If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Hehe okay - thaaat ^^

Back then, I neglected to look at actual energy available from explosive charge and make sure energy is conserved. I started with an assumption of the velocity of the reaction products of the explosion, rather than computing it. I suppose I had an idea from unstated sources what those velocities really, empirically, are for common high explosives, so I wasn't making stuff up from whole cloth. It should then come as not big surprise that my recent calculations "from scratch" land in the same order of magnitude - these velocities are, after all, the result of chemical energy being transfered to kinetic energy (and some waste heat and shock waves), and must adhere to CoE.
(In 2011, I assumed 4000 m/s absolute going in all directions, with 2000 m/s effective velocity in the direction away from the "ejection". My new spreadsheet calculates the absolute velocity: It's in the vicinity of 3000 m/s for an explosive with a specific energy of 4.5 kJ/g, just under 2450 m/s at 3 kJ/g, 1725 m/s at 1.5 kJ/g). I think I should have divided that absolute velocity by SQRT(2) instead of by 2 to account for the +/90° omnidirectional trajectories - which lands me close to 2000 m/s for a 4.5 kJ/g explosive - just what my assumption was in 2011 :cool:

I made a mistake in my assumption back then: I divided both velocity and mass of the explosive by 2 to account for omnidirection, where I should have left m unchanged. This overestimated the amount of explosives needed to attain those 20 m/s. But no biggie, it's the same order of magnitude.


Remember that Truthers, following Chandler's arguments, believe this:
- Wall panels were punched out of the wall and ejected by explosives at a height h (80 or 95 floors? 415 m? )
- They flew ballistically all the way to other buildings (a distance d of 450 feet? 600 feet?), which means they must have had a lateral velocity of at least v = ... 55, 60, 70 mph

I now have a spreadsheet where I enter as variables
- h (height from which panel was ejected horizontally
- d (lateral distance to landing spot on ground)
- energy density of hypothetical explosive
and it gives me
- v (horizontal velocity for ballistic curve to fly distance d from height h)
- minimum charge size to attain v per ton of steel
- resulting velocity of explosive gases

The absolute theoretical minimum charge size varies between 2.9 and 12.4 kg/ton for
- h in a range 180 to 360 m
- d in a range 80 m (Bankers Trust Building) to 183 m (600 ft - a common Truther claim)
- Energy density 1.5 to 6.0 kJ/g (experimental nanothermite to best HE)

Multiply by SQRT(2) to account for the +/- 90° spread of the explosion.
Multiply further by whatever to account for the fact that only a part of ChE is converted to KE of explosives products
Multiply further by whatever to account for any angular momentum caused by explosive not acting exactly on center of gravity
Multiply further by whatever to account for any deformation and fracture of steel due to static pressure / acceleration


I doubt AClark will ever get to this point, if he or she is at all still in the debate :eek:
 
Hey, I just thought of something.
Don't make a habit of it. And don't do it around here - it could be contagious.
I still can't be bothered making a video, but at about 30 seconds (quite an impressive Time To First Lie), Cole claims that,

"Whenever there's a big structural failure, there's always a detailed study as to its cause, except on 9/11 [...]"
The whole lead in is multiple lies and lies by innuendo - propagandist style - setting the bias of tilted playing field for what is to come. In fact that would turn me off before he even gets to the deliberate use of false models - which are the first bits of hard defined false fact he wants to put across.

There is some irony which could disconcert Bazantophiles - he correctly identifies that crush-down crush-up does NOT apply to WTC. But you can bet he doesn't understand why.
 
Hehe okay - thaaat ^^

Back then, I neglected to look at actual energy available from explosive charge and make sure energy is conserved. I started with an assumption of the velocity of the reaction products of the explosion, rather than computing it. I suppose I had an idea from unstated sources what those velocities really, empirically, are for common high explosives, so I wasn't making stuff up from whole cloth. It should then come as not big surprise that my recent calculations "from scratch" land in the same order of magnitude - these velocities are, after all, the result of chemical energy being transfered to kinetic energy (and some waste heat and shock waves), and must adhere to CoE.
(In 2011, I assumed 4000 m/s absolute going in all directions, with 2000 m/s effective velocity in the direction away from the "ejection". My new spreadsheet calculates the absolute velocity: It's in the vicinity of 3000 m/s for an explosive with a specific energy of 4.5 kJ/g, just under 2450 m/s at 3 kJ/g, 1725 m/s at 1.5 kJ/g). I think I should have divided that absolute velocity by SQRT(2) instead of by 2 to account for the +/90° omnidirectional trajectories - which lands me close to 2000 m/s for a 4.5 kJ/g explosive - just what my assumption was in 2011 :cool:

I made a mistake in my assumption back then: I divided both velocity and mass of the explosive by 2 to account for omnidirection, where I should have left m unchanged. This overestimated the amount of explosives needed to attain those 20 m/s. But no biggie, it's the same order of magnitude.


Remember that Truthers, following Chandler's arguments, believe this:
- Wall panels were punched out of the wall and ejected by explosives at a height h (80 or 95 floors? 415 m? )
- They flew ballistically all the way to other buildings (a distance d of 450 feet? 600 feet?), which means they must have had a lateral velocity of at least v = ... 55, 60, 70 mph

I now have a spreadsheet where I enter as variables
- h (height from which panel was ejected horizontally
- d (lateral distance to landing spot on ground)
- energy density of hypothetical explosive
and it gives me
- v (horizontal velocity for ballistic curve to fly distance d from height h)
- minimum charge size to attain v per ton of steel
- resulting velocity of explosive gases

The absolute theoretical minimum charge size varies between 2.9 and 12.4 kg/ton for
- h in a range 180 to 360 m
- d in a range 80 m (Bankers Trust Building) to 183 m (600 ft - a common Truther claim)
- Energy density 1.5 to 6.0 kJ/g (experimental nanothermite to best HE)

Multiply by SQRT(2) to account for the +/- 90° spread of the explosion.
Multiply further by whatever to account for the fact that only a part of ChE is converted to KE of explosives products
Multiply further by whatever to account for any angular momentum caused by explosive not acting exactly on center of gravity
Multiply further by whatever to account for any deformation and fracture of steel due to static pressure / acceleration


I doubt AClark will ever get to this point, if he or she is at all still in the debate :eek:


This is all very interesting but terribly unnecessary. All one need do is look at an overhead shot of Ground Zero in the days after the attack to see these steel sections toppled to get where they are.

It truly is that simple.
 
Remember that Truthers, following Chandler's arguments, believe this:
- Wall panels were punched out of the wall and ejected by explosives at a height h (80 or 95 floors? 415 m? )

At The Toronto Hearings Richard Gage hypothesized that this may have been accomplished from explosives placed in the core columns alone! :jaw-dropp
 
Don't make a habit of it. And don't do it around here - it could be contagious.
The whole lead in is multiple lies and lies by innuendo - propagandist style - setting the bias of tilted playing field for what is to come. In fact that would turn me off before he even gets to the deliberate use of false models - which are the first bits of hard defined false fact he wants to put across.

There is some irony which could disconcert Bazantophiles - he correctly identifies that crush-down crush-up does NOT apply to WTC. But you can bet he doesn't understand why.

Does anyone know exactly what FF is trying to argue anyway? I've been following the thread and it seems he's saying Cole's video satisfies Newton's Law of Motion, which no one is denying. He then seems to be implying that this means the collapses should have arrested! :eye-poppi

Am I missing something?
 
This is all very interesting but terribly unnecessary. All one need do is look at an overhead shot of Ground Zero in the days after the attack to see these steel sections toppled to get where they are.

All true, but.....

It truly is that simple.


....you know this isn't the case with CTers involved. ;)
 
Does anyone know exactly what FF is trying to argue anyway? I've been following the thread and it seems he's saying Cole's video satisfies Newton's Law of Motion, which no one is denying. He then seems to be implying that this means the collapses should have arrested! :eye-poppi

Am I missing something?

Basicly a false premise, that 36% resistance can't drop though 36% resistance with out a noticeable deceleration.

He is using Chandler's physics, where he calculated in the gravitational energy of the upper block as the weight of the block on earth, not the mass of the block in zero G.

So Gave more energy to resist the collapses that is possible, an upward pull on the building below by the mass above.
 
Basicly a false premise, that 36% resistance can't drop though 36% resistance with out a noticeable deceleration.

He is using Chandler's physics, where he calculated in the gravitational energy of the upper block as the weight of the block on earth, not the mass of the block in zero G.

So Gave more energy to resist the collapses that is possible, an upward pull on the building below by the mass above.

Has he been able.....

I'm sorry. Never mind. It's not fair to discuss him while on suspension and not here to answer for himself. I'll leave it at that and thank you.
 
This is all very interesting but terribly unnecessary. All one need do is look at an overhead shot of Ground Zero in the days after the attack to see these steel sections toppled to get where they are.

It truly is that simple.
And Major_Tom did a lot of work identifying what bits fell were and how they toppled as they fell.

The published versions were hosted on imageshack and were lost a few years back:

The thread is here - minus a lot of the images:
http://the911forum.freeforums.org/wtc1-perimeter-behavior-finally-revealed-t141-75.html?hilit=htf

As often so femr2 coined an acronym HTFCPNST - tho' that may be M_T's original before femr cleaned it up. If that one had gone as viral as ROOSD the mental gymnastics of denial would have been......"interesting" ;)
 
Last edited:
Does anyone know exactly what FF is trying to argue anyway? I've been following the thread and it seems he's saying Cole's video satisfies Newton's Law of Motion, which no one is denying. He then seems to be implying that this means the collapses should have arrested! :eye-poppi

Am I missing something?

You're not missing a thing. FF falls into the trap of "action=reaction" and can't reason his way out. He can't understand that when a kid's errant throw hits a window, the window exerts as much force on the baseball as vice versa. But the baseball still breaks the window.

See the "horse pulls wagon" experiment I posted up thread. For a cool video illustrating Newton's Laws, I prefer a Newton's Cradle, or a slo-mo of a player running down the court dribbling a basketball.
 
Another illustration that high explosives make poor propellants. The 3 lb. explosive charge here didn't move the lawnmower much, but it blew a piece of shrapnel loose with grisly results. Spectators at real controlled demolitions have been accidentally injured or even killed by flying shrapnel, though the support columns weren't tossed for hundreds of yards.

OTOH, the 10-ton perimeter column panels from WTC 2 that were embedded in the Deutsche Bank Building traveled a fair distance but appear remarkably undamaged. So it's safe to assume that they weren't propelled by explosive charges.

WARNING! DISTURBING VIDEO.
 
As often so femr2 coined an acronym HTFCPNST - tho' that may be M_T's original before femr cleaned it up. If that one had gone as viral as ROOSD the mental gymnastics of denial would have been......"interesting" ;)

"as viral as ROOSD" is substantially equivalent to "as scholarly as Paris Hilton".

Have they figured out that the structural engineering world already has an acronym for this sort of progressive failure?
It's called "C.O.L.L.A.P.S.E."
It stands for "collapse".

Let me know if any real structural engineer ever uses "ROOSD", "HTFCPNST" or any of their acronyms in any published paper or in any engineering textbook.

Are those guys still trying to pull off "stealth Trutherism"?
Or have they finally figured out that they were wrong for 5 years?
 
"as viral as ROOSD" is substantially equivalent to "as scholarly as Paris Hilton".

Have they figured out that the structural engineering world already has an acronym for this sort of progressive failure?
It's called "C.O.L.L.A.P.S.E."
It stands for "collapse".

Let me know if any real structural engineer ever uses "ROOSD", "HTFCPNST" or any of their acronyms in any published paper or in any engineering textbook.

Are those guys still trying to pull off "stealth Trutherism"?
Or have they finally figured out that they were wrong for 5 years?

I call it connection failure do to dynamic loading, always have always will.
 
What does HTFCPNST stand for?

I don't consider femr2 nor Tom dyed in thew wool conspiracy theorist. It seems to me that they were trying to understand the event by analyzing visual data... and doing some calculations like Greening and several others.

NIST called the collapses "global" which is synonymous with total... and global and total are not engineering terms either. Whether anyone likes the acronym ROOSD or not... it does basically describe the process of the collapse and as a runaway floor destruction which bypassed the columns and left them with too high a slenderness ratio therefore too unstable to stand without the floors and beams that braced them and reduced the slenderness ratio to a stable one. Engineers know this mode of column failure as Euler buckling.

It seems that their "work" was a refinement in some cases of what NIST did.... not articulate the nature of the "global" collapse.

I don't subscribe to the sagging truss theory of initiation in the case of the twin towers... and I believe they failed to explain how a single column failure on one floor "morphed" into "global" collapse. It may well have... but they punted by just calling it "global collapse" Global collapse is not a mechanism... again... it simply means total... Well duh... everyone could see that.
 
Last edited:
What does HTFCPNST stand for?

I don't consider femr2 nor Tom dyed in thew wool conspiracy theorist. It seems to me that they were trying to understand the event by analyzing visual data... and doing some calculations like Greening and several others.

NIST called the collapses "global" which is synonymous with total... and global and total are not engineering terms either. Whether anyone likes the acronym ROOSD or not... it does basically describe the process of the collapse and as a runaway floor destruction which bypassed the columns and left them with too high a slenderness ratio therefore too unstable to stand without the floors and beams that braced them and reduced the slenderness ratio to a stable one. Engineers know this mode of column failure as Euler buckling.

It seems that their "work" was a refinement in some cases of what NIST did.... not articulate the nature of the "global" collapse.

I don't subscribe to the sagging truss theory of initiation in the case of the twin towers... and I believe they failed to explain how a single column failure on one floor "morphed" into "global" collapse. It may well have... but they punted by just calling it "global collapse" Global collapse is not a mechanism... again... it simply means total... Well duh... everyone could see that.

www.ing.unitn.it/~bigoni/flutter.html

ROOSD does not exactly describe what happened to this Columns, it was not just Slinderness,
But vibration and flutter that destroyed them and the connections.
 
"as viral as ROOSD" is substantially equivalent to "as scholarly as Paris Hilton".

Have they figured out that the structural engineering world already has an acronym for this sort of progressive failure?
It's called "C.O.L.L.A.P.S.E."
It stands for "collapse".

Let me know if any real structural engineer ever uses "ROOSD", "HTFCPNST" or any of their acronyms in any published paper or in any engineering textbook.

Are those guys still trying to pull off "stealth Trutherism"?
Or have they finally figured out that they were wrong for 5 years?

Whether you like or even given a rats left testicle about the ROOSD acronym, it is a detailed and pretty accurate description of the progression phase of WTC Twin Towers collapse based on observation. It has nothing to do with collapse initiation and therefore is agnostic to what caused the buildings to fall in the first place. So why is it wrong - because a person who is commonly identified as a Truther came up with it?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom