Hehe okay - thaaat ^^
Back then, I neglected to look at actual energy available from explosive charge and make sure energy is conserved. I started with an assumption of the velocity of the reaction products of the explosion, rather than computing it. I suppose I had an idea from unstated sources what those velocities really, empirically, are for common high explosives, so I wasn't making stuff up from whole cloth. It should then come as not big surprise that my recent calculations "from scratch" land in the same order of magnitude - these velocities are, after all, the result of chemical energy being transfered to kinetic energy (and some waste heat and shock waves), and must adhere to CoE.
(In 2011, I assumed 4000 m/s absolute going in all directions, with 2000 m/s effective velocity in the direction away from the "ejection". My new spreadsheet calculates the absolute velocity: It's in the vicinity of 3000 m/s for an explosive with a specific energy of 4.5 kJ/g, just under 2450 m/s at 3 kJ/g, 1725 m/s at 1.5 kJ/g). I think I should have divided that absolute velocity by SQRT(2) instead of by 2 to account for the +/90° omnidirectional trajectories - which lands me close to 2000 m/s for a 4.5 kJ/g explosive - just what my assumption was in 2011
I made a mistake in my assumption back then: I divided both velocity and mass of the explosive by 2 to account for omnidirection, where I should have left m unchanged. This overestimated the amount of explosives needed to attain those 20 m/s. But no biggie, it's the same order of magnitude.
Remember that Truthers, following Chandler's arguments, believe this:
- Wall panels were punched out of the wall and ejected by explosives at a height h (80 or 95 floors? 415 m? )
- They flew ballistically all the way to other buildings (a distance d of 450 feet? 600 feet?), which means they must have had a lateral velocity of at least v = ... 55, 60, 70 mph
I now have a spreadsheet where I enter as variables
- h (height from which panel was ejected horizontally
- d (lateral distance to landing spot on ground)
- energy density of hypothetical explosive
and it gives me
- v (horizontal velocity for ballistic curve to fly distance d from height h)
- minimum charge size to attain v per ton of steel
- resulting velocity of explosive gases
The absolute theoretical minimum charge size varies between 2.9 and 12.4 kg/ton for
- h in a range 180 to 360 m
- d in a range 80 m (Bankers Trust Building) to 183 m (600 ft - a common Truther claim)
- Energy density 1.5 to 6.0 kJ/g (experimental nanothermite to best HE)
Multiply by SQRT(2) to account for the +/- 90° spread of the explosion.
Multiply further by whatever to account for the fact that only a part of ChE is converted to KE of explosives products
Multiply further by whatever to account for any angular momentum caused by explosive not acting exactly on center of gravity
Multiply further by whatever to account for any deformation and fracture of steel due to static pressure / acceleration
I doubt
AClark will ever get to this point, if he or she is at all still in the debate