If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
FalseFlag, here's a challenge to you, returning the burden of proof to where it should have been all along. Having accepted that Cole's videos demonstrate that Newton's laws are what they are, please provide compelling evidence that the behaviour of Cole's models is representative of the behaviour of the WTC towers while collapsing, to a sufficient precision to be predictive of the specific aspects of the collapse they are intended to predict. Until you've proven this point, there's really nothing here to talk about.

Dave

His videos do exactly what you are challenging me to do. If you have eyes and ears you can see what he is doing.

Your post is nothing more than an attempt to get me to explain what I see in the video, and then drag out the attacks on me by criticizing the minutia of every word I write. No. I'm not falling for this. Cole made the video. Perform an experiment to prove he's wrong. I'm still waiting.

You really think you are dealing with an amateur. I will never say I'm an expert, but you have to be seriously delusional to continue to treat me as some sort of amateur.
 
Funny. You are the one making the claim and you expect everyone to prove you wrong.
No. What I have said is that you say I'm wrong, then you need to provide proof. If you say nothing, there is nothing you need to prove.
 
You make a claim, you need to support it if you expect to have it accepted. You made a claim about the initial fall of the upper section of WTC 1. You based your claim on a video of the collapse. Your claim; your burden to back it with evidence.

This post admits I provided proof. The issue is that you disagree with it so you claim it's not credible. I have met my burden of proof. You simply refuse to accept the proof.

(Well, actually, you based your claim on comments made by Cole, comments that were either taken out of context by you, misinterpreted by you, or just flat out wrong to begin with.)

Here you make a claim. You now have the burden of proof. What comments were taken out of context by me? What did I misinterpret? What was I flat out wrong with (in regards to Cole's videos)?

Rather than supporting your claim with credible evidence, instead you exposed your ignorance of video technologies, their impact on data gathering from video images, what video technologies would have been available in 2001, what raw data was collected, how it was collected, the meaning of "constant" versus the meaning of "average"...the list goes on.
Please explain how anything I have posted regarding videos supports your claim. Please explain how, throughout this entire thread, I have continued to remain ignorant to the subjects you are mentioning. Then, if you actually do prove this, explain how this ignorance prevents me from understanding NIST's claim of freefall for 2.25 seconds.

You claimed the upper section of the WTC 1 tower fell with constant acceleration. You have yet to support this claim with credible evidence.
I have posted credible evidence. You just refuse to accept it.
 
...scaling errors...
You do understand that at least three skeptics, including yourself, have stated scale does not matter in Newton's laws of motion. Did you forget what you posted? I guess you did, or you wouldn't be mentioning it again.
 
...not even close...

Not even constant realtive motion.

Try again, sparky.

You really could learn this...

LOL. You just went on record saying my example was wrong, yet you fail to provide a credible source which proves I'm wrong.

OK, play on, but I'm pretty sure you are the one refusing to learn anything.
 
This is funny. From where I'm sitting, it looks like I'm the one getting the points.
You can't keep up because you're running out of absurd arguments, lies, deceit, and silly tactics.

I do wish we did not have that rule that prevents us from telling the truth about you and your claims. Not my fault though. So you will just have to wonder for a few more months!!!!!
 
No. What I have said is that you say I'm wrong, then you need to provide proof. If you say nothing, there is nothing you need to prove.

Don't be ridiculous, FF. There has been an official enquiry. If you think they got it wrong, you need to provide proof to back up your claims. You're the one making the claim, not us. The enquiry claims are all evidenced. Burden of proof seems so difficult for creationists and "truthers" to understand.
 
Semantics. Or grasping. Or both. Whatever it takes not to concede a point.

Are you here for comic relief?

Except this is disputed by numerous skeptics in this very thread. They have thrown everything they can at NIST to dismiss what you just said can't be disputed.


I know we are talking about WTC7, but didn't Bazant revise their paper on WTC1 and WTC2 to abandon the crush-up theory since it was not observed. Are there any experiments anywhere which support a "crush-up" theory?

What you mean to say is that you are ignoring all other evidence other than fire.


Did you see this in a dream? You must have because I have found no evidence anywhere to support your claims.



Do you understand what "rational" means?


The vast majority of the links I post to support my claims are from physics/teaching forums that have nothing to do with 9/11. Did you really want to argue actual facts or did you just feel the need to throw a temper-tantrum?



https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YvrKfWkxdw

Your argument is that they are not on the audio record. If so, you're right, what can clearly be heard was ignored by NIST and the 9/11 CR. I guess they had issues with volume on their computers and other playback devices.




Other skeptics have already conceded scale is not relevant in Cole's experiments. You're also right that his experiments don't duplicate NIST's claim. What is the title of this thread? If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong. So, if NIST's claims can't be duplicated by experiment, NIST is wrong. Once again, thank you for supporting my thesis
You deserve 1000 internets for that one. It's pure gold.

This is funny. From where I'm sitting, it looks like I'm the one getting the points.
You can't keep up because you're running out of absurd arguments, lies, deceit, and silly tactics.

Wouldn't it be easier to post the link instead of saying it has been posted. Also, where is the link?


I would like to do this. Where is the video?

Are you here for comic relief, too?

NIST ruled out diesel fires. They also never looked for explosives, even though it's SOP to do so when a building collapses. You do know this, right?

Really? Did you watch the video? Which model duplicates the motion observed during the collapses of WTC1 and WTC2? What did he have to do in order to duplicate the observed motion?

Your conclusion, "therefore what really happened couldn't," is wrong. It is wrong because what Cole is demonstrating is how what happened did happen. You are failing to understand the purpose of his demonstration and his conclusions. If you did understand them you would quote them accurately, and then post your arguments against the actual quotes and conclusions. I'm not saying you can't disagree, what I am saying is that your arguments are against something that is not seen in the videos.

This is the most unsettling post in this thread. It represents the exact opposite of what is true. Truthers are looking for a new investigation. Skeptics are here to continue the cover-up and hide the truth. Skeptics are here to "run-interference" against those who are seeking the truth. Don't think for one second I don't know this as a fact, and don't think for one second I won't do everything in my power to expose this.

www.ae911truth.org

Your opinion is noted as uninformed and nothing but wishful thinking.

Then your post was nothing but a meaningless drive-by attack. Noted.


So am I.

This is an attempt to discredit me. It fails. I know exactly what Cole is demonstrating.



Why? If the purpose of Cole's experiments is solely to demonstrate downward motion, how will his experiments differ from a larger model, or the actual WTC buildings? You have just claimed that Newton's laws apply to the models and real towers. If the laws apply equally, how will the results be different?

Um...

I would say that I'm ripping you to shreds, but you're doing a better job ripping yourself to shreds than I am.

If NIST's model, "scrupulously, rigorously adheres to Newton’s Laws", then why bother with them at all if they are "100% INSUFFICIENT to say anything about the collapse of the towers."

I hope your meltdown is complete, but at the same time I hope there is more.

I'm just going to leave this here by itself for you to stew over for awhile.

You'll be baaack.

The record of the posts in this thread disproves your claim.

What you're really mad about is that I'm not a mindless zombie you can win over with your arguments. I admit that some of the claims you make are correct. The issue is that your conclusions are wrong. Most of the people here can't see that.

What you are doing is posting accurate, technical information to appear to be a person who knows what they are doing. You then make incorrect conclusions based on that data, and people believe you.

Not me.

What is your definition of "experiment"? I really have to see this.

I do wish we did not have that rule that prevents us from telling the truth about you and your claims. Not my fault though. So you will just have to wonder for a few more months!!!!!

That's some high quality truthering you got going there, I doubt anyone has ever kept count, but I'm willing to bet you've just set the record for dodging posts in a thread.

Congratulations!

Let us know how that new investigation is coming. LOLZ
 




The explosion recorded in the video you posted happened at 11:01:07. It was also captured on 2 other videos and can be seen in the seismic record.

Screen%20Shot%202016-03-20%20at%2012.39.32%20am.png




It is most likely a gas explosion originating from here.



Screen-shot-2015-07-17-at-11.41.gif



There are 2 other explosions in the seismic record. One at 11:15:04 and one at 11:29:46. The last one can be definitely confirmed on video as a gas explosion.

The seismic graph describes them as "further collapse" but all 3 coincide with explosions caught on tape.

Those are all the known explosions you have to work with.
 
There has been an official enquiry. If you think they got it wrong, you need to provide proof to back up your claims.
The investigation was done by "sloppy", but "expert" professionals. That is a claim made by another skeptic. Don't you think we need an investigation that isn't sloppy?

I am providing proof. See my first post in this thread.
 
Last edited:
I tend to avoid CT threads on 9/11, mainly because I know I do not know the physics and engineering. I was, for example, a bit taken in by the second video, and then returned to the thread to see what the more informed had said. (For the record, I did in fact miss both high school chemistry and physics, so perhaps there is a tad of an excuse in that.)

At any rate, the square-cube law did not take long at all to comprehend. So scaling. So the videos are no proof. Therefore, how did this thread reach 44 pages with the same claims as on the first page? Because CT.

[All that said, there are frequent uses of words such as "idiocy" to describe the condition of those not familiar with the science. I'd like to point out that the proper term would be "ignorance," not "idiocy."]
 
Post your three sphere example again. I need to laugh.

Ah but you failed to grasp, that it was energy vs inertia, in dealing with resistance.
http://www.physicscentral.com/experiment/askaphysicist/physics-answer.cfm?uid=20080509042817

Exactly the point that is wrong in Cole's experiments, you get a Big F for Fail in physics.

The micro sphere lacks sufficient mass to develop enough momentum to over come wind resistance.

The one inch steel has sufficient mass, to over come wind resistance there fore it falls at enough momentum to store enough energy to bounce and the floor has sufficient energy to cause it to bounce.

The Larger steel wrecking ball can not bounce because, it's momentum and applied energy is greater than the floor can provide back though resistance.

The problem in Coles experiments is that motion over scale models must duplicate applied energy.

So If Cole dropped 2600 pounds from 12 feet on a mock up of a joint in the world trade center in a one foot off center eccentric strike, he would find that the joints do fail, to balance the energy Cole would have to use the maxwell equations.

The energy balance is credical to duplication of motion per Cole's experiments, and that is where you and Cole fail.

I realize that you didn't want to address the three spheres problem as it is an effective example of the balance of applied energy in modeling.
 
Does Newton's first law of motion apply to both the gymnast and the elephant? Yes. Since the answer is yes, scale does not matter.

Yes, all physical laws apply to both. Now you explain why the elephant can't do somersaults.
 
Your statement can be found here:

Is your argument now one purely of semantics? It can't be, because in your very next statement you say I'm right.

You've just proved you're lying, because the statement you posted doesn't say anything about "instantaneous" or "simultaneous," which you claimed it did. This is not a semantic difference; it's you deliberately misrepresenting what I said.

Dave
 
[All that said, there are frequent uses of words such as "idiocy" to describe the condition of those not familiar with the science. I'd like to point out that the proper term would be "ignorance," not "idiocy."]

Willful ignorance is indistinguishable from gross stupidity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom