If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, a point made by myself and others over the years is that even IF every floor's columns were sequentially blown out as collapse progressed, and the physics were as simplistic as truthers contend, the collapse would not proceed AT g due to conservation of momentum as you describe.
Indeed. Julio (who is a member of our team) even made a video that explains how the demolition would need to be accomplished in order to obtain free fall. It's in Spanish, though, sorry. The narrators are Julio and my wife. :cool:



Of course, and that's just one point that FalseFlag missed, immediately after that quick impulse,which destroys one floor's connections, both all now free falling objects start accelerating again due to gravity, and given the right circumstances, the process can be unstoppable (the floors in Ronan Point is an example where the process was unstoppable).
FTFY
Yeah. By "both" I meant the rubble pile and the impacted floor. In reality the details are gorier. I remember MT and femr2 mentioning that the collapse front reached a terminal velocity, which means that acceleration must have decreased to eventually reach zero. My guess is that it may have been due to air cushioning.
 
Dave, you are of course correct that the law of conservation of momentum tells us the final speed after the collision is complete, but it doesn't postulate that the deceleration must be infinite. However, in this case the collided object is directly on the way, and therefore its whole inertial mass. The only ways for the acceleration not to be infinite that I can think of are bypassing, penetration, and compression, neither of which happened in any significant amount here.

You're also right that the impacts were not pure floor-on-floor; more like pile-of-rubble-on-furnishing-and-floor-assembly. Disregarding the furnishing, which isn't expected to be a significant amount of mass, compression is the most likely real-world cause for the acceleration not to be infinite, and that's expected to be negligibly small (concrete is hard to compress).

Not really. Think about what's hitting what. There's a ragged mess of bits of column sticking out downwards, with maybe (but probably not) a few bits of floor slab hanging off them (I think the floors probably collapsed ahead of the columns in an internal avalanche), interpenetrating a similarly ragged mess of bits of column sticking out upwards, again with maybe bits of the floors surviving. The steel will deform on impact, the concrete will fracture on impact, and there's enough empty space around, above and below everything that things will slide past each other or miss completely. Remember, too, that everything, however hard, will still deform in some way under impact; infinite deceleration is an idealized fiction.

If you think about the collapses in terms of rigid slabs of concrete falling on to other rigid slabs of concrete, the truthers have already got inside your head to an unhealthy degree. The concrete was a negligible part of the structure. It's what the steelwork did that matters, and that determines how any visible part of the structure moved. And it's quite certain that the steel failed in quite a chaotic manner, as we can see at the very least in films and pictures of the perimeter columns during collapse.

Dave
 
If you think about the collapses in terms of rigid slabs of concrete falling on to other rigid slabs of concrete, the truthers have already got inside your head to an unhealthy degree. The concrete was a negligible part of the structure. It's what the steelwork did that matters, and that determines how any visible part of the structure moved.
clap.gif
clap.gif
 
I remember MT and femr2 mentioning that the collapse front reached a terminal velocity, which means that acceleration must have decreased to eventually reach zero. My guess is that it may have been due to air cushioning.

No. There is air cushioning at all velocities, and it plays a part, but is not the main reason acceleration will tend to approach 0 asymptotically. There are two ways to think about the true reason:
a) The faster the collapse goes, the more floors are collided against per time unit. Velocity and acceleration are expressed as functions of time. While g remains the same (same gain of velocity per second), more floors involves means more velocity loss per second
b) As the falling mass increases (and velocity) increases, the resistance offered by the zero momentum of newly hit floors represents a decreasing resistance expressed as a fraction of kinetic energy. In a purely CoM-determined inelastic collision of N floors with 1 floor, the loss of velocity, and also the loss of kinetic energy, is, 1/N. This converges on 0, and offsets the gain of mass and velocity.

While I am writing this, b) gets cloudy in my head :o I guess I should look at the formulas in my spreadsheet again. I have a hunch that the terminal velocity can be analytically computed.
(Before oz chimes in: This is an excercise in pure mechanics, for the fun of it)
 
Not really. Think about what's hitting what. There's a ragged mess of bits of column sticking out downwards, with maybe (but probably not) a few bits of floor slab hanging off them (I think the floors probably collapsed ahead of the columns in an internal avalanche),
Note that I'm focusing on that part: the collapse front (which consists of a pile of rubble hitting every floor and depriving the columns of their lateral support as the floors get detached).

True, I may have introduced confusion by mentioning the roofline when discussing measurement methods. Apologies for that. I just couldn't think of any other possible measurable external indication of any deceleration on impacts whatsoever, other than that, and implicitly conceded that in principle, certain impacts (not the kind that I focused on) should be measurable that way, without explicitly mentioning the shift of focus.


interpenetrating a similarly ragged mess of bits of column sticking out upwards, again with maybe bits of the floors surviving. The steel will deform on impact, the concrete will fracture on impact, and there's enough empty space around, above and below everything that things will slide past each other or miss completely.
Not so much for the floors collapse which I was talking about.


Remember, too, that everything, however hard, will still deform in some way under impact; infinite deceleration is an idealized fiction.
That's basically what I've said. In the real world there must be some degree of compression that would make the deceleration non-infinite.


If you think about the collapses in terms of rigid slabs of concrete falling on to other rigid slabs of concrete, the truthers have already got inside your head to an unhealthy degree.
No, as I said, it's
more like pile-of-rubble on furnishing-and-floor-assembly.
 
a) The faster the collapse goes, the more floors are collided against per time unit. Velocity and acceleration are expressed as functions of time. While g remains the same (same gain of velocity per second), more floors involves means more velocity loss per second
Julio did the math. My recollection of his results is that this sets a non-zero asymptote for acceleration, not velocity.
 
...... In reality the details are gorier. I remember MT and femr2 mentioning that the collapse front reached a terminal velocity, which means that acceleration must have decreased to eventually reach zero. My guess is that it may have been due to air cushioning.

Not really. Think about what's hitting what. There's a ragged mess of bits of column sticking out downwards, with maybe (but probably not) a few bits of floor slab hanging off them (I think the floors probably collapsed ahead of the columns in an internal avalanche), interpenetrating a similarly ragged mess of bits of column sticking out upwards, again with maybe bits of the floors surviving. The steel will deform on impact, the concrete will fracture on impact, and there's enough empty space around, above and below everything that things will slide past each other or miss completely. Remember, too, that everything, however hard, will still deform in some way under impact; infinite deceleration is an idealized fiction.

If you think about the collapses in terms of rigid slabs of concrete falling on to other rigid slabs of concrete, the truthers have already got inside your head to an unhealthy degree. The concrete was a negligible part of the structure. It's what the steelwork did that matters, and that determines how any visible part of the structure moved. And it's quite certain that the steel failed in quite a chaotic manner, as we can see at the very least in films and pictures of the perimeter columns during collapse.

Dave

I think Dave said the same thing, with more detail, as pgimeno.
 
I don't see it as giving credence. It's more allowing them explore why the claim is so absurd by trying to support it with evidence that obviously doesn't exist.

Except it never works that way.

The CT either never gets to that point of realizing the absurdity or if they start knocking on that door they quickly turn and run away when they do start to get an idea of what is ahead. Then you end up chasing endless derails, evasions and personal attacks.
 
Note that I'm focusing on that part: the collapse front (which consists of a pile of rubble hitting every floor and depriving the columns of their lateral support as the floors get detached).

True, I may have introduced confusion by mentioning the roofline when discussing measurement methods. Apologies for that. ...

The roofline could be considered part of the "pile of rubble hitting every floor" :p
 
While I am writing this, b) gets cloudy in my head :o I guess I should look at the formulas in my spreadsheet again. I have a hunch that the terminal velocity can be analytically computed.
(Before oz chimes in: This is an excercise in pure mechanics, for the fun of it)

CHIME!!


It is cloudy in my head - and I don't see any need for me to defog myself at this stage. I've totally lost track of why this aspect is being discussed. So it may be discussing alligator teeth when the objective may have been "drain the swamp". Nothing hinges on it AFAICS so no need for me to buy in.

Remember that my ranking of the sins of debunker "thinking":

worst sin is falling for a false truther determined context/scenario - working within the false context AND not realising that you have fallen for the trap - which is the possibility I raised some posts back in this thread but in the other topic. Dave Rogers also identified it and I commented
clap.gif
clap.gif
. That type of errant reasoning sin is a felony by my standards. :(

If it is a sin it is only a misdemeanour at worst when discussing the physics for fun...
AND in territory where the data is not available
AND any needed answer is readily available by taking a direct path through the logic - not an indirect and probably convoluted path.
AND IF it is between consenting adults with no risk of misleading innocent third parties....


BUT IF I was involved in a long path of ongoing discussion I would certainly be going back to check what the objective was.
Oystein will be aware of recent discussion of modelling on another forum which has suffered from serious drifting of objective. Where my pleas to be clear on the objective were not accepted. Not even acknowledged in fact.

If truthers do it we call it "moving the goalposts" :rolleyes:

In fact if the truthers do shift goalposts - at least they have a goal even tho they change it. So I suppose not having any objective is a worse sin.

[/EndChime]

:runaway
 
Last edited:
Except it never works that way.

The CT either never gets to that point of realizing the absurdity or if they start knocking on that door they quickly turn and run away when they do start to get an idea of what is ahead. Then you end up chasing endless derails, evasions and personal attacks.
clap.gif
clap.gif
 

CHIME!!

...

How about this:

Truther makes a claim of fact based on implied premises, and insinuates some conclusion to be drawn from the claim via unstated reasoning.
Truther believes the argument is (at least tentatively) valid.

What's the problem here?
I say: The problem is not the false premise, nor the unclear objective, nor the vague reasoning nor the predetermined conclusion - the problem is that the Truther, being a Truther, cannot think, and has not thought, and is unaware of this.

I am trying to make AClark try to think within his own frame of assumptions - to make the unstated reasoning explicit - and discover in the process that there actually is no reasoning. I figure this would be easier than trying to convince him that his frame of assumptions is faulty.

Of course we all notice that AClark has chosen not to respond. Which confirms what Mark F wrote. AClark, being an intelligent fellow, has probably understood that his vacuous proto-argument cannot lead anywhere, and has run away.
 
The CT either never gets to that point of realizing the absurdity or if they start knocking on that door they quickly turn and run away when they do start to get an idea of what is ahead.

^^This^^

Anyone with a modicum of technical sense in matters of physics or engineering understands that simplifications are both useful and not reality.
(What ozeco often refers to as either "swamps/alligators" or "what really happened")

Yes, noting that conservation of momentum dictates that plastic collisions will result in a change in velocity, that is a very simplistic approximation of the WTC tower collapses if it is applied to solid blocks of structure hitting solid blocks of structure.
((Cue Gage with his cardboard boxes)

Noting that at collapse initiation, as soon as the upper section of the tower is moving downwards, all columns are failed, leads directly to the above point that the downwards fall of that upper section has, as its leading points of contact, the lower ends of those upper section columns.
(Gage needs to put spikes on the bottom of his upper box, and top of his next lower box.)

We have already moved away from that first simplification since now its obvious that its not solid block on solid block.

Next note is that this first set of collisions between upper and lower structure is going to massively disrupt the connections between steel components and shatter concrete flooring in many places.

(Gage's cardboard box simplification now is about as relevant to collapse as the colour of the WTC lobby flooring.)


The really funny thing about all of this is that when it comes to NIST and FEAs, truthers loudly complain that this, that, or another thing has been deliberately left out of the model.
(How does Gage sleep at night?)
 
What's the problem here?
I say: The problem is not the false premise, nor the unclear objective, nor the vague reasoning nor the predetermined conclusion - the problem is that the Truther, being a Truther, cannot think, and has not thought, and is unaware of this.

I am trying to make AClark try to think within his own frame of assumptions - to make the unstated reasoning explicit - and discover in the process that there actually is no reasoning. I figure this would be easier than trying to convince him that his frame of assumptions is faulty.

I agree. Challenging the validity of the logical inference is usually more convincing, IMO, than questioning the soundness of the premises. It's often hard to be 100% sure about premises, but a conclusion that doesn't follow from the premises anyway is unsustainable.
 
But only if there is "containment' - some device to constrain and focus the blast to act on the steel. It would take one humongous blast - possibly of nuclear scale - to project/eject big lumps of steel as a side effect of demolition cutting. Unconstrained the blast moves outwards as a 3D expanding sphere. For enough to focus on fractions of a percent of that sphere - the bit occupied by a steel beam - the overall blast would be horrendous.

R Mackey was one - there were others - BUT non of them explained HOW - which was the point I made in my post. Calculating the energy is easy. Explaining how it could be focused is beyond many.

Righto. The columns that were supposedly hurled hundreds of yards by explosive charges appear to be in remarkably good shape in spite of it, like these embedded in Deutsche Bank.

As Ryan Mackey pointed out, high explosives make terrible propellants. A shape charge placed against a column would simply blow a hole through it. A non-shape high explosive charge placed against a column would bend it way out of shape. In order to not do so, a high explosive charge would have to be set back from the columns, and would be so large that people at the southern tip of New Jersey would hear it.

That's why I recommend that Truthers experiment with black powder. Black powder is actually a pretty good propellant and you can place a chunk of steel next to an unconfined charge without having it be damaged much. "Smokeless" powders, even those with nitroglycerin content comparing to gelignite, won't detonate, and won't give any push unless they are confined.

A 5 lb. charge of black powder placed against 1" A36 won't damage it. It might propel a 100 lb. slab a foot or two. But it would make a real bang. It would be the coolest Truther video yet. A few Truthers might even learn something.

The only problem would be, given the competence of Truthers, there might be some Darwin Awards... :D;)

The really silly thing, of course, is that if in some alternate universe the Twin Towers had been brought down with demolition charges, there would have been no need to blow columns for hundreds of yards. This isn't done in actual controlled demolitions. It'd be a black mark on the operators. So I guess this is an example of how the conspiracy made their controlled demolition look like something other than a controlled demolition! :rolleyes:
 

Attachments

  • WTC 2 Columns in Deutsche Bank.jpg
    WTC 2 Columns in Deutsche Bank.jpg
    95.6 KB · Views: 3
The really silly thing, of course, is that if in some alternate universe the Twin Towers had been brought down with demolition charges, there would have been no need to blow columns for hundreds of yards. This isn't done in actual controlled demolitions. It'd be a black mark on the operators. So I guess this is an example of how the conspiracy made their controlled demolition look like something other than a controlled demolition! :rolleyes:

And that's not counting the vast quantities of magic silent explosives placed all over the concrete floors to (pointlessly) "dustify" them.
 
Originally Posted by Myriad
FalseFlag, have you ever worked through the Horse Cart Problem? It's a standard student exercise for learning to understand and correctly apply basic Newtonian physics instead of falling into common errors.

The problem is this: A horse is hitched to a cart. The cart is motionless. The horse pulls on the cart; this applies a force to the cart, in the forward direction (the way the horse is facing). But the cart, by Newton's third law, applies an equal force to the horse, in the opposite direction. Because the forces are balanced, the cart will not move.

Given that horses can in fact pull carts, what is wrong with the reasoning in the previous paragraph? There is a more accurate explanation of what actually happens when a horse pulls a cart, which is in fact consistent with Newton's laws. Can you provide it?

Right now we are talking about Newton's first law of motion.

I will answer your question, only in regards to Newton's first law of motion. When we get to Newton's third law of motion, I will expand on my answer.

If the cart is at rest, it will only move when an unbalanced force is applied. Again, I am only going to discuss this example in terms of Newton's first law of motion. Bring this up again when we get to Newton's third law of motion.

FF, you are confused as to the distinction between an "unbalanced force", and "equal and opposite reaction". During your time out for bad behavior, try this experiment:

Instead of a horse wagon, obtain a dog cart like this one. Also get two scales like anglers use to weigh their catch. You'll note that there is provision for attachments at both ends.

Now secure both scales to a handle, but in reverse directions. Then secure the scales to the harness of the dog cart and pull. You will notice that no matter how hard you pull or how much load you place in the dog cart, both scales read the same! :eye-poppi The cart is pulling on you, just as hard as you are pulling the cart! :eye-poppi But you and the cart are moving! How is this possible?

Now, for your mind blower: Attach only one scale to the front, and attach the other to the rear. Have a friend pull on the cart when you pull on it such that the cart doesn't move. Again, both scales read the same, but this time, the net force is zero! The cart doesn't move! How is this possible?

Many of us here know the answer. But as you yourself have admitted, you have no training in physics. No shame in that. But instead of coming hear to learn in the manner of a newbie getting instruction from an old pro, you came here with an "attitude", and copped the Dunning-Kruger Lifetime Achievement Award.
 

Attachments

  • dog-cart.jpg
    dog-cart.jpg
    54.7 KB · Views: 3
  • Sport Fishing Scale.jpg
    Sport Fishing Scale.jpg
    97.3 KB · Views: 3
How about this:

Truther makes a claim of fact based on implied premises, and insinuates some conclusion to be drawn from the claim via unstated reasoning.
Truther believes the argument is (at least tentatively) valid.

What's the problem here?
I say: The problem is not the false premise, nor the unclear objective, nor the vague reasoning nor the predetermined conclusion - the problem is that the Truther, being a Truther, cannot think, and has not thought, and is unaware of this.
There is a pair of hypotheses with well reasoned support posted some years back - (1) Most truthers cannot think; (2) that is why most of them became truthers. I'm trying to remember who posted those hypotheses - but from memory they attracted little attention.
(Note both uses of "most" - neither are global assertions. AKA there is a minor subset for each where the premise could be different. Note also "could" is not global.)

I mean if every truther said "I don't understand this bit of WTC9/11 (sample bit included) BECAUSE I cannot think" there wouldn't be a lot of discussion. Agreement would be easy "Yes, we agree you cannot think"!

And possibly not a lot of conspiracy theories.

I am trying to make AClark try to think within his own frame of assumptions - to make the unstated reasoning explicit - and discover in the process that there actually is no reasoning. I figure this would be easier than trying to convince him that his frame of assumptions is faulty.

Of course we all notice that AClark has chosen not to respond. Which confirms what Mark F wrote. AClark, being an intelligent fellow, has probably understood that his vacuous proto-argument cannot lead anywhere, and has run away.
Which tends to support that he is not a truther. Back to my other issue of false global classifications. I still prefer to distinguish "trolling" and "Poeing" whilst many members over recent years have conflated the distinctly different behaviours and resort to pejoratives such as "twoofer".
 
Last edited:
As Ryan Mackey pointed out, high explosives make terrible propellants. A shape charge placed against a column would simply blow a hole through it. A non-shape high explosive charge placed against a column would bend it way out of shape. In order to not do so, a high explosive charge would have to be set back from the columns, and would be so large that people at the southern tip of New Jersey would hear it.
All those are true - even if lesser mortals like you or I make the assertions. ;)

That's why I recommend that Truthers experiment with black powder. Black powder is actually a pretty good propellant and you can place a chunk of steel next to an unconfined charge without having it be damaged much. "Smokeless" powders, even those with nitroglycerin content comparing to gelignite, won't detonate, and won't give any push unless they are confined.
Wont give much push - but ignore the nit pick pedantry - I agree.

The really silly thing, of course, is that if in some alternate universe the Twin Towers had been brought down with demolition charges, there would have been no need to blow columns for hundreds of yards. This isn't done in actual controlled demolitions. It'd be a black mark on the operators. So I guess this is an example of how the conspiracy made their controlled demolition look like something other than a controlled demolition! :rolleyes:
Don't tempt me - the misuse of the terminology "Controlled Demolition" is endemic and I've never seriously made the pedantic objections.. EXCEPT on a few rare occasions when one side or the other argued to false conclusions on the presumption that making the WTC buildings collapse needed controlled demolition. It didn't.

I even go with the crowd myself and call it CD - saves having to explain the objections every second post. :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom