If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
But my conundrum is that your analysis is sound as well. In my analysis, gravity does not intervene for the conservation of momentum argument. But the object colliding the other object is accelerating (and both are afterwards), and I wonder if that acceleration may have a repercussion on the resulting speed.

the 90+ floor collisions did slow the collapse but the resistance was so small the amount would be impossible to measure with video. Each floor collision is like a speed bump. Clearly arrest is not gonna happen. And clearly the rate of decent is less than FF.
 
I'm trying to make up my mind on this. In a perfect plastic collision, the combined masses' speed is less than the initial mass', and that happens instantaneously, and therefore acceleration (deceleration in this case) is infinite. Of course no real world collision is a perfect plastic collision, but assuming it's overwhelmingly plastic, I can't help wondering if the velocity does not decrease on each impact just by conservation of momentum.

That's what would happen if no other forces were involved, but in this case, gravity is still accelerating the mass. If the structure's resistance force is less than the static weight of the mass hitting it (i.e. if that amount of dead weight couldn't be supported), then the acceleration of gravity would only be partially offset: velocity would still increase but at a reduced rate.
 
Last edited:
AClark's claim...

...implies / insinuates (at least) the following:...
(LIST presented.)
All understood and agreed.
Every one of these is FALSE:
(Second LIST presented.)
Also understood and agreed.
You are of course totally right to strike down AClark's claim right at the beginning - the premise, my list point 1.
I chose to go for the last point, number 6.
Either one is good to debunk the claim.
Fully agreed. Within the context of debunk AClark's claim.

My concern is that by discussing aspects that are moot - that do not arise - probably cannot arise - we tend to give credence to those issues. Not a problem within the context of debunk AClark.

But in the full setting of WTC 9/11 debate the obvious example of the risks I reference is T Szamboti's "Missing Jolt" which rests on two false premises. The scenario for "Missing jolt" could never occur but the multiple false concepts which rely on it have gained credence through very extensive discussions which accepted Szamboti's pair of false assumptions. Sure many seem to enjoy the fun of discussing things which could never be....but....:o.

..the result is that many debunkers accept one of Szamboti's false premises and some accept 1.5 of the 2 false premises. For a scenario that was impossible. And resulting from megabytes of discussion of impossible situations.

Now the status of "ejections" AKA "throwing large lumps of steel by explosive propellant" is NOT IMO 100% proven false. It stands as an unsupported hypothesis - no one has shown that it is possible AFAICS. I am aware of some prominent debunker(s) calculating the amount of explosive needed to impart the necessary energy. BUT AFAIK never showing HOW the explosive energy could be imparted. So "Not proven" rather than "Impossible"

And I doubt that AClark's prominence would equal Szamboti's so the risk of him misleading debunkers to the extent that Szamboti has succeeded is -- "remote" ;)
 
Originally Posted by FalseFlag
Really? You want to go on record saying this?

The only way the chance of collapse is high is if they hired the same CD team. I don't think that's possible because I'm pretty sure most of them are dead.

Dead men tell no tales.

You have evidence of a 'CD Team' and their ultimate fate?

Who were they?

How did they do it?

Who killed them?


The crack demolition team should have watched all those movies where the supervillain kills off his henchmen when they are of no further use. :rolleyes:

But considering that they pulled off the first surreptitious demolition of a burning building in history, it shouldn't be too hard to figure out who they were. There couldn't be more than a handful of people in the whole world who would even attempt it. ;)
 
... So "Not proven" rather than "Impossible" ...
I agree it would be possible for explosives to blast a large section of steel many feet at "great speed" (aka, whatever speed that is which AClark will never define anyway...)

Someone did the calculation...? doubt 911 truth followers have done more than say "inside job", CD, and other BS.

BUT, Please, Please --- Please warn me~! I want to be over a mile (or the next state) away if "we" use explosives to propel random steel pieces 100 to 600 feet to the side; "we" might be killed by shrapnel over 2500 feet away, or more...

If explosives were used on 911 to propel steel hundreds of feet, associated shrapnel would have travel thousands of feet and killed people running in the street, over a thousand feet away...

CD by high explosives (or thermate, super thermate, nano-super..), "silent" high explosives has to be "one" of the most brain dead claims by what appear to be idiots on 911 truth issues.

There are formulas for minimum safe distances for explosives, and those are based on statistics, and not totally safe...

The Cole fire cracker experiment; proof of ignorance. (who worked ordinance... )
 
I'm trying to make up my mind on this. In a perfect plastic collision, the combined masses' speed is less than the initial mass', and that happens instantaneously, and therefore acceleration (deceleration in this case) is infinite. Of course no real world collision is a perfect plastic collision, but assuming it's overwhelmingly plastic, I can't help wondering if the velocity does not decrease on each impact just by conservation of momentum.

A perfectly inelastic collision (or, indeed, a perfectly elastic one) doesn't have involve instantaneous changes in speed; all that it specifies is the initial and final speeds, before the two objects touch and after all the processes of the collision have come to an end. It's easier to understand that if you think about what actually happens in an inelastic collision.

When two objects collide inelastically, they lose energy by damaging each other, typically by crushing or permanently deforming each other. That process doesn't have to be instantaneous. A classic example would be a collision between two cars with crumple zones; after the initial contact, the two cars keep moving as the crumple zones are crushed, but slow down as the energy of the collision is absorbed in deformation energy. Each car experiences a deceleration due to an applied force, but that deceleration doesn't have to be infinite, even in a perfectly inelastic collision. If two cars of the same weight collide at equal and opposite velocities, and both eventually come to a dead stop, then all the conditions for a perfect inelastic collision have been met.

And similarly with an elastic collision; both objects experience forces as they deform elastically, and then again as they spring back. If you work out the forces and accelerations in either case, you'll end up with the same initial and final velocities of both objects as you get if you just assume perfectly elastic, or perfectly inelastic, collisions.

So when two objects collide inelastically, they experience forces, and the details of those forces depend on the strength, shape and elasticity of the objects colliding. There's no law that specifies how quickly the collision process takes place, and clearly a longer-lasting collision, with a greater amount of damage needed to absorb the energy lost, will exert a smaller force. So, in the case of a falling object, if the force from the collision is less than the force due to gravity, overall the falling object will not actually decelerate, it will just see a reduction in acceleration.

Add to that one other point: that the 90+ floor collisions JSanderO mentions, and whose existence is almost an article of faith to some truthers, didn't actually exist as separate events. Bits of the falling mass collided with bits of the stationary mass more or less continuously, with each collision being relatively small and absorbing relatively little energy, but all of them adding to a continuous, though not particularly constant, force on whatever was falling at any given time. The result was that only the largest jolts, where a large number of these small impacts happened to combine, would have actually reduced the acceleration below zero; in fact, we only see one in the collapse of WTC1, though there are other smaller jolts where the acceleration reduces significantly.

If the towers had collapsed like a stack of planks falling on each other, then the whole missing jolt argument would have some merit. And in fact, in verinage demolitions, where for the first stage at least the collapse is that orderly and controlled, the jolt is in fact seen. But it's because the collapse was complex and uncontrolled that there was never a clean enough impact to see a jolt. And that's one of the great ironies of the missing jolt hypothesis. The absence of the jolt is actually evidence against, not for, a controlled demolition, because only a controlled process is orderly enough to produce a jolt.

Dave
 
...
Now the status of "ejections" AKA "throwing large lumps of steel by explosive propellant" is NOT IMO 100% proven false. It stands as an unsupported hypothesis - no one has shown that it is possible AFAICS. I am aware of some prominent debunker(s) calculating the amount of explosive needed to impart the necessary energy. BUT AFAIK never showing HOW the explosive energy could be imparted. So "Not proven" rather than "Impossible"
...
I'd love to see AClark trying to do the leg work - and fail.

I am among those who have calculated the amount of explosives. Roughly, it takes 1% of the mass of the propelled object just to satisfy CoM+CoE. This is assuming that there are almost no losses of energy to effects such as
- steel object deforming
- steel object rotating
- gasses flying off in directions other than directly away from the direction of ejection
- heat
- sound waves

It would obviously require careful attention to the engineering details of placing the explosives to minimize these losses. But as Porkpie Hat already pointed out, this would require the ridiculous assumption that the perpetrators would deliberately engineer these ejections, separately and in addition to engineering the collapse, and to expend major amounts of explosives for this unnecessary effect.

Complete wall panels were found to have hit nearby buildings. The lightest wall panels weighed 6-7 tons. This would mean an absolute minimum charge size (for the "perfectly engineered" solution) on an order of magnitude of 50 kg. Assuming that there was no engineering solution to minimize the losses, it is perfectly reasonable to expect the efficiency by which explosives placed for other purposes would propel steel segments to be no better than 10%. Now our minimum charge size for a single wall panel is 500 kg or larger - detonated at once.
The insinuation parroted by AClark would require dozens of such half-ton bombs having detonated within a time span of just a few seconds - and going unnoticed.
Only a mad person could hold on to such a proposition.
Or a movement that never did its legwork.
 
BUT, Please, Please --- Please warn me~! I want to be over a mile (or the next state) away if "we" use explosives to propel random steel pieces 100 to 600 feet to the side; "we" might be killed by shrapnel over 2500 feet away, or more...

If explosives were used on 911 to propel steel hundreds of feet, associated shrapnel would have travel thousands of feet and killed people running in the street, over a thousand feet away...

CD by high explosives (or thermate, super thermate, nano-super..), "silent" high explosives has to be "one" of the most brain dead claims by what appear to be idiots on 911 truth issues.

I would suggest that Truthers do an experiment with black powder instead of a high explosive. Black powder licenses are fairly easy to get. And it shouldn't be too hard finding a country location.

But I would suggest scaling down the experiment. (Did I say "scale"? :rolleyes:) Instead of steel sections weighing ~10 tons, take a 100 lb. slab of 1" thick A36 steel and see how far you can toss it with black powder. Lean it at 45 deg. from vertical against a 5 lb. keg of black powder. (It'd be wise to build a three-sided blast shield to keep debris from being tossed in any direction other than the direction of the hurled steel.) Get way back and detonate the charge. Be sure and video record the whole thing. See how loud the detonation is. Record the distance the A36 is hurled.

Now, scale (there's that word again! :rolleyes:) that up to doing ten tons of steel and tell us what you think it would look like. If nothing else, the video should be kinda cool. It'll be the first worthwhile thing that truthers have ever done. :D
 
Yes, I have been away for two days and now I'm catching up. I also have about 500 posts next to my name. How many thousands of posts do other members have? Whatever you think my posting means, it doesn't. It might mean I have some free time right now, and it might mean I want to answer other member's posts, but I'm not sure you want to admit that's what I'm doing.

I have about twice yours, in almost 4 years of posting. An average of a bit fewer than one per day, much lover than yours. Quality, not quantity. :D
 
You also need to stop the nonsense with Ronan Point, and Verinage and whatever else. Was Ronan Point a steel-framed high rise? No.

Correct. And neither were the Skyline Towers. And neither is Cole's model. So, if you are correct about Ronan Point, then by your own logic, Cole's model is useless. (A splendid case of reasoning to a true conclusion from faulty logic!:D)

But two of these are much more useful for studying progressive collapse than the third. Which ones are they? HINT: It has to do with scale! ;)

Did Ronan Point collapse at freefall for any period of time? No.

Almost surely false. The floors must have collapsed at freefall at the intervals between floor collisions. The average acceleration must have been less than g, the same as WTC 1, but in neither case was there a continuous, uniform acceleration. Perhaps, in your "time out" for bad behavior you could think about this, and realize where you have so wrong for so long about this.

Does verinage apply to steel-framed high rises? No?

The patentees of the Verinage technique claim it is applicable to any type of framing, including steel. Are you calling them liars? Do you think they might be part of the Vast Conspiracy?

Is constant acceleration observed in verinage? No.
Finally, you're right about something. But it wasn't in WTC 1,2,7, or anywhere else.
 
Dang, now I've got to replace that screen shot.

This video "CBS-Net Dub5 24.avi” is NOT the Dan Rather video, but instead a video from a different angle.
This can be seen by the fact that the top of WTC7 does NOT align with the horizon, meaning that this camera is higher than the Dan Rather camera.


The tilt that I showed is real, from that camera's viewpoint. Here is the image again, and it IS taken before the collapse began.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=176&pictureid=10624[/qimg]

Sorry for the confusion about the videos.

FF, you'll have to look thru the CBS videos listed in the NIST site to find the Dan Rather video.

There were two cameras continuously recording WTC 7 from a distance. The other was the CNN camera atop 5 Penn Plaza. I, too missed this for some time.

In fact, I once claimed that there were only 4 videos that showed the fall of the East Penthouse. There are actually 5. I took penance for my error by watching some Truther videos. ;)
 
You do understand that at least three skeptics, including yourself, have stated scale does not matter in Newton's laws of motion.

You can add me to the list. But scale is very relevant to studying structural modeling. Perhaps some day when you're older, you'll understand this. :D

(Apologies for posting several times in succession, which usually bugs me when others do it, but it took me days to catch up on this thread. I felt little motivation to devote much time to a thread which is a poster child for Dunning-Kruger. But there was some useful info I didn't know previously, provided by debunkers, of course.)
 
Originally Posted by jaydeehess
Asked and answered earlier by another poster. They did not feel any need to include it but because public questions were put forth about it they ammended the report to invlude a reference to it. Still doesnt make it relevant.

If it wasn't relevant, why is it in the NIST report?

There's a whole lot in NCSTAR 1-9 that isn't directly relevant to the collapse. You'd have known this if you had ever read it. There's a whole section about WTC 7 evacuation. That's because the NIST report is about a whole lot more than just the collapse. NIST was very thorough.
 
I agree it would be possible for explosives to blast a large section of steel many feet at "great speed" (aka, whatever speed that is which AClark will never define anyway...)
But only if there is "containment' - some device to constrain and focus the blast to act on the steel. It would take one humongous blast - possibly of nuclear scale - to project/eject big lumps of steel as a side effect of demolition cutting. Unconstrained the blast moves outwards as a 3D expanding sphere. For enough to focus on fractions of a percent of that sphere - the bit occupied by a steel beam - the overall blast would be horrendous.

Someone did the calculation...?
R Mackey was one - there were others - BUT non of them explained HOW - which was the point I made in my post. Calculating the energy is easy. Explaining how it could be focused is beyond many.

BUT, Please, Please --- Please warn me~! I want to be over a mile (or the next state) away if "we" use explosives to propel random steel pieces 100 to 600 feet to the side; "we" might be killed by shrapnel over 2500 feet away, or more...
You and I are on the same sheet of music beachnut. I've posted on other occasions the precautions which the AU Army engineers had to observe with demolition cutting of steel on the training range. It was under one of the approach paths to Sydney Kingsford Smith airfield. At ( from memory) the 7,000 ft level of the DME let down. That approach had to be shut down when we were cutting simple bits of steel.

If explosives were used on 911 to propel steel hundreds of feet, associated shrapnel would have travel thousands of feet and killed people running in the street, over a thousand feet away...
And potentially put holes in aircraft at 7000ft
There are formulas for minimum safe distances for explosives, and those are based on statistics, and not totally safe...
Has to be - there is nothing to STOP the extremes of the statistical distribution....only increasingly low probabilities BUT no guarantees of "never" or "none will".

The Cole fire cracker experiment; proof of ignorance. (who worked ordinance... )
The whole Cole video is crap and must be deliberate lying for any qualified engineer. And I don't accept that ANY engineer could be as incompetent as that video pretends.
 
A perfectly inelastic collision (or, indeed, a perfectly elastic one) doesn't have involve instantaneous changes in speed; all that it specifies is the initial and final speeds, before the two objects touch and after all the processes of the collision have come to an end. It's easier to understand that if you think about what actually happens in an inelastic collision.
AKA "Work from the known end points OR known macro (overall) position".

..and don't make the same bleeding mistake as truthers trying to work UPWARDS from details.

Work DOWNWARDS from known fact. (Or BACKWARDS if the DOWN metaphor throws you when discussing time sequences.)

If you know the "initial" and "final" who gives a damn about the transition details - except those stuck in "left brain" mode and cannot think without all the details.

F'rinstance look at the nonsense we often see about WTC Twin Towers.

The known point between "initiation" and "progression" is "Top Block falling" THEREFORE "all columns have failed". Bleedingly obvious true fact to most normal people - except those trapped in "left brain mode".

Look at the history of "left brain denials" - "I don't know all the details so it must be false".

OR the softer version "I don't have all the details so I cannot understand why it is true" - and sadly that version is probably true.
 
F'rinstance look at the nonsense we often see about WTC Twin Towers.

The known point between "initiation" and "progression" is "Top Block falling" THEREFORE "all columns have failed". Bleedingly obvious true fact to most normal people - except those trapped in "left brain mode".

Look at the history of "left brain denials" - "I don't know all the details so it must be false".

OR the softer version "I don't have all the details so I cannot understand why it is true" - and sadly that version is probably true.

Well you are correct for sure is the top is collapsing down what held it up... the columns "failed". I think people get hung up on what is a "failed column" and conceptualize it as a crushed on... scrunched up or busted and twisted... And surely these are examples of failed columns...

BUT there are cases when a column fails... ie... to support what it's supposed to support... because axial alignment has be destroyed. And that can happen when and if the column to column connections misaligned.

We can see some pretty good examples of gross "misalignment" when the facade columns/panels slip past one another. So all the slipped past columns are "failed" columns but really no "destroyed" or mangled of crushed....just not where they are supposed to be relative to one another.

So how could this have happened? Well the top moved laterally a sufficient distance to clean brake the column to column connections and that was likely related to a buckling situation where core columns were connected to the ones above... but there were so few that the buckled and we know buckling can be a lateral motion. We have the horse shoe columns as examples of a gross lateral movement . Those bent and buckled core columns are what most think of as a failed column....

BUT a whole lot of columns were "failed" because the were "dragged" or pulled or pushed laterally out of axial alignment.

*Failed* is the correct word for the various column failures though it lacks specificity as the the types of column failures. And NB that this sort of slipping failure is more one of a column to column connection failure.
 
My concern is that by discussing aspects that are moot - that do not arise - probably cannot arise - we tend to give credence to those issues. Not a problem within the context of debunk AClark.
I don't see it as giving credence. It's more allowing them explore why the claim is so absurd by trying to support it with evidence that obviously doesn't exist.

I'm pretty sure we can all agree that "truthers" tend to lead from a conclusion then try fitting facts around that conclusion to support it. Very unscientific but it's the way they think and what got them to where they are now so let instead of trying to get them to think differently, let them reason out the ridiculousness of their claims.

TFK already pointed out the little to no energy was required as these sections simply became disassociated as the collapse progressed then fell in an arc to where they landed. We all know it's just a simple calculation to figure out how far from x=0 the sections could land based on the height the fell from and the angle of the arc.

"Truthers" tend not to see simple solutions so let them try to figure out how much energy was required then explain why some nefarious entity would engineer such a pointless act. You and many others here excel at reality but sometimes you need to delve into absurdity to get your point across:p
 
Thanks for the responses, JSanderO, WilliamSeger and Dave Rogers. I think I have a somewhat better understanding now.

Dave, you are of course correct that the law of conservation of momentum tells us the final speed after the collision is complete, but it doesn't postulate that the deceleration must be infinite. However, in this case the collided object is directly on the way, and therefore its whole inertial mass. The only ways for the acceleration not to be infinite that I can think of are bypassing, penetration, and compression, neither of which happened in any significant amount here.

You're also right that the impacts were not pure floor-on-floor; more like pile-of-rubble-on-furnishing-and-floor-assembly. Disregarding the furnishing, which isn't expected to be a significant amount of mass, compression is the most likely real-world cause for the acceleration not to be infinite, and that's expected to be negligibly small (concrete is hard to compress).

So, there must have been a deceleration.

I think I see the problem, though. First, as JSanderO notes, measurement with video would probably not be adequate without a high speed, high resolution camera. Second, we can't measure the impacts where they happen, namely on the floors, and we need some indirect means. If we measure the roofline, then we have the problem that such a deceleration is transmitted through an inherently elastic structure. That elasticity will dampen the impacts and it's possible (likely?) that all we can see there is jolts.
 
I'm trying to make up my mind on this. In a perfect plastic collision, the combined masses' speed is less than the initial mass', and that happens instantaneously, and therefore acceleration (deceleration in this case) is infinite. Of course no real world collision is a perfect plastic collision, but assuming it's overwhelmingly plastic, I can't help wondering if the velocity does not decrease on each impact just by conservation of momentum.
Yes, a point made by myself and others over the years is that even IF every floor's columns were sequentially blown out as collapse progressed, and the physics were as simplistic as truthers contend, the collapse would not proceed AT g due to conservation of momentum as you describe.

Of course, and that's just one point that FalseFlag missed, immediately after that quick impulse,which destroys one floor's connections, both all now free falling objects start accelerating again due to gravity, and given the right circumstances, the process can be unstoppable (the floors in Ronan Point is an example where the process was unstoppable).
FTFY
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom