False Flag
I see that you’re back, and still blathering nonsense.
You are a clueless amateur & you haven’t the slightest idea what you’re talking about.
I tried to help you.
You are clearly too ignorant &/or too lazy to be helped.
Prior to my first response to you, I spent the time to go get you a link to a textbook in EXACTLY the pertinent field: “constructing valid engineering models of structures":
Structural Modeling and Experimental Techniques
By Harry G. Harris
That link allows you to read the first couple of chapters for free.
IF you had bothered to make an effort to inform yourself, you would understand that you are spewing ignorant nonsense every time you attempt justify Cole’s incompetent “experiments” by invoking “Newton’s Laws”.
Newton’s laws are a cornerstone embedded in of all physics & engineering.
But they are NOT sufficient to obtain valid experiments.
If Newton’s laws were sufficient to produce accurate scaled models, then Harris' textbook would be one paragraph long, listing Newton’s Laws.
That textbook is NOT one paragraph long.
It is over 750 pages long, with hundreds of equations (other than Newton's) & dozens of examples of correct & incorrect models.
Tell me, FF, which of Newton’s Laws tells you the ultimate strength of steel or aluminum?
Which of Newton’s Laws tells you the toughness of a material or a structure?
Which of Newton’s Laws tells you the deformation of a structure as it is loaded?
The correct answer is: Newton’s laws tell you NONE of that.
And yet, ultimate strength, toughness & deformation are all absolutely CRITICAL to the construction of a valid model.
Mechanical engineering tells you those things.
__
In my second post to you,
I gave you a link to one of the most famous (& loved) professors of physics in the world (Prof. Walter Lewin at MIT) explaining (at 11 minutes into the video) the crucial concepts behind scaling, and why ignorance of scaling produces garbage analyses.
Did you watch that video?
My bet, from your continuing posted nonsense, is “no”.
__
In my 3rd post to you, I provided you with some Lecture Notes from a Laboratory Class in “Modeling in Structures” class
Did you read any of that?
I seriously doubt it.
But, in the slim chance that you did, you understood none of it.
__
Absolute nonsense.
Your “educational background” seems to have informed you that you should ignore the knowledge of those who are experts in their various fields, and instead depend on your own ignorance for your answers.
Your “educational background” is not sufficient for you to figure out the proper field of study.
It AIN’T “physics”, FF.
It’s “mechanical & structural engineering”.
They are NOT the same.
You’re so clueless that you can’t even get that trivial fact thru your head.
Stop deluding yourself.
Your "educational background" has failed you completely.
You should give back any diploma that they gave you.
I put in about 2 - 3 hours chasing down information & writing those posts, in order to try to help you understand what you need to know, & how ludicrously you’re screwing up in this topic.
Clearly that was a complete waste of my time.
I'll not waste any more of my time.
I’ll stop trying to inform you.
From now on, I’ll be the one just pointing fingers & laughing at your resolute, determined ignorance.
I see that you’re back, and still blathering nonsense.
You are a clueless amateur & you haven’t the slightest idea what you’re talking about.
I tried to help you.
You are clearly too ignorant &/or too lazy to be helped.
Prior to my first response to you, I spent the time to go get you a link to a textbook in EXACTLY the pertinent field: “constructing valid engineering models of structures":
Structural Modeling and Experimental Techniques
By Harry G. Harris
That link allows you to read the first couple of chapters for free.
IF you had bothered to make an effort to inform yourself, you would understand that you are spewing ignorant nonsense every time you attempt justify Cole’s incompetent “experiments” by invoking “Newton’s Laws”.
Newton’s laws are a cornerstone embedded in of all physics & engineering.
But they are NOT sufficient to obtain valid experiments.
If Newton’s laws were sufficient to produce accurate scaled models, then Harris' textbook would be one paragraph long, listing Newton’s Laws.
That textbook is NOT one paragraph long.
It is over 750 pages long, with hundreds of equations (other than Newton's) & dozens of examples of correct & incorrect models.
Tell me, FF, which of Newton’s Laws tells you the ultimate strength of steel or aluminum?
Which of Newton’s Laws tells you the toughness of a material or a structure?
Which of Newton’s Laws tells you the deformation of a structure as it is loaded?
The correct answer is: Newton’s laws tell you NONE of that.
And yet, ultimate strength, toughness & deformation are all absolutely CRITICAL to the construction of a valid model.
Mechanical engineering tells you those things.
__
In my second post to you,
I gave you a link to one of the most famous (& loved) professors of physics in the world (Prof. Walter Lewin at MIT) explaining (at 11 minutes into the video) the crucial concepts behind scaling, and why ignorance of scaling produces garbage analyses.
Did you watch that video?
My bet, from your continuing posted nonsense, is “no”.
__
In my 3rd post to you, I provided you with some Lecture Notes from a Laboratory Class in “Modeling in Structures” class
Did you read any of that?
I seriously doubt it.
But, in the slim chance that you did, you understood none of it.
__
Although I am not an expert, my educational background supports my claim that I understand basic physics. My understanding of basic physics is enough to draw accurate conclusions based on what I can see during the collapses of WTC1, 2 and 7.
Absolute nonsense.
Your “educational background” seems to have informed you that you should ignore the knowledge of those who are experts in their various fields, and instead depend on your own ignorance for your answers.
Your “educational background” is not sufficient for you to figure out the proper field of study.
It AIN’T “physics”, FF.
It’s “mechanical & structural engineering”.
They are NOT the same.
You’re so clueless that you can’t even get that trivial fact thru your head.
Stop deluding yourself.
Your "educational background" has failed you completely.
You should give back any diploma that they gave you.
I put in about 2 - 3 hours chasing down information & writing those posts, in order to try to help you understand what you need to know, & how ludicrously you’re screwing up in this topic.
Clearly that was a complete waste of my time.
I'll not waste any more of my time.
I’ll stop trying to inform you.
From now on, I’ll be the one just pointing fingers & laughing at your resolute, determined ignorance.
Last edited: