If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by Redwood
That's why I recommend that Truthers experiment with black powder. Black powder is actually a pretty good propellant and you can place a chunk of steel next to an unconfined charge without having it be damaged much. "Smokeless" powders, even those with nitroglycerin content comparing to gelignite, won't detonate, and won't give any push unless they are confined.

Wont give much push - but ignore the nit pick pedantry - I agree.

As a kid, me and my fellow nerd/budding mad scientists would make our own rockets. We started with black powder as a propellant. (One of us had an older brother who could buy powder.) We quickly found that even the "hottest" smokeless powders, although they have much more energy than black powder, wouldn't burn fast enough to provide much thrust, unless they were confined so pressure could build up. Which can get pretty dicey. It's the difference between power and energy.

The burning rate of black powder, OTOH, varies only with granule size and is otherwise constant. We found that small cannon granule size worked best.

Believe it or not, we used to launch them almost in the flight path of L.A. International Airport! The area used to have homes, but they were bought out long ago by LAX and demolished. Not from fear of terrorism, but because jet noise made them unlivable. :(
 
Originally Posted by Redwood
The really silly thing, of course, is that if in some alternate universe the Twin Towers had been brought down with demolition charges, there would have been no need to blow columns for hundreds of yards. This isn't done in actual controlled demolitions. It'd be a black mark on the operators. So I guess this is an example of how the conspiracy made their controlled demolition look like something other than a controlled demolition!

And that's not counting the vast quantities of magic silent explosives placed all over the concrete floors to (pointlessly) "dustify" them.

A key part of the ethos here at Vast Conspiracy HQ is that we must always tip our hand, whether before the fact (as in countless TV shows or movies, most notably the pilot episode of The Lone Gunman), or afterwards (as with Larry Silverstein's confession/boast about "pulling" WTC 7). Where's the fun of controlling the entire world if you can't rub it into the noses of the few people smart enough to figure it out, and then watch them flail about trying to persuade the "sheeple". You'd think a few of them would realize that it's futile, and join us! ;)
 
Except it never works that way.

The CT either never gets to that point of realizing the absurdity or if they start knocking on that door they quickly turn and run away when they do start to get an idea of what is ahead. Then you end up chasing endless derails, evasions and personal attacks.

So you've met Bman? ;)
 
How about this:

Truther makes a claim of fact based on implied premises, and insinuates some conclusion to be drawn from the claim via unstated reasoning.
Truther believes the argument is (at least tentatively) valid.

What's the problem here?
I say: The problem is not the false premise, nor the unclear objective, nor the vague reasoning nor the predetermined conclusion - the problem is that the Truther, being a Truther, cannot think, and has not thought, and is unaware of this.

I am trying to make AClark try to think within his own frame of assumptions - to make the unstated reasoning explicit - and discover in the process that there actually is no reasoning. I figure this would be easier than trying to convince him that his frame of assumptions is faulty.

Of course we all notice that AClark has chosen not to respond. Which confirms what Mark F wrote. AClark, being an intelligent fellow, has probably understood that his vacuous proto-argument cannot lead anywhere, and has run away.

I tried the same thing on FF, with the three balls bouncing thought experiment, but it was way over his head, it not only allows you to grasp the concept is scale, but it also gives you the real
reason the collapses were so rapid.
 
Bump for Oz...

I'm personally disappointed that the standard of discussion has fallen so dramatically in the last 2-3 years. Especially since there are still three big issues of technical explanation which are (mostly) being avoided...

What "3 big technical issues"?
 
Bump for Oz...



What "3 big technical issues"?

I would say that among them are:

How did the heat + mech damage lead to the columns of the top and bottom misaligning such that the top dropped?

How would the buckling of col. 79 lead to the global collapse? Obviously col 79 and 80 "failed" as indicated by the drop of the EPH... so what "failed" to produce the drop in the WPH and how did that/those columns fail?

Was the OB of the facade of the twin towers before "release"/collapse of the top.... caused by pulling of the sagging trusses or buckling from new / redistributed loads? If the later... why there?

Did the material which came off of the north side of 1wtc and slashed the SW corner of 7wtc cause the damage that Jennings and Hess encountered when they claimed they were on the 8th floor and it was below them in the stair well? Which stair well? How did the material cause that damage so far inside and so low down in the building?
 
Bump for Oz...



What "3 big technical issues"?

Ooops. Missed that. :o

I was referring to the cluster of issues where many debunkers have accepted false leads set up by T Szamboti. Missing Jolt the classic.

The common technical theme is the need to understand the cascade failure of columns which drove the "initiation stage" of collapse for the "Twins" - where Szamboti parodied/misrepresented Bazant on at least three premises. The process issue is debating within the Szamboti false scenario.

So the big three:
1) Why "Missing Jolt" is wrong in the setting of the actual initiation stage mechanism;
2) Why the arguments about "tilt" causing (or preventing) axial impact of columns is without foundation;
(Both those two re-surface and recycle on this forum from time to time) AND
3) Why the "Top Block" didn't topple - which is more popular on a couple of other forums.

And several other variants on the same core theme - understanding of the initiation mechanism and transition to progression. So add in "What started the mechanism of ROOSD whether or not we like the acronym or the person who coined it." ;)
 
I would say that among them are:

How did the heat + mech damage lead to the columns of the top and bottom misaligning such that the top dropped?
Yes - you know me too well. ;)

How would the buckling of col. 79 lead to the global collapse? Obviously col 79 and 80 "failed" as indicated by the drop of the EPH... so what "failed" to produce the drop in the WPH and how did that/those columns fail?
Wasn't one I was thinking about BUT it is the same sort of process - most debate prepared to follow the arse about logic defined by Szamboti and more recently here copied by Gerrycan - after a period of tag-teaming with T Sz.

Why support Szamboti et al by accepting their "logic" esp their false premises - hence the recent bits of fun discussion with Oystein et al. ;)
 
Wasn't one I was thinking about BUT it is the same sort of process - most debate prepared to follow the arse about logic defined by Szamboti and more recently here copied by Gerrycan - after a period of tag-teaming with T Sz.

Why support Szamboti et al by accepting their "logic" esp their false premises - hence the recent bits of fun discussion with Oystein et al. ;)

IMVHO, the salient point is that global collapse followed from failure of col 79. The supposed tie between collapse as global and the 2.25 seconds of at(sort of) free fall cannot exist. The entire building was moving well before those few seconds. Even before that the entire north face except the corners was moving , because of complete loss of support along the vertical line of the 'kink' which itself aligns with col 79 or 80.
TSz ignores this, AE911T ignores this, Chandler ignores this.

While what led to col 79 failure is quite relevant for the task NIST had, it was obviously not brought about by massive explosions severing all lower floor columns.
 
IMVHO, the salient point is that global collapse followed from failure of col 79. The supposed tie between collapse as global and the 2.25 seconds of at(sort of) free fall cannot exist. The entire building was moving well before those few seconds. Even before that the entire north face except the corners was moving , because of complete loss of support along the vertical line of the 'kink' which itself aligns with col 79 or 80.
TSz ignores this, AE911T ignores this, Chandler ignores this.

While what led to col 79 failure is quite relevant for the task NIST had, it was obviously not brought about by massive explosions severing all lower floor columns.

First it wasn't global collapse, it was progressive collapse strain building up over time until something finally broke.
 
IMVHO, the salient point is that global collapse followed from failure of col 79. The supposed tie between collapse as global and the 2.25 seconds of at(sort of) free fall cannot exist. The entire building was moving well before those few seconds.
That was the point femr2 made many times but deliberately stating in a somewhat obtuse style - too subtle for members who don't do tongue in cheek humour. ;)
 
err... :jaw-dropp

The last time I checked the WHOLE of WTC 7 had collapsed. You don't get more global than that. ;)

Nist stated that Global collapse occured in both Towers, but that progressive collapse occured in World Trade 7, just pointing that out, though I actually agree it makes little difference.:thumbsup:
 
I see little difference between collapse of an entire structure that has floor assemblies destroyed by an avalanche of debris beginning at an upper level, and one that has a combination of vertical and horizontal progression of various component failures, starting at a lower floor.

Like ozeco says, doesnt get much more global than having an entire structure become unstructured.
 
Last edited:
Nist stated that Global collapse occured in both Towers, but that progressive collapse occured in World Trade 7, just pointing that out, though I actually agree it makes little difference.:thumbsup:
Still "err...." :boggled:

Global collapse refers to the EXTENT of collapse

Progressive collapse refers to the MECHANISM of collapse.

I don't get hung up over what NIST said (or Bazant for anyone who hasn't noticed my subtle hints.)

I'll agree with them if they are right and disagree if they are wrong.

BUT The progression of collapse for the twins ended with global collapse.

Same story for WTC7

[/PedanticMode]

;)
 
Last edited:
Still "err...." :boggled:

Global collapse refers to the EXTENT of collapse

Progressive collapse refers to the MECHANISM of collapse.

I don't get hung up over what NIST said (or Bazant for anyone who hasn't noticed my subtle hints.)

I'll agree with them if they are right and disagree if they are wrong.

BUT The progression of collapse for the twins ended with global collapse.

Same story for WTC7

[/PedanticMode]

;)

This is precisely correct. Gobal means total.... DUH we all so there was total collapse. The more interesting an descriptive was that the collapse was a PROGRESSION of sequential mechanical failures over time.

It is the PROGRSSION that NIST did nothing with IMO. And this is really a key aspect of their failures considering they were made of tens of thousands of elements all of which failed in the end...
 
I'd love to see AClark trying to do the leg work - and fail.

I am among those who have calculated the amount of explosives.

(snip)

I believe I was the one who actually posed the question which inspired Oystein to perform this calculation many moons ago. The closest I could find in the real world of a large amount of steel being propelled a great distance from explosives was the case of The Halifax Explosion:

....while the shank of her anchor, weighing half a ton, landed 3.2 kilometres (2.0 mi) south at Armdale.

The Halifax Explosion was a collision between 2 ships in the city's harbor on December6, 1917. One, the cargo ship Mont-Blanc, was carrying "2622 tons of explosives" which ignited after the ship burned for 20 minutes. The resultant explosion leveled the north end of the city and caused 11,000 deaths and injuries. The explosion was the largest man-made explosion prior to the atomic bomb, shattered windows in the town of Truro 100 Km away and was felt on the Province of PEI 250 kms away.

To recap, 2600 tons of TNT propelled a 1000 lb anchor 2 miles. And was felt 250 km from the epicenter.

And just as a footnote for those readers from Massachusetts: the city of Boston was very quick to offer aid and supplies to Halifax after the tragedy. To this day, the city of Halifax sends a Christmas tree to Boston in appreciation. :)
 
I believe I was the one who actually posed the question which inspired Oystein to perform this calculation many moons ago.
You were? I think I first did my calculation in a debate with Rick Shaddock on another forum, a good year ago or so.


The closest I could find in the real world of a large amount of steel being propelled a great distance from explosives was the case of The Halifax Explosion:
...
To recap, 2600 tons of TNT propelled a 1000 lb anchor 2 miles. ...

Ignoring air resistance, and assuming an initial angle of 45° of the ballistic curve, this would mean a starting velocity of 177 m/s (ca. 400 mph) and a max. height of 800 m, reached after 1600 m of flight.

I can plug these numbers into a spreadsheet I made some months ago to figure out the explosives charge size per ton of steel ejection: Only about 64 kg TNT per ton of steel; or ca. 32 kg for the anchor.
Under theoretical, perfect circumstances, of course. In reality, multiply by not a little (10 or more).
Of course the 2600 tons did a lot more than fling an anchor.
 
Hey, I just thought of something.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJNzaMRsN00

Instead of attacking me, or Mr. Cole, I challenge anyone in this forum to conduct an experiment proving just ONE of Mr. Cole's claims are wrong.

I still can't be bothered making a video, but at about 30 seconds (quite an impressive Time To First Lie), Cole claims that,

"Whenever there's a big structural failure, there's always a detailed study as to its cause, except on 9/11 [...]"

Can someone make a quick video of Googling the NIST reports on the Twin Tower collapses and WTC7, and finding that they exist? This would be an experiment conclusively disproving Cole's claim, clearly implied above, that there was no "detailed study as to [the] cause" of the collapses on 9/11.

Dave
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom