If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
It should come as no particular revalation that vibration affected connections. The seismic record indicates very heavy shaking. The energy that seismic record represents had to pass through the entire building from connected component to connected component.
 
Well, I'll make one more (but probably my last) attempt to get at my point: What does "open office space" have to do with anything being said, other than the circumstantial details? I'm quite willing to be proven wrong, but my contention is that if the entire top 12 stories of WTC1 began falling, then the entire building was doomed, regardless of design details. If that's a conceded point, then excuse me for wasting time, but if it's a disproved point, I must have missed it.

The entire 12 stories began falling?

That's not entirely correct and sounds like Gage and his blocks...

YES the entire top DID over time fall and it likely was not a block which fell but the interior collapse was gutting the top. It's just not possible to know what actually was still part of the top when it begins to move downward.

This may seem like much ado about nothing... But I think there was in the post strike thru release of the top a gradual "gutting" and collapse inside the tower which at 3.75 seconds AFTER top release was fulling floor collapse or ROOSD mode which was a 15 or so second collapse of the floors with the facade peeling off leaving the core columns which feel about 10 or so seconds after.
 
Well, I'll make one more (but probably my last) attempt to get at my point: What does "open office space" have to do with anything being said, other than the circumstantial details? I'm quite willing to be proven wrong, but my contention is that if the entire top 12 stories of WTC1 began falling, then the entire building was doomed, regardless of design details. If that's a conceded point, then excuse me for wasting time, but if it's a disproved point, I must have missed it.

William, ROOSD is more a way for lay people like JSO to understand the collapses, than an engineering idea, the thing is any building is an energy structure, it can be made rigid, to resistant to wind energy, or it can be made to dissipate wind energy as motion, as tall buildings must.
Global collapse is the simple price paid for being able to build tall, and any building that is built tall with connections designed to dissipate wind energy as motion must be guarded against fires or one type of global collapse or another will occur.

It really doesn't matter if we term it ROOSD, or WTGFJ, (Where the Gigantic Frog Jumped)
It will happen because of the natural realities of building tall on a planet with Gravity.
PS. Your not wrong, neither is Banzant, Ozzie, it is simply the type of structure and the way the collapses progressed though it, M.T.' failure the thing that keeps him from being published is he wants to debunk Banzant, and he can't do that because Banzant Identified the collapse mechanics before he did.
David Benson, Tried too explain all this to him but Benson is a little hard to translate sometimes, to normal lay people.
That's one of the problems between some early Truthers, and the Scientific community trying to explain the collapses.
No one able to translate in a way they could understand it.
 
The entire 12 stories began falling?

That's not entirely correct and sounds like Gage and his blocks...
You are no doubt misconstruing what WS said - you listen to a strawman in your head. No one said blocks, no one meant blocks.

YES the entire top DID over time fall and it likely was not a block which fell
Strawman.

but the interior collapse was gutting the top.
Which top? The top 12 floors which are already bodily falling? What's the sense in saying this?

It's just not possible to know what actually was still part of the top when it begins to move downward.
So what?

This may seem like much ado about nothing... But I think there was in the post strike thru release of the top a gradual "gutting" and collapse inside the tower which at 3.75 seconds AFTER top release was fulling floor collapse or ROOSD mode which was a 15 or so second collapse of the floors with the facade peeling off leaving the core columns which feel about 10 or so seconds after.

The point WS tries to make is dead simple:
The mechanism that M_T labels "ROOSD"- which is one of three mechanisms that ozeco holds as true - could be labeled "RD" without losing any information or descriptive tower, for that mechanism would have happened exactly like it did
  • if the floors had not been "Open" (e.g. if there had been fixed partition walls from floor to ceiling)
  • if the use of the floors had been something other than "Office" (e.g. residential or museum or...)
  • if there hadn't been as much "Space" between core and perimeter (e.g. more conventional structural floor spans)
Of the three, only the last is perhaps contentious, and I would be interested to hear if you, JSO, or oz or CC claim that short span floors would not have suffered Runaway Destruction if the weight of 12+ floors had fallen down on them.
 
William, ROOSD is more a way for lay people like JSO to understand the collapses, than an engineering idea, the thing is any building is an energy structure, it can be made rigid, to resistant to wind energy, or it can be made to dissipate wind energy as motion, as tall buildings must.
Global collapse is the simple price paid for being able to build tall, and any building that is built tall with connections designed to dissipate wind energy as motion must be guarded against fires or one type of global collapse or another will occur.

It really doesn't matter if we term it ROOSD, or WTGFJ, (Where the Gigantic Frog Jumped)
It will happen because of the natural realities of building tall on a planet with Gravity.
PS. Your not wrong, neither is Banzant, Ozzie, it is simply the type of structure and the way the collapses progressed though it, M.T.' failure the thing that keeps him from being published is he wants to debunk Banzant, and he can't do that because Banzant Identified the collapse mechanics before he did.
David Benson, Tried too explain all this to him but Benson is a little hard to translate sometimes, to normal lay people.
That's one of the problems between some early Truthers, and the Scientific community trying to explain the collapses.
No one able to translate in a way they could understand it.

With all due respect this is prattling about nothing.

I am not an expert in anything... but neither am I a "lay person" with respect to buildings. I graduated in 1970 and have worked as an architect since that time including for Emery Roth & Sons at the time the WTC was going up.

NIST had a mandate which was not aimed at engineering journals but for congress, the public and perhaps recommendations to improve life safety issues of high rises.

Greening has apparently gone whacky with his latest theories about fuel explosions and so forth.

Vibrations probably only account for a small percentage or the reasons the core columns collapsed at the end...
 
Well, I'll make one more (but probably my last) attempt to get at my point: What does "open office space" have to do with anything being said, other than the circumstantial details? I'm quite willing to be proven wrong, but my contention is that if the entire top 12 stories of WTC1 began falling, then the entire building was doomed, regardless of design details. If that's a conceded point, then excuse me for wasting time, but if it's a disproved point, I must have missed it.

Open Office Space means fewer, more widely spaced columns, bigger floor bays. It is important in that the lattice is more open.
It would seem that the required scaling up of columns to accomplish this, is not the same scaling required to resist progression of collapse. Something akin to , (but not the exact same thing) as the square-cube law.

In a closer spaced lattice the initial collapse would likely not have involved as large an initial falling mass. We saw all of the structure above initial collapse on the move. There is a greater likelihood of arrest if only a small area fails first.

This type of thing has a related analogue in electrical power systems and forest fire protection.
 
Last edited:
Of the three, only the last is perhaps contentious, and I would be interested to hear if you, JSO, or oz or CC claim that short span floors would not have suffered Runaway Destruction if the weight of 12+ floors had fallen down on them.

It depends ;-)

If the collapse was within a bay of a grid/lattice design... the collapse like Ronan Point would not necessarily spread laterally to other bays...

So...

The real issue is how did the first 3.75 seconds of the event evolve to include the collapse of the entire foot print?

If it collapsed POOF as a "block" of 12 stories it likely would have not arrested regardless of what the structural scheme was below that.

And one might argue... that the OOS design facilitated the entire top to collapse all together over the entire foot print.
 
Last edited:
Of the three, only the last is perhaps contentious, and I would be interested to hear if you, JSO, or oz or CC claim that short span floors would not have suffered Runaway Destruction if the weight of 12+ floors had fallen down on them.
There's the rub. In a short span structure how likely is it that such a large section of the upper structure would be moving at the same time? If not then progression through the entire structure is also less likely.
(Please note the qualifiers "likely")
 
In electrical grids the move has been to increase capacity of all sectors. However a curious thing has resulted; while the incidence of small local blackouts has gone down, large scal blackouts are much more common than the models predicted. Very heavy transmission lines can go offline due to cascade of the now much larger subsystems going down.

See the similarity?
 
With all due respect this is prattling about nothing.

I am not an expert in anything... but neither am I a "lay person" with respect to buildings. I graduated in 1970 and have worked as an architect since that time including for Emery Roth & Sons at the time the WTC was going up.

NIST had a mandate which was not aimed at engineering journals but for congress, the public and perhaps recommendations to improve life safety issues of high rises.

With the detailed understanding of the collapse progression that ROOSD gives you, then, would your recommendations include making floor connections stronger and avoiding the OOS design?
 
Open Office Space means fewer, more widely spaced columns, bigger floor bays. It is important in that the lattice is more open.
It would seem that the required scaling up of columns to accomplish this, is not the same scaling required to resist progression of collapse. Something akin to , (but not the exact same thing) as the square-cube law.

In a closer spaced lattice the initial collapse would likely not have involved as large an initial falling mass. We saw all of the structure above initial collapse on the move. There is a greater likelihood of arrest if only a small area fails first.

This type of thing has a related analogue in electrical power systems and forest fire protection.

It depends ;-)

If the collapse was within a bay of a grid/lattice design... the collapse like Ronan Point would not necessarily spread laterally to other bays...

So...

The real issue is how did the first 3.75 seconds of the event evolve to include the collapse of the entire foot print?

If it collapsed POOF as a "block" of 12 stories it likely would have not arrested regardless of what the structural scheme was below that.

And one might argue... that the OOS design facilitated the entire top to collapse all together over the entire foot print.
.
Ignoring the goalpost shift to initiation instead of ROOSD progression, one might also argue (as I did but you didn't respond) that the top acted as a block during initiation because of its rigidity rather than the OOS design.
 
It depends ;-)

If the collapse was within a bay of a grid/lattice design... the collapse like Ronan Point would not necessarily spread laterally to other bays...
Irrelevant to the mechanism.
There wasn't a spread to oher bays at the WTC

So...

The real issue is how did the first 3.75 seconds of the event evolve to include the collapse of the entire foot print?
By the time the top had tilted and was moving down bodily, every column had failed already. This was before RD became the dominant progression mode.

If it collapsed POOF as a "block" of 12 stories it likely would have not arrested regardless of what the structural scheme was below that.
The 12 stories didn't collapse "POOF" - there was a cascading failure leading to the bodily fall of the 12 stories. But that's not ROOSD, nor RD, it's the collapse initiation sequence.
ROOSD / RD doesn't apply to collapse initiation (horizontal spread, if you will), it merely labels/describes a mechanism of collapse progression (vertical).

If And one might argue... that the OOS design facilitated the entire top to collapse all together over the entire foot print.
And this may well be where he "ROOSD" label may have confused instead of helped your understanding.
 
There's the rub. In a short span structure how likely is it that such a large section of the upper structure would be moving at the same time? If not then progression through the entire structure is also less likely.
(Please note the qualifiers "likely")

As WS spotted: You moved the goal post to discuss collapse initiation instead of the later progression stage that R(OOS)D is about.
 
As WS spotted: You moved the goal post to discuss collapse initiation instead of the later progression stage that R(OOS)D is about.
As I read it he meant to deliberately identify the similar issue as it applies in "initiation"

My version - which as stated quite a few posts back - is that I and several other members identify that fewer columns more open floor plans are inherently more vulnerable to progression - less able to arrest. I've always taken that aspect as an obvious given - until I met WilliamSeger's objection in previous discussions.

WilliamSweger holds the opposite view. He and I discussed it at length some months (??) back without resolving our differences.

I am confident "we" are correct for "progression" and I think JDH makes a valid point worthy of consideration that the same could apply to initiation.

THEREFORE:
Open Office Space means fewer, more widely spaced columns, bigger floor bays. It is important in that the lattice is more open. << Yes
It would seem that the required scaling up of columns to accomplish this, is not the same scaling required to resist progression of collapse. Something akin to , (but not the exact same thing) as the square-cube law. << Yes

In a closer spaced lattice the initial collapse would likely not have involved as large an initial falling mass. We saw all of the structure above initial collapse on the move. There is a greater likelihood of arrest if only a small area fails first. << Yes - and your assessment is IMO correct despite the problem that several missed the point that you were deliberately discussing the initiation stage similarity to progression on that same vulnerability.

This type of thing has a related analogue in electrical power systems and forest fire protection. << Yes

Notice that several members keep trying to address their own perspective on individual points.

None explicitly agreeing or disagreeing with the key facts as I state them although Oystein went close and Crazy Chainsaw put the lot in one excellent summary.

And AFAICS no one other than me trying to state what should be the agreed facts:

1) The technical description of the progression mechanism - The progression mechanism for WTC1 and WTC2 involved three sub-mechanisms:
(a) Material falling in the outer tube of the office space as it was for both twins - sheared off the floors;
(b) The perimeter columns simply fell away - they were not buckled - not significantly involved in resisting collapse - AKA they were bypassed;
(c) The core failed - probably by an analogous action of stripping horizontal beams off the columns

Who agrees with that explanation? Who disagrees? If disagree why and what alternate?

2) I'll set aside the discussion of matters of terminology until we see who agrees on WTF we are talking about rather than what we call it.
 
With the detailed understanding of the collapse progression that ROOSD gives you, then, would your recommendations include making floor connections stronger and avoiding the OOS design?

I am not sure what you are asking here... I think the OOS system which moved the axial capacity to the perimeter AND was use as a wind shear strategy created... an effective tube which funneled the falling debris and caused the peel sending material as far away as 400+ feet. Having the wind shear strategy as a 4 large membranes with only really weak ties to the core in compression saw no diagonals which would have also made the core stronger.

As for why those buildings when ROOSD as they did it was not ONLY truss to floor seat failures..

NB that the floor trusses were at 80" OC and to connect them to the core's 24 perimeter columns a cantilever belt truss... a transfer was used... This moved all the point loads of the truss to the girder and then to 28 short beam stubs connected to the 24 columns. There were multiple places the inboard side of the floor system could and DID fail... not ONLY the truss to see connections.

However... MOST the the floor destruction in my opinion... which doesn't matter much.... was destruction of the slabs themselves from huge dynamic loads busting through and ripping the slabs apart. The connections 20 times stronger would not have stopped the crushing and shattering or the floor plates from the material smashing down on to them. But of course the materials falling close to/adjacent to the truss connections would destroy them...

I suspect a system of beams and girder would fair better but it require larger columns at the facade where the concentrated girder loads would be carried. For a 110 story building this would mean much larger facade columns and loss of the membrane wind shear strategy... so the engineer made the facade of multiple smaller columns, made them vierendeel truss like a membrane would could move the forces effectively.. Clever but not for resisting an OOS runaway collapse.

OOS is only use to make the building light and cheap and promote office landscape and fewer stud walls... and supposedly offer more tenant flexibility. Super high rise buildings do not make sense in the first place.
 
1) The technical description of the progression mechanism - The progression mechanism for WTC1 and WTC2 involved three sub-mechanisms:

(a) Material falling in the outer tube of the office space as it was for both twins - sheared off the floors;
.....
Who agrees with that explanation? .

This is not actually correct or only partially correct. It sounds more like a pancake collapse... floors are loaded.. plates hold... but the connections to the columns shear...

I've written scores of time that the MAIN failure mechanism which destroyed the floors IMO was fracturing and crushing and shattering of the floor plates from dynamic loads... the CONCRETE itself failed "in shear" and in some cases the connected failed in shear or bolt tear out.
 
Irrelevant to the mechanism.
There wasn't a spread to oher bays at the WTC


By the time the top had tilted and was moving down bodily, every column had failed already. This was before RD became the dominant progression mode.

What do you mean by failed already? Are you asserting that ever core column experience buckling and the column above simply moved over and had nothing beneath it to bear on


The 12 stories didn't collapse "POOF" - there was a cascading failure leading to the bodily fall of the 12 stories. But that's not ROOSD, nor RD, it's the collapse initiation sequence.
ROOSD / RD doesn't apply to collapse initiation (horizontal spread, if you will), it merely labels/describes a mechanism of collapse progression (vertical).

Yes and no... None of the columns can survive a ROOSD and so it destructive effect DOES move laterally if you will... ROOSD pushes the facade columns in the twin towers nudging them outward.. and it jostles the core columns a similar process went on inside the core... but the ROOSD DID impact some of the perimeter core columns...


And this may well be where he "ROOSD" label may have confused instead of helped your understanding.

I am perfectly clear of what ROOSD is and isn't. Thank you for your concern.
 
By the way... ROOSD cannot start in its full blown manifestation... there is a "ramp" up in the first 4 seconds or so in 1WTC collapse when the material inside.. INCLUDING the OOS floors were beginning to rain down separating from the core. The hat truss and the antenna along with some collapsing inside the core floor slabs, machinery and so on destroyed the integrity of the upper 12 floors such that it was already RUNAWAY as it got going. No peel however.... probably because peel required a mass to bulge the facade an break the panel to panel connection. The top sections facade either slipped inside or outside and mostly came straight down with no peel.
 
This is not actually correct or only partially correct. It sounds more like a pancake collapse... floors are loaded.. plates hold... but the connections to the columns shear...

I've written scores of time that the MAIN failure mechanism which destroyed the floors IMO was fracturing and crushing and shattering of the floor plates from dynamic loads... the CONCRETE itself failed "in shear" and in some cases the connected failed in shear or bolt tear out.
Sander PLEASE focus and stop drifting. I cannot help clarify for other members if you keep disagreeing the point I make because you micro focus a detail.

1) Did the OOS floors become disconnected - leaving the outer perimeter without cross bracing to the core?
2) Did the perimeter columns - having lost the bracing - peel away and fall?
3) Did the core also disintegrate in the same time frame leaving the "spires" which then fell?

I am trying to build a consensus of understanding and it is like herding cats.

It is hard whilst most other members are looking for holes in other members arguments RATHER than looking for bits where they agree. And do not/will not say which bits they agree with - only where they disagree.

Consensus is built on what bits we agree - progressively removing/resolving the bits of disagreement.


And - YES - I know the process is not trusted on this and other forums - where people are nervous about "gotcha" games.

So - restating just the first point of those three I made - "Did the floors in the OOS become disconnected from the columns?

Whether in one part or seven hundred gazillion parts?"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom