, ECM, FTS, the list goes on.

We don't need another ... acronym...

In my years at Transport Canada the place was stinky with acronyms but it was easier to say VOR than Veryhighfrequency Omni-Range. :D

The corporate acronyms were worse, I could keep only keep a few straight such as CPAY (Central region Payroll). For some reason that one stuck with me. :D So did TAM (Transport Area Manager) although it got a bit confusing what with the existence of NOTAM, which is completely different.
 
In my years at Transport Canada the place was stinky with acronyms but it was easier to say VOR than Veryhighfrequency Omni-Range. :D

The corporate acronyms were worse, I could keep only keep a few straight such as CPAY (Central region Payroll). For some reason that one stuck with me. :D So did TAM (Transport Area Manager) although it got a bit confusing what with the existence of NOTAM, which is completely different.

When I was trying to give a talk to fellow officers in the USAF, I quickly learned my flying jargon related to my job (ARCP, RZ, ARIP) was not USAF universal, and if I said Air Refueling Control Point, or Air Refueling Initial Point, they meant BS to my non-pilot/aircrew audience.

Yes, if a pilot says VOR long form, I might wonder what he is talking about as I fly the VOR route... (what are you talking about... what high frequency... what he heck is an omni... )

Cole's experiments are best explained with an acronym, BS. It is amazing anyone defends Cole's claims.
 
When I was trying to give a talk to fellow officers in the USAF, I quickly learned my flying jargon related to my job (ARCP, RZ, ARIP) was not USAF universal, and if I said Air Refueling Control Point, or Air Refueling Initial Point, they meant BS to my non-pilot/aircrew audience.

Yes, if a pilot says VOR long form, I might wonder what he is talking about as I fly the VOR route... (what are you talking about... what high frequency... what he heck is an omni... )

Cole's experiments are best explained with an acronym, BS. It is amazing anyone defends Cole's claims.

:D

Your AF buddies would probably give you a puzzled look if you referred to a TACtical Air Navigation system as well. Though they probably have used it a lot. "just give me the TACAN frequency!"

I also worked on RVR, RTTY, GMDS/ADRES, VHFDF ...... and of course rx and tx comm units.
 
I would not object to calling it Runaway Floor Destruction. That would cover what happened to the WTC OOS -- including JSO's conception of slabs breaking up before connections failed -- and also what happened to the WTC cores, and also what happened at Ronan Point and Skyline Towers and several other examples. In each case, the details are specific to the design and construction, but it simply recognizes that in a progressive collapse, floors are much more vulnerable than columns or load-bearing walls, and that columns and walls typically depend on floors for lateral restraint.

Here's the deal about "ROOSD" and the twin tower collapses.

Obviously for a building to collapse... the whole thing ends up on the ground... in pile. In the floor collapse model... the floors will ONLY collapse if they become over loaded... the beams which support them "collapse" or buckle severely or if the connections of the beams/girders fail. We are discussion stick built steel frames... not pour concrete.

Columns collapse when they see too much load and buckle... or lose their bracing and become to slender and unstable. Columns will self buckle... from their own weight when their slenderness ratio exceeds a limit for the material. Self buckling does not require any applied service loads...

Columns failures in the collapse phase were from being left without lateral bracing... and also without applied loads.

Most of the column failures (not the ones which buckled from taking on redistributed loads... came down from "instability"... self buckling or jostling, swaying in the wind and cracking the splice... or lateral forces from the bulging debris mass... perhaps nudged by wind pressure to topple... and so on. What held them up straight was the floor plates outside the core and in the core the beams and girders.

So one can make the claim that the peeling or collapse of the facade was a integral part... or direct result of the floor collapse... floor collapse means facade collapse...

Not that it matters.... but facade peel is a ROOSD component.

What would happen withing a bay if a AIA Abrams tank was dropped on it? I suspect it would smash through the top floor and take out everyone below WITHIN the 4 columns and griders of that one bay... It would leave a shaft running right to the ground. The load was pretty much spread throughout the one bay.... but the framing isolated it from adjacent floor sections.

The twin cores... that survived show some interesting bits. The bracing between rows 500 and 600 seems to be connected... not busted.. and that was likely because it was in shafts with no floor slabs to come crashing down on it. The parts of the core which didn't do too well included surrounded floor slabs.

My hunch is that the floor collapse of the OOS areas propagated to include the entire OOS floor... and there was little to confine it laterally as the mass grew with each section of collapse.
 
No. I will not waste any more time performing your pointless tasks.

But you'll go on wasting everyone's time, engaging in more posturing, when if you would simply honestly look into the challenges you are receiving here will help you better understand the laws of Physics you claim to be carrying water for, so that you can quickly stop embarrassing yourself.

They're not "pointless tasks". Well, not most of them, at any rate. :)
 
But you'll go on wasting everyone's time, engaging in more posturing, when if you would simply honestly look into the challenges you are receiving here will help you better understand the laws of Physics you claim to be carrying water for, so that you can quickly stop embarrassing yourself.

They're not "pointless tasks". Well, not most of them, at any rate. :)

Here is the first post in this thread, in case you missed it:
The thread title is part of a famous quote by Richard P. Feynman. The full quote is, "It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong."

Recently, two new videos were posted by Jonathan H. Cole, PE.

The first video is a response to the blacksmith video which recently went viral. The second video discusses the collapse of WTC1 and WTC2.

Everyone should watch them both.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WgCtvTmshZ8

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJNzaMRsN00

Instead of attacking me, or Mr. Cole, I challenge anyone in this forum to conduct an experiment proving just ONE of Mr. Cole's claims are wrong. You pick the claim, and you make your own video showing how he is wrong. Words and computer models don't count. Prove, by an experiment conducted by yourself and documented in your own video, just one of Mr. Cole's claims are wrong.

I know this challenge will go unanswered until the end of time, but good luck, anyway.

So many skeptics on this forum insist the truther movement is dead. I think it's alive and well, and continuing to gain momentum.

Let the personal attacks begin. I know that is what will happen, because that is all the skeptics have.

So far there have been 1975 posts in this thread, and not one person has, by experiment, proved that Mr. Cole is wrong.

What is everyone waiting for?
 
Here is the first post in this thread, in case you missed it:


So far there have been 1975 posts in this thread, and not one person has, by experiment, proved that Mr. Cole is wrong.

What is everyone waiting for?

For you to comprehend the utter irrelevancy of your demand.

For you to realize how utterly unnecessary it is to validate or invalidate an "experiment" so utterly wrong that even an overeducated carpenter like me can see how poorly his "experiment" replicated conditions of anything at all.
 
For you to comprehend the utter irrelevancy of your demand.

For you to realize how utterly unnecessary it is to validate or invalidate an "experiment" so utterly wrong that even an overeducated carpenter like me can see how poorly his "experiment" replicated conditions of anything at all.

Translation: Words, and only words, because it's not possible to do an experiment proving Cole is wrong.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom