Whether you like or even given a rats left testicle about the ROOSD acronym, it is a detailed and pretty accurate description of the progression phase of WTC Twin Towers collapse based on observation. It has nothing to do with collapse initiation and therefore is agnostic to what caused the buildings to fall in the first place. So why is it wrong - because a person who is commonly identified as a Truther came up with it?
First, it would really help a lot if EUTPA*.
IHWYAS**, but IMRD***.
We've got a DOOOADF.****
I've analyzed this in some detail, and IFTMES.*****
I've put forth my MES (see IFTMES) in order to eliminate confusion & enhance clarity, so it'll really help if EUTPA*.
I'll be reminding you often to credit me with this important discovery. I'm thinking of writing my Big Book about it.
__
* Some people think that this is "Everyone Uses The Proper Acronyms".
. That's wrong. It's "Everyone Uses Tom's Proper Acronyms".
. Since we've not been formally introduced, "Hi, I'm 'Tom'."
** I hear what you are saying.
*** I must respectfully disagree.
**** Difference Of Opinion On A Debate Forum.
***** I've found the most elegant solution.
__
These guys, including Major Tom & femr, can create any nonsense they want. I don't care.
My consistent position is that the terminology ("terms of art") & opinions of the experts matter. Amateurs' writing on the collapse is irrelevant.
And, be utterly assured, these guys are 100% amateur. Last time I checked, there was not one single engineering class, much less a degree, amongst the lot of them.
Yet they've Rah-Rah'ed themselves into thinking that they've "corrected" and/or "proven wrong" Zdenek Bazant, Gene Corley, John Gross, Therese McAllister, et al. I've found their claims along these lines to be a continuing source of amusement.
And, as far as I can see, their only
imagined contribution has been the fabrication of a few acronyms ... that not one real structural engineering expert has ever heard of, much less used.
If Major Tom wants to step into the professional ring, by submitting something to JEM, Structures, or some engineering journal, let him introduce his term & see if it sets the SE world afire. I presume that he can figure out how to submit a paper.
If he does that, I'll give him a begrudging tip of my hat.
I am seriously curious if they are still trying to pull off the "stealth Truther" charade. If Oz (or you) could give me an answer on this, I'd be grateful.
I'd give them a
sincere hip of my hat if/when they come out and publicly admit, "We were wrong all those years. We were arrogant to think that we knew as much as, or more than, PhD & Pro Engineers. We see now that they were right, and we were wrong. And we were especially wrong to accuse those honest, dedicated NIST engineers of incompetence, fraud & cover-up."
I'm 63 years old. I do NOT expect to live to see THAT event seeing the light of day.
Until then, my GiveADamn about acronyms, including TPAs*, is just plain busted.
Until then, I kinda wish that they'd ST******U.
****** F
JMO, of course...