If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is this in the official record? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=

Yes that is in the official record.



The three firemen in this video were in the lobby of the Marriott Hotel when WTC 2 collapsed on it. Not being able to see the building collapsing they had no idea WTF was going on and mistook the collapse of WTC2 as an explosion.

The Marriott Hotel can be seen in this photo:

Collapse-SouthTower-HugeChunksFallOntoMarriottVista-3WTC--RichardDrewAP-400.jpg


The firemen talk about 4 "explosive" events.
1 plane hits North Tower
2 plane hits south tower
3 WTC 2 collapse
4 Wtc 1 collapse

Tyrone Johnson is the fireman on the left. Check the number on his helmet he is with ladder 24.

My name is Tyrone Johnson, firefighter first grade, assigned to Ladder 24.......


Then maybe about five, ten minutes later, we were ordered to go into the Marriott Hotel. At that time the company and three other companies in front of us went inside the Marriott Hotel......

We went to the Marriott. We got inside the lobby. The chief told us take your gear off, relax, until you find out what you want us to do.
Maybe 10 or 15 minutes later he gave us the command put the gear on because we're getting ready to head upstairs. There were about three companies in front of us. We were the last company to go up the steps. Maybe about five minutes into the process of going up the steps, that's when the building collapsed on us.

http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/nyregion/20050812_WTC_GRAPHIC/9110443.PDF

The firefighter on the right is James Duffy.


James Duffy. CHIEF CONGIUSTA: Firefighter third of
Ladder 24 of the New York City Fire Department....

We were told to report to the south tower, but the only way to get to the south tower -- you couldn't walk down Liberty Street to get into the main entrance because of the jumpers and the falling debris, so we had to go in through the corner entrance of the Marriott, which is on West and Liberty. We went in there......

over there right next to us. 22 Truck was in the lobby also. Then we were just waiting to go into the south tower. As we were waiting, we looked up and all I saw was -- I heard this huge noise, and I saw hundreds and hundreds of people running towards us. They were running out of the south tower to the Marriott, to the lobby.

We just turned. We started to like run also. We got about ten feet before getting blown across the lobby. We got blown across the lobby, just got covered with debris.

http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/nyregion/20050812_WTC_GRAPHIC/9110444.PDF


Here is another quote from James Duffy the fireman on the right.



Q. When either tower came down, did you have any advanced warning?

A. Oh, no. I didn't know what it was when we were inside. I didn't know the building had collapsed, actually. I thought it was a bomb. I thought a bomb had gone off. That's why I really didn't know until after.

Q. Afterwards?

A. Yeah, that that's when it came down. I wasn't expecting that. I thought it was a bomb or something that went off.

Q. Glad you made it.

A. Yeah.

Q. Thanks for the interview.

http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/nyregion/20050812_WTC_GRAPHIC/9110444.PDF



Jimmy Grillo is the fireman in the middle


My Story, September 11, 2001

Once we reached the doorway I thanked God that we had made it and then entered the hotel lobby. There was a sea of firefighters all waiting their turn to start heading up. We knew we had to wait a while, so we loosened our coats and put down all our gear so we wouldn't overheat. While we waited, I noticed Jimmy Grillo, a member of our company, holding a five-gallon bottle of water, filling up cups with water so we would all be properly hydrated. Standing by, just waiting for our turn, I also noticed a bank of pay phones on the lobby wall. The lieutenant and I approached the phones trying to get a working line. We had a dial tone but all the circuits were busy. I even attempted to use my cell phone to get in touch with my family, but that failed. I was concerned about how much they must be worrying about me.

It was our turn to go up.

We started heading to the stairwell when this dark, overpowering shadow started heading toward us. It seemed as if it was in slow motion. People were yelling to run. My first instinct was to run away from the shadow thinking another plane must be coming in. I made a turn toward another lobby, trying to get away from the front of the building. Then I felt this force, like being in a massive wind tunnel. Firefighters were getting tossed around like rag dolls. I found myself being blown across the floor landing into what appeared to be a closet. The South Tower was collapsing.


http://www.newsweek.com/my-story-september-11-2001-144971

http://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/2002/09/10/my-story-september-11-2001.html

The three firemen in the video were in the lobby of the Marriott hotel when WTC 2 collapsed on top of them

They never made it in to WTC1 or WTC2.
 
Rather than reply directly to FF, I just wanted to highlight a couple of his more amusing gaffes in the last few pages.

Firstly, I issued him a challenge, which he quite predictably both refused and claimed to have met:

Time to stop playing. FalseFlag, here's a challenge to you, returning the burden of proof to where it should have been all along. Having accepted that Cole's videos demonstrate that Newton's laws are what they are, please provide compelling evidence that the behaviour of Cole's models is representative of the behaviour of the WTC towers while collapsing, to a sufficient precision to be predictive of the specific aspects of the collapse they are intended to predict. Until you've proven this point, there's really nothing here to talk about.

However, he seems more interested in proving the other side of the argument.

Proof 1: Verinage is done to low-rise concrete buildings. A low rise concrete building is not a steel-framed high rise.

[...]

Proof 3: Ronan Point was not a steel-frame high rise. Ronan Point had no external support structure.

[...]

Proof: Skyline Towers was also not a steel-frame high rise. Here is a direct quote from the investigation:

So his claim, quite clearly stated, is that we cannot predict the detailed behaviour of a steel-framed high-rise building from something that is not a steel-framed high-rise building. In the absence of any experiments by Cole on actual steel-framed high-rise buildings, therefore, we can reject Cole's results as not being representative of steel-framed high-rise buildings on exactly the same basis as FF rejects verinage, Ronan Point and Skyline Towers.

(Incidentally, from the point of view of someone rational and competent, clearly the latter three examples are closer in scale and will therefore have some greater degree of predictivity than a small-scale structural model. But we knew that already.)

Secondly, there's this quite spectacular piece of circumlocution to try and justify the use of the word "simultaneously" to a series of events happening over a timescale of several seconds (and, incidentally, to try to bolster the deliberate and blatant lie that I "admitted" that failures were simultaneous):

I knew this argument was coming. What you are claiming is that a certain number of columns failed before the last ones did. Then, when the last ones failed, the building collapsed. This is actually correct, but you don't like what it proves, and you're trying to twist the truth to support your claims instead of coming to the correct conclusion

We do know that some columns ceased to provide support first because the penthouse collapsed before the rest of the building. Then, the entire top of the building came down at once, and it descended at freefall for 2.25 seconds, which is about the distance of 100 feet or 8 floors. In order for the entire building to come down at freefall for 2.25 seconds, all of the columns left that provided support had to fail at once, or at the same time, or instantaneously, or simultaneously.

So the argument is that, although the columns didn't fail simultaneously, some of them failed simultaneously (incidentally, we know from the kink in the north wall that even this isn't true), and because some of them failed simultaneously, therefore CD. Note, also, that "instantaneously" is sneaked in without even a shred of evidence (and of course, we know from the initial lesser acceleration that the failures were anything but instantaneous), by pretending it's a synonym for "simultaneously". And the beauty of it all is that he goes on to claim, after this magnificent piece of word-twisting, that:

Dave's argument is a pretty good attempt to take the truth, and obscure it to it support the skeptics position.

Finally, every single assertion he makes in his summary of the collapse is contradicted by the evidence.

The claim that some columns failed first is 100 percent true, but it fails to recognize how many support columns were still left supporting the entire building [1]. Every single one of these remaining columns failed at exactly the same time [2]. Not only did they fail at the same time, they failed over the same length at the same time [3]. There is only one explanation for this, and it's not progressive collapse [4].

[1] The core was gone completely by the time the façade started to move, so an entire component of the structure had been lost together with the lateral support it provided to the remainder, so the remaining columns were obviously incapable of supporting even themselves, and definitely not "the entire building; we know this from basic structural engineering understanding of unbraced lengths, and from the collapse of both engineering penthouses. FF is so incompetent at understanding structures that he seems to equate the number of columns still standing with the structural strength.
[2] We know this not to be true from the kink in the north face, which clearly shows a cascade (i.e. sequential) failure outwards from the middle of the wall.
[3] We have no reason whatsoever to even suspect this to be true, and FF advances none; in fact, the steady decrease in deceleration after the near-freefall period strongly indicates variation in the initial buckle length and hence distributed rather than single impact when the façade had fallen through the initial buckle length.
[4] And finally, the false conclusion arising from a set of false premises.

As I said, I'm not really interested in arguing at this point; exposing his deliberate and calculated lies is about the only thing worth doing now.

Dave
 
Last edited:
I think Truthers misunderstand the report.
It's purpose was to make recommendations concerning building safety snd construction.
The recommendations have been accepted by the worlds construction industry and their regulatory bodies.
If there were gross mistakes or deliberate obfuscation then it would have been noticed and pointed out by these regulatory bodies, engineers and architects.
 
You might be able to see them, but you choose not to comprehend them.

Oh, I comprehend them alright.

I said scale does not matter when it comes to Newton's laws of motion

That is not what you said initially. That's your current story, now that you've been shown wrong.

Your attempt is lame, amateurish, and typical of the tactics skeptics use to continue the cover up.

Let me get this straight: you think I, a Canadian computer programmer, am in on this conspiracy?

That's insane.
 
I am not violating any rules. I am responding to each post as it is read. This is not spamming.

Yes it is. You are flooding the pages with your own posts. Use multi-quoting so you have fewer posts.

Deceit is not proof, at least not to me. It might work on others, but it will not work on me.

You have amply demonstrated that you cannot tell the difference between truth and falsehood.

Do you have actual arguments to make?

Do you?

I'm not the one making the claims, silly.
 
Although the thread has moved on many pages since this happened, please note that accusations of posters being 'shills' / being paid to post are breaches of rule 12.

As well as sticking to the topic, please ensure that you are all civil and polite, and that you address the arguments rather than attacking the arguers.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Agatha

Back on page 15, I posted the above modbox. It seems that in the subsequent pages, some people have forgotten that modboxes are not a suggestion, they are an instruction.

Will you all please follow the membership agreement to which you agreed on joining this site. In particular, we expect you to follow rule 0 and rule 12. This means you must be civil and polite, and you must not attack each other. Address the arguments without the personal remarks, please.

If I have to come in here again with more yellow cards and AAH moves, there is a real possibility that this thread will be put on moderated status, and I doubt that anybody really wants that to happen.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Agatha
 
The investigation was done by "sloppy", but "expert" professionals. That is a claim made by another skeptic. Don't you think we need an investigation that isn't sloppy?

You are intentionally misquoting me.
I never said anything REMOTELY like this.
Please STOP misquoting me.
 
You are intentionally misquoting me.
I never said anything REMOTELY like this.
Please STOP misquoting me.

You certainly were not the only one to notice that extreme example of out of context attribution. I suspect that others, like myself, simply rolled their eyes at it and couldn't be bothered to point out the intellectual dishonesty in FF's post.
 
Edited by darat: 
Various breaches of the Membership Agreement - 0, 10, 11, 12 - removed.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'll try again, perhaps AClark sees this now, with FF suspended for a week and noise decreasing as a result:
That's all very well and mathy, but it makes some very glaring omissions. Primarily the trigonometry of the situation. If you are going to have pieces toppling, then you are going to need pivot points, and enough geometry for your javelin.
You are Moving the Goal Posts.

You had declared:
The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large...
So I asked:
Can you quantify this "very large" energy required?

There are basically two theories on the table that would explain the source of that energy:
  • Gravity (GPE - Gravitational Potential Energy)
  • Explosives (ChE - Chemical Energy)
I quantified the requirement for the first theory - that GPE is the energy source: Drop height of 10 to 40 floors - easily available for collapses starting 78+ floors above ground.

Remember: You made a claim about the quantity of energy.

Now you:
How much explosives (equivalent to chemical energy, ChE) does it take, per mass unit of steel to propel a steel section to 60 mph?
That calculation is much less straightforward.
I have done it.
Have you?
Can you guess?
 
The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large,

So I asked:
Can you quantify this "very large" energy required?
I wouldn't be granting him the starting premises that "steel sections" were in fact "ejected" a "considerable distance",

Given that we know one simple mechanism for the longest travel of steel sections - such as those "outliers" which implanted in the building adjoining the wintergarden. They were NOT "ejected".

So which long distance travelled steel sections is he asserting WERE "ejected"?

AND we know that no one (other than me AFAIK ;)) has proposed a mechanism for explosive ejection of steel sections.

So I suggest consideration of the energy involved is moot without either a valid example OR a valid mechanism to employ the energy. I would challenge him to prove his premises THEN he can address the detail.

Otherwise he is playing the T Szamboti SOP trick of building on false premises and we are discussing what cannot have happened. All same as "Missing Jolt" which also couldn't have happened.

My bet is he will evade both approaches.
 
Last edited:
I am formally ejecting the idea of steel being ejected. There is no evidence of this.

of saying... is not IS

This is beginning to sound like religious views.... Moses parted the waters!!!!!!!!!!
 
I wouldn't be granting him the starting premises that "steel sections" were in fact "ejected" a "considerable distance",
...
My bet is he will evade both approaches.

AClark's claim...
The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large...
...implies / insinuates (at least) the following:
  1. It's an evidence-based fact that steel sections were ejected at high speeds to hit other buildings
  2. There is no mechanism other than "ejection" that readily explains how the steel sections could have travelled all the way to other buildings
  3. These ejection, i.e. the imposing of large lateral velocity, of each such steel section occurred (almost) instantaneously
  4. The energy required to give such steel sections such lateral momentum is "very large", i.e. significantly larger than what the GPE of the tower released during the collapse could provide
  5. There is therefore another source of energy other than GPE that is sufficient to explain such ejections
  6. And finally, let's face it: AClark wishes to sugges that explosives are a plausible such energy source (he had replied to Porkpie Hat, who had brought up high explosives, and only HE specifically, as an alternative energy source, which AClark did not reject).
Every one of these is FALSE:
  1. No large steel section is actually known to have been ejected
  2. There is at least one other mechanism, which I mentioned previously: Toppling
  3. It is not in evidence that any of the steel found some distance away was accelerated instantaneously
  4. The energy required to give such (imaginary) steel sections such lateral momentum is not "very large" - it is only a smallish percentage (<25%) of the GPE of any such steel segment, provided it originated somewhere in the upper half of the tower
  5. Therefore, no additional source of energy needs to be postulated
  6. Explosives are NOT a plausible energy source for such ejections, as they would require insanely large charges of HE placed suitably for the purpose of ejecting steel, but unsuitably for the dismemberment of the structure

You are of course totally right to strike down AClark's claim right at the beginning - the premise, my list point 1.
I chose to go for the last point, number 6.
Either one is good to debunk the claim.

What I really want to show is not so much how much energy this or that and whence and where, but to expose the (lack of) thinking that AClark put into his claim. He claimed that some quantity (KE of ejected steel) is "very large", implying that it probably is significantly larger than some other quantity (GPE of the falling steel), and further insinuating that a third quantity (ChE of hypothetical explosives) is plausibly equal to or larger than the first quantity.
In short: GPE < KE < ChE
But AClark has not evaluated these claims of inequality: This is a case of Dave Roger's "Unevaluated Inequality Fallacy", of which I am a fan, as you may recall. And that's the reason why I chose that route.

I am hoping that, by trying to answer my oft-repeated questions, AClark would come to realize that
  • He hasn't verified if his claim is correct
  • He parroted a claim that he didn't come up with himself but found it on some Truther website(s)
  • The claim is actually false
  • The Truthers with whom the claim originated, and many of those who still promote it (AE911T, David Chandler, David Griscom), never verified the claim is true
  • These Truthers, despite some of them claiming relevant expertise, are not trustworthy with such claims
The argument "steel ejections require forces and energies unaccounted for by a gravity collapse, therefore explosive demolition" is rather elaborate - and complete hogwash from beginning to end. It fails at every single step along the way. If we merely convince AClark that the premise is wrong, therefore we need not look at the false logic that follows, then he might think this is just another case of Truthers merely not seeing something small and subtle - much like he gives Truthers who didn't see the plane in the Pentagon video the benefit of the doubt.
The problem with Truthers runs much much deeper than that. One must wade through heaps and stages of falseness to accept an elaborate argument like this, or suspend skepticism altogether and take it all on blind faith: Skip verifying the premises, refuse checking the logic, ignore the math, turn a blind eye to alternatives - all this is required to give at least initial credence to this argument. That's what I would love to teach AClark, and perhaps some lurkers.

ETA: The quoted post where AClark made that claim also contains a brief reference to the "molten steel, therefore CD" argument so beloved by Truthers:
Bingo, give that man a teddy bear. That's the whole point. The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large, just as the temperature required to melt steel is quite hot. It's not the sort of thing you can do by casually spilling a cup of coffee.
...
Several of us will recall how that argument, too, is hogwash from beginning to end, and fails at every single step. Here are just some of them:
  • There is no convincing evidence that there actually was molten steel
  • Molten steel is not actually created by explosive CDs
  • There is no reason to think that any molten steel observed after the collapse was melted during or prior to the collapse
We had a thread in ... perhaps 2011, where we engaged a baby engineer from northern Texas - what was his name, Dave Johnson? - to whom we granted the premise that there was molten steel days and weeks after 9/11, and I remember I had a more elaborate list of all the steps where that argument failed.
 
Last edited:
Several of us will recall how that argument, too, is hogwash from beginning to end, and fails at every single step. Here are just some of them:
  • There is no convincing evidence that there actually was molten steel
  • Molten steel is not actually created by explosive CDs
  • There is no reason to think that any molten steel observed after the collapse was melted during or prior to the collapse
.

,,,,,,,and my favourite:
Molten steel/metal reports are fairly common in large fires. If true then it's existence at the WTC is trivial, and if it doesn't actually occur it points to the fact that erroneous reports of molten steel/metal are common in large fires.
 
Last edited:
FalseFlag started out attempting to use physics and the results of others' "experiments" (poorly scaled models) for the necessity of deliberate demolition in the tower collapses. The crux of his argument was that based on Newton's second law of motion, the force of the falling mass should have been met by an equal and opposite resistance force from each floor impacted:

The floors should have exerted an opposite and equal force on the falling mass.


... and thus the falling mass should have decelerated.

While Newton's second law is applicable, FalseFlag's reasoning was erroneous, and it's important to understand why. One can note with simple analogies that by the same reasoning, no object no matter how powerfully propelled could ever accelerate against the slightest resistance (for instance, a truck hitting a series of bugs with its windshield as it tries to accelerate on the highway), but correcting the actual application of the laws of physics in that faulty reasoning is necessary sooner or later.

"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

The force of the gravitational attraction between the earth and the falling mass acts upon the falling mass, pulling it downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the earth, pulling it upward. (The earth, being rather large, does not move very much as a result of that pull. F = ma means a = F/m.)

Simultaneously, the force of the impact between the falling mass and a floor acts upon the floor, breaking it and accelerating the floor material downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the falling mass. That force might decelerate the falling mass, but only if that force exceeds the force of gravity pulling the falling mass down.

There is no physical law requiring the upward force of impact of the floor upon the falling mass to be equal in magnitude to the downward force of gravity acting upon the falling mass. And there is no reason to expect they would be equal. They are two different forces. As long as the latter is greater, there will be no deceleration. As the latter was in fact greater (throughout most of the collapse), there was no deceleration (throughout most of the collapse).
 
FalseFlag started out attempting to use physics and the results of others' "experiments" (poorly scaled models) for the necessity of deliberate demolition in the tower collapses.
That must be the understatement of the year.


The crux of his argument was that based on Newton's second third law of motion, the force of the falling mass should have been met by an equal and opposite resistance force from each floor impacted:
(FTFY)


There is no physical law requiring the upward force of impact of the floor upon the falling mass to be equal in magnitude to the downward force of gravity acting upon the falling mass. And there is no reason to expect they would be equal. They are two different forces. As long as the latter is greater, there will be no deceleration. As the latter was in fact greater (throughout most of the collapse), there was no deceleration (throughout most of the collapse).
I'm trying to make up my mind on this. In a perfect plastic collision, the combined masses' speed is less than the initial mass', and that happens instantaneously, and therefore acceleration (deceleration in this case) is infinite. Of course no real world collision is a perfect plastic collision, but assuming it's overwhelmingly plastic, I can't help wondering if the velocity does not decrease on each impact just by conservation of momentum.

Of course, and that's just one point that FalseFlag missed, immediately after that quick impulse, both objects start accelerating again due to gravity, and given the right circumstances, the process can be unstoppable (the floors in Ronan Point is an example where the process was unstoppable; the ball hitting glass panes in that geek contest video is an example where it actually arrests, probably due to the small height between panes, which gives the ball no time to accelerate sufficiently between impacts).

But my conundrum is that your analysis is sound as well. In my analysis, gravity does not intervene for the conservation of momentum argument. But the object colliding the other object is accelerating (and both are afterwards), and I wonder if that acceleration may have a repercussion on the resulting speed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom