If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, it's not wrong.
If you take the time to claim I'm wrong, then you have the burden of proof to show this. If you refuse to do this, then your post is nothing more than a drive-by attack, and that is all you have left in your bag of tricks, lies, and deceit.
 
Gymnasts can do double somersaults; elephants can't even jump despite being much stronger. Scale.

Does Newton's first law of motion apply to both the gymnast and the elephant? Yes. Since the answer is yes, scale does not matter.
 
I know of no such thing, because it makes no sense in context. You've simply moved the goalposts.

Your claim: FalseFlag has moved the goalposts.

Example:

Nope. No example.

Proof:

Nope. No proof that the example actually describes "moving goalposts".
 
You are a bit of a petulant, demanding little cuss, aintcha?
Is that your definition of someone who sees through a skeptic's BS?

How about this: How about YOU go find the video that NIST used ... which you want to see.

I have tried. It seems quite odd it isn't easy to find on the internet. I wonder why. Is it because anyone with a basic understanding of physics and a free computer program could use that video to prove something independently? Hmmm. Nothing to see here, folks.

NIST is a bunch of experts. Guess what: they put together the report in an expert fashion.

They are experts who are sloppy? I mean you are the one who said they were sloppy, right? If they are sloppy experts, don't you think we should have a well-funded, independent, completely open investigation by experts who are NOT sloppy?

Amazing how that all works when professionals do the job.

If they are experts and professionals, then why won't you accept their finding of freefall?

LOL. You are making this WAY too easy.


Now, Chandler is not a professional.

This is nothing more than your opinion. I think his educational background and methodology prove that your opinion might not be an informed one.


We already know that you don't give a rat's butt about truth or facts. You've proved that one over & over & over.
Give one example of where I don't care about the truth or facts.

So, let me put it this way: If you can't find an original copy of the video that NIST used, then you are incompetent.

Show that I am incompetent by posting the actual video. Show where in the NIST report that your video is the actual one you have posted. You already did this once, and you failed hard, but I will give you a second chance.
 
Last edited:
You're either incompetent or lying, because I admit no such thing.

Your statement can be found here:
The implications of the average acceleration being 9.8ms-2 for 2.25 seconds is that the structure exerted negligible force on the falling section over this period, as would be expected from the initial failure being a multi-storey buckle.

Is your argument now one purely of semantics? It can't be, because in your very next statement you say I'm right.
 
Last edited:
Wrong.

You're the twoofer trying to convince the world you need a "new" investigation.

So far (almost 15 years now) you and others of your ilk are failing badly.

I'd tell you to do better, but I know you can't.

I thought they were trufers/troofers
 
Utter nonsense. Freefall for a particular interval is simply evidence that, at some point in the collapse, they had all done so; it doesn't imply they did so instantaneously (we know from the earlier period of lower acceleration that they did not), or simultaneously (we know from the kink in the face that they did not). All this is obvious to anyone intelligent who studies the evidence impartially. So I'll snip the irrelevant nonsense you've followed up with, and move on to:
I knew this argument was coming. What you are claiming is that a certain number of columns failed before the last ones did. Then, when the last ones failed, the building collapsed. This is actually correct, but you don't like what it proves, and you're trying to twist the truth to support your claims instead of coming to the correct conclusion

We do know that some columns ceased to provide support first because the penthouse collapsed before the rest of the building. Then, the entire top of the building came down at once, and it descended at freefall for 2.25 seconds, which is about the distance of 100 feet or 8 floors. In order for the entire building to come down at freefall for 2.25 seconds, all of the columns left that provided support had to fail at once, or at the same time, or instantaneously, or simultaneously.

Dave's argument is a pretty good attempt to take the truth, and obscure it to it support the skeptics position. He knows that some columns were undoubtedly taken out first, so he uses that against the claim that all columns failed instantaneously. The claim that some columns failed first is 100 percent true, but it fails to recognize how many support columns were still left supporting the entire building. Every single one of these remaining columns failed at exactly the same time. Not only did they fail at the same time, they failed over the same length at the same time. There is only one explanation for this, and it's not progressive collapse.

I am unable to conceive of a level of misunderstanding that would prompt such a question. You now seem to be confusing the process of averaging acceleration over an interval with the experimental uncertainty of the measurement, or possibly completely failing to grasp the concept of measurement error, or possibly both. As I said before, you really need to read an introductory text on experimental techniques; sadly, I'm not sure a simple enough one exists.

At this point, this is nothing more than a meaningless personal attack. They are not working, but I do admire your consistency.
 
Last edited:
As I'm sure you've discussed with Oystein, the equation for the amount of work for moving any mass is
...
I assume (bet?) that Oystein mentioned that the toppling sheets were visible emerging thru the could of debris during the fall
You are quite the optimist. No, there has been no discussion of any of this. AClark made this vague and asinine remark and insinuation about some "energy" he claims is "very large", I called on him to quantify this in order to justify the judgemental "very large", and he has dodged and played blind ever since.
I mentioned the observed fact the the walls toppled over, but for the sake of argument also allowed the (false) Truther claim of "lateral ejection" at velocities of, e.g., 60 mph.
AClark is free to calculate the amount of energy required for either scenario - which would trivially translate to an estimate of the amount of hypothetical explosives needed.

...
W = F x d = F d cos(Ω)
...
For any toppling structure [...] that is pivoting about some low point, F is the force that the lower structure applies to the upper, which acts along the line of the structure, and d is the motion of the upper portion of the structure, which is always 90° to the force throughout the fall. Therefore Ω = 90° throughout the fall, which means that cos(Ω) is always 0 throughout the fall & it takes no work, once it begins to fall.
...
Hehe cute :thumbsup:

Gravity acts on the toppling structure and accelerates it - that is some positive work. Let's assume a 500-foot ladder, no air resistance.
  • How long from first tipping out of 90 ° (upright) to 0° (flat on the ground)?
  • What's the velocity of the tip of the ladder as it impacts the ground?
  • What's the lateral component of that velocity then?
  • What's the kinetic energy energy then, assuming mass m = 1,000 tons equally distributed along the length?
  • What was the average lateral velocity of the tip during the topple?
  • What was the maximum lateral velocity of the tip during the topple?
^__ These would make a nice problem for an 11th grade high school physics exam :)
(ETA: And any deviation of measured times and velocities in grainy videos from the calculated theoretical results would give Truthers occasion to jump up and down and dance "Inside jobby job!!")
 
Last edited:
Just picking this one up: No, they failed almost simultaneously. I know you've explained this later in the post, but FalseFlag is likely to pick up the above statement, take it out of context and gibber over it like an excited baboon.

Dave

Semantics. Or grasping. Or both. Whatever it takes not to concede a point.
 
Here's the deal... the close to FF descent was about 100' or 2.1 secs... then it slowed significantly. This is not disputed.
Except this is disputed by numerous skeptics in this very thread. They have thrown everything they can at NIST to dismiss what you just said can't be disputed.

crush up from the bottom.
I know we are talking about WTC7, but didn't Bazant revise their paper on WTC1 and WTC2 to abandon the crush-up theory since it was not observed. Are there any experiments anywhere which support a "crush-up" theory?
 
Shouldn't this argument be prefaced by the fact that no evidence for any mechanism other than fire and damage exists for any of the September 11 collapses?
What you mean to say is that you are ignoring all other evidence other than fire.

It's clear that FF's/Cole's claims have been utterly destroyed
Did you see this in a dream? You must have because I have found no evidence anywhere to support your claims.

regardless of the fact that FF behaves more as a child's punching clown than a rational person

Do you understand what "rational" means?

and that he would never test his claims by going outside of 911 "truths" internet bubble of forum posting to verify for himself that he's correct.
The vast majority of the links I post to support my claims are from physics/teaching forums that have nothing to do with 9/11. Did you really want to argue actual facts or did you just feel the need to throw a temper-tantrum?

Given that, we're right back to explosives and explosions which were not heard on the audio record of the day and all the back and forth trying to convince FF he's incorrect won't change that.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YvrKfWkxdw

Your argument is that they are not on the audio record. If so, you're right, what can clearly be heard was ignored by NIST and the 9/11 CR. I guess they had issues with volume on their computers and other playback devices.


And it is clear from Cole's video experiments replicating the collapses that scale is relevant. His entire premise is based on the strength and behaviour of materials which he didn't even attempt to scale properly. Additionally, his experiments obviously fail given they don't even replicate the type of failures NIST has claimed which were failures of connections where Cole's experiment shows cement boards breaking in half.

Other skeptics have already conceded scale is not relevant in Cole's experiments. You're also right that his experiments don't duplicate NIST's claim. What is the title of this thread? If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong. So, if NIST's claims can't be duplicated by experiment, NIST is wrong. Once again, thank you for supporting my thesis
You deserve 1000 internets for that one. It's pure gold.
 
Last edited:
Coles models are wrong - they are NOT models of how the WTC Towers collapsed.

So Coles argument in essence is "Here are three wrong models - therefore what really happened couldn't."

Really? Did you watch the video? Which model duplicates the motion observed during the collapses of WTC1 and WTC2? What did he have to do in order to duplicate the observed motion?

Your conclusion, "therefore what really happened couldn't," is wrong. It is wrong because what Cole is demonstrating is how what happened did happen. You are failing to understand the purpose of his demonstration and his conclusions. If you did understand them you would quote them accurately, and then post your arguments against the actual quotes and conclusions. I'm not saying you can't disagree, what I am saying is that your arguments are against something that is not seen in the videos.
 
, considering that what "truthers" are peddling isn't ordinary idiotic nonsense; it's toxic waste.
This is the most unsettling post in this thread. It represents the exact opposite of what is true. Truthers are looking for a new investigation. Skeptics are here to continue the cover-up and hide the truth. Skeptics are here to "run-interference" against those who are seeking the truth. Don't think for one second I don't know this as a fact, and don't think for one second I won't do everything in my power to expose this.
 
I don't know what you think Cole's experiments are supposed to do.
This is an attempt to discredit me. It fails. I know exactly what Cole is demonstrating.

Newton's laws apply to the models and the real towers.
But that doesn't mean that exactly the same things will happen in both cases.

Why? If the purpose of Cole's experiments is solely to demonstrate downward motion, how will his experiments differ from a larger model, or the actual WTC buildings? You have just claimed that Newton's laws apply to the models and real towers. If the laws apply equally, how will the results be different?
 
In other words, every single one of NIST’s models scrupulously, rigorously adheres to Newton’s Laws.
Newton’s Laws are 100% INSUFFICIENT to say anything about the collapse of the towers.

Um...

I would say that I'm ripping you to shreds, but you're doing a better job ripping yourself to shreds than I am.

If NIST's model, "scrupulously, rigorously adheres to Newton’s Laws", then why bother with them at all if they are "100% INSUFFICIENT to say anything about the collapse of the towers."

I hope your meltdown is complete, but at the same time I hope there is more.

I'm just going to leave this here by itself for you to stew over for awhile.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom