If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
The investigation was done by "sloppy", but "expert" professionals. That is a claim made by another skeptic. Don't you think we need an investigation that isn't sloppy?

Context, dear boy, context. "Sloppy" in the minutiae of the wording, not in the work itself.

I am providing proof. See my first post in this thread.

You have provided no proof whatever, anywhere. All your assertions have been shredded, and your slippery, selective, and substance-free responses taken together show a pattern of evasion, as though you have something to hide.
 
The investigation was done by "sloppy", but "expert" professionals. That is a claim made by another skeptic. Don't you think we need an investigation that isn't sloppy?

A better description would be a half-hearted effort to a feature they really didn't think needed explaining.

The NIST got sucked in by the short lived attention the "truth movement" got from the Popular Mechanics article and other bits of publicity at that time.

They should have just ignored it. It is not really a significant feature and the "truthers" have never shown it to be anything more then a talking point they exploit to keep the argument going to no end.
 
Last edited:
We can all see your posts.

You might be able to see them, but you choose not to comprehend them.
Your post is nothing but a lame attempt to deceive that anyone can see through. I said scale does not matter when it comes to Newton's laws of motion, and scale does matter when it comes to scale modeling. You have taken my statements from different threads, and posted them completely out of the context in which they were made.

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove incivility
 
Last edited by a moderator:
A better description would be a half-hearted effort to a feature they really didn't think needed explaining.

The NIST got sucked in by the short lived attention the "truth movement" got from the Popular Mechanics article and other bits of publicity at that time.

Is your claim that they are easily-manipulated? If so, you might have a point. If NIST got sucked in by the short-lived attention from the truth movement, imagine how easy it would have been to get sucked in by the government which was funding the investigation. If your claim is true, it would indicate they were easily susceptible to all sorts of outside influences, which would make their entire investigation not credible.
 
mainly because I know I do not know the physics and engineering. and then returned to the thread to see what the more informed had said. (For the record, I did in fact miss both high school chemistry and physics

You admit that you don't know physics and engineering. There is nothing wrong with this. I am only pointing this out to prove a point. This is not an attack, so don't even go there. I am simply using your points to prove mine. There is nothing personal, whatsoever.

In fact, I will change "you" to "a person". No, it doesn't help much, but this is not an attack.

Although a person admits they know nothing about physics and engineering, they came here to see what the "more informed" had said. Why on earth would anyone come here thinking there are more informed people? This defies all logic and reason. There are neutral forums a person could have visited to seek understanding of the concepts they didn't understand.

I admire that you have admitted you don't understand physics and engineering. The problem is that if you really wanted to understand them, you would NOT come here first.

At any rate, the square-cube law did not take long at all to comprehend. So scaling. So the videos are no proof. Therefore, how did this thread reach 44 pages with the same claims as on the first page? Because CT.

You have demonstrated that your lack of understanding, and your choice to come here, has influenced you to make the wrong conclusions. At the very least you should have seen where are least 3 skeptics have admitted scaling does not apply to Newton's laws of motion. That, at the very least, should be proof that your conclusion is wrong.
 
Last edited:
Do the laws of physics apply differently to them?
No. The laws of physics apply to everything. You should use this statement to understand why you are wrong. Verinage collapses do comply with the laws of physics, which is why one can clearly observe deceleration.

So is in WTC1.

Where is deceleration observed? Please post your source, and your definition of deceleration.

Neither is there in WTC1.

Good point. You are correct. Freefall, or acceleration downwards at the rate of 9.8m/s/s was observed during the collapse of WTC7. During the collapse of WTC1, nearly uniform acceleration downwards (at approximately 6.31m/s/s was observed. This is not the same value as freefall, so it is absolutely correct to state that freefall was not observed during the collapse of WTC1.

Here is a more detailed explanation: http://www.911speakout.org/Chandler_DownwardAccelerationOfWTC1-NoMath.pdf

Do the laws of physics apply differently to it?
The laws of physics apply to all buildings. Whenever you admit this as being true, you are conceding that Cole's experiments are correct.
 
Last edited:
Good point. You are correct. Freefall, or acceleration downwards at the rate of 9.8m/s/s was observed during the collapse of WTC7. During the collapse of WTC1, nearly uniform acceleration downwards (at approximately 6.31m/s/s was observed. This is not the same value as freefall, so it is absolutely correct to state that freefall was not observed during the collapse of WTC1.

There was no uniform acceleration in 1WTC... You have a 1100 foot collapse.. so where is the data? It was more or less a uniform velocity and that was measured only for a brief period when the collapse front was visible... The collapse was for the most part, obscured by the debris which was ejected outside and fell at close to FF fall and was AHEAD of the collapse front.

Chandler is dead wrong and you are a parrot.
 
So FF... Simple Question that will clarify things a lot.

Is Cole's video...

A) Trying to demonstrate Newton's Laws of Motion?

or

B) Trying to replicate the Tower collapses on 9/11?
 
Indeed, the professional investigations,such as NIST's, only considered the mechanisms for damage for which they could find evidence of.
Thus, no explosives, no therm!te, no space-a-beams, no nukes, no ghost planes, no drones, and ,after investigating some possibilities , they were also dropped. Case in point, Diesel fuel fire driven WTC7 collapse.
Good point.

If NIST was really trying to pull the wool over every ones eyes they would have been better off including the energy contribution from diesel fuel known to be in the building and damage from falling debris from the towers in the final report on WTC 7.
 
Is your claim that they are easily-manipulated? If so, you might have a point. If NIST got sucked in by the short-lived attention from the truth movement, imagine how easy it would have been to get sucked in by the government which was funding the investigation. If your claim is true, it would indicate they were easily susceptible to all sorts of outside influences, which would make their entire investigation not credible.

As all the worlds professionals with the relevent qualifications, experience and expertise along with their professional bodies, journals and universities etc agree with the report or have raised no objection I guess they were all influenced by the US govt as well.
 
Except "debunkers" as we now call them have traditionally accepted "reversed burden of DISproof" because the poor truthers never could formulate their own hypotheses. Remember - that is why most of them are truthers - they cannot think.
I think that's part and parcel in the sport of arguing with ideologues.

Just telling them over and over they're wrong gets boring so some resort to pointing out their failures of logic and reasoning as a form of entertainment.

And the status at that level is also a grade or two more basic. Coles models are wrong - they are NOT models of how the WTC Towers collapsed.

So Coles argument in essence is "Here are three wrong models - therefore what really happened couldn't."

No point following all the details when the foundation argument is utter nonsense. There is current discussion along the same lines on another forum "Here are three models referenced by Cole plus seven examples of buildings where progressive collapse arrested. Therefore the WTC Towers should have arrested."

Bleeding nonsense "None of the satellites of the solar system (M, V, E, M, J, U, N, [P]) have rings THEREFORE Saturn cannot have rings."

"Look - here are photos of Mars - no rings!"
-- and we still talk to clowns who make these silly "arguments".


:o :boggled:
Exactly! My knowledge of physics is definitely basic yet it's very easy to spot the ridiculousness of Cole's experiments and the ineptness of FF's attempts to defend them.
 
No. The laws of physics apply to everything. You should use this statement to understand why you are wrong. Verinage collapses do comply with the laws of physics, which is why one can clearly observe deceleration.


The laws of physics stipulate that deceleration of the downward progression of such a collapse is conditional upon the upward force of impact of the resistant structure below upon the falling mass being greater than the downward force of gravity upon the falling mass.

While those two forces act in roughly opposite directions in a collapse, they are not equal except by sheer coincidence. There is no law of physics (including any of Newton's) that require them to be equal.

Thus the laws of physics allow the downward velocity of a progressive collapse to accelerate, decelerate, or remain approximately constant depending on variables relating to the composition of the specific structure, the onset of the collapse, and the current state of its progression.
 
Does Newton's first law of motion apply to both the gymnast and the elephant? Yes. Since the answer is yes, scale does not matter.

Please stop beating that poor dead thing. Where has anyone here ever said that scale matters in the statement of Newton's laws, or that they don't "apply" to everything? Yet you keep trying to pick a fight with that strawman while ignoring what everyone is trying to tell you about the application of those laws if you're going to use a scale model to infer anything about the behavior of a larger or smaller object. It doesn't matter how often you deny it, Cole is saying that the behavior of his scale models proves that the WTC towers must have been demolitions. Nothing in his video remotely resembles an application of Newton's laws (which isn't enough anyway) to support that conclusion. In fact, the video proves he has no clue what he is talking about. You lost that argument on page one.
 
What you mean to say is that you are ignoring all other evidence other than fire.
In the 15 years since 9/11 there has been nothing but speculation and unsupported assertions from 9/11 "truth".

You can pretend that isn't the case all you want but that won't change reality.


Did you see this in a dream? You must have because I have found no evidence anywhere to support your claims.
You've ignored and hand waved away every post that proves your understanding and application of the physical laws has no connection to reality.

Again, you can pretend all you want but that won't change reality.

I have zero doubt if you walked into any institute of higher learning with a physics department with Cole's videos and your explanations the only results would be laughter.



Do you understand what "rational" means?
Yes. Your attempts of rationalisations for Cole's nonsense are not in accordance with the definition.


The vast majority of the links I post to support my claims are from physics/teaching forums that have nothing to do with 9/11. Did you really want to argue actual facts or did you just feel the need to throw a temper-tantrum?
You've misconstrued every one of those links then ignored every post that explained why your understanding is faulty.



https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YvrKfWkxdw

Your argument is that they are not on the audio record. If so, you're right, what can clearly be heard was ignored by NIST and the 9/11 CR. I guess they had issues with volume on their computers and other playback devices.
That occurred a full 5-6 hours before the collapses. Do you really want to pretend these sounds had anything to do with the collapse?

If anything it's a great example of you trying to fit a square peg into a round hole.




Other skeptics have already conceded scale is not relevant in Cole's experiments. You're also right that his experiments don't duplicate NIST's claim. What is the title of this thread? If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong. So, if NIST's claims can't be duplicated by experiment, NIST is wrong. Once again, thank you for supporting my thesis
You deserve 1000 internets for that one. It's pure gold.
Again, it's all about inept attempts to win cheap internet points by misrepresenting and misinterpreting others posts by you.

Nothing more, nothing less.

Take me up on my challenge FF! Walk into the nearest university with a physics department and play Cole's videos for one of the profs then explain why you think Cole is correct.

Record the even and post it here.

I have no doubt the prof will offer you the exact same refutations you've heard from the more knowledgeable posters here...because they're right.
 
.......typical of the tactics skeptics use to continue the cover up...........

OK, so are you accusing me of knowingly covering up the truth about the destruction of the WTC buildings, or of being a dupe of those who are spreading lies about what really happened?
 
An explanation is not relevant. I will not get sucked into a side argument, where once again you disagree with everything I say just because you want to.
If scale is irrelevant to Cole's experiments then have him repeat the one with the cement boards and a 1000lb weight.

Record the results and post them here.
 
I think that's part and parcel in the sport of arguing with ideologues.

Just telling them over and over they're wrong gets boring so some resort to pointing out their failures of logic and reasoning as a form of entertainment.

Well, in all fairness, one hopes that it might also be instructive to objective lurkers. BS that's ignored doesn't disappear; it procreates in dark places.
 
Although a person admits they know nothing about physics and engineering, they came here to see what the "more informed" had said. Why on earth would anyone come here thinking there are more informed people? This defies all logic and reason. There are neutral forums a person could have visited to seek understanding of the concepts they didn't understand.

I admire that you have admitted you don't understand physics and engineering. The problem is that if you really wanted to understand them, you would NOT come here first.

This is as good of an online location to get solid information as anywhere. There are many folks on this board who are qualified to assess the science of the collapse, and they have debated among themselves many times about specific technical issues (which you would know had you bothered to read any of the dozens of threads on the subject).

You're using the failed A&E9-11 Truth playbook and have been spinning in circles since the beginning. I have the NIST report on my hard drive. I'm tried to read it, and most of the science is way over my head. However, when I got to the Recommendations section I found it easy to read into the report their deeper findings based on the many structural changes they make, and those changes have been made to most similarly designed skyscrapers since 2002.

You need to read the recommendations. Most all of your questions about the collapse are answered there if you open your eyes.

You have demonstrated that your lack of understanding, and your choice to come here, has influenced you to make the wrong conclusions. At the very least you should have seen where are least 3 skeptics have admitted scaling does not apply to Newton's laws of motion. That, at the very least, should be proof that your conclusion is wrong.

I think that if Newton were alive he'd look at the footage and point out that there is a lot of structural failure that is unseen in all of the videos of the collapses. And since there is not enough visual evidence there is no way to say anything violates laws of physics, and he'd point out that gravity won...and then Newton would ask to be driven to the airport of watch 767s take off for the rest of the day.
 
No. The laws of physics apply to everything. You should use this statement to understand why you are wrong. Verinage collapses do comply with the laws of physics, which is why one can clearly observe deceleration.
So does collapse of WTC1.


Where is deceleration observed? Please post your source, and your definition of deceleration.
This graph, obtained by feature tracking by femr2, depicts vertical velocity vs. time for the roofline of WTC1.

931368518.png


Deceleration is negative acceleration. Its result is a reduction in velocity. Such a reduction can be seen in the graph between fields 248 and 256 approximately. Jerks (variations of acceleration) are also visible.


Good point. You are correct. Freefall, or acceleration downwards at the rate of 9.8m/s/s was observed during the collapse of WTC7. During the collapse of WTC1, nearly uniform acceleration downwards (at approximately 6.31m/s/s was observed.
Wrong. Deceleration was observed. The acceleration averaged about 6.3 m/s² for some period.


This is not the same value as freefall, so it is absolutely correct to state that freefall was not observed during the collapse of WTC1.
Yep.


That link states that the position was taken every 6 frames:

The vertical position of the roof line was marked every six frames (0.2 s intervals) and the data was exported to a spreadsheet for analysis. (See Table 1.)
​
(p.6 of the PDF). That is likely to miss details such as the above, which lasts just about 8 fields (4 frames).



The laws of physics apply to all buildings. Whenever you admit this as being true, you are conceding that Cole's experiments are correct.
Hogwash. The fire- and damage-induced collapse of the WTC towers obeyed Newton's laws, and Cole's experiments make huge mistakes of scale when he pretends that they represent the WTC collapses.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom