If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
By the way... ROOSD cannot start in its full blown manifestation... there is a "ramp" up in the first 4 seconds or so in 1WTC collapse when the material inside.. INCLUDING the OOS floors were beginning to rain down separating from the core. The hat truss and the antenna along with some collapsing inside the core floor slabs, machinery and so on destroyed the integrity of the upper 12 floors such that it was already RUNAWAY as it got going. No peel however.... probably because peel required a mass to bulge the facade an break the panel to panel connection. The top sections facade either slipped inside or outside and mostly came straight down with no peel.

Sander as you and other members here are well aware I disagree with the various hypotheses which assert that "accumulation of debris" was the primary initiator of ROOSD.

It wasn't. It was concentrated impact force from the descending perimeter of the Top Block as shown by this graphic derived from Achimspok's work.
ArrowedROOSD.jpg


The left side yellow arrow of descending Top Block perimeter impacts OOS floors at the blue lines.

Same thing the other way up on the opposite - right - side. The examples is WTC2 BUT exactly the same principles apply to the other two sides of WTC2 and all four sides of WTC1.

AND debris accumulation was secondary.

And that same graphic shows that "crush up" did not follow "crush down" for the twins - the processes ran concurrently at the start of progression - crush up did NOT wait till the top parts hit ground level.
 
Last edited:
Ozzie.
I agree with your points and it is like herding cats...
:thumbsup: :thumbsup:

Thank you.
clap.gif


Now if we can get a few more members "on side" - - agree how the mechanism ran - we can address the other aspects like terminology and who was or was not right.


...IF anyone can still see any point of discussing those secondary matters. :boggled: :rolleyes:
 
Meanwhile back on the OP:
The thread title is part of a famous quote by Richard P. Feynman. The full quote is, "It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong."

That assertion is obviously FALSE.

The true position has two options viz:
" If it [your theory] doesn't agree with experiment, EITHER
..your theory is wrong; OR
..the experiment does not validly model the situation."

AND FF was following others quote mining Feynman's use of hyperbole out of the context in which he made the comment.

Recently, two new videos were posted by Jonathan H. Cole, PE.

The first video is a response to the blacksmith video which recently went viral. The second video discusses the collapse of WTC1 and WTC2.
...and both videos are garbage. The blacksmith correctly demonstrated ONE simple principle - heated steel loses strength.

And the model experiments Cole included in the second video are not valid representations of the WTC Twin Towers collapses.
 
Last edited:
Sander as you and other members here are well aware I disagree with the various hypotheses which assert that "accumulation of debris" was the primary initiator of ROOSD.

It wasn't. It was concentrated impact force from the descending perimeter of the Top Block as shown by this graphic derived from Achimspok's work.
[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/webpics/ArrowedROOSD.jpg[/qimg]

The left side yellow arrow of descending Top Block perimeter impacts OOS floors at the blue lines.

Same thing the other way up on the opposite - right - side. The examples is WTC2 BUT exactly the same principles apply to the other two sides of WTC2 and all four sides of WTC1.

AND debris accumulation was secondary.

And that same graphic shows that "crush up" did not follow "crush down" for the twins - the processes ran concurrently at the start of progression - crush up did NOT wait till the top parts hit ground level.


I agree with your Points Ozeco41, and with the initiation, also the top block idea is not well understood, by people here the top block is only a theoretical simplification, to save the computer from having to calculate separate bits falling though the lower structure.

Also the Vibrations I refered to, allow the formation of hinge joints, that lower the energy of induced sheer. That occurs on all connections, not just core Column welds.

If the energy to sheer a connection, is 1,000,000 fpi a one foot off center eccentric strike will lower that to 100,000 Fpi, vibration damage, and hinge formation will lower that By about one half to 1 fourth.

So if originally it took, per Benson's calculation of maxwells Equation, 2600 pounds dropped 12 feet, to break a connection, it would with vibration forming hinges take 1300 dropped 8 feet to break the same vibration damaged connection.

The colder the structure the faster it will fall, I have trouble understanding why the collapses
Were so slow, not why they were fast and energetic, which is what most truthers find so amazing.

The OOS design might have played a role more as a design that allowed for collapses to initiate do to concentration of Columns in the core where an intense chimney effect would have damaged critical bracing, leaving Columns more susceptible to Eular buckling.
 
I agree with your Points Ozeco41, and with the initiation,...
Thank you. I take it that you mean the initiation or starting of ROOSD progression. Best to be specific when using the words "initiation" or "progression" ;)

also the top block idea is not well understood, by people here the top block is only a theoretical simplification,
That must surely qualify for understatement of the week. :rolleyes:

AND most discussion falls into a false two way - maybe three way choice:
1) We would mostly agree that Heiwa's version - rigid inelastic Top Block - is wrong;
2) (The other extreme) It's too complicated to understand because it involved a lot of bits
OR
3) "even though you explain it I don't want to know because it is too complicated for me". Usually disguised as insults and PA and....other bits of evasion.
to save the computer from having to calculate separate bits falling though the lower structure.
Maybe. I suggest the real issue is even more basic - cannot visualise the mechanism even before we get to computers or calculators.
Also the Vibrations I referred to, allow the formation of hinge joints, that lower the energy of induced sheer. That occurs on all connections, not just core Column welds.

If the energy to sheer a connection, is 1,000,000 fpi a one foot off center eccentric strike will lower that to 100,000 Fpi, vibration damage, and hinge formation will lower that By about one half to 1 fourth.

So if originally it took, per Benson's calculation of maxwells Equation, 2600 pounds dropped 12 feet, to break a connection, it would with vibration forming hinges take 1300 dropped 8 feet to break the same vibration damaged connection.

The colder the structure the faster it will fall, I have trouble understanding why the collapses
I understand all the aspects you focus on. The point where we differ is that I see them as secondary to more significant issues. I wont take them point by point - it is a different "balance" of factors rather that outright disagreement.

Were so slow, not why they were fast and energetic, which is what most truthers find so amazing.
Yes - plus truthers mostly lack the reasoning skill needed to comprehend complex multi factor events. That is probably why they were predisposed to become truthers.

The OOS design might have played a role more as a design that allowed for collapses to initiate do to concentration of Columns in the core where an intense chimney effect would have damaged critical bracing, leaving Columns more susceptible to Eular buckling.
The macro effect IMO was simple shearing of the floor beams caused by impact of the falling core sections - at the start it was integral Top Block structure - later it became "weight of accumulated debris". Same effect. The horizontal beams in the core were stripped off the columns HENCE >>> spires.
 
Thank you. I take it that you mean the initiation or starting of ROOSD progression. Best to be specific when using the words "initiation" or "progression" ;)

That must surely qualify for understatement of the week. :rolleyes:

AND most discussion falls into a false two way - maybe three way choice:
1) We would mostly agree that Heiwa's version - rigid inelastic Top Block - is wrong;
2) (The other extreme) It's too complicated to understand because it involved a lot of bits
OR
3) "even though you explain it I don't want to know because it is too complicated for me". Usually disguised as insults and PA and....other bits of evasion.
Maybe. I suggest the real issue is even more basic - cannot visualise the mechanism even before we get to computers or calculators.
I understand all the aspects you focus on. The point where we differ is that I see them as secondary to more significant issues. I wont take them point by point - it is a different "balance" of factors rather that outright disagreement.

Yes - plus truthers mostly lack the reasoning skill needed to comprehend complex multi factor events. That is probably why they were predisposed to become truthers.

The macro effect IMO was simple shearing of the floor beams caused by impact of the falling core sections - at the start it was integral Top Block structure - later it became "weight of accumulated debris". Same effect. The horizontal beams in the core were stripped off the columns HENCE >>> spires.

I agree totally, it is not that people have been arguing apples and oranges, it is more like they are arguing yellow apples can't be apples, because they aren't red, and navel oranges can't be Oranges because they have no seeds, it is quite frustrating.
 
It's safe to say that people of all ilk can more easily conceptualize a "collapse" whatever it's called... than the complex process of the top section losing its integrity and "collapsing" as bits and partially integrated structure.

Idiots see it as a block coming down... and you get Heiwa and Gage's cartoon thinking... NIST punts and doesn't explain much...Perdue shows stuff dropping inside the core... Tony magically removes columns so the top is supposed to jolt when it drops...no jolt means some funny business was used... NIST ignores the goings on in the core... playing with sagging trusses...Bazant ignores the actual visuals and demonstrates some theoretical proof that the top can destroy the bottom...Cole thinks the floors should arrest a collapse...

Clearly it's hard to visualize 1 hr or things going from stable to all hell having broken loose... after the plane damage and uncontrolled fires. Many can't conceptualize what uncontrolled fires would do to the core framing... Many can't conceptualize load redistribution or runaway progress systems failures. Truthers hang on to the primitive notion that CD can and do cause buildings to fall straight down... so it looks like a duck ergo it is a duck.

No one can prove much of anything because the 4D data is non existent... any "theory" will be a limited series of assumptions... and be cartoon like as well. The initiation was much to complex in its details... much like the obsession on a single girder for 7wtc.

Lots of insults and too little critical thinking...
 
As WS spotted: You moved the goal post to discuss collapse initiation instead of the later progression stage that R(OOS)D is about.

I disagree. I could hardly be accused of moving the goalpost when it was you who asked if any construction style could be expected to withstand the entire upper mass coming down. I simply addressed the point you brought up.
I contend that that very initial condition (for the progression we refer to as ROOSD) would be much less likely in a closer spaced lattice.

However, we are discussing what really happened after the initial collapse occurred. That was a tearing away of the structural system of lateral support between perimeter frame columns and core columns by an internal avalanche of material from above.

I don't give a rats gluteus what any particular perspn wants to call that. To me "pancake collapse" doesn't say enough. While ROOSD also has issues, it says enough, as a short form descriptor, for me personally.
 
Last edited:
I disagree. I could hardly be accused of moving the goalpost when it was you who asked if any construction style could be expected to withstand the entire upper mass coming down. I simply addressed the point you brought up.
That is the way I read your post.
...I contend that that very initial condition (for the progression we refer to as ROOSD) would be much less likely in a closer spaced lattice.
My engineer's gut feeling says you are probably right. BUT dont ask me to prove it....


....YET. ;)

However, we are discussing what really happened after the initial collapse occurred. That was a tearing away of the structural system of lateral support between perimeter frame columns and core columns by an internal avalanche of material from above.
Agreed and TAOTSSOLSBPFCACCBAIVOMFA somehow doesnt strike me as likely to gain support.
I don't give a rats gluteus what any particular perspn wants to call that.
Me 2

... ROOSD also has issues, it says enough, as a short form descriptor, for me personally.
Which is the purpose despite all the garbage that has been heaped on it.
 
JSO, it looked a bit like a duck but didn't quack like one nor was it found to be capable of flight. Yet truthers call it a duck even though it was actually a platypus.
 
Last edited:
My engineer's gut feeling says you are probably right. BUT dont ask me to prove it....


....YET. ;)
ETA: oh yeah I was going to chime in on this aspect.
In a closer spaced lattice the columns and trusses would be individually less robust. They would be required to carry less load each. The columns will also be more proximate to the actual burning office contents. Therefore they heat faster. Collapses occur in local bays earlier. In the towers though, columns were not directly surrounded by burning office material, the core columns were quite heavy and perimeter columns have at least one side out in open air.
So with the concentration of core columns being heated each column creep transfer load to that concentration of support which is all heating up at pretty much the same time. Finally collapse involves a very large 'bay', essentially the entire floorspace of one level or combination on a few levels that involves the equivalent of the entire floor space.
Ah but the towers failed so quickly one might say! Yes, and the fires themselves began as very large and involved several vertically adjacent levels. That , and impact damage, is why it failed so quickly. ( hope that made sense. Good Scotch)
Agreed and TAOTSSOLSBPFCACCBAIVOMFA somehow doesnt strike me as likely to gain support.
The V should be an A. Yeah not catchy at all. Hell AIDS does not properly and fully explain the disease but viral hijacking of T-cells and subsequent loss of immune response to foriegn tissue , VHOTCASLOIRTFT, ,,,,, well its a good tune but you can't dance to it.

Which is the purpose despite all the garbage that has been heaped on it.
Much better on the dance tune mix tape.


Hmmm. Had a few Scotch at my parent's house for Easter dinner. Does it show? :)
 
Last edited:
It's safe to say that people of all ilk can more easily conceptualize a "collapse" whatever it's called... than the complex process of the top section losing its integrity and "collapsing" as bits and partially integrated structure.
True. All of us limited to our own ability to visualise complex 4D events. Most of us cannot do it. The problem comes when those who cannot visualise the real event deliberately choose to limit explanations to within their own limits of comprehension.

AND if it is a Grade 5 complexity problem it is near certain that limiting explanations to Grade 3 will cause problems.

No one can prove much of anything because the 4D data is non existent... any "theory" will be a limited series of assumptions... and be cartoon like as well.....
I disagree as you already know. There is more than enough generic material for the Twins to identify some actual and some probable sub-mechanisms. We will never know exactly which columns failed in specific sequence BUT we do know the consequences when a non specific column fails and its load redistributes to its non-specific but probably nearby neighbours.

The initiation was much to complex in its details... much like the obsession on a single girder for 7wtc.
Once again I disagree the analogy. The initiation of Twins collapses was compound rather than complex at the sub mechanism level. The complexity such as there was came in adding up the bits of mechanism - knowing that the bits existed somewhere but not knowing exactly where. And that is the precise reason why "left brain dominated" engineers cannot process the add up complexity. Those who understand what I just posted will understand -- and those who don't won't. And there is zero point in trying to explain more. WTC7 differs in that there is far less visual evidence. Reasoning for WTC1 & 2 can reach secure conclusions in the qualitative domain - i.e. without need to resort to maths. (The realities including energy levels are overwhelming so quantifying where it was 30.45 times overload OR 43.78 times is redundant. Especially when those doing the sums/FEA have the starting premises wrong.) For WTC7 we cannot be assured of enough because too much hidden.

Lots of insults and too little critical thinking...
Sure - persons pushed to their limit or out of their comfort zones. More comfortable playing "Whack-a-Mole" with truthers and their long dead canards.
 
The V should be an A. Yeah not catchy at all. Hell AIDS does not properly and fully explain the disease but viral hijacking of T-cells and subsequent loss of immune response to foriegn tissue , VHOTCASLOIRTFT, ,,,,, well its a good tune but you can't dance to it.
:o So much for my smartarse bad proof reading. ;)
Hmmm. Had a few Scotch at my parent's house for Easter dinner. Does it show? :)
I have no excuse - I'm jober as a sudge.


15:30 Monday here as I write - I just finished outlining a UNI assignment in philosophy for my son-in-law.

Strange territory for an engineer or half a lawyer. Probably should have tried the Scotch.
 
Last edited:
I disagree as you already know. There is more than enough generic material for the Twins to identify some actual and some probable sub-mechanisms. We will never know exactly which columns failed in specific sequence BUT we do know the consequences when a non specific column fails and its load redistributes to its non-specific but probably nearby neighbours.

For sure researchers can identify various mechanisms which would weaken the frame in assorted ways. Without more data they could not tell where and when it happened with any specificity at all. We do have the design... without actual construction details and shop drawings for the steel... but we can make a guesstimate of the plane damage and the quantity of fuel it delivered and how it might have spread and burned. And then it gets harder to know what sequence of failures was happening during the next 90 minutes. The pre release drop of the antenna and the IB at the SW and perhaps the location of smoke and flames seen from the outside is all we really have except maybe some views into the hole made by the plane.

And of course we know when something drops it has nothing to prevent it or what was holding it up is not doing that. So we have... various fails to consider... beam fails... connections falls, beam expansion, concrete spalding and fracture, column weakening, truss fails, column misalignments, dropping mass/dynamic impacts and perhaps more. It's obviously a fools errand to explain a sequence including all the fail mechanisms especially since one failure leads to other(s)... the matrix of failures get very complex and will have all sorts of alternate paths converging on loss of axial alignments and the dropping of what was still up there and connected "together".

I suppose some expert can assert X failure mechanism dominated leading to Y, Z etc... But truly getting an sequence to ultimate loss of axial support is probably not happening and no provable... at least to the standard for truthers... even if they acknowledge the assorted failure mechanisms exist.

Even the fuel load is a huge variable.
 
For sure researchers can identify various mechanisms which would weaken the frame in assorted ways. Without more data they could not tell where and when it happened with any specificity at all. We do have the design... without actual construction details and shop drawings for the steel... but we can make a guesstimate of the plane damage and the quantity of fuel it delivered and how it might have spread and burned. And then it gets harder to know what sequence of failures was happening during the next 90 minutes. The pre release drop of the antenna and the IB at the SW and perhaps the location of smoke and flames seen from the outside is all we really have except maybe some views into the hole made by the plane.

And of course we know when something drops it has nothing to prevent it or what was holding it up is not doing that. So we have... various fails to consider... beam fails... connections falls, beam expansion, concrete spalding and fracture, column weakening, truss fails, column misalignments, dropping mass/dynamic impacts and perhaps more. It's obviously a fools errand to explain a sequence including all the fail mechanisms especially since one failure leads to other(s)... the matrix of failures get very complex and will have all sorts of alternate paths converging on loss of axial alignments and the dropping of what was still up there and connected "together".

I suppose some expert can assert X failure mechanism dominated leading to Y, Z etc... But truly getting an sequence to ultimate loss of axial support is probably not happening and no provable... at least to the standard for truthers... even if they acknowledge the assorted failure mechanisms exist.

Even the fuel load is a huge variable.

You have more than that J.S.O, you have the Chemistry, as shown by the high number of micro spheres, that indicate massive chimney effects, and those effects will be dictated
By structure, and air flows.

It is highly likely that critical components of the inner core bracing failed first, do to the chimney effect fires, freeing up the columns to move.

Hydrogen, or carbon monoxide with soot would have played a key Role in that sinario,
Igniting soot in an air stream. Producing temperatures of above 1400C.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom