FalseFlag,
Cole is NOT performing a structural experiment. It is absurd to think his experiment is modeling structural data when his floors consist of paper and toothpicks, or matchsticks.
Absolute, unmitigated rubbish. You haven’t the slightest clue…
OF COURSE it’s a “structural experiment”. And proven below.
If Jonathan Cole were competent enough to run a competent experiment, then toothpicks & paper are far, FAR too massive & strong to accurately model the towers at this stupid scale factor.
Cole is performing experiments to show Newton's laws of motion in action.
Absolute & utter rubbish.
NOBODY needs Cole to demonstrate or prove any of Newton’s Laws.
Further, that is NOT what he is doing. This is YOUR delusion, not our mistake.
If Cole were doing that, he’d be sliding or hitting a plastic puck across an air table.
Everyone here knows that Newton’s laws always hold.
__
As an aside, one key factors that YOU don’t realize is that all 3 of Newton’s laws are accurately & reliably built into the software that NIST used to model the Towers & WTC7. (The first two into every static model, and all 3 into the WTC7’s collapse model.) And that the engineers who use that software have no access to feature. they can’t turn them on or off, they can’t increase or decrease their effects, etc.
In other words, every single one of NIST’s models scrupulously, rigorously adheres to Newton’s Laws.
__
Although everyone seems to be kicking and screaming while denying this, scale has no effect on Newton's laws. They apply equally regardless of the magnitude of the mass of the object and the magnitude of the forces involved.
Yes, you keep saying this.
The ONLY reason that you keep saying this is that you’re not HEARING that nobody is disagreeing about this.
Scaling does NOT affect Newton’s laws.
But Newton’s laws are NOT the only laws that need be applied.
Newton’s Laws are 100% INSUFFICIENT to say anything about the collapse of the towers.
And THAT is the issue under contention.
NOT Newton’s Laws.
See if you can follow:
A heavy block is placed on a span of thin glass. The glass breaks & the block falls.
A heavy block is placed on a span of thicker glass . The glass bows very minimally & supports the block.
The same block is place on a span of thin wood. The wood bows a lot, & supports the block.
The same block is placed on a span of thick wood. The wood bows somewhat, & supports the block.
All 3 of Newton’s Laws are ALL true, ALL of the time, in ALL of 4 these “experiments”.
Other than determining the weight of the block, Newton’s Laws, while true, are completely, utterly INSUFFICIENT to the outcome ("the structure either fails or supports the block") of these experiments.
Material science & mechanical engineering (shape, thickness, length of the span, strength & toughness) are REQUIRED determine the outcomes.
Next, you drop the block onto the 3 remaining “structures”. (Yes, they are structures.)
The thin wood breaks, the thick glass breaks & the thick wood survives.
All 3 of Newton’s Laws are ALL true, ALL of the time, in ALL of 3 this group of “experiments”, too.
Newton’s Laws are required to determine the speed with which the block impacts the structure.
But Newton’s Laws are, again, completely, utterly, 100% unable to predict the outcome of these experiments.
Again, material science & mechanical engineering are REQUIRED to determine the outcome.
QED.
NOBODY needs Jonathan Cole to demonstrate or prove Newton’s Laws.
This is YOUR fantasy.
It is also YOUR fantasy that anybody here is saying that any of Newton’s Laws are being violated in ANY event that has ever happened, from the collapse of the tower to the partial collapse of Cole’s clueless experiment.
If YOU stop blabbering this stupid assertion, then people will stop blabbering about “scale & Newton’s Laws”.
The part that IS true, is that scale is an absolutely CRITICAL aspect of the study (mechanical engineering) that IS required to determine the outcome of the above experiments.
And, if you could get it thru your thick skull …
NOBODY (except you) needs any convincing about Newton’s Laws.
EVERYBODY is discussing the applicability of mechanical engineering to the collapse of Cole’s model vs. the collapse of the WTC Towers.
And Jonathan Cole is included in this last “EVERYBODY”. He is also pompously, cluelessly, incompetently bloviating about the applicability of his model to the collapse of the towers. He is NOT talking about Newton’s Laws either. He IS talking about mechanical engineering. And totally screwing up the discussion.
The 100% PROOF that Cole does, in fact, view his contraption as “a structural model” as well as “a structural model for the WTC towers”, and even more so, “a structural model for the collapse of the WTC towers” is explicitly stated every single time he states “Is this (whatever his model did) what we saw in the collapse of the towers?”
Even Jonathan Cole, in his stupidity, does not match you, in yours.
I keep saying this, correctly, and it keeps being ignored. It is being ignored because you don't like it, so you refuse to accept it.
whatever...