If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Two questions:

Why is it everyone else's burden to prove FalseFlag wrong in his ignorant and baseless statements?
Why are so many of you letting him get away with it?
 
Shouldn't this argument be prefaced by the fact that no evidence for any mechanism other than fire and damage exists for any of the September 11 collapses?

It's clear that FF's/Cole's claims have been utterly destroyed regardless of the fact that FF behaves more as a child's punching clown than a rational person and that he would never test his claims by going outside of 911 "truths" internet bubble of forum posting to verify for himself that he's correct.

Given that, we're right back to explosives and explosions which were not heard on the audio record of the day and all the back and forth trying to convince FF he's incorrect won't change that.

And it is clear from Cole's video experiments replicating the collapses that scale is relevant. His entire premise is based on the strength and behaviour of materials which he didn't even attempt to scale properly. Additionally, his experiments obviously fail given they don't even replicate the type of failures NIST has claimed which were failures of connections where Cole's experiment shows cement boards breaking in half.

If there's better proof the 911 "truth" movement has no value beyond comedic enjoyment I'd love to see it!
 
Two questions:

Why is it everyone else's burden to prove FalseFlag wrong in his ignorant and baseless statements?
Why are so many of you letting him get away with it?

The first one: because the stupid things he says are so obviously stupid, nobody can resist a shot at an open goal. The second one: I think the biggest problem is that he's throwing out rapid fire stupid so fast, it's impossible to keep up.

Dave
 
OK, then find the actual video NIST used, and the actual video Chandler used. Please post working links. If you can't find it then I guess you aren't looking for facts and truth, according to your own statement.

The link has been posted.
It's also possible, for anyone such as you, to find it. YOU keep calling for it yet in doing so you never attempt to find it yourself. Instead, you demand that others do it for you.

I don't require the video. YOU say you do. YOU go look for it.

In addition, tfk quoted Chandler explaining that it is 29.97 fps, the same as every single ENG and broadcast TV recording and every single video camcorder used in the USA and Canada in 2001. Only security cameras and slow motion videos would be the exception to this.
YOU are bucking against not only well known fact of 29.97 fps NTSC video but also Chandler's description of the video. If YOU are so questioning, YOU go and investigate the video.
 
Shouldn't this argument be prefaced by the fact that no evidence for any mechanism other than fire and damage exists for any of the September 11 collapses?
!

Indeed, the professional investigations,such as NIST's, only considered the mechanisms for damage for which they could find evidence of.
Thus, no explosives, no therm!te, no space-a-beams, no nukes, no ghost planes, no drones, and ,after investigating some possibilities , they were also dropped. Case in point, Diesel fuel fire driven WTC7 collapse.
 
Two questions:

Why is it everyone else's burden to prove FalseFlag wrong in his ignorant and baseless statements?
clap.gif
clap.gif

It isn't but given no serious discussions some members are desperate for something to post and resort to troll feeding. Which is a self sustaining activity.

Why are so many of you letting him get away with it?
Same answer. Count the number of times I have called "Poe" and been ignored. ;)

The first one: because the stupid things he says are so obviously stupid, nobody can resist a shot at an open goal.
The more complicated version is why do people of High School or better grade NOT resist the temptation to shoot at a grade school or lower open goal? What is the satisfaction in playing below your grade?

The second one: I think the biggest problem is that he's throwing out rapid fire stupid so fast, it's impossible to keep up.
Sure - the late creationist Duane Gish has a lot to answer for But at least he was serious and genuinely obsessed.

BUT that misses the point here - why do people want to play Gish Gallop with someone who is pretending - and not very good at it?

It is - has been from the outset - bleedingly obvious that he is mostly pretence. So why treat pretence as if he is serious?
 
Sure - the late creationist Duane Gish has a lot to answer for But at least he was serious and genuinely obsessed.

BUT that misses the point here - why do people want to play Gish Gallop with someone who is pretending - and not very good at it?

It is - has been from the outset - bleedingly obvious that he is mostly pretence. So why treat pretence as if he is serious?

When people are bored they do things for entertainment. When bored enough, their standards for entertainment decrease. Some people like making fun of pseudoscience on a particular topic, such as 9/11 conspiracy theories. However, there's no one left who puts any actual thought into trutherism. It's just about dead.

So they mock this guy because they have nothing better to do, even though he has nothing but posturing, because he's the only one left here posting so much.
 
Shouldn't this argument be prefaced by the fact that no evidence for any mechanism other than fire and damage exists for any of the September 11 collapses?
True enough although the situation is a full grade more basic.

There is nothing legitimate to argue. The extant - default - hypotheses are agreed - initial damage plus unfought fires == collapses. There is no valid counter claim hypothesis. So strictly by protocol there is nothing to argue.

Except "debunkers" as we now call them have traditionally accepted "reversed burden of DISproof" because the poor truthers never could formulate their own hypotheses. Remember - that is why most of them are truthers - they cannot think.

It's clear that FF's/Cole's claims have been utterly destroyed regardless of the fact that FF behaves more as a child's punching clown than a rational person and that he would never test his claims by going outside of 911 "truths" internet bubble of forum posting to verify for himself that he's correct.
And the status at that level is also a grade or two more basic. Coles models are wrong - they are NOT models of how the WTC Towers collapsed.

So Coles argument in essence is "Here are three wrong models - therefore what really happened couldn't."

No point following all the details when the foundation argument is utter nonsense. There is current discussion along the same lines on another forum "Here are three models referenced by Cole plus seven examples of buildings where progressive collapse arrested. Therefore the WTC Towers should have arrested."

Bleeding nonsense "None of the satellites of the solar system (M, V, E, M, J, U, N, [P]) have rings THEREFORE Saturn cannot have rings."

"Look - here are photos of Mars - no rings!"
-- and we still talk to clowns who make these silly "arguments".


:o :boggled:
 
The first one: because the stupid things he says are so obviously stupid, nobody can resist a shot at an open goal.

And around here, whenever a volunteer piñata shows up, it's party time!

Some folks wish that wasn't so, but I don't have a problem with that, considering that what "truthers" are peddling isn't ordinary idiotic nonsense; it's toxic waste. We live in a world where terrorists are real and will probably strike again and again. Instead of helping to understand and deal with that serious problem, conspiracism offers nothing but a spiraling feedback loop of self-delusion that eventually leads to being completely unable to recognize reality, much less deal with it.
 
When people are bored they do things for entertainment. When bored enough, their standards for entertainment decrease. Some people like making fun of pseudoscience on a particular topic, such as 9/11 conspiracy theories. However, there's no one left who puts any actual thought into trutherism. It's just about dead.

So they mock this guy because they have nothing better to do, even though he has nothing but posturing, because he's the only one left here posting so much.
:thumbsup: :thumbsup:
Spot on.

I'm personally disappointed that the standard of discussion has fallen so dramatically in the last 2-3 years. Especially since there are still three big issues of technical explanation which are (mostly) being avoided. Both "sides" mainly retreating into "whack-a-mole" comfort zones. But that's life for a conspiracy theory - the conspiracists set the pace for obvious reasons - and we are well into the "tail" diminishing asymptotically towards but not reaching zero. There seem to be no "serious truthers" AKA "genuine truthers" left on the scene.
 
.... but I don't have a problem with that, considering that what "truthers" are peddling isn't ordinary idiotic nonsense; it's toxic waste. We live in a world where terrorists are real and will probably strike again and again. Instead of helping to understand and deal with that serious problem, conspiracism offers nothing but a spiraling feedback loop of self-delusion that eventually leads to being completely unable to recognize reality, much less deal with it.
Parallel thoughts to my own.

There may still be some unresolved concerns about the US political management of 9/11. There certainly are concerns about the consequences.

Yet we still see truthers relying on dishonest claims about technical false issues such as CD at WTC.

I've many times opined that AE911Truth probably does more harm to any genuine truth movement concerns than any other group.

Still arguing "There was CD"
 
You should look up the meaning of "dodge" before you post it so many times. Also look up "delusions", "denial", and "cognitive dissonance" while you're at it. Once you understand those terms completely and need to find a real-world example, look in the mirror.

No need, I'm not a truther ignorant of science and embarrassing himself on the interwebs, you on the other hand...

Please continue though, I'm enjoying the free comedy!
 
I'll try again, perhaps AClark sees this now.
That's all very well and mathy, but it makes some very glaring omissions. Primarily the trigonometry of the situation. If you are going to have pieces toppling, then you are going to need pivot points, and enough geometry for your javelin.
You are Moving the Goal Posts.

You had declared:
The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large...
So I asked:
Can you quantify this "very large" energy required?

There are basically two theories on the table that would explain the source of that energy:
  • Gravity (GPE - Gravitational Potential Energy)
  • Explosives (ChE - Chemical Energy)
I quantified the requirement for the first theory - that GPE is the energy source: Drop height of 10 to 40 floors - easily available for collapses starting 78+ floors above ground.

Remember: You made a claim about the quantity of energy.

Now you:
How much explosives (equivalent to chemical energy, ChE) does it take, per mass unit of steel to propel a steel section to 60 mph?
That calculation is much less straightforward.
I have done it.
Have you?
Can you guess?
 
Cole is NOT performing a structural experiment. It is absurd to think his experiment is modeling structural data when his floors consist of paper and toothpicks, or matchsticks.

Cole is performing experiments to show Newton's laws of motion in action. Although everyone seems to be kicking and screaming while denying this, scale has no effect on Newton's laws. They apply equally regardless of the magnitude of the mass of the object and the magnitude of the forces involved.

I keep saying this, correctly, and it keeps being ignored. It is being ignored because you don't like it, so you refuse to accept it.
I don't know what you think Cole's experiments are supposed to do.

You say they are only meant to show Newton's laws in action, not to make any point about structures. Then you emphasize that Newton's laws always apply, regardless of scale. So then Newton's laws are illustrated in any video of a real event. If Cole only wanted to show Newton's laws in action, he could have shown a video of a dancing monkey, or a potato stuck in a sink, or a ticking clock. Newton's laws always apply, so they are clearly at work in those videos. Newton's laws in action. That does not seem plausible. Cole obviously intended to do more than that.

Maybe you mean his experiments were meant to test Newton's laws. That would actually make sense of the title of this thread. He could be saying, "If Newton's laws don't agree with experiment, they're wrong. I'm going to do an experiment to test them." Trouble is, he didn't do any analysis in the video to verify that the experiments conformed to Newton's laws. He did not measure the forces, momenta, impulses, accelerations, etc. to make sure that they all obeyed Newton's laws. He just assumed that the experiments obeyed Newton's laws because those laws are already confirmed. So he is not testing Newton's laws.

Which brings us to what Cole obviously is doing: he is claiming that the behavior of his various little towers should be the same as the behavior of the actual towers. That goes way beyond just making a claim about Newton's laws. A potato stuck in a sink obeys Newton's laws (approximately, relativistic, quantum, blah blah whatever), but it mysteriously does not behave the same way Cole's towers did. Same with a column of sand. In order to claim that the WTC towers should have behaved the same as the model towers, Cole has to be claiming that his models are good scale models of the towers in relevant ways. That is a claim about structures, modeling, and scaling, just like everyone in the thread has been saying from the beginning.

Newton's laws apply to the models and the real towers. But that doesn't mean that exactly the same things will happen in both cases.
 
Last edited:
I don't know what you think Cole's experiments are supposed to do.

You say they are only meant to show Newton's laws in action, not to make any point about structures. Then you emphasize that Newton's laws always apply, regardless of scale. So then Newton's laws are illustrated in any video of a real event. If Cole only wanted to show Newton's laws in action, he could have shown a video of a dancing monkey, or a potato stuck in a sink, or a ticking clock. Newton's laws always apply, so they are clearly at work in those videos. Newton's laws in action. That does not seem plausible. Cole obviously intended to do more than that.

Maybe you mean his experiments were meant to test Newton's laws. That would actually make sense of the title of this thread. He could be saying, "If Newton's laws don't agree with experiment, they're wrong. I'm going to do an experiment to test them." Trouble is, he didn't do any analysis in the video to verify that the experiments conformed to Newton's laws. He did not measure the forces, momenta, impulses, accelerations, etc. to make sure that they all obeyed Newton's laws. He just assumed that the experiments obeyed Newton's laws because those laws are already confirmed. So he is not testing Newton's laws.

Which brings us to what Cole obviously is doing: he is claiming that the behavior of his various little towers should be the same as the behavior of the actual towers. That goes way beyond just making a claim about Newton's laws. A potato stuck in a sink obeys Newton's laws (approximately, relativistic, quantum, blah blah whatever), but it mysteriously does not behave the same way Cole's towers did. Same with a column of sand. In order to claim that the WTC towers should have behaved the same as the model towers, Cole has to be claiming that his models are good scale models of the towers in relevant ways. That is a claim about structures, modeling, and scaling, just like everyone in the thread has been saying from the beginning.

Newton's laws apply to the models and the real towers. But that doesn't mean that exactly the same things will happen in both cases.

Quoted for entertaining excellence :D :thumbsup:
 
FalseFlag,

Cole is NOT performing a structural experiment. It is absurd to think his experiment is modeling structural data when his floors consist of paper and toothpicks, or matchsticks.

Absolute, unmitigated rubbish. You haven’t the slightest clue…

OF COURSE it’s a “structural experiment”. And proven below.

If Jonathan Cole were competent enough to run a competent experiment, then toothpicks & paper are far, FAR too massive & strong to accurately model the towers at this stupid scale factor.

Cole is performing experiments to show Newton's laws of motion in action.

Absolute & utter rubbish.

NOBODY needs Cole to demonstrate or prove any of Newton’s Laws.

Further, that is NOT what he is doing. This is YOUR delusion, not our mistake.
If Cole were doing that, he’d be sliding or hitting a plastic puck across an air table.

Everyone here knows that Newton’s laws always hold.
__

As an aside, one key factors that YOU don’t realize is that all 3 of Newton’s laws are accurately & reliably built into the software that NIST used to model the Towers & WTC7. (The first two into every static model, and all 3 into the WTC7’s collapse model.) And that the engineers who use that software have no access to feature. they can’t turn them on or off, they can’t increase or decrease their effects, etc.

In other words, every single one of NIST’s models scrupulously, rigorously adheres to Newton’s Laws.
__

Although everyone seems to be kicking and screaming while denying this, scale has no effect on Newton's laws. They apply equally regardless of the magnitude of the mass of the object and the magnitude of the forces involved.

Yes, you keep saying this.
The ONLY reason that you keep saying this is that you’re not HEARING that nobody is disagreeing about this.

Scaling does NOT affect Newton’s laws.

But Newton’s laws are NOT the only laws that need be applied.
Newton’s Laws are 100% INSUFFICIENT to say anything about the collapse of the towers.

And THAT is the issue under contention.
NOT Newton’s Laws.

See if you can follow:

A heavy block is placed on a span of thin glass. The glass breaks & the block falls.
A heavy block is placed on a span of thicker glass . The glass bows very minimally & supports the block.
The same block is place on a span of thin wood. The wood bows a lot, & supports the block.
The same block is placed on a span of thick wood. The wood bows somewhat, & supports the block.

All 3 of Newton’s Laws are ALL true, ALL of the time, in ALL of 4 these “experiments”.
Other than determining the weight of the block, Newton’s Laws, while true, are completely, utterly INSUFFICIENT to the outcome ("the structure either fails or supports the block") of these experiments.

Material science & mechanical engineering (shape, thickness, length of the span, strength & toughness) are REQUIRED determine the outcomes.

Next, you drop the block onto the 3 remaining “structures”. (Yes, they are structures.)
The thin wood breaks, the thick glass breaks & the thick wood survives.

All 3 of Newton’s Laws are ALL true, ALL of the time, in ALL of 3 this group of “experiments”, too.
Newton’s Laws are required to determine the speed with which the block impacts the structure.
But Newton’s Laws are, again, completely, utterly, 100% unable to predict the outcome of these experiments.

Again, material science & mechanical engineering are REQUIRED to determine the outcome.

QED.

NOBODY needs Jonathan Cole to demonstrate or prove Newton’s Laws.
This is YOUR fantasy.

It is also YOUR fantasy that anybody here is saying that any of Newton’s Laws are being violated in ANY event that has ever happened, from the collapse of the tower to the partial collapse of Cole’s clueless experiment.

If YOU stop blabbering this stupid assertion, then people will stop blabbering about “scale & Newton’s Laws”.

The part that IS true, is that scale is an absolutely CRITICAL aspect of the study (mechanical engineering) that IS required to determine the outcome of the above experiments.

And, if you could get it thru your thick skull …
NOBODY (except you) needs any convincing about Newton’s Laws.
EVERYBODY is discussing the applicability of mechanical engineering to the collapse of Cole’s model vs. the collapse of the WTC Towers.

And Jonathan Cole is included in this last “EVERYBODY”. He is also pompously, cluelessly, incompetently bloviating about the applicability of his model to the collapse of the towers. He is NOT talking about Newton’s Laws either. He IS talking about mechanical engineering. And totally screwing up the discussion.

The 100% PROOF that Cole does, in fact, view his contraption as “a structural model” as well as “a structural model for the WTC towers”, and even more so, “a structural model for the collapse of the WTC towers” is explicitly stated every single time he states “Is this (whatever his model did) what we saw in the collapse of the towers?”

Even Jonathan Cole, in his stupidity, does not match you, in yours.

I keep saying this, correctly, and it keeps being ignored. It is being ignored because you don't like it, so you refuse to accept it.

whatever...
 
Last edited:
Stop being mathy
:thumbsup: :thumbsup:

There is no point pretending to use maths when you don't know what you are talking about.

And - for the WTC Twin Towers collapses - if you know what you are talking about - you don't need the maths. Since the available energies/forces were 20>>> times more than can be resisted it makes no difference if it is 30times or 45.7 times. The thing that is hit will fail.

And coming at the argument arse about - truther style - from velocities - doesn't help.

The velocities and accelerations are what resulted when overwhelming forces met relatively weak connections. End of story UNLESS you are into interminable circling discussion with truthers who don't do thinking.

(Or are one of those engineers who make the trees not forest error - and forget draining the swamp if I mix my metaphors. :rolleyes: )
 
Please entertain us. Explain why I'm wrong.

It won't matter. I have already given an example to prove my understanding. I then had a skeptic say my example was not wrong.

And this is one of the main reasons that I'm done replying to this person.

I've actually wasted some significant amount of time digging up references, & presenting them, with explanations, to this clown. Anything that he cannot address, anything that refutes his claims, he simply ignores.

Like the above.

This sort of cavalier, useless & lazy response deserves no effort to help him out of his pit of stupidity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom